News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Behind Silicon Valley and the GOP’s campaign to ban state... by Spivak on Saturday May 17, 2025 @07:11AM (#44013453)
I think you're inventing a hypocrisy that doesn't really exist.

Abortion protection should exist at a federal level because it's healthcare. If a pregnant woman is traveling and has an emergency that requires an abortion she should be able to receive one regardless of what state she's in.

Vaccine mandates are a federal issue because the virus doesn't give a shit about state lines and right of movement is a thing neither states nor the federal government can restrict.

AI is a state issue because it can be contained within a particular state. It works like pornography bans. If you are in a state that bans pornography you can't distribute it nor consume it regardless of whether it originated on a computer outside the state.

Marijuana should be a state issue for the same reason. Whether you're allowed to import it from outside the country or if you move your marijuana from a legal state to an illegal state is a federal issue. Whether states that ban it should have to respect medical cards is a federal issue.

Education is a federal issue because the state has an interest in children getting a quality public education even if they move.

Nobody is all federal or all states rights. To do so would literally be unamerican.

Re:Behind Silicon Valley and the GOP’s campaign to ban state... by aspenmayer on Sunday May 18, 2025 @08:31AM (#44020900)
> AI is a state issue because it can be contained within a particular state. It works like pornography bans. If you are in a state that bans pornography you can't distribute it nor consume it regardless of whether it originated on a computer outside the state.

I think the first amendment preserves the right to read and write, including arbitrary computer programs, dare I even say pornographic ones. I agree the rest of your post though.