News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by _heimdall on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:21AM (#43936430)
Unpopular opinion I'm sure, but I very much quantum today as smoke and mirrors. I've tried to dive down that rabbit hole and I keep finding myself in a sea of theoretical mathematics that seems to fall into the "give me one miracle" category.

I expect this won't be the last time we hear about quantum research that has been foundational to a lot of work turns out to have been manipulated, or designed poorly and unverified by other research labs.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by AndrewStephens on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:55AM (#43936800)
In 2001, a pure quantum computer using Shor's algorithm correctly gave the prime factors of 15. In 2012 they managed to find the prime factors of 21. Since then, everyone has given up on the purely quantum approach by using lots of traditional CPU-time to preprocess the input, somewhat defeating the purpose.

Its a shame. I was really looking forward to finding out what the prime factors of 34 are.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by JohnKemeny on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:15AM (#43937036)
If I understand correctly, they didn't actually find the prime factors, they merely verified them, so it's unfortunately up to you to factor 34. Maybe some time in the future a quantum machine can verify whether you were right.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by teekert on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:19AM (#43937081)
It's 2 and 17, I asked Claude.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by AndrewStephens on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:32AM (#43937229)
AI can do that now? Looks like I have to upgrade all of my 5-bit SSL keys.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by xxs on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:12AM (#43937698)
>5-bit SSL keys.

34 requires 6 bits, though

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by Bootvis on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:15AM (#43937721)
Hence the urgency.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by Lionga on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:23AM (#43937129)
Not sure if it was more wasteful of energy asking Claude or trying to solve it with Quantum.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by solardev on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:55AM (#43937476)
A twelve year old could do it for 500 kcal of cookies.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by tomashubelbauer on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:15AM (#43937723)
I volunteer as a tribute
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by solardev on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:17PM (#43941829)
The twelve year old would probably be too full and tired after eating you to do any math.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by dontlaugh on Saturday May 10, 2025 @07:06AM (#43944740)
Humans are typically paid for their labour after they have performed it.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by pfdietz on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:22PM (#43938544)
Reminds me of the Groucho Marx line: "A child of five could understand this. Send someone to fetch a child of five."
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by RHSeeger on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:42AM (#43938091)
We could ask Claude to generate the schematics for a quantum computer that can find the prime factors of 21. Then we get the best of both worlds.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by rbanffy on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:22AM (#43937820)
At least quantum computers are cool.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by _heimdall on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:37PM (#43943038)
I believe it was both at the same time, until you check the monthly bill at which point you forced one to become more wasteful.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by dreamcompiler on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:46PM (#43941992)
Gemini told me it was -12 and pi.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by xxs on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:15AM (#43937734)
The infamous 21 (which is half of 42) was my 1st thought when I heard 'unpopular' which is of course a very popular opinion.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by thesz on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:06PM (#43939009)
https://eprint.iacr.org/2015/1018.pdf

"As pointed out in [57], there has never been a genuine implementation of Shor’s algorithm. The only numbers ever to have been factored by that type of algorithm are 15 and 21, and those factorizations used a simplified version of Shor’s algorithm that requires one to know the factorization in advance..."

If you have a clue what these factors are, you can build an implementation of Shor's algorithm for them, I guess.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by EvgeniyZh on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:41PM (#43939310)
There was for this year's sigbovik [1]

[1] https://fixupx.com/CraigGidney/status/1907199729362186309

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by bwfan123 on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:28AM (#43937185)
What amazes me is how big tech wants to be in on this bandwagon. There is fomo, and each company announces its own chip that does something - and nobody knows what. The risk of inaction is bigger than the risk of failure.

Meanwhile, a networking company wants to "network" these chips - what does that even mean ? And a gpu company produces a library for computing with quantum.

