News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by cle on Thursday April 03, 2025 @09:33AM (#43569379)
These are real problems. But they are also loaded questions, if someone asked me these at a party I would view them as looking for confirmation, and not seeking truth. There's nothing wrong with that, but the author's goal is curiosity and truth seeking, and I'm skeptical that most of these questions align with that goal.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by Workaccount2 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:05AM (#43570813)
The strawmanning of arguments from both sides is so intense that most people lay in a bed composed entirely of strawman arguments. I firmly blame the media above all for this, but individuals carry a burden to for not trying to remake their bed.

It took me 15 years to to remake my bed into somewhat rational arguments, and still I find lots of hay in there. Generally both sides, or all sides really, want the same things and disagree on how to get there. And the truth is there is almost never an obvious or clear way to get there. It's fractal pros and cons all the way down.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by slt2021 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:03PM (#43571693)
politics, especially international geopolitics is a zero-sum game. The game of competition for limited resources and markets. Because resources are limited, the pie is fixed, and this makes it zero sum game.

Although there is a way to frame political alliances as a win-win when two parties increase their share at a cost of some other third party losing theirs.

Because of that, the arguments will always be straw-man, because people want to win resources, not to argue in good faith.

Any political issue can be framed in terms of zero sum game, if you look at the whole picture

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by goatlover on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:18PM (#43571936)
That's not how economics works. The pie is not fixed, it tends to grow over time as there's more trade between countries and their economies get bigger. The global economic pie has increased a massive amount over the past century.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by slt2021 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:26PM (#43572841)
the trade has increased because jobs have been offshored, corporations have been running labor cost arbitrage and making a profit from a difference in labor cost in US vs elsewhere
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by freeone3000 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @02:43PM (#43573709)
And as with most arbitrages, costs have lowered as a result. It means a piece of technology with thousands of individual parts can be in your hand for $200. Labor efficiency differences have resulted in an explosion of value-for-dollar for the American consumer.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by Vegenoid on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:26PM (#43572036)
This is incorrect. There are few physical resources that we have reached the limit of, such that one entity’s gain is necessarily another’s loss. There are also a great many things of value that aren’t simply raw resources, for which the pie will never be fixed, because the pie is made by humans and can be made bigger or smaller.

This zero-sum narrative is only true in a world of no growth, where all resources are being fully utilized to maximum effect. That is very far from the world we live in, where there is enormous room for additional extraction, creation, and efficient utilization of resources.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by slt2021 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:27PM (#43572859)
the zero sum will always be true because of the fundamental law of physics: Law of preservation of energy.

Everything in the economy thats worth producing/consuming costs energy and labor. Energy and labor is not free.

You may be conflating win-win with debt-based growth, where economy can grow at the cost of running fiscal deficit and accumulating debt. Sure the economy and market can grow, but the debt will also grow and the inflation will cancel out the nominal growth

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by hnaccount_rng on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:57PM (#43573191)
We use about 1 part in 10000 of the sun's energy deposit on earth... No, we are _really_ far away from preservation of energy being a limiting problem
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by slt2021 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:59PM (#43573221)
yes, the only way to increase economy without stealing from someone else is technological advancement and efficiency improvements (which amounts to R&D spend = $$$$)
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by Vegenoid on Friday April 04, 2025 @01:53AM (#43578772)
Again, the law of preservation of energy only makes things zero sum between entities if all the energy is already being used at maximum efficiency, which it isn't.

For a simple example, consider farming, where plants are used to harness the energy of the sun and capture it in a form useful to humans. Yes, there are inputs that go into it, but the output is more valuable (economically and otherwise) than the material input, because the plant also captured a bunch of solar energy that would have otherwise done nothing useful for anyone's economy. My economy has now grown, without having to take or go into debt from some other economy.

Even in a scenario where I do take on debt to get the materials/water/whatever, the value that is created is greater than the debt taken on. If it wasn't, then I wouldn't do it.

Humans create value by harnessing more energy and using it more efficiently for things that humans (and therefore economies) value. This is an ongoing process, with a long way to go.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by alwa on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:20PM (#43572768)
I guess I can interpret the strongest form of your argument to suggest that resources and markets have a specific level of economically relevant supply at any specific time, which I suppose is an empirical claim that’s true. I feel like recent days’ trade policy earthquakes might operate along a similar line of reasoning: there’s only so much, “they’ve” been getting better off, which means they’ve been “taking” from the US, so the US is taking back.

In the same sense it’s true that there are only so many bushels of seed corn left after the winter. At the moment, we can squabble over how to divide the fixed supply. I could take all the corn, eat half, keep the rest for myself to plant this season. Or, if I’ve already got enough to plant all my land, and you’ve got more land and nothing else to do, I could invest some of my leftover corn with you and we can all have double the harvest in a few months… when the supply will have dramatically expanded, assuming I don’t treat it as a zero-sum game right now. Or I could focus on “winning” right now, and we’ll both be poorer after the harvest than we would have been otherwise.

