Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by k310 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @10:54PM
(#43431386)
I saw this previously, and Asahi is still bashing HN. I haven't visited the site recently, until today.
> Hi! It looks like you might have come from Hacker News.
> Asahi Linux developers are frequent targets of abuse on Hacker News. Despite our pleas, the moderators have not taken effective action to improve the situation.
> Overtly hateful content is often flagged on HN and not immediately visible. Unfortunately, when a comment is flagged and killed, its child subthread is not. That preserves the 'clean' image of the website, but the reduced moderation activity enables abuse to continue. Although you don't see those threads, search engines do. HN uniquely has a high page rank and low moderation, making it a prime target for bad actors to poison search results with abuse, bigotry, and nastiness. This isn't low-level trolling, but an organized attempt to destroy lives, including of developers in our communities.
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by apetresc on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:00PM
(#43431413)
I'm out of the loop, what bashing and abuse? Every time I've seen Asahi mentioned, everyone here's falling over themselves to remark on how impressive a technical achievement it is.
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by viraptor on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:12AM
(#43431756)
Look at older posts with showdead on - there's a lot of personal attacks, claims about vtuber identity, trans hate, etc. It's been a bit more chill recently, but the history is there. (apart from the recent https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=43406393 which has lots of terrible people again)
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by defrost on Friday March 21, 2025 @01:11AM
(#43432025)
A fair assessment might be that instead of a large number of regular users leaving bad comments there is a small number, potentially even one, that spin up sock accounts to make a disproportionally larger number of bigoted comments.
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by umanwizard on Friday March 21, 2025 @04:22AM
(#43433059)
"with showdead on" -- that's the point, isn't it? Personal attacks against people involved with Asahi are swiftly downvoted and killed. I guess the project members would like them to be actually deleted, but that's not really how HN works.
I too had the impression people here love asahi Linux. But as the comment said those negative posts tend to disappear.
I’m not fully onboard (I don’t have a MacBook, supporting closed hw from a single vendor) but I see the appeal, and to me getting more people using Linux is major plus that outweighs the negatives. I’m not going to tell people who are generously donating their time to something not to do so.
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by orangecat on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:42PM
(#43431606)
Asahi Linux is great. Also, it's weird that the former lead developer has a VTuber sockpuppet that he pretends is a separate project member, and pointing that out is not abusive or hateful or transphobic or whatever else he wants to claim.
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by ziddoap on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:18PM
(#43431505)
It generally gets flagged, but there's definitely been some bad comments.
I don't think that what I've seen, if directed at me, would get the same response -- but I obviously don't see it all, nor have it directed at me, so it's not really fair for me to say.
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by colechristensen on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:02PM
(#43431425)
>an organized attempt to destroy lives, including of developers in our communities
I saw this as well... what are they talking about? Is this overreacting to random trolling or is some group actively trying to target folks to actually cause harm?
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by LukeShu on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:45AM
(#43431927)
Several down-thread comments speculate that the banner is due to recent events. Some form of an HN block or banner has been present since 2023-03-21[1] (well, until about an hour ago[2]).
HN threads about Asahi, while generally positive about the project, also tend to include trans hate and speculation about a pseudonymous developer's identity. Those comments are often "dead", but show up on search engines. This has caused real harm in the lives of Asahi's trans and pseudonymous developers.
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by cadamsdotcom on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:22PM
(#43431524)
Amazing to see Asahi Linux push ahead despite the headwinds - gaining D3D12 AND microphone support AND fex, AND bundled nicely up with all the goodies in Fedora 42.
Thanks to a very small number of generous humans your M-series Macbook will still be usable even after Apple declares it vintage - and in the meantime you have an alternative which works better for gaming, and hardware support will only keep getting better.
Congrats to those whose work made this update such a bonanza.
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by mwinatschek on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:36PM
(#43431585)
I’d be very happy if they could introduce disk encryption by default or maybe with a yes/no question during the installation. Because the current way to do it is a little bit to difficult and unsafe for me to be honest:
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by alberth on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:57PM
(#43431664)
> Given the nature of what we do, this can mean spending upwards of $10,000 a year on Macs.
Please know that donating isn’t just about helping the developers financially, it’s also needed just to purchase new Mac’s every year to test & support (because each new M-series requires additional development to work).