Smoke-and-mirrors can carry on for a long time, and fool the best of them. Isaac Newton was in on the alchemist bandwagon.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by cjbgkagh on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:42AM (#43937332)
AFAIK, in the case of Microsoft, it's less FOMO and more about execs being able to impress their peers at other companies. So not really a fear of missing out but a desire to have an exclusive access to a technology that has already been socialized and widely understood to be impressive. It's a simple message, 'that impressive thing you've been reading about, we're the ones building that'.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by jhallenworld on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:13PM (#43938437)
Also: the big company "thought leaders" need something new to talk about every year at conferences like "Microsoft Ignite" or whatever. These people will push funding into things like quantum research just for this. I'm sure they're getting lots of mileage out of LLMs these days...

I'm maybe a little jaded having worked on whole products that had no market success, but were in fact just so that the company had something new to talk about.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by shalg on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:26AM (#43937875)
There are exactly 2 reasons we might want quantum networks.

1. 100% secure communication channels (even better we can detect any attempt at eavesdropping and whatever information is captured will be useless to the eavesdropper)

2. Building larger quantum computers. A high fidelity quantum network would allow you to compute simultaneously with multiple quantum chips by interfacing them.

The thing that makes quantum networking different from regular networking is that you have to be very careful to not disturb the state of the photons you are sending down the fiber optics.

Im currently doing my PhD building quantum networking devices so im a bit biased but I think it’s pretty cool :).

Now does it matter I’m not sure. Reason 1 isn’t really that useful because encryption is very secure. However if quantum computers start to scale up and some encryption methods get obsoleted this could be nice. Also having encryption that is provably secure would be nice regardless.

Reason 2 at the moment seems like the only path to building large scale quantum computing. Think a datacenter with many networked quantum chips.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by nativeit on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:11PM (#43938422)
> 100% secure communication channels (even better we can detect any attempt at eavesdropping and whatever information is captured will be useless to the eavesdropper) chips. A few follow up questions:

1. What is it about quantum computers that can guarantee 100% secure communication channels?

2. If the communications are 100% secure, why are we worried about eavesdropping?

3. If it can detect eavesdropping, why do we need to concern ourselves with the information they might see/hear? Just respond to the detection.

4. What is it about quantum computing that would make an eavesdroppers’ overheard information useless to them, without also obviating said information to the intended recipients?

This is where the language used to discuss this topic turns into word salad for me. None of the things you said necessarily follow from the things that were said before them, but rather just levied as accepted fact.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by foota on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:27PM (#43939204)
Sorry, but I think the way you're phrasing this implies a burden on them to explain well understood and widely accepted principles of quantum physics that you seem to be implying are pseudoscience.

This seems like a decent overview if you want to learn more: https://www.chalmers.se/en/centres/wacqt/discover-quantum-te....

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by _heimdall on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:42PM (#43943056)
From the source you linked

> According to the laws of quantum physics, it is impossible to measure or copy an unknown state of a quantum particle without noticeably changing it.

That alone is a very clear description of how quantum mechanics is pseudoscience. Its based entirely on an untestable principle. When the initial state can't be measured because doing so changes the state we are left entirely unable to run a controlled study on it. You must know Tue state before and after an intervention to reliably and accurately deduce what happened or to begin to understand why it happened.

This is the one miracle that we must grant to allow the rest of quantum research to become possible.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by immibis on Saturday May 10, 2025 @05:06PM (#43948996)
No, it's all well-defined science. There's known mathematics for how the operations you do affect the probability distribution of the answer. The initial state can be prepared. It can't be measured after it's been prepared, because that would ruin it. But so what - that happens all the time in science. Your comment is like saying chemistry is a pseudoscience because if we put a pH indicator strip in before doing a certain reaction to prove it's an acid, the contamination by the indicator chemical stops the reaction from working.

We can simulate a quantum computer using a normal computer (in exponential time). Simulations of tiny quantum computers agree with the experiments using tiny quantum computers. We can also simulate less-tiny (but still pretty small because it takes exponential time) quantum computers. But we haven't built an actual one of those yet. It seems they're really hard to build But also no fundamental reason is known why it should be impossible to build one. Shouldn't it just be the same as a tiny one, but bigger? The tiny ones were hard enough to build, so maybe it's just really hard and we need better techniques.