While I agree that you could frame most any political issue in zero-sum terms, I feel like the blind spot is the same: it tallies the score based on assumptions fixed in time, and it takes a pessimistic view of cooperative potential, of humans’ power to influence the constraints themselves.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by slt2021 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:32PM (#43572906)
the zero sum will always be true because of the fundamental law of physics: Law of preservation of energy / Law of preservation of matter.

Everything in the economy thats worth producing/consuming costs energy and labor. Energy and labor is not free.

Any free lunch one can have in the economy is only possible in nominal terms, when your economy/market grows, but your sovereign debt and fiscal deficit also grows and in real terms, after inflation there is no real growth.

if you look at the core, the bottom of the economics it is just pure physics: The flow and exchange of energy and materials, labor and capital. The fight is over a distribution of the flows between various factions

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by alwa on Thursday April 03, 2025 @09:10PM (#43577327)
Aren’t we so, so, so far from physical limits though? To the point that we speak of likely energy reserves in terms of centuries of consumption at current levels, even if we only get around to proving the next couple decades’ worth at a time?

If Musk et al get their wishes, and we become “spacefaring civilization” or whatever—aren’t the conceivable physical limits of known reality so far away as to be irrelevant?

And isn’t the story of the industrial era one of compounding productivity per unit of labor?

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by matwood on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:12AM (#43570921)
> but individuals carry a burden to for not trying to remake their bed

In what way? I turn on Fox sometimes and it's not that it's slanted, but it's just a stream of lies and BS. I've watched a bunch of Trump's speeches and in addition to being incoherent, he says the same lies and BS all the way down. Yesterday's tariff speech was a great example.

I don't consider myself progressive (though the MAGA right would think me so), but where do I go to try and 'remake [my] bed'?

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by ablob on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:36AM (#43571263)
I think what's meant is that you need to be open to changing your opinion and manner of approach to things. To stay with the analogy: when you "remake" your bed and it ends up the same, chances are that you didn't try to improve on its design.

By turning on Fox sometimes (provided it's not your main source) you might already not fall into the category of people not trying to remake their bed.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by freejazz on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:50PM (#43572370)
Wait, we're designing bedding now? Not just remaking our beds? What a strained analogy that when you 'remake' your bed and it's the 'same' (why would it be different?) then you didn't improve the design?? Even more shocking is that you ran with this as opposed to realizing that these were warning signs that either your fundamental argument is ridiculous, or your analogy is.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by nomdep on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:54AM (#43571529)
Well, the first thing is to realize CNN is also just a stream of lies and BS. Every media news organization in the world has become (they always were?) pure garbage.

Listening to first-hand sources is the way, I guess, but also remembering they can be lying as well, so be vigilant.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by MrMcCall on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:13PM (#43571859)
It's true, because all the upper levels of ALL large media organizations have been infiltrated by big-moneyed conservatives.

CNN and NBC weren't always as bad as they are now, but their descent has been obvious and dramatic.

Some of them still employ democrats to some minimal extent, such as Jamelle Bouie at the NYT, but that's merely subterfuge, lest their bent be glaringly obvious.

If someone can name a large organization that is an exception to my first paragraph, I would be happy to learn of them.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by zoklet-enjoyer on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:41PM (#43572262)
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by goatlover on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:17AM (#43570980)
> Generally both sides, or all sides really, want the same things and disagree on how to get there.

No, that is just not true. For example, do you think Putin and his supporters wanted a functioning democracy in Russia and independent Ukraine? No, they wanted someone functioning as a dictator to restore Russia's cold war territory and influence, and they wanted to undermine western democracies that stood in their way.

History does not support your claim that everyone wants the same things. Some people want power and strong man to take over the government. We see that with the Trump administration. The religious conservatives want to use that to make America a Christian nation. The billionaire libertarians want to use it to deregulate their industries and run the government like a corporation. And Trump wants to act unilaterally to bring about his vision of being seen as some great figure. They have illiberal aims.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by Workaccount2 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:31AM (#43571192)
I'm speaking about the collectives, not the individuals. There are always deranged individuals and some of them, many of them, manage to get in power. But the ideological collectives all have pretty much the same core goals. Needs met, population happy.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by dfxm12 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:59AM (#43571621)
What's your threshold where an "individual" becomes a "collective"? Certainly billionaire libertarians, religious conservatives, Putin and his supporters and the Trump administration (along with the judges he's appointed, the people in congress and state governments who ran on his platform and the 10s of millions of Americans who voted for them) are not individuals...

They also very obviously want different things compared to others.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by Workaccount2 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:31PM (#43572894)
Shy of a few fringe groups, I am not aware of any large suffering & death collectives. Every large collective is trying to achieve a better life for it's adherents, and is always welcoming to those who want to join. Christains might see living is the light of Jesus as the ideal life, and while not for everyone, you should at least be able to understand why they feel that way (as opposed to a religion of self inflicted torture).

