News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by steve8918 on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:14AM (#4341467)
It seems logical that the easiest attack vector for any type of cloud storage is through social engineering. You're essentially protecting potentially valuable or incriminating data behind millions of dollars worth of firewalls, encryption and other technology... or a customer service representative paid $10-15/hr, if that.

Depending on how valuable the data is to you, it might be easier to just pay off a CSR, and then fake a phone call where you pretend to convince that CSR that you are that person. The person will get fired, but probably won't go to jail unless they can prove collusion. And then they can either find a new job, or depending on which country the person is living in, they can live nicely off of the money for a while.

I'm not sure how to solve this problem, except by having highly paid and specially trained CSRs that do the account resetting, or by never allowing resetting ever, and if you forget your password and your security questions, you're SOL.

I have to admit this only makes me more leery of putting anything on cloud storage, although my own personal data is pretty useless to anyone, which is my only saving grace. Others who are more important might need to think twice about relying on these types of services.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by thaumaturgy on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:44AM (#4341545)
I'll confess, I honestly didn't even consider the possibility that the hacker just social-engineered Apple support. I mean, Mitnick wrote an entire book about that kind of stuff, and the whole HBGary thing went down in sort of the same way, but ... still, to be able to call up the support department of a major technology (!) company, in 2012, pretending to be someone else and get access to their account that way? Apple didn't send a text message to his number-on-file? They didn't try a callback? Were there any challenge-response questions at all?

That's absurd.

This should make every iCloud user reeeeeaally nervous.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ghshephard on Sunday August 05, 2012 @08:13PM (#4343149)
A good social engineering attack knows more about me than I do. They know my first pet, my mother's maiden name, and where all my banking records are. Lots of ways of getting that. Notice - the call was because the guys _phone_ was inoperable. A call back could go to a burner, and Apple would be none the wiser.

Very few, if any, defenses against social engineering, other than (A) Not allowing it, or (B) Requiring a Notarized-registered-letter of identification to start the process.

I'm a fan of using Notaries for password resets. Particularly to my email account, as it's the most valuable thing I own. Double-notarize in the event of two-factor resets. Make it a HUGE burden. Lock me out of email for a week or two if required, but don't give anyone access to my email.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ams6110 on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:11PM (#4341942)
This should make every user of every online service really nervous. It sort of makes the Google/Facebook model of "it's impossible to actually talk to a human" look good.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by tuxidomasx on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:15PM (#4342116)
Indeed, but even companies who don't offer a phone-based customer support service can be susceptible to basic social engineering.

When Facebook was still granting new users access by checking that their email matched a school's domain, I was able to make accounts at multiple schools by sending a forged email (claiming to originate from the school domain) to Facebook support saying something like: "I never received the confirmation email. Will you please activate my account at [email protected]?"

And it worked 90% of the time.

I wonder how many websites nowadays would be susceptible to a targeted and personalized forged email to customer service (especially since emails are frequently used to prove account ownership).

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by sigkill on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:23PM (#4341981)
You know, as much as I laughed at your comment I think you have a point here.

The long times it takes for them to even answer a mail (if at all) would probably give a heads-up to anything fishy going on in your account. Secondly, unless your account is actually worth the wait, they would probably try to attack an easier target instead of Google or Facebook.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by Udo on Sunday August 05, 2012 @03:42PM (#4342398)
True, however it also means if your account does get hacked, you will have to wait weeks until they respond to your plea for help (if they respond at all).

I think neither of these is the solution. If you can't talk to a human you'll never get help if you're locked out. If human support is available, there is always a chance they'll hand over your account to some scammer. Two-factor authentication means you'll be screwed if your second medium is unavailable or highjacked.