Perhaps it will turn out to be a failed branch of science that leads to no practical applications, but it's certainly real science, studying real things and making testable predictions (which are true so far). I suppose your next objection will be that since we only have tiny quantum computers, non-tiny problems are pseudoscience, but that's like saying particle physics was pseudoscience before we built the Large Hadron Collider.

Recently 3Blue1Brown made a video attempting to explain Grover's algorithm, which is one of the main applications of quantum computing, that also covers basic ideas of quantum computing and some common misconceptions - have you seen it yet? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RQWpF2Gb-gU and followup: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Dlsa9EBKDGI

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by _heimdall on Saturday May 10, 2025 @08:48PM (#43950281)
You're describing a field based on simulations and predictions. That is interesting, but it isn't scientific as you aren't actually testing anything when you only run simulations.

A simulation is an interesting indicator for future scientific research, but it is never scientific research in and of itself.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by immibis on Sunday May 11, 2025 @02:54AM (#43951933)
When your predictions are testable and agree with reality you did science.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by SAI_Peregrinus on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:36PM (#43939272)
1. Nothing. Quantum Key Distribution is what they're talking about, and it still requires P!=NP because there's a classical cryptographic step involved (several, actually). It just allows you to exchange symmetric keys with a party you've used classical cryptography to authenticate, it's vulnerable to MITM attacks otherwise. So you're dependent on classical signatures and PKI to authenticate the endpoints. And you're exchanging classical symmetric keys, so still dependent on the security of classical encryption like AES-GCM.

2. Because they're not 100% secure. Only the key exchange step with an authenticated endpoint is 100% secure.

3. Eavesdropping acts like a denial of service and breaks all communications on the channel.

4. It makes the information useless to everyone, both the eavesdropper and the recipients. Attempting to eavesdrop on a QKD channel randomizes the transmitted data. It's a DOS attack. The easier DOS attack is to break the fiber-optic cable transmitting the light pulses, since every endpoint needs a dedicated fiber to connect to every other endpoint.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by staunton on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:46PM (#43941208)
> Only the key exchange step with an authenticated endpoint is 100% secure.

It's 100% secure in theory, assuming a model of the hardware (which is impossible to verify even if you could build it to "perfectly" satisfy all model assumptions, which of course you also can't).

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by SAI_Peregrinus on Sunday May 11, 2025 @09:35AM (#43953735)
Yeah, the key exchange portion is secure. The resulting shared secret in RAM, on the other hand, is only as secure as the computer it's on. The moment you're out of the quantum realm by measuring the exchanged quanta, you lose the 100% security guarantee of the quantum portion of the key exchange. The Q part of QKD is actually secure, it's just that it's also useless and QKD as a whole exists mostly to fleece investors. It's a nerdy party trick, not a serious security mechanism.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by staunton on Sunday May 11, 2025 @10:40AM (#43954156)
There is no such thing as a magical "quantum realm". Devices performing quantum state preparation or measurements are just devices. They aren't perfect and can never be made to "100%" satisfy any assumptions.

The Q part is secure in theory, assuming your devices satisfy a specific theoretical model. That's not a 100% guarantee. In fact, it's just the same kind of guarantee as we get for any other security system: "We carefully examined the system and it seems like it satisfies the assumptions of our theoretical model, thus promising security".

Not that this is a bad thing, it's just that "quantum" doesn't make anything "magically 100% secure". There's no such thing as "100% security".