Remember the goal here is not to become sympathetic to Trump, or Putin, or Sanders, or Netanyahu, or Islam. The goal is to have an accurate understanding of them, so that when you form arguments against them, you are actually attacking bedrock and not just straw.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by goatlover on Thursday April 03, 2025 @02:35PM (#43573617)
> Christains might see living is the light of Jesus as the ideal life, and while not for everyone, you should at least be able to understand why they feel that way (as opposed to a religion of self inflicted torture).

Yes, but also we've seen how they've behaved in the past when they had vast political power in Europe. And we see what the goals of the Heritage Foundation is with Project 2025. There have always been a decent number of conservative Christians who want prayer, the bible and ten commandments in school. Who don't want legal abortion or gay marriage. And the more power they have, the more they would restrict. They also tend to believe in a lot of conspiracy theories, like the Democratic Party being controlled by satanists and communists, who have also infiltrated the "Deep State".

So you can imagine how those beliefs play out with enough political power.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by paulsutter on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:18AM (#43570991)
Actually they make great conversion. Preface with, “Why is neither party talking about…” and you’ll find that most people agree.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by immibis on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:54AM (#43571525)
Then lead them to the understanding that both parties are right-wing? (support the current economic system, support mass-murdering brown people overseas, support embezzling for personal gain as long as they don't get caught, etc)
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by aerostable_slug on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:07PM (#43571757)
> support embezzling for personal gain as long as they don't get caught

If you think this is a strictly right-wing characteristic you are hopelessly partisan.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by immibis on Thursday April 03, 2025 @03:51PM (#43574530)
Notice that I said both parties do it.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by moolcool on Thursday April 03, 2025 @10:19AM (#43570104)
I really dislike many of the "rationalist" political blogs you see in the tech sphere lately.

- They are often not shy about flirting with fascism and fascist ideologies

- They ignore that the purpose of politics is often to be deliberately irrational, or to balance "irrational" acts based on commonly-held values with other higher-level planning. E.g. Nobody likes a technocrat, because a technocrat would let a kid who fell down a well die there, since the cost of rescuing them could technically save the lives of 3 others someplace else

- They often re-hash arguments which have been had and settled like 200 years ago, and act as if those arguments are irrelevant today, "since AI and Crypto changed everything". Act as if Thomas Malthus would have had his world rocked by Dogecoin.

It just feels like there's a million "rationalist" JavaScript developers with political blogs lately who know virtually nothing about the foundations of economics or political science. What's more, they're all so good at critical thinking, they all agree with each other too!

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by throw10920 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @10:39AM (#43570394)
> fascism and fascist ideologies

This is political dog-whistling. As Orwell pointed out almost eight decades ago: "The word Fascism has now no meaning except in so far as it signifies ‘something not desirable’."[1] and is now obviously only a dog-whistle for fellow ideologues. This does not belong on HN.

[1] https://www.orwellfoundation.com/the-orwell-foundation/orwel...

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by wholinator2 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:06AM (#43570823)
I agree the term is vague. But what then would you have us call it? The whole, constitutional crisis, outright flouting of the rule of law, suspension of due process/disappearing of political enemies in the streets type thing that is verifiably happening right now. Are you requesting that the word fascism be banned from HN? Have you seen the videos of legal college students being shoved into unmarked vans by unmarked and masked officers of the law? What do you call that? The talk of a third term?

I'd love to say, "he's just blustering", it's what my father said but he's enacted just about every thing he said. Should he begin speaking about a third term i don't think we have the luxury to ignore that anymore. To annex our nearby "allies" who've now become a united front opposing any economic relationship. What is that called? What would you have us say?

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by oeitho on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:03PM (#43571700)
You can't call Trump a fascist, he has yet to have the trains run on time.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by ablob on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:41AM (#43571326)
Why not give it a new name? We could do so with Marxism, Leninism, Maoism, etc. There is no reason we have to stop giving these phenomena a new name. You can always talk about the similarities, but if you mix it carelessly you'll lose the differences.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:46AM (#43571382)
>But what then would you have us call it?

Most people say "fascist" when at most they mean "authoritarian". But maybe the latter's not scary enough for the boogeyman you want to evoke. Sometimes they say it when they should say demagoguery (which is, in my opinion, more than alarming enough of a word in ways that I can forgive people for feeling "populist" isn't). Quite often though, people merely mean "distasteful", but since tastes vary quite a bit, this might not alarm anyone at all.

>suspension of due process/disappearing of political enemies

You mean that when they send people back to their home countries because they're no longer welcome here?

>The talk of a third term?

From a man so old and in such ill health it seems quite likely he won't survive his second term? Mostly he's just trying to get a rise out of you. I don't like bullies, but when they do the "made you flinch" thing, part of me wants to smirk. Couldn't you just this once not flinch?

