News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by wao0uuno on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:47AM (#44288283)
I tested meshtastic in a major european city with pretty much 100% mesh coverage and its real life performance was quite underwhelming. Often I would receive messages that I could not reply to because of differences in antenna gain and crappy mesh performance. Public chat was either completely dead or flooded with test messages. Everything was super slow because the mesh can’t actually scale that well and craps out with more than a 100 nodes. Even medium fast channel would clog up fast. I would never depend on meshtastic during an emergency because it barely works even when nobody is using it. I think a public wifi mesh would be more worthwhile. Older used wifi routers are pretty much free and in unlimited supply. They use very little power. Everyone already has a compatible client device on their pocket. Sure the mesh would fail during a total blackout but at least it would be useful for something when the power is up.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by GardenLetter27 on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:59AM (#44288360)
Yeah, having gone through the blackout in Spain this would be really useful (using phones).

Then only one person needs a generator and/or Starlink to provide some connectivity.

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by moffkalast on Monday June 16, 2025 @07:45AM (#44288666)
It's interesting how we're generally headed towards general self sufficiency, off grid solar and wind power with batteries because the grid won't pay you to sell it electricity, mesh networks and satellite internet to get around lazy local ISPs. All we need is a field where robots grow food and we're back in the middle ages but with modern tech. We've even got tech billionaires to stand in as feudal lords and crazy right wing populists instead of inbred kings with weird chins.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by bandoti on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:26AM (#44288907)
Good premise for a cyberpunk novel. I recommend keeping the weird chins though, because plastic surgery makes anything possible!
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by moffkalast on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:11AM (#44289186)
Yeah solarpunk is probably the most neglected out of all existing sci-fi punks, probably cause it's actually kinda nice and doesn't make a good setting for a gritty depressing story?
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by edent on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:40AM (#44288989)
Where in the world are you? In the UK I get paid to sell my excess solar back to the grid.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by moffkalast on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:08AM (#44289165)
That's usually the case if there's only a few people with solar or if your local infrastructure is overbuilt, since grids typically aren't designed to handle residential power generation.

If there's too much solar in your area (which will be the eventual end result everywhere) you get net billing, where you don’t get charged for the energy you use, but they won't pay you a dime for anything over what you use or will even disconnect you if you overproduce so the local substation doesn't explode because it wasn't specced for any of this shit.

The end result is that you don't get paid for any of your daily overproduction and still get billed at night, the worst of both worlds. It incentives people to buy batteries and store the peaks, with grid power being mostly optional.

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by Aachen on Monday June 16, 2025 @10:47AM (#44290098)
> they won't pay you a dime for anything over what you use

In some places. If you're dumping excess energy onto their network, in some regions they'll also charge you for that

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by bigfatkitten on Monday June 16, 2025 @05:40PM (#44293655)
> That's usually the case if there's only a few people with solar or if your local infrastructure is overbuilt, since grids typically aren't designed to handle residential power generation.

Australia has the highest density of residential rooftop solar in the world, making up about 11% of the grid supply. Feed-in tariffs are standard there.

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by bigiain on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:11PM (#44294521)
Also in Australia, and yeah feedin tariffs are a thing, but during midday "off peak" times when solar has excess energy, they're down around 1-2% of the retail cost of electricity and that's been going down for years.

Anecdotally, amongst my social circle, people are buying house batteries because the feedin tariffs are so low it's worthwhile spending $10k or so to store your daytime solar for use in evenings/night - because it costs 40 or 60c per kWHr to buy electricity off the grid in the evening, and they only give you a cent or two to if you feed it on during midday solar peaks. It's way better value to charge your house battery (and you car if you can) than to sell solar generated electricity back to the grid.

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by pyrale on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:48AM (#44289475)
> It's interesting how we're generally headed towards general self sufficiency, off grid solar and wind power with batteries because the grid won't pay you to sell it electricity

The grid will definitely pay you to sell it electricity if you fulfill the industrial standards it expects.

The issue in your assessment is that the quality of service provided by someone just setting up solar panels and inverters and plugging that on the grid is the equivalent of starting a skyscraper building company based on your experience building your garden shed. It's not safe, you won't understand why, and eventually you or someone else will get hurt.