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by SAI_Peregrinus on Sunday May 11, 2025 @08:59PM (#43958673)
Yeah, I should have specified "the photon packet in the fiber" instead of generic "quantum", but there isn't always actually a photon packet even when light is the medium, and there isn't always a fiber, and just mashing it all up as "quantum" was faster. Any interference with the actual stuff that's doing the information exchange will cause the communication to fail, so that one part of the system can't be eavesdropped on passively.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by nativeit on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:05PM (#43938363)
I feel like most of your answer was just re-stating the question. I’m happy to admit that’s almost certainly a mix of my ignorance on the topic at hand, and I have been primed to view the discussions surrounding quantum computing with suspicion, but either way, that’s the way it reads to this layperson.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by chatmasta on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:06PM (#43938366)
If studio execs have their way, Quantum DRM will be the killer use case…
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by autoexec on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:23PM (#43939696)
Jokes on them, we'll just end up creating and using quantum pirating systems or even the dreaded Quantum Analog Hole to evade it.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by thesz on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:22PM (#43939158)
What is the difference between channel error or distortion and eavesdropping?
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by staunton on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:48PM (#43941224)
For eavesdropping, there is someone there who cares about what you're sending and is successfully learning things about it.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by thesz on Saturday May 10, 2025 @06:20AM (#43944536)
How can one quantumly differentiate between photon lost due to eavesdropping and photon lost due to some other error?
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by staunton on Sunday May 11, 2025 @06:54AM (#43952911)
Other than by going around and finding the eavesdropper sitting somewhere, one cannot.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by mepian on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:39AM (#43937296)
It is really desperation, the low-hanging fruit of computing paradigm shifts to fuel the "tech" industry's growth was completely plucked more than a decade ago.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by sharpshadow on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:34PM (#43938656)
It’s not only big tech. Since months I’m reading about joint venture types between companies of European countries with state sponsoring in QC. When you follow the path there are a bundle of fresh created companies in every country each claiming a branch like quantum communication, quantum encryption, quantum this.. all working together and cooperating with the same companies in other EU countries.

Still trying to figure out what is going on. Are they preposition for the upcoming breakthroughs and until then it will be like the beginning in AI where many claimed to have it but actually just pretended. Additionally they likely want to access the money flow.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by no_wizard on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:57PM (#43939958)
>Isaac Newton was in on the alchemist bandwagon

An often overlooked or unmentioned fact too!

I think its a shame, because it humanizes the (for lack of a better term) smartest people in history to know these things about them.

Yes, Newton invented calculus, but he also tried to turn lead into gold!

So you too, might be able to do something novel, is the idea.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by BlueTemplar on Sunday May 11, 2025 @06:56AM (#43952912)
Let's not forget that the cutting edge of modern science included alchemy at that time : one of the purposes for which the first thermostat was invented was to control alchemical fires.

Or how the "perpetual motion machine" (by the same guy, Cornelis Drebbel) led to barometers and the discovery of atmospheric pressure. (Also connected to astrology because astrologers were the ones making predictions, including of weather.)

EDIT : bonus soundtrack : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Jy99ywCp3qU

(> it is only a small subset of this song, a fully differentiable song will come in the future)

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by rowanG077 on Sunday May 11, 2025 @07:46PM (#43958254)
I think it's kinda disingenuous to look at people of the past like that. I expect the exact same curiosity for the unknown and intelligence that allowed Isaac Newton to crack calculus was also the driver for him entering alchemy. The only difference looking back is that one was correct and the other wasn't. Something that no one knew for sure at the time. It's like looking back to the stone age and laughing at the cave men "look how stupid they were why don't they just do X".
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by gaze on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:11PM (#43938427)
Pessimistically I think it's most comparable to fusion. Theoretically possible but very difficult. I'm biased because I'm in the industry, but nothing has cropped up that I've seen that requires a miracle.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by naasking on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:16PM (#43938476)
> I'm biased because I'm in the industry, but nothing has cropped up that I've seen that requires a miracle.

Scaling is itself the open question. Gravitational effects start creeping in when you scale up sensitive entangled systems and we don't have a good understanding of how gravity interacts with entanglement. Entangled systems above a certain size may just be impossible.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by cwillu on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:59PM (#43942888)
That would itself be a tremendous theoretical breakthrough for all of physics.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by shrubble on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:14PM (#43939622)
The difference is that whenever it’s daytime and there aren’t many clouds in the sky, you can see an example of fusion working at scale…
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by krastanov on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:25PM (#43940178)
And every time you use a transistor, observe a green plant living, or see that your hand does not pass through the table when you tap it, you see quantum mechanical effects working at scale. Every time you use a telescope, you see quantum information processing (interference) at scale. The control over that process is the difficult part, same as with fusion.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by walleeee on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:21PM (#43940545)
Transistors, plants, hands, and tables are all macroscopic. We see quantum mechanical effects, but we do not see stable superpositions. None of these real-world examples seem to shield a quantum state from decoherence in the way a quantum computer needs to. The sun demonstrates clearly that fusion is controllable (albeit in a regime we struggle to match). I don't think your examples show that a quantum state can be controlled at the scale we need it to be, and I don't know of any extant phenomena that do. But I am no expert, yell at me if I'm wrong.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by krastanov on Friday May 09, 2025 @05:59PM (#43941311)
On the contrary, we have plenty of examples of long-lived (many hours, days, or more) examples of superposition in many solid state materials and chemical systems. For a quantum computer you need both (1) something that can retain superposition and (2) be easily controllable. Point 2 is the difficult one, because if you can control it (interact with it), the "environment" can interact with it and destroy it as well.