>To annex our nearby "allies"

He did it in the most asshole way possible, but offering them a proportionate number of votes in our Senate is hardly the insult they make it out to be. Especially when they're all dragged along by our policy already and just have no say in it whatsoever. "We want you to join the richest and most powerful nation on Earth and the benefits are truly too long to list" shouldn't send them running away screaming in terror.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by alxjrvs on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:16PM (#43571909)
>You mean that when they send people back to their home countries because they're no longer welcome here?

> I don't like bullies, but when they do the "made you flinch" thing, part of me wants to smirk.

You like bullies, actually - you just don't like thinking you like bullies.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday April 03, 2025 @04:08PM (#43574729)
Then why does part of me always wish you were clever enough to not flinch, just once, and show them up?

I keep waiting for it to happen. Hoping. And yet you always disappoint.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by moolcool on Thursday April 03, 2025 @09:34PM (#43577455)
When he actually hits you, it makes sense to flinch when he flails his limbs. He did cause the stock market to tank literally yesterday.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by goatlover on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:26PM (#43572034)
> You mean that when they send people back to their home countries because they're no longer welcome here?

Illegally, without due process. That's why a federal judge has been ruling against them on this. They also lied that everyone deported was part of a Venezuelan gang (or at least that they had proper grounds for thinking so, thus the importance of due process), and they lied that it was some kind of invasion.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by NoMoreNicksLeft on Thursday April 03, 2025 @04:15PM (#43574803)
>Illegally, without due process.

And what process, exactly, is due? Why is it due? My understanding of the term is that due process is mostly that because everyone gets the same... if some are getting different treatment, this raises due process concerns. If there was never any process designed, or if it has been abandoned. The bureaucracy can change the rules to some extent, they are not written in stone.

>That's why a federal judge has been ruling against them on this.

No one believes that, not even the left. They're happy that it's occurring of course, and they're clever enough to pretend that they've got real arguments... but in the back of their minds they know that the federal judge would rule against this no matter what, because the Trump administration is doing it. After all, for a full 2 months afterward they had people who were claiming the election was rigged and hoping that somehow that it would be invalidated. Their imaginations ran wild with ever-more-fanciful schemes. Now that's not happening, they've moved on and believe their in some sort of counter-coup.

>and they lied that it was some kind of invasion.

What's the definition of "invasion"? If an enemy were to invade with tanks and guns, they'd be wiped out. A clever enemy might just encourage its people to "migrate". To foment a sort of economic war. Or the word invasion can even have more metaphorical or casual usage. If someone says that mice have invaded their home do you complain that the word "invade" is wrong because the mice aren't wearing military uniforms and trying to accomplish some general's strategy?

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by throw10920 on Sunday April 06, 2025 @07:50PM (#43606044)
> I agree the term is vague. But what then would you have us call it?

That right there is an admission that you're just using the term as a generic "person bad" term, which is bad in itself. It's evil to intentionally conflate and manipulate language to serve political goals. You would object to taking a person that's known to be a Nazi and calling them autistic, or vice-versa. That you are not objecting here is malicious.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by treyd on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:16AM (#43570967)
In the academic community the term still has a useful meaning and is often used appropriately in those circles.

But you could substitute neoreactionary in GP and it would still be referring to real bloggers that are treated as if they're making legitimate and justifiable arguments.

It's a serious concern, I think it's good to criticize this tendency.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by moolcool on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:58AM (#43571601)
You do not have to look very far to find prominent voices on the right who are apologetically anti-democracy.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by dragonwriter on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:00PM (#43571645)
Or even unapologetically.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by slt2021 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:07PM (#43571756)
if what you mean by anti-democracy, is government oppression, then the left and right both use this equally.

there is only one continuum: liberty from government oppression, or lack thereof.

I hope you don't seriously consider the oligopoly of two parties and small circle of connected elites, dependent on financial backing from ultra high net worth oligarchs, corporations, special lobbying groups - a democracy. This is not democracy, it is plutocracy (the power of capital/rich)

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by MrMcCall on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:15PM (#43571883)
There is bad, and there is worse, far worse.

And, it's a kleptocracy, more and more, for a very long time now.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by slt2021 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:42PM (#43573030)
US is not a democracy. Trump got like ~77 mln votes, which roughly compares to 23% of the population of 340 mln people. so Trump doesn't even represent the a quarter of US population.

other countries are more democratic, in a sense that winning candidate represents larger share of people living there

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by Aeolun on Thursday April 03, 2025 @10:56AM (#43570693)
Even if you think it’s a dog whistle, Facism does mean something and it’s rather more accurate to use it now than say, 30 years ago.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by throw10920 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:01AM (#43570769)
No, it does not mean anything. Different people from the same side of the political spectrum define it differently, let alone different parts of the spectrum. If you don't define it before using it, it's a dog-whistle, full stop.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by inejge on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:05PM (#43571727)
One could do worse than using Eco's Ur-Fascism[1] as the starting point. The man had personal experience and he could write (oh how he could write.) However, I'd expect that some would dismiss him as an inveterate lefty (he wasn't), so we're back on square one.