Maybe the only way to protect yourself is having independent (offline?) backups that only can control. Sadly, that's not an option regarding a lot of walled-garden services such as Facebook or iCloud.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by niels_olson on Sunday August 05, 2012 @09:00PM (#4343262)
Bluehost requires ID on file before granting SSH access. Seems to me having that link to a meat-space audit trail should be required. In that sense, it would seem to me Google and Facebook should not only offer but demand two-factor authentication to a node in their social graph.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by caller9 on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:44PM (#4342032)
Security through support obscurity?
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ralfn on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:11PM (#4342108)
Not really. More having a smaller attack vector. There are less people that could authorize a reset, they are better paid, and centralized. (rather than being an underpaid store clerk)
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by nikcub on Monday August 06, 2012 @02:52AM (#4344182)
> Apple didn't send a text message to his number-on-file?

"Sir, we are just going to need to send an SMS to your phone number"

"Ok which number is that.. "

"it is the 065 488 48.."

"..that is my old work phone, which I no longer have access to"

Works all the time. The tip with social engineering is to ask for a little at a time. You don't call up and say "I don't have my phone, email, password, and nor do I know my mothers maiden name.. please let me into my account"

You take it all a step at a time and give it a narrative, just like a real user in the predicament would (and I have been in the predicament and called Apple). Works almost every time.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by niels_olson on Sunday August 05, 2012 @09:16PM (#4343301)
My father-in-law told me yesterday about a novel he's reading. The thief wanted to test the target's security system, so he threw clods of dirt over the fence until security came out and investigated. For a week. Then he threw cats over (good luck finding a pissed off cat in the middle of the night). Then they declared the alarm dysfunctional and posted a sign in the security shack: until further notice, disregard alarms between 0300 and 0500.

Makes you wonder if offering accessible customer service, at scale, eventually it's not even the guy on the phone that's the problem. The policy person cries uncle.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by TwoBit on Monday August 06, 2012 @02:28AM (#4344103)
People have been doing this for years to steal cars. Set off its alarm every night till the owner disables it.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by hexagonal on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:42PM (#4342200)
"Humans are the security hole that can never be patched."

Social engineering will always work.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ansgri on Sunday August 05, 2012 @03:46PM (#4342412)
There was an article about HFT recently [0] that mentioned a case where social influence is of small importance: the game is played beyond human capabilities even when really needed.

[0] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4339531

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by Tloewald on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:16AM (#4341634)
On the positive side, perhaps the publicity will cause Apple to tighten up. They have demonstrated that they are serious about security.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by reinhardt on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:34PM (#4342006)
I don't know, I have mixed feelings about this. It's akin to building even more inscrutable captchas or tightening up airport security measures every time a new breach happens. At best it might close one particular loop hole but at what cost and incovenience to millions of people and billions of transactions?

I had the misfortune to lock myself out of my bank account once or twice and the process for unlocking it was so dreadful (a 30 minutes interrogation with questions like "when and where did I make my last ATM transaction") that since then I keep the required sensitive info in a GPG encrypted file so that I never have to call them again. Other equally frustrated but less tech savvy customers are probably doing the same with post-it notes. Is this an improvement?

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by orbitingpluto on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:56PM (#4342248)
I was out of town and went to make a large cash purchase. (The retailer added a very hefty 10% for using debit or credit cards.) So I ran into the problem of a daily cash withdrawal at the ATM. I also did not have anything with me other than an ATM card and a Credit card with me (No ID). Turned out the bank didn't even ask for my ID when I went in. I just explained my situation and they just handed over a couple thousand...

Security at the bank seems discretionary at best.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by rogerbinns on Sunday August 05, 2012 @03:55PM (#4342442)
> Security at the bank seems discretionary at best

No, it is a cost benefit decision. Do you know they don't check the signature on cheques or credit card transactions? Heck I bet if you mail in a change of address they will go ahead and do it, possibly sending something to your old address.

The reality is that fraud is at low levels compared to legitimate transactions. Putting in lots of extra hoops just makes the legitimate transactions harder, and chances are it won't affect those trying to commit fraud since they have a wide variety of things to try while tellers don't (eg fake id in this case).