All of the examples of macroscopic effects above are possible thanks to effects explainable only through the existence of superposition. It is just that they are not particularly controllable and thus not of interest for storing quantum information.

Another fun point: the example you are focusing on, fusion happening in the sun, is only possible due to the quantum tunneling effect, which is itself dependent on "superposition" being a real thing. Looking past the clouds at our star is already an example of quantum mechanics working, which is very much an experimental observation of an effect possible only thanks to the existence of superposition.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by walleeee on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:26PM (#43942992)
Thanks, I'll stand partially corrected. It was a badly written comment, or muddled thoughts, or both. I didn't mean to doubt the existence of superposition or our ability to achieve it for sustained periods.

But doesn't the point stand? I meant to say that none of the examples seem to demonstrate both 1) and 2). Do we know of any natural system which can maintain and precisely manipulate a quantum state like a quantum computer needs to?

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by immibis on Saturday May 10, 2025 @05:19PM (#43949088)
Well no, but we also don't know any natural system that does fusion using an amount of material smaller than about a billion billion billion tonnes. Getting from A (what we know works) to B (what we'd like to work) is the hard problem. That's called research.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by _heimdall on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:46PM (#43943068)
In don't think the argument is whether nuclear fusion is possible at all. The question is whether it is possible to reliably control it and whether Tue captured energy output will be worth the inputs required to run the system.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by _heimdall on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:10PM (#43940053)
Quantum state is the miracle in my opinion. By definition it can never really be confirmed.

You cannot observe the initial state because that collapses the super position. Said more simply, we can only see the end result and make educated guesses as to how it happened and what the state was prior to the experiment.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by gaze on Sunday May 11, 2025 @01:27PM (#43955314)
There's plenty of valid criticisms of the quantum computing industry but the idea that quantum mechanics is whole-cloth invalid is nonsense. You can absolutely verify a quantum state through tomography
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by baxtr on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:32AM (#43937948)
I was also skeptical until Sabine recently changed her mind in one of her videos, citing the latest advancements in photonic quantum computing as the reason.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by yesbut on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:40AM (#43936626)
It is all a scam. The research side is interesting for what it is, but the idea of having any type of useful "quantum computer" is sci-fi make believe. The grifters will keep stringing investors and these large corporations along for as long as possible. Total waste of resources.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by cess11 on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:51AM (#43936750)
IBM has given the public access to qubits for close to a decade, including a free tier, and as far as I know it produced a stream of research articles that fizzled out several years ago and nothing generally useful.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBM_Quantum_Platform

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by roflmaostc on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:49AM (#43936710)
Why do you think so?

Your words sounds like what people said in the 40s and 50s about computers.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by os2warpman on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:54AM (#43937466)
In the 40s and 50s programmable general-purpose electronic computers were solving problems.

Ballistics tables, decryption of enemy messages, and more. Early programmable general-purpose electronic computers, from the moment they were turned on could solve problems in minutes that would take human computers months or years. In the 40s, ENIAC proved the feasibility of thermonuclear weaponry.

By 1957 the promise and peril of computing entered popular culture with the Spencer Tracy and Katharine Hepburn film "Desk Set" where a computer is installed in a library and runs amok, firing everybody, all while romantic shenanigans occur. It was sponsored by IBM and is one of the first instances of product placement in films.