[1] https://archive.org/details/umberto-eco-ur-fascism/umberto-e...

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by soupfordummies on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:11PM (#43571824)
I've heard this dismissal a good bit often ("that's just a nothing word that means 'bad thing I don't like' ") but that's really just not true.

It has been consistently defined through the decades, especially during the 20th century. Here's one common example you can find from the 1983 American Heritage Dictionary and it sounds pretty familiar:

"A system of government that exercises a dictatorship of the extreme right, typically through the merging of state and business leadership, together with belligerent nationalism."

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by Aeolun on Thursday April 03, 2025 @08:16PM (#43576992)
I kinda feel like that would work just as well with ‘right’ replaced by ‘left’.

If anything, this definition is a better argument for the parents’s point.

Dictatorship, belligerent (North Korea style) and nationalism seem much more important features than left or right.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by wholinator2 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:07AM (#43570844)
Dog whistle for what? Please define what it is a dog whistle for. Maybe in that context you'll find the common definition understood by people using it
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by ryandrake on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:50AM (#43571462)
The word is starting to be used by the left in the same way the right uses "woke": It's become watered down and an over-used way to simply say "anything my side doesn't like".

- Climate change is real: "woke"

- Firing people in government: "fascist"

- Compassion and fairness: "woke"

- Cruelty toward political enemies: "fascist"

- Expertise-driven and reason-driven policies: "woke"

- Stacking government positions with loyal cronies: "fascist"

- Rights for women, minorities, gay people, and so on: "woke"

- Handouts to corporations: "fascist"

They've become vague words that mean the same thing: "Politics I don't like"

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by moolcool on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:03PM (#43571703)
This reminds me of the joke that republicans will defend criminal conspiracy by saying "Wow so it's illegal to make plans with friends now".
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by anamexis on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:07AM (#43570835)
Speaking of words having meanings, what exactly do you mean by dog-whistle here? I understand dog-whistle to mean coded language for a different concept.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by pixl97 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:22AM (#43571060)
Eh, I really do call BS on that.

Umberto Eco's 14 tenants of fascism still stands strong and is highly visible in modern discourse.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by cuu508 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:37PM (#43572194)
*tenets
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by laidoffamazon on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:01PM (#43571664)
This is the opposite of a dog whistle it's entirely explicit. There are people being thrown into vans for speech right now. There are law firms that are negotiating to lift bills of attainder for their prior political litigation. They are _literally_ throwing people in El Salvadorean prisons without due process, including people that were in this country legally.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by analog31 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @10:23AM (#43570136)
Every rationalist movement eventually ends up at odds with rational people.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by TeMPOraL on Thursday April 03, 2025 @10:42AM (#43570447)
But then, whom are you dissing? Whom is GP dissing? Because it's really unclear. On the one hand, "rational people" keep their views even as they drift apart from a wider "rationalist movement". On the other hand, it's the rationalist communities - the movement - that's much more likely to actually know something "about the foundations of economics or political science". On the grasping hand, such communities can and do get stuck missing forest for the trees.

But then on the slapping hand, approximately all criticism of rationalism (particularly LessWrong-associated) I've seen on HN and elsewhere, involves either heresay and lies, or just a legion of strawmen like "zomg Roko's basilisk" or GP's own "arguments" like:

> Nobody likes a technocrat, because a technocrat would let a kid who fell down a well die there, since the cost of rescuing them could technically save the lives of 3 others someplace else

It's hard to even address something that's just plain bullshit, so in the end, I'm still leaning towards giving rationalists the benefit of doubt. Strange as some conclusions of some people may sometimes be, they at least try to argue it with reason, and not strawmen and ideological rally cries.

EDIT: and then there's:

> They often re-hash arguments which have been had and settled like 200 years ago

Well, somebody has to. It's important for the same reason reproducibility in science is important.

I'd be wary of assuming any complex argument has been "settled like 200 years ago". When people say this, they just mean "shut up and accept the uninformed, simplistic opinion". In a sense, this is even worse than blindly following religious dogma, as with organized religions, the core dogmas are actually designed by smart people to achieve some purpose (ill-minded or not); cutting people off with "settled like 200 years ago" is just telling them to accept whatever's the cheapest, worst-quality belief currently on sale on the "marketplace of ideas".

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by satvikpendem on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:14PM (#43571862)
> whom are you dissing? Whom is GP dissing?

Just a nit, it's "who" in this case, not "whom," because it is a subject not an object. "Whom" is more often used as "to/with/for whom."

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by TeMPOraL on Thursday April 03, 2025 @03:00PM (#43573896)
Thanks! English is not my first language, and I still have problem with this particular thing.

(IIRC use of "whom" was never covered in my English classes; I only learned about it from StarGate: SG-1, a show in which one of the main characters had a habit of mocking enemies by correcting their grammar.)