In this specific case, anyone coming into the branch is on security cameras inside and out. TV shows, the Internet and technology make it increasingly easier to match up the footage with real people. And the bank doesn't bear the full costs of any investigation since they are passed off to the police/FBI.

If you ran the bank would you add a dollar in expenses and one minute per transaction that has a 10% chance of catching fraud, and fraud occurs one in every 25,000 transactions? Would you have the same measures in every branch across the country or have their expense and severity proportional to the amount of fraud that does actually happen at any location?

Despite what we see in films and TV shows, bank robbery is pitiful way to not make money:

http://www.thefiscaltimes.com/Articles/2012/06/11/Why-Robbin...

http://crimeblog.dallasnews.com/2009/04/new-bank-robbery-sta...

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by orbitingpluto on Sunday August 05, 2012 @05:16PM (#4342684)
I totally agree with you but on two points:

1) Cost benefit analysis and discretionary security is not mutually exclusive. It's cost benefit analysis ergo discretionary security.

2) Crime pays. You just have to be sophisticated and powerful enough to not be indicted. (TARP?)

The interesting thing about your comment is when you apply your logic towards combating terrorism. The cumulative harm of prevention of terrorism outweighs the damage and death caused by the terrorism itself. The 'cost-benefit analysis' must take into account the 'positive' externalities for those who advocate those policies.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by rogerbinns on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:31PM (#4343587)
On 1) that is what I meant. The level of security measures is proportional to the risks, and a realisation that every measure costs time and money.

For 2) white collar crime certainly has shorter prison sentences in the US. It is a little harder to apportion blame as directly as with a bank robber. The general cause of problems has been the US government bailing out creditors. Because of that creditors have been laxer in their standards, had lower oversight and a greater tolerance for risk. This is virtually US government policy and has been going on since the 1984 rescue of the creditors of Continental Illinois. Ultimately fixing this involves fixing the US government and the corruption of Congress - see Lawrence Lessig's talk about they operate around money - and smaller things like regulatory capture.

The response to 9/11 has been to massively amplify the original effects, giving a huge return on investment to Al-Qaeda. In the positive column has been some of the security theatre - the appearance of improved security will be reassuring to some people. But everything else has been negative - the government expenditures, making new enemies in Iraq and Afghanistan, the loss of freedom for Americans, the massive invasive spying on Americans, the use of "terrorism" as an excuse for inexcusable things, the loss of American prestige (Guantanamo Bay isn't good PR), the additional friction on American life in both time and money (try taking a flight) and the list goes on.

I don't want to belittle 9/11, but the same number of people die each and every single month on American roads. It happened that same month, and every month since.

IMHO it would be a far better remembrance to the victims if we said "fuck you" to the perpetrators and lived free and open lives despite them, rather than the crippling effects that did happen.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by xenophanes on Monday August 06, 2012 @07:03PM (#4347780)
Some of the people dying on roads are suicides.

Very few are murders. Murders and accidents are not the same thing and not equally bad.

One difference: if you don't do anything about accidents, the rate stays the same. If you don't do anything about murder and just let it happen, the rate goes up as more people realize they can get away with it and serial killers or terrorists get more bold.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by jontas on Sunday August 05, 2012 @08:55PM (#4343254)
Once, while getting a certified check, I was unable to sign correctly (you have to sign two or three times). After a couple of failures the teller turned her computer screen around to show me my saved signature and said "just sign it so it looks like this"
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ralfn on Sunday August 05, 2012 @05:14PM (#4342678)
>Is this an improvement?

Yes. Without the strict checks by your bank, none of their customers would be secure. With their checks in place, some, including you, are now secure.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by TwoBit on Monday August 06, 2012 @02:29AM (#4344109)
Absolutely it is an improvement. I would gladly be subjected to a half hour of questions to protect tens of thousands of dollars.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by omgbear on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:46PM (#4342040)
Sure - you need physical access to get to someone's post-its. Might as well install a keylogger then.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by tomflack on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:34AM (#4341680)
Have they? (Honest question.)
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by uxp on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:13PM (#4341948)
I would argue that yes, they have.