People knew "electronic brains" were the future the second they started spitting out printouts of practically unsolvable problems instantly-- they just didn't (during your timeframe) predict the invention and adoption of the transistor and its miniaturization, which made computers ubiquitous household objects.

Even the quote about the supposed limited market for computers trotted out from time-to-time to demonstrate the hesitance of industry and academia to adopt computers is wrong.

In 1953 when Thomas Watson said that "there's only a market for five computers" what he actually said was "When we developed the IBM 701 we created a customer list of 20 organizations who might want it and because it is so expensive we expected to only sign five deals, but we ended up signing 18" (paraphrased).

Militaries, universities, and industry all wanted all of the programmable general-purpose electronic computers they could afford the second it became available because they all knew that it could solve problems.

Included for comparison is a list of problems that quantum computing has solved:

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by phire on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:36PM (#43942273)
Exactly. There were many doubts about exactly how useful computers would be. But they were already proving their usefulness in some fields.

The current state of quantum computers is so much worse than that. It's not just that they have produced zero useful results. It's that when these quantum computers do produce results on toy problems, the creators are having a very hard time even proving the results actually came from quantum effects.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by RhysabOweyn on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:22AM (#43937123)
I don't think that you can really make that comparison. "Conventional" computers had more proven practical usage (especially by nation states) in the 40s/50s than quantum computing does today.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by lucianbr on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:22AM (#43937118)
Survivor bias. Just because a certain thing seemed like a scam and turned out useful does not mean all things that seem like a scam will turn out useful.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by monooso on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:59AM (#43937513)
GP's comment didn't suggest that every supposed scam will turn out to be useful.

Quite the opposite, in fact. It was pointing out that some supposed scams do turn out to be useful.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by mrguyorama on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:55PM (#43938895)
GP is just blatantly wrong. Electronic computation was NEVER considered a "scam".

The Navy, Air Force, government, private institutions, etc didn't dump billions of funding into computers because they thought they were overrated.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by empath75 on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:39AM (#43937297)
By the 1940s and 50s, computers were already being used for practical and useful work, and calculating machines had a _long_ history of being useful, and it didn't take that long between the _idea_ of a calculating machine and having something that people paid for and used because it had practical value.

They've been plugging along at quantum computers for decades now and have not produced a single useful machine (although a lot of the math and science behind it has been useful for theoretical physics).

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by skywhopper on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:51AM (#43936741)
Do you have any citations for that?
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by roflmaostc on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:20AM (#43937101)
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by reaperducer on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:02AM (#43936885)
Do you have any citations for that?

I'm not the OP, but when you're of a certain age, you don't need citations for that. Memory serves. And my family was saying those sorts of things and teasing me about being into computers as late as the 1970's.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by Henchman21 on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:02AM (#43937559)
When you’re of a certain age, time has likely blurred your memories. Citation becomes more important then. Source: me I’m an old SOB.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by reaperducer on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:09AM (#43937660)
Source: me I’m an old SOB.

By your own criteria, a citation better than "me" is needed.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by pessimizer on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:04PM (#43938353)
Looks like you've got it.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by DangitBobby on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:15AM (#43937035)
I would actually like to read about that, though.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by autoexec on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:30PM (#43939740)
I can attest to the fact that people who didn't understand computers at all were questioning the value of spending time on them long after the 1970s. The issue is that there are people today who do understand quantum computing that are questioning their value and that's not a great sign.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by oldgradstudent on Friday May 09, 2025 @08:29PM (#43942242)
In the 1970s both my parents were programming computers professionaly.

Computing was already a huge industry. Just IBM's revenues were in the multi billion dollar range in the 1970s. And a billion dollar in the 1970s was A LOT of money in the 1970s.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by belter on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:56PM (#43939951)
You can't put a man on the Sun just because you put one on the Moon.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by Mistletoe on Friday May 09, 2025 @09:50AM (#43936739)
I became disillusioned when I learned that 5x3=15 was the largest number that has been factored by a quantum computer without tricks or scams. Then I became even more disillusioned when I learned the 15 may not be legit…

https://www.reddit.com/r/QuantumComputing/comments/1535lii/w...

