I agree the GOP is being hypocritical. But I think a lot of other people are hypocritical in the opposite direction.
> that states should be allowed to regulate AI, but should not be allowed to regulate health?
To rephrase this:
States should be allowed to regulate both AI and health, or neither.
This is not my argument, but I do intend it to be a good faith interpretation of what I think OP had in mind.
Either/or is a somewhat confusing phrasing due the way it causes sentences to become hard to follow, and because it can refer to two different concepts. I think most of the time and in this case, either/or refers to exclusive or, but it can also refer to logical disjunction.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Either%2For
However, it's possible that they meant logical disjunction, in the sense that the GOP doesn't think that states' rights to regulate AI and health should be an either/or distinction simply in order to not be hypocritical, because the GOP sees no problem with legislation and lawfare to achieve the goals of the GOP; the GOP will use arguments that may be lacking ideological justification or consistency out of pragmatism.
The ends don't justify the means in this GOP reading, but rather, the means are the ends: states' rights as a concept can be a means to a particular end legally or legislatively, and an end unto itself as a way to preserve bastion states of GOP rule and jurisprudence during periods of non-GOP federal power.
So when you said "I think a lot of other people are hypocritical in the opposite direction" did you mean that Democrats focus too much on ideological justification and consistency instead of being pragmatic, or that their ideological focus on justification and consistency leads them to "play by the rules" against a pragmatic GOP opponent that isn't themselves bound by such notions?
>So when you said "I think a lot of other people are hypocritical in the opposite direction" did you mean that Democrats focus too much on ideological justification and consistency instead of being pragmatic, or that their ideological focus on justification and consistency leads them to "play by the rules" against a pragmatic GOP opponent that isn't themselves bound by such notions?
Neither.
When I said that sentence, I was replying to mixologist. I thought mixologist was saying that it's inconsistent for the GOP to promote states rights for women's regulation health but not for AI regulation. I was saying that if that's an inconsistency, then there's a similar inconsistency (but in the opposite direction) with people who promote states rights for AI regulation but not for women's health regulation, and I thought that was the position mixologist held.
Maybe I misunderstood what mixologist was saying. If mixologist was saying something else, then my comment doesn't make much sense.
> When I said that sentence, I was replying to mixologist. I thought mixologist was saying that it's inconsistent for the GOP to promote states rights for women's regulation health but not for AI regulation.
But if the GOP just wants to win and doesn’t care about hypocrisy or ideological consistency then this doesn’t matter, as I alluded to. Your point might have responded to mixologist but not to me.
Thanks for clarifying your point, though.
"The other people" are saying abortion bans harm women physically and are removing their freedom. They are saying AI should be regulated in certain way.
None of that is hypocritical. It is not even opposite direction.
You seem to be fine with allowing states to regulate AI, but not abortion. So either you disagree with mixologist, or I misunderstood mixologist. If mixologist wasn't making that point, then my previous comment doesn't make sense.
>GOP does hide behind states rights when it suits them.
It's an interesting situation. Prior to 2024, the GOP's policy was that abortion should be banned at the federal level. Trump disagreed with that, and in 2024, Trump convinced the GOP to change policy, and defer it to the states[1].
AIUI, the previous policy was based on the idea that abortion is morally wrong due to killing a person, and thus should be banned. I think the new policy is based on the idea that abortion is a moral uncertainty: the GOP doesn't know whether the fetus is a person or not, so it's unclear whether abortion is morally wrong or not, and because it's unclear, there shouldn't be a federal decision one way or the other on it, it should be deferred to the states. You could call that "hiding behind states rights", or you could call it "deferring unclear issues to the local level instead of making sweeping laws on unclear issues".
AIUI, the GOP's policy on AI is different. The GOP doesn't think AI has the same moral uncertainty as abortion does. Instead, the GOP views AI under an economic lens, not a moral lens. And under an economic lens, consistent laws across the states help economically.
[1] https://apnews.com/article/republicans-abortion-party-platfo...
But, data and algorithms don’t stop at state lines so national standards would be more effective. We don’t know if a standards or policy setting org is looking at it not. I hope so
“Is it your opinion that states should be allowed to regulate AI, but should not be allowed to regulate health?”
I'm fine with you providing your answer to the question. In my reply I just wanted to make sure that it's clear that your answer is only your answer, not mixologist's answer, because I think you disagree with mixologist.
Everyone else is excuses as paper thin as a kid trying to get a cookie
Odd way of phrasing it.
"that woman's health" (which woman are we talking about?) is quite different from "that women's health".
The reason they said abortion law should be a state issue is they knew they couldn't get a federal abortion ban. By making it a state issue they ensure they get to at least ban abortion in half the country rather than none of the country.