They removed the copy on their website that claimed that "Macs don't get PC Viruses"[1]. They disabled automatic execution of Java Applets in response to Flashback[2]. The introduction of Gatekeeper and the App Store model shows their intention for reducing the vectors average users can install random software (which reduces rogue installations like Flashback). ASLR is fully implemented in Lion now, and the inclusion of FileVault 2 suggests they are aware of and trying to mitigate offline attacks[3]

Regardless if you think this is enough, it does show that they are doing something. For every couple steps forward in closing a security issue, issues such as this article show that more could be done. Security is hard, no OS or company will ever be Perfectly Secure(tm). Apple is not "doing nothing". Claiming that they aren't is an uneducated answer, claiming that they could do more and be more transparent about it is a more valid argument.

[1] http://www.wired.com/wiredenterprise/2012/06/mac_viruses/ [2] http://support.apple.com/kb/HT5242 [3] http://www.securitynewsdaily.com/960-apple-mac-osx-lion-secu...

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by sidewalksuper on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:32PM (#4342000)
I would also argue that with iOS, they have the safest (big) mobile OS available as well. ASLR and DEP have long been implemented and with iOS 6 they are also implementing Kernel ASLR.

Almost everything is sandboxed and there are no known viruses out there (for devices that haven't been jailbroken).

Jailbreaks are still possible (like you said nothing is perfectly secure), but have been slowed down to a point where hackers wait for a big OS release, before they decide to burn the exploits.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by encoderer on Sunday August 05, 2012 @03:28PM (#4342345)
I have no idea if this is related, but just now I attempted to purchase an app on the Mac AppStore and, after authenticating, I was given a prompt to re-enter my password and:

Improve Apple ID Security

- To help ensure the security of your Apple ID, choose three security questions and answers.

Just random because I don't have challenge responses on record, or immediate low-hanging fruit in response to this breach?

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by _djo_ on Sunday August 05, 2012 @04:04PM (#4342462)
Probably just a result of having no challenge responses on record. I experienced something similar a couple of months ago.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by guylhem on Sunday August 05, 2012 @03:18PM (#4342313)
Never considered? Try to call them someday if you forget your passwords, you'll see how easy it is.

My solution at the moment is to remove every passwords from icloud. There're some nice scripts online - just did that and blogged about it on http://en.blog.guylhem.net/post/28778777551/icloud-remove-ke...

It's obvious it can't be trusted until 2-way auth is implemented. hell - if I manage to forget my password and loose my cellphones and homephone numbers, I WANT my icloud data to be gone for good!

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by moe on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:50AM (#4341559)
I'm not sure how to solve this problem

It's easily solved, banks and other institutions have been doing it for years.

The solution is trivial, too: Require physical ID.

In order to open a bank account you have to either show up in person, or provide equivalent proof (e.g. PostIdent).

Why should it be different with cloud-services whose stated goal is to silo all your life's data? Why are they excused on lax security?

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by blaines on Sunday August 05, 2012 @12:44PM (#4341871)
That's a great idea, and I think they already have a platform to do that with, the Apple Store and their Genius Bar. Most major cities have two Apple stores these days, and for people that aren't near one, an option to fax or mail could exist. In addition, a callback or text just plan seems necessary, even if the number is inactive.

The less information the other person (hacker/user) has to offer, the more time it should take to reset. In the meantime Apple should be notifying all the contact information on file about what's going on and offer a way to stop it.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by berntb on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:14PM (#4341950)
>>for people that aren't near [an Apple Store], an option to fax or mail could exist.

Almost ten years ago, I asked an old friend (that got rich doing security for online gambling companies) about verifying identity with VISA cards.

He told me that the Russian mob would open a new account in e.g. the English countryside. When the security people called the (non-mobile) phone number, then someone answered and verified that it was their VISA card and yes, they wanted to open an account.

Edit: If my point