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by 77pt77 on Friday May 09, 2025 @10:43AM (#43937343)
> I very much quantum today as smoke and mirrors

The most accurate and expirimentaly tested theory of reality is "smoke and mirrors".

There are so many other areas to say that about, even in physics. But this?...

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by tokai on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:21AM (#43937811)
With the context of the article its clear that GP means quantum computing.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by tjpnz on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:30PM (#43938626)
Quantum annealers have been working on real world problems for a while now - assuming they can be expressed as combinatorial optimization problems of course.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by krastanov on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:27PM (#43940190)
But there is no scalable computational advantage with quantum annealers. They are not what most people in the field would call a "(scalable/digital) quantum computer".
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by hnthrow90348765 on Friday May 09, 2025 @12:42PM (#43938747)
D-Wave venturing into blockchain stuff raised a red flag for me as a layman investor: https://ir.dwavesys.com/news/news-details/2025/D-Wave-Introd...

There are maybe other reasons to invest, but this caused me to sell my shares

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by aurareturn on Saturday May 10, 2025 @06:32AM (#43944590)
Looks like they want to become a meme stock.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by EvgeniyZh on Friday May 09, 2025 @01:51PM (#43939402)
> won't be the last time we hear about quantum research that has been foundational to a lot of work

This research wasn't foundational to a lot of work. Most of important/foundational works in quantum (doesn't matter if computing or general, I'm not sure which one you meant) are verified. How can you possibly base your experimental work on someone else's work if you can't replicate it?

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by _heimdall on Friday May 09, 2025 @03:08PM (#43940035)
Scientific research today is largely about publishing positive results, we rarely see negative results published and most people focus on publish novel work rather than attempting to validate someone else's work.

I agree with you, its a terrible idea to base your work on someone else's when it hasn't been well confirmed in independent research.

I consider the source work in the OP as foundational because Microsoft built so much work and spent so many resources building on top of it. It's not foundational to the entire field but it is foundational to a lot of follow-up research.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by EvgeniyZh on Friday May 09, 2025 @04:26PM (#43940583)
> I agree with you, its a terrible idea to base your work on someone else's when it hasn't been well confirmed in independent research.

It's not about whether it's good or bad idea. To make follow-up experiments you need to first reproduce the original experiment. That's why faking "big" experiments like Schön could never work.

> Microsoft built so much work and spent so many resources building on top of it. It's not foundational to the entire field but it is foundational to a lot of follow-up research.

Will all due respect, a single group (even large one) doing a single type of experiments (even important and complicated one) is not a lot of research. Also, Microsoft knew about data manipulation, that why they moved the experiments in house. They didn't do experiments under assumption that the early Majorana papers are correct, then they wouldn't need to develop their own complicated (and somewhat controversial) protocol to detect Majoranas. It was quite clear for everyone that regardless of data manipulation people were too optimistic interpreting Majorana signatures in these early papers.

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by _heimdall on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:44PM (#43943062)
We can debate what merits consideration as a large body of research, but it seems unhelpful as its entirely subjective.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by EvgeniyZh on Saturday May 10, 2025 @02:49AM (#43943700)
The point still stands, Microsoft didn't build their research on top of that, but started their research because of these problems.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by andrepd on Friday May 09, 2025 @02:02PM (#43939527)
Wait just so I'm sure I understand what you're saying: you tried to read but don't understand the mathematics, therefore it's smoke and mirrors.
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by m101 on Friday May 09, 2025 @07:09PM (#43941784)
Perhaps one only needs to realise that reality is not mathematics?
Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by _heimdall on Friday May 09, 2025 @11:48PM (#43943079)
I would be lying to say I understood every bit of theoretical mathematics in the field of quantum mechanics, or any field for that matter.

Would you rather I make that blanket claim so you can rightfully call me out for not understanding some part of the mathematical theory or nomenclature instead?

Re:Data manipulations alleged in study that paved way for Mi... by andrepd on Saturday May 10, 2025 @06:22AM (#43944543)
"I don't quite understand internal combustion engines so I'm bearish on automobiles" seems a pretty dumb take, to put it bluntly.