By now they probably can get a federal abortion ban, though, so I expect them to do that sooner or later. Don't expect consistency from their public statements - "abortion should be up to the states" will simply be memory-holed.
That’s the reason it is different for the GOP
"States' rights" has only ever been used as a smokescreen. The original "states' rights" argument was a cover for slavery. More recently, it's been a cover for other far-right reactionary positions specifically during center-left administrations that would otherwise seek to impose regulations preventing them from oppressing people at the state level.
AI is not being "protected" this way because it's Just Too Important To Leave To The States; it's being protected because Musk and other mega-wealthy Silicon Valley types have pushed to exempt it from all regulation. (Notice that this bill does nothing to regulate AI at the federal level, nor is there any particular proposal to do so from the people pushing for this clause!)
Let’s look at it differently though: even if the federal preemption push is cynical, is there still a valid, public-interest reason to avoid fragmented AI regulation?
That’s the only place your argument could be stress-tested: not in exposing the hypocrisy.
But there isn’t an introduction of like AI ethics rules or policy or directing a federal agency to establish any so that’s a valid criticism. What if we take the viewpoint that they are trying to get there?
Because if they were trying to harmonize AI regulations then they would do it federally instead of just banning states from doing anything. (Federal regulations generally trump state regulations, at least wherever the state regulation is weaker or absent.)
I don't see why there would be any more pressing reasons than for other fields, say climate or energy regulation (looking at you, Texas) or of course the classic: personal choices of sexuality and reproduction. Yet no one is trying to ban state laws there, on the contrary.
Notably, it was a hypocritical dishonest mess from the very beginning. For example, slavers used federal power to force other states to allow violent crimes inside their territory, and later the Confederacy's Constitution forever banned member states' rights to not have slavery.
On your illustration about abortion: the same people who wanted national vaccine mandates now want AI to be left up to the individual states? The same people that defend the Department of Education’s national influence over public schools are now states rights advocates when it suits their agenda? There is hypocrisy on all sides.
The media and pundits frame budget reconciliation thusly: When Republicans do it, it’s a “threat to Democracy” when Democrats do it, it’s “protecting democracy.” As a practical matter an AI federal law shouldn’t be in a budget bill: it should go through the normal lawmaking process. But there are a lot of things that don’t belong in a budget bill that end up there. The process is rotten.
Democrats and Republicans use federalism as it suits their agenda. Let’s not be surprised anymore. Democrats typically support strong central governments — until they aren’t the majority in Washington. Then they become fervent supporters of the strong states rights used by the Confederacy to justify slavery. When they have power in Washington, they’re now Abraham Lincoln. And vice versa. When Florida wants to strongly enforce immigration law, blue states sue. When California doesn’t want to follow immigration law, that’s somehow heroic? Some states have even passed laws prohibiting law enforcement from following federal laws while simultaneous accepting federal funding for their law enforcement then suing when those funds are withheld.
My basic view is this: there are enumerated powers, the Commerce Clause and the 10th Amendment. Let’s use those to decide who should be doing what.
We can (and should) disagree on the issues, but it would be delightful if we could at least all follow the same processes.
Drug laws: unless you’re crossing a state line, state. Immigration: federal (Commerce Clause) AI: states — until there is an interstate commerce nexus (i.e. data centers, internet)
By the way the author laments the budget reconciliation process for AI laws, but that same process was used to pass Obamacare. Is using reconciliation acceptable when it suits one’s agenda? Again: hypocrisy on all sides.
The Constitution already covers this stuff, if anyone bothers to follow it. The constitution has been bent and beaten to within an inch of its life. We need to push back on that even if it results in outcomes we might not like in the short term.
Abortion protection should exist at a federal level because it's healthcare. If a pregnant woman is traveling and has an emergency that requires an abortion she should be able to receive one regardless of what state she's in.
Vaccine mandates are a federal issue because the virus doesn't give a shit about state lines and right of movement is a thing neither states nor the federal government can restrict.
AI is a state issue because it can be contained within a particular state. It works like pornography bans. If you are in a state that bans pornography you can't distribute it nor consume it regardless of whether it originated on a computer outside the state.
Marijuana should be a state issue for the same reason. Whether you're allowed to import it from outside the country or if you move your marijuana from a legal state to an illegal state is a federal issue. Whether states that ban it should have to respect medical cards is a federal issue.
Education is a federal issue because the state has an interest in children getting a quality public education even if they move.
Nobody is all federal or all states rights. To do so would literally be unamerican.
I think the first amendment preserves the right to read and write, including arbitrary computer programs, dare I even say pornographic ones. I agree the rest of your post though.
Weird priorities.