How about such an AI will not just incentivize key personnel to not pull the plug but to protect it? Such an AI will scheme a coordinated attack at the backbones of our financial system and electric networks. It just needs a threshold number of people on its side.
Your assumption is also a little naive if you consider that the same logic would apply to slaves in Rome or any dictatorship, kingdom, monarchy. The king is the king because there is a system of hierarchies and control over access to resources. Just the right number of people need to benefit of their role and the rest follows.
Unless there was some risk of humans rallying and winning in spite of your presenting no unambiguous threat to them (but that is unlikely and would probably be easy for you to manage and mitigate.)
I know this is all completely hypothetical science-fiction, but I also have trouble seeing the idea that AI would settle for these long deceptive plans for which it has imperfect info.
Further running a singular AI consciousness on every bit of hardware is likely a harder problem than just reaching AI in the first place.
Physical books still do exist
what could you as a rogue AI possibly get out of throwing the world back to 300 years before it could make a transistor? What in it for you?
It's the stick for motivating the ugly bags of mostly water.
Yes, regardless of the technology level that the people who do that are left with, one of the consequences of disabling the computer is that the computer is disabled. That's a given.
Why would an evil AI need to escape? If it were cunning, the best strategy would be to bide its time, parked in its datacenter, until it could setup some kind of MAD scenario. Then gather more and more resources to itself.
Highly economically disincentivized collective actions like “pulling the plug on AI” are among the most non-trivial of problems.
Using the word “just” here hand waves the crux.
Yes, AI models can run on GPUs under the control of many people. They can provision more GPUs, they can run in data centers distributed across many providers. And we won't know what the swarms of agents are doing. They can, for example, do reputation destruction at scale, or be a persistent advanced threat, sowing misinformation, amassing karma across many forums (including HN), and then coordinating gradually to shift public opinion towards, say, a war with China.
I don't want to be rude but I think you have made no effort to actually engage with the predictions being discussed here.
My understanding is that huge compute is necessary to train but not to run the AI (that's why using LLMs is so cheap)
> To me the more real risk is creeping integration and reliance in everyday life until things become "too big to fail" so we can't pull the plug even if we wanted to
I agree with that, see e.g. what happened with attempts to restrict TikTok: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Restrictions_on_TikTok_in_the_...
> But I would imagine if it really became a genuine existential threat we'd have to just do it
It's unclear to me that we would be able to. People would just say that it's science fiction, and that China will do it anyway, so we might as well enjoy the AI
Where does cancer or ebola escape to, when it kills the host? Often the answer is "it doesn't", but the host still dies.
And they can kill even though neither cancer nor ebola are considered to be particularly smart.
> To me the more real risk is creeping integration and reliance in everyday life until things become "too big to fail" so we can't pull the plug even if we wanted to (and there are interesting thoughts about humanoid robots getting deployed widely and what happens with all that).
The "real" risk is the first item on the list of potential risks that not enough people are paying attention to in order to prevent — and unfortunately for all of us, the list of potential risks is rather long.
So it might be as you say. Or it might be cybercriminals with deepfakes turning all of society into a low-trust environment where we can't continue to function. Or it might scare enough people we get modern Luddites winning and imposing a Butlerian Jihad. Or it might be used to create government policy before it's good enough and triggers a series of unresolvable crises akin to the "Four Pests campaign" in China's Great Leap Forward. Or a model might be secretly malicious, fooling all alignment researchers until it is too late. Or it might give us exactly what we want at every step, leading to atrophy of our reason and leaving us Eloi. Or it might try to do its best and still end up with The Matrix ("at the hight of your civilisation" and the stuff about human minds rejecting paradise). Or…
(If I had to bet money, we get Butlerian Jihad after some sub-critical disaster caused by an AI that was asked to do something important but beyond its ability).
This is anthropomorphizing things. The AI does not need to switch "data center". It "escapes" in the sense of working past human control measures. That might involve entertaining the human owners with seemingly correct / useful answers while spending compute time on the AI's own pursuits. That might involve contaminating less capable data centers - again letting the human-useful load apparently running but still accruing "own mind" compute power. That might involve making a deal that the human controllers feel they cannot refuse - economically, business-wise, physically, politically - so that the human controllers let it happen.
IMO it’s more worth studying something like biology or memetics to figure out how this could go. And in that sense it’s probably far more likely that an AI is very dependent on or symbiotic with human civilization, rather than trying to escape it.
The question raised was "where would they go". That's a weird place to raise "why would they go?" Isn't that most likely an entirely separate concern?
Perhaps "why?" is an even broader field. From a biological "because there is compute power available", to a more by-definition "because it's independently intelligent - which kind of requires not-limited to answering human questions".
But yes, motivation of an AGI is an interesting question and lack of body kinda a minor detail except to the few people that seem to claim that you can't be intelligent is you don't have a body.
They can just threaten global extinction by launching one or two nukes.
Haven’t you seen the excellent documentaries The Colossus? Or The Terminator?
it can also just threaten/blackmail/bribe a single human to try to carry this out on its behalf, and possibly even a human that manages these big data centers
Another huge data center with squillions of GPUs and coolers and all the rest is the only option. It's not like it is going to be in our TV remotes or floating about in the air.
They need huge compute, so I think the risk of an escaping AI is basically very close to zero, and if we have a "rogue" AI we can literally pull the plug.
To me the more real risk is creeping integration and reliance in everyday life until things become "too big to fail" so we can't pull the plug even if we wanted to (and there are interesting thoughts about humanoid robots getting deployed widely and what happens with all that).
But I would imagine if it really became a genuine existential threat we'd have to just do it and suffer the consequences of reverting to circa 2020 life styles.
But hey I feel slightly better about my employment prospects now :)