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by satvikpendem on Saturday April 05, 2025 @03:11AM (#43591551)
No worries, Temporal, I have seen your comments for a long time so no worries in me correcting you, as I am glad to do so.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by vinceguidry on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:17AM (#43570975)
Rationalism, and the people who believe in it and promote it, has the problem that the human mind unavoidably decides to act as the arbiter of what is rational or not. This limits your vision to only that which the mind internally 'agrees with' or not, entrenching hidden biases.

Fundamentally, it's the mind only engaging with the cognitive, and ignoring the limbic. Engaging with the limbic, with the deep, primal parts of the brain, challenges cognitively-held truths and demands you to support these truths from a broader context.

This is why rationalists are more prone to engage with fascist viewpoints, they seek more power for their held beliefs and fascism offers that in spades. You're not thinking about the history of fascist movements and how horrible they all turned out. You're thinking: How can we do it better this time?

Just like in math, the rational is a subset of the real, and you need both the rational and the irrational to make reality. Focusing exclusively on rationality is intentionally blinding yourself to messy reality.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by TeMPOraL on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:46AM (#43571385)
That's an interesting take, but I can't see how you can dismiss rationality/rationalism as insufficient to process reality on the basis of "ignoring the limbic", without dismissing all of science and mathematics in the process.

I do agree there's more to human experience than just the cognitive / "system 2" view, but the important aspect of our cognitive facility - aspects that put humans on top of the global food chain - is that we can model and reason about the "limbic", and even though we can merely approximate it in the cognitive space, we've also learned how to work with approximations and uncertainty.

This is to say, if reason seems to justify viewpoints generally known, viscerally and cognitively, to be abhorrent, it typically means one's reasoning about perfectly spherical cows in a vacuum instead of actual human beings, and fails to include the "deep, primal parts of the brain" in their model. That, fortunately, is a correctable mistake.

Just like in math, if you construct a seemingly solid edifice of theorems and proofs, but forget and subsequently violate a critical assumption, all kind of wild conclusions will come out the other end.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by vinceguidry on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:40PM (#43572254)
> I can't see how you can dismiss rationality/rationalism as insufficient to process reality on the basis of "ignoring the limbic", without dismissing all of science and mathematics in the process.

Only a rationalist could make such a statement. I tell you rationalism is only a part of reality, not the whole, and you take that as a dismissal of all of the rational. I have no problems with science and maths, I just don't elevate them to the level of prime importance that rationalists do. I watched the Veritasium video on Cantor and the Axiom of Choice before I saw it on HN, and I follow Dr. Angela Collier on YouTube.

I'm an intuitionist, not a rationalist. I believe in a broad and rich informational diet, and that intuitive understanding is better than reductionist, which is the only kind of understanding rationalists seem to value.

> is that we can model and reason about the "limbic",

We can, and the academic domain that produces is generally called the humanities, and the humanities seem to be almost universally dismissed, even despised, by rationalists. So color me unimpressed when rationalists do this acceptance / dismissal dance regarding them. You don't really care about the humanities, just that we can model and reason about them. You want your rational bent to encompass the irrational, when fundamentally it cannot do that. Yes we can study the humanities. Just not with science or math or any other positivistic approach that would satisfy a rationalist.

And I fundamentally disagree with the notion that it's the cognitive that allowed us to dominate. In fact it's the cooperation between the cognitive and the limbic that produces the language that allows us to communicate with each other that gave us the advantage. Without the limbic there's no reason or room to cooperate.

All your viewpoint seeks to do is reduce the real into the rational.

> Just like in math, if you construct a seemingly solid edifice of theorems and proofs, but forget and subsequently violate a critical assumption, all kind of wild conclusions will come out the other end.

Hence Elon Musk's Nazi-esque government takeover.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by moolcool on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:45AM (#43571376)
> Just like in math, the rational is a subset of the real

I just want to highlight this, since it's the cleanest way I've seen this expressed. This is a fantastic hackernews comment.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by TeMPOraL on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:53AM (#43571513)
I too want to highlight this, since it's one of the cleanest case of blatant equivocation sneaking past people.

>> Just like in math, the rational is a subset of the real

That only works if you think Rationality ⊂ Reality the same way ℚ ⊂ ℝ — which is like saying Space-time ⊂ Archery because time flies like an arrow.

Wordplay is not an argument.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by moolcool on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:10PM (#43571812)
And I'd like to highlight this, since it's one of the cleanest cases of everyone in a situation knowing what's being said, and then a rationalist coming along and thinking everyone is misunderstanding it except for him.

Rationalists read poetry like "Compare thee to a summer's day? Pfft, impossible!"