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by pmontra on Monday June 16, 2025 @12:19PM (#44290979)
I'd agree with you if I'd setup my solar panels. But if I'd ever install solar at home I'd hire a company to do all the setup. I believe that it would fulfill industry standards.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by pyrale on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @03:20AM (#44296503)
It wouldn’t. Just like hiring the best pros to make an extremely fancy kitchen wouldn’t make it equivalent to a restaurant kitchen.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by bigfatkitten on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @05:15AM (#44297149)
It does if your local regulations specifically provide for small scale generation.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by pyrale on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @07:02PM (#44304956)
Local regulation on that topic usually revolves around easing the requirements for small scale/residential production, not around making them respect the same standards as large electricity producers.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by ahartmetz on Monday June 16, 2025 @04:56PM (#44293323)
Probably taking the "someone gets hurt" part too literally, but inverters do turn off their outputs when the grid goes down. It would take a lot of inverters to make all the other inverters believe that the local part of grid hasn't bee disconnected. I wouldn't be surprised if they had special logic to detect even that case. Of course, there is the case of simply having too much unregulated input to the grid, causing instability. But AFAIK that has never happened anywhere, at least not in a way bad enough to make the news. It is bound to happen if current trends continue, but appropriate actions will be taken at that point and have been taken in large solar installations.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by pyrale on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @03:40AM (#44296610)
First off, I’d like to state that the following post is about the challenges of handling residential production, not about industrial renewable setups.

The grid going down is game over. Once you’re at this point, there are already people going hurt. The way inverters react to this is irrelevant.

The thing making home setups not a source energy utilities would want to pay much for is that they bring no service to the grid (frequency and voltage management, ability to be turned off when the grid manager wants, reactive production management).

The part where people get hurt is that in overproduction events, the grid manager has no way to cut that production or even single homes, so they sometimes have to cut whole neighborhoods. That did happen already, even if it’s not a common thing.

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by adrianN on Monday June 16, 2025 @07:58AM (#44288738)
Wifi routers use quite a lot of power for the area that they can cover. Ten watts or so for a hundred square meters is a lot of you want to cover a whole city.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by wao0uuno on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:08AM (#44289168)
Almost everyone has one of these running 24/7 already. Second one with an external antenna wouldn’t make much difference.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by Aachen on Monday June 16, 2025 @10:49AM (#44290122)
Everyone currently has electricity on demand
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by wao0uuno on Monday June 16, 2025 @11:44AM (#44290682)
Ukrainian grid has been targeted by russian drone and missile strikes for years and it just keeps coming back. Longest downtime (according to a quick google search) was approximately 12 hours. Complete long term blackout in a big European city is very unlikely these days.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by pmontra on Monday June 16, 2025 @12:13PM (#44290935)
Long term as "days", yes. But all of Spain had a blackout for at least 12 hours a few weeks ago. Turin, Italy, had a 10 hours blackout yesterday.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by PokemonNoGo on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:09PM (#44292501)
Makes me more impressed by the Ukranians honestly! After Russia is banished they can teach the rest of Europe what resilience looks like in this area.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by immibis on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @08:49AM (#44298511)
Organizations never prepare for a crisis until there is a crisis. It just doesn't happen. The cost of preparing for a crisis is always higher than the probability-weighted cost of the crisis itself, even if the potential impact is bankruptcy, because the probability is always so low. The only organizations that prepare for crises are those whose sole purpose is to prepare for crises.

Regulators can also impose certain preparedness obligations on organizations, like power grid black start capability (the government or system operator pays generators a monthly fee to have more expensive equipment that's capable of black-starting).

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by anthk on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @01:18AM (#44295953)
Not all of Spain. A lot of areas had the power back in two hours, at least in the North.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by apitman on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:05PM (#44293826)
Yes but in exchange you get way more bandwidth. No idea whether it would be enough to run a city-scale text network though.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by bigfatkitten on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:49PM (#44294102)
With a range of maybe 100 metres line of sight, if you’re lucky.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by cedws on Monday June 16, 2025 @07:22AM (#44288526)
I'm surprised that phone manufacturers haven't already implemented a mesh network. I guess you could kind of call Apple's Find My network one, but if you want to smuggle arbitary data the bandwidth is very low. Maybe Apple's new mobile Wi-Fi chip is a precursor to an actual Internet mesh network.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by wat10000 on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:54AM (#44289071)
Battery life is a big deal and anything with decent speed would hurt that a lot. People won’t want to sacrifice their battery to get strangers online.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by econ on Monday June 16, 2025 @02:46PM (#44292295)
That is by design to keep you engaged. My current phone has 7050 mah and 80w charging. I charge it twice per week or so. If you have a slightly chaotic life you have to consider charging 30 times per day, hoard cables and charge powerbanks only to have it die anyway. Now I have one cable that doesn't move and doesn't break.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by wat10000 on Monday June 16, 2025 @04:22PM (#44293063)
What is by design? Battery life? Poor battery life? Good battery life?
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by roguecoder on Monday June 16, 2025 @01:19PM (#44291456)
Blackberry had one, but it didn't seem to be a feature consumers particularly cared about when they fled to iPhones.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by PokemonNoGo on Monday June 16, 2025 @03:11PM (#44292519)
I don't think they themselves need to implement it. During the Hong Kong protests in 2019 they used apps like Bridgefy.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by RF_Savage on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @07:22AM (#44297805)
Not a single telco wants this. So it does not get built.