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by loeg on Sunday March 23, 2025 @01:58AM
(#43451140)
You need a specific organization structure, registration, and certain documentation requirements to be a formal non-profit organization. Asahi Linux doesn't seem to have that.
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by eminence32 on Thursday March 20, 2025 @11:45PM
(#43431617)
The beamforming bit is neat. I have no personal experience with it, but I was surprised that 2cm separation between the microphones was enough. Do any other laptops use this technique for noise rejection?
Re:Asahi Linux Progress Report - Linux 6.14
by wronglebowski on Friday March 21, 2025 @12:26AM
(#43431854)
As I understand it’s very unlikely to happen anytime soon as the M1/2 GPUs are very similar but M3 has a completely new architecture. With their reduced staff and the GPU in the M1/2 being notoriously simple in retrospect we’re probably years away.
> Hi! It looks like you might have come from Hacker News.
> Asahi Linux developers are frequent targets of abuse on Hacker News. Despite our pleas, the moderators have not taken effective action to improve the situation.
> Overtly hateful content is often flagged on HN and not immediately visible. Unfortunately, when a comment is flagged and killed, its child subthread is not. That preserves the 'clean' image of the website, but the reduced moderation activity enables abuse to continue. Although you don't see those threads, search engines do. HN uniquely has a high page rank and low moderation, making it a prime target for bad actors to poison search results with abuse, bigotry, and nastiness. This isn't low-level trolling, but an organized attempt to destroy lives, including of developers in our communities.
> Please demand change within your community.
Here we are, still able to see that content.. and so can search engines and AI.
No one here at HN has done anything to remove the content that only exists to attack and demean, even though it looks like troll accounts.
We down vote it, flag it, hide it, but it's still there.
I don't know much about this particular situation, but I can empathize.
I too had the impression people here love asahi Linux. But as the comment said those negative posts tend to disappear.
I’m not fully onboard (I don’t have a MacBook, supporting closed hw from a single vendor) but I see the appeal, and to me getting more people using Linux is major plus that outweighs the negatives. I’m not going to tell people who are generously donating their time to something not to do so.
One of which apologizes on behalf of HN, and thanks Asahi and assures them a majority is grateful for their work.
Another, like most of us, curious, wondering why the reaction is so unhinged, and finding every post from the site is treated this way.
What is the actual proof of that?
There are a few other oddities, but nothing 100% that I'd feel comfortable repeating as I don't have an opinion whether it's true or not.
My read is this is a case of a person taking on a huge project and burning out emotionally.
I don't think that what I've seen, if directed at me, would get the same response -- but I obviously don't see it all, nor have it directed at me, so it's not really fair for me to say.
And there aren’t all that many comments yet.
Nobody has any doubts left at this point in time.
Whole deal is ridiculous.
I'm out of loop, but I demand a dark mode. Burning my eye balls was enough -.-
I saw this as well... what are they talking about? Is this overreacting to random trolling or is some group actively trying to target folks to actually cause harm?
Of course, it's all vague allegations and not a hint of evidence.
HN threads about Asahi, while generally positive about the project, also tend to include trans hate and speculation about a pseudonymous developer's identity. Those comments are often "dead", but show up on search engines. This has caused real harm in the lives of Asahi's trans and pseudonymous developers.
[1]: https://github.com/AsahiLinux/AsahiLinux.github.io/commit/a7...
[2]: https://github.com/AsahiLinux/AsahiLinux.github.io/commit/e0...
Thanks to a very small number of generous humans your M-series Macbook will still be usable even after Apple declares it vintage - and in the meantime you have an alternative which works better for gaming, and hardware support will only keep getting better.
Congrats to those whose work made this update such a bonanza.
https://davidalger.com/posts/fedora-asahi-remix-on-apple-sil...
Please know that donating isn’t just about helping the developers financially, it’s also needed just to purchase new Mac’s every year to test & support (because each new M-series requires additional development to work).
You can donate here: https://asahilinux.org/support/
I'd love to see a ledger, rather than blindly trust donations are used responsibly.
Who even owns the donation account?
If so, where can I buy Asahi Linux for use? Or pay for Asahi Linux software support?
Regarding wanting to see a ledger, their Board minutes can be read here: https://asahilinux.org/docs/project/board/asahi-board/