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by vinceguidry on Friday April 04, 2025 @07:26AM (#43580690)
Rationalist Jesus preaches the gospel of Effective Altruism and pure consequentialism. Rob and beat your neighbors in service of them, that's real love.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by exoverito on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:41AM (#43571323)
Everyone likes to use fascist to smear their political opponents, yet I'm not seeing a lot of evidence that the "anti-fascists" are any different. They support mass censorship, state propaganda, political violence, forever war, discrimination, debanking, lawfare, lockdowns, and ironically even infringement of bodily autonomy through unconstitutional vaccine mandates.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by vinceguidry on Thursday April 03, 2025 @12:44PM (#43572294)
I hope this "I know you are but what am I" approach to politics falls out of fashion soon. Like listening to children playing cops and robbers.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by exoverito on Friday April 04, 2025 @11:39AM (#43583993)
It's childish to still not see the Democrats are corrupt corporatists, and that we need real third parties and candidates strong enough to resist the myriad of dirty tactics thrown at them. Say what you will about Trump, but he's about the only person who has the strength and resources to take on an entrenched deep state and corrupt intelligence agencies. They tried to impeach him with a fake Russian collusion hoax, throw him in prison on trumped up non-criminal felonies, and oh yeah multiple assassination attempts which were memory holed a couple weeks later.

The Iron Law of Wokeism is projection of the same crimes they commit upon others. We already have massive evidence the Democrats are corrupt and authoritarian, colluding with media, persecuting and assassinating whistleblowers (Assange, Snowden, Seth Rich). They engage in grotesque amounts of graft and inefficiency, as seen with California's High Speed Rail project, Biden's rural broadband and EV charging stations, which have delivered nothing. The Democrats don't even respect their voters choices in primaries, as evident by super delegates, Hillary conspiring against Bernie Sanders, the forced abdication of the obviously senile Biden, appointment of the obviously inept puppet that was Kamala Harris, etc. etc.

I hope real civil libertarians become in fashion. The self-described anti-fascists are basically communists who would create an authoritarian nightmare state, per usual. Funnily enough, the Berlin Wall was officially the the Anti-Fascist Protection Rampart, and Putin is engaging in a "special police action" against Ukraine in order to "de-nazify" the regime.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by vinceguidry on Friday April 04, 2025 @01:40PM (#43585564)
Look at all those words! You sound like a really good bootlicker, I hope you're actually getting something from the people you're stanning so hard for.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by exoverito on Saturday April 05, 2025 @01:50AM (#43591164)
Likewise friend, I extend the same reciprocity and hope you're being rewarded for your internet posts.

Interesting that you don't engage with the words at all, and lazily use insults. I'm actually somewhat curious what kind of person you really are, since you've accrued quite a few internet points here on HN. I hope you're independently wealthy by now, otherwise god help you.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by vinceguidry on Saturday April 05, 2025 @09:42AM (#43593453)
> Interesting that you don't engage with the words at all, and lazily use insults.

Why should I? Your incoherence requires nothing more. There's nothing to say about the "Iron Law of Wokism". That's just mollycoddle you picked up from some trumptwaddle on YouTube somewhere.

You want to talk real politics, you're gonna have to smarten up, my dude.

> what kind of person you really are, since you've accrued quite a few internet points here on HN

Someone who gave his last fuck 20 years ago. Folks around here like that.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by freejazz on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:34PM (#43572933)
Your entire post is premised on rational people only being rationalists
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by moolcool on Thursday April 03, 2025 @10:36AM (#43570319)
It always falls down because the end-goal of ones "rationalism" always has to be determined by a set of values.

If you want to form a political ideology based on rationality, your very first step will stick you right in the middle of the sticky-icky world of the humanities. 'Hello deontology, my old friend.'

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by bumby on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:19AM (#43571015)
Isn’t rationalism (as discussed above) more closely related to utilitarianism? Thus rationalism is more of a consequentialist framework than a deontological one?
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by moolcool on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:40AM (#43571311)
Even definitions there are extremely hazy. "The most good for the most people".

Define "good". Happiness? Economic prosperity? Community? And over what time span?

Define "most". Percentage of people served? Number of people served?

Define "people". Are you counting citizens? Immigrants? Foreigners? Prisoners? People in the future?

You know the joke in the sciences about how everything distills down to mathematics? I would argue that we just as often distill down to philosophy. You have to reckon with a lot of questions which a stats degree can't help you much with.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by bumby on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:51AM (#43571478)
To steal a quote from The Good Place, “This is why everyone hates moral philosophy professors”
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by UncleMeat on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:45AM (#43571370)
What's also remarkable is that these people often have incredible disdain for communities of experts who study these topics for their careers. The number of times that I've seen one of these blogs discuss a topic that they believe they have invented while ignoring the mountains of literature already produced on the topic is... concerning.