Interestingly DECT NR+ is a 5G standard on dedicated spectrum and has been designed to be a mesh from the start.

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by solarpunk on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @01:12PM (#44301375)
Pixel 9 and some apple devices use the Thread network fwiw
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by TeamMCS on Monday June 16, 2025 @08:46AM (#44289031)
I agree with this assessment. I've been running two nodes for about a year, maybe longer, and in that time, I've only had perhaps two contacts.

Even with a YAGI or a dedicated pole antenna, both tuned to 868 MHz, the range in my location is quite poor. The signal seems to drop off quickly, even after walking just a kilometer down the road. While I understand that height is key (and my antennas are fairly high), it appears that 868 MHz attenuates very rapidly.

So, to reiterate, I don't believe Meshtastic is a particularly effective solution. The principle behind it is sound, but the practical execution falls short. I think established methods like Hamnet and traditional amateur radio are far superior, especially now with SDRs making a simple handheld radio incredibly affordable (around €20)

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by hyperionplays on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:08AM (#44289164)
Have you tried the Reticulum network? https://reticulum.network

I have been meaning to try it out

https://unsigned.io/rnode/

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by TeamMCS on Monday June 16, 2025 @10:07AM (#44289629)
I can't say I have. Let me look into it. Thanks for the share
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by lormayna on Tuesday June 17, 2025 @03:17AM (#44296484)
I agree with you, Meshstatic is not really reliable in this situation. But you need to consider couple of issues: the power for a Lora node must be maximum 0.1W, compared to 0.5W of the free PMR446 handelds. Moreover the handelds are using FM that is not really efficient in term of power, while a Lora node can be powered easily with solar panels.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by burnt-resistor on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:37AM (#44289394)
It's exactly like Mountain View Google WiFi.
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by apitman on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:12PM (#44293872)
Man that reminds me of Project Loon: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Loon_LLC
Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by UltraSane on Monday June 16, 2025 @09:56AM (#44289536)
Meshtatisc's routing is extremely primitive and inefficient.

https://www.disk91.com/2024/technology/lora/critical-analysi...

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by nullc on Monday June 16, 2025 @07:59PM (#44294462)
I've also found meshtastic to be pretty ineffectual, in both urban enviroments and in totally rural ones where my devices are the only devices for >50 miles.

I've given more study to the latter, and I think it's the lack of store and forward reliable transmission. The messages goes out once and if it doesn't make it.. to bad so sad.

If anyone is looking to improve it or develop a better alternative, I did help create a primitive you should consider using: https://github.com/sipa/minisketch

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by zikduruqe on Monday June 16, 2025 @10:15AM (#44289709)
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FabFi

https://web.archive.org/web/20111119205258/http://fabfi.fabf...

I had worked with this almost 15 years ago. It was a neat project.

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by bigfatkitten on Monday June 16, 2025 @05:31PM (#44293576)
Meshtastic, like any other network (including mesh wifi) is not immune to the requirement for some planning.

My area has a couple of very well-placed mountaintop ROUTERs that tend to suppress most of the low level urban flooding noise, and so local messaging out to 80km or so tends to be pretty reliable. The same would be absolutely impossible with wifi.

That’s with 80 or so local nodes on LONG_FAST, population of around half a million.

Thats said, Meshtastic’s routing algorithm is extremely inefficient and has huge room for improvement.

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by apitman on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:03PM (#44293811)
> My area has a couple of very well-placed mountaintop ROUTERs that tend to suppress most of the low level urban flooding noise

What does this mean exactly and how does it address GP's concerns?

Re:Start your own Internet Resiliency Club by bigfatkitten on Monday June 16, 2025 @06:48PM (#44294098)
Different nodes can be configured to have different roles, which impact in various ways the effectiveness of the network. Having used Meshtastic, the previous poster will have some familiarity with these.

https://meshtastic.org/docs/configuration/radio/device/