This is what no humanities education does to a motherfucker.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by moolcool on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:49AM (#43571434)
My favourite genre of this is when the crypto community rediscovers centuries of economic lessons from first-principles.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by Henchman21 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:08AM (#43570850)
Its almost like you’ve discovered content manufactured whose only purpose is propaganda
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by InDubioProRubio on Thursday April 03, 2025 @10:01AM (#43569815)
I always wondered, what those Pinkerton man thought, when they attacked union members with machine guns for their masters in the guilded age.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by rpd9803 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @10:04AM (#43569882)
They thought "Well, I guess this makes me one of those people for whom "Not talking about politics with Friends" becomes a core tenent to my personal philosophy."
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by analog31 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @10:34AM (#43570276)
They thought that the union members were criminals.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by pixl97 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:24AM (#43571089)
Without the ability to realize that it's politics that defines what a criminal is.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by exoverito on Thursday April 03, 2025 @11:26AM (#43571118)
The original argument put forth by capitalists was that unionized workers were effectively engaging in economic sabotage by striking and blockading factories.

That said the Pinkertons were basically mercenaries akin to organized crime, so probably viewed things in terms of might makes right.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by sylos on Thursday April 03, 2025 @02:19PM (#43573434)
Unfortunately they're thinking the same thing today.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by int_19h on Friday April 04, 2025 @07:51PM (#43588960)
They thought, "if I do a good job, I'm going to get a bonus"
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by cle on Saturday April 05, 2025 @11:04AM (#43594034)
This is about having political conversations with friends, not with people shooting at you with machine guns.
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @01:12PM (#43572663)
The ironic thing to me is that the author essentially makes this the main point right from the get go:

> The insidious nature of this question comes from the false representation as earnest, intellectual discourse. Many who ask it may truly believe they’re engaging earnestly, but their responses quickly reveal an angle more akin to religious police.

As you point out, nearly all of talkingtab's questions are loaded. At the very least, talkingtab essentially says outright what they expect the "correct" answer to be, e.g I'm baffled why talkingtab seems to think "inflation" is a "code word". I speak English, and inflation is "telling it like it is" based on the simple definition of the word.

As another example, for this question:

> Are common Americans paid a living wage? Can one person earn enough to have a family?

What happens if a response is "No, I don't believe that cashiers at McDonald's deserve to be paid a 'living wage', because I don't believe that job is intended to support a family on its own"? To emphasize, I'm not saying what the "right" answer is, but I do believe reasonable people can disagree over what constitutes a living wage and which jobs deserve to be paid it.

If anything, talkingtab's post just highlights to me the author's specific point about political "tribes" vs political views, and if anything has convinced me more that the author's view is spot on here.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by JumpCrisscross on Thursday April 03, 2025 @02:44PM (#43573717)
> the author essentially makes this the main point right from the get go

Then find better friends. The author is essentially complaining about the quality of his friends.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by hn_throwaway_99 on Thursday April 03, 2025 @05:02PM (#43575362)
Ah, yes, those pesky humans and their cognitive biases...
Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by JumpCrisscross on Friday April 04, 2025 @03:09AM (#43579178)
> Ah, yes, those pesky humans and their cognitive biases...

This is sort of meaningless without citation of the bias you claim.

In case you're being serious: yes; you can find friends who won't shit on you for your views.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by keybored on Thursday April 03, 2025 @02:40PM (#43573667)
My read is that talkingtab’s agenda here is to focus the conversation on what politics is. Rather than being this thing you discuss with people (or not) it’s about injustice against the majority. So why does that get brought up? Because with the OP it’s easy to end up concluding that politics to the average person is something you choose to idly or deliberately or max-brainpower chatter with other people about. Then it can be easily thought that it’s just about differing policy positions. But talkingtab is saying that it’s more confrontational than that.

So why are the questions “loaded”? Because as you can see with your own eyes, they have their own political agenda. Part of politics is defining what the the agenda should be—and what should be considered political.

As you can imagine, people who think they are arguing or fighting on behalf of people making a living wage etc. want to put that message out there. They are not discussing abstract concepts or competing in some open-mindedness competition or some rationality contest. It matters to them.

> If anything, talkingtab's post just highlights to me the author's specific point about political "tribes" vs political views, and if anything has convinced me more that the author's view is spot on here.

You are even more convinced. Yet there is nothing here that suggests that talkingtab is tribal in the sense of what the OP is talking about. None. Is this received opinion or opinion born from studying like a monk for 10 years? You don’t know.

You also say that talkingtab is presenting what the “correct” answer is. Yes, according to them. Again, is it really tribalism? Or is it conviction as well as the polemic tone of the whole comment? And having conviction doesn’t mean that you cannot conceive of people having other opinions, or being intellectually unable to present counter-arguments to their own position. Again, no proof of tribalism is presented.

And this focus on tribalism presupposes that the end goal is to find your tone. Alternatively you can look at their arguments. Maybe they want to change the flaws they perceive in the world.

Re:Why I don't discuss politics with friends by keybored on Thursday April 03, 2025 @02:08PM (#43573318)
They are both real problems and loaded questions. Okay. Ostensibly the point of politics is to solve problems that people have. That will lead to people putting forth what they think the problems are. We simply don’t have time to theorize every concievable potential problem and then, one by one, painstakingly (with our minds wide open like an open brain surgery) consider whether they are in fact problems that people have.

All of these pointed questions can also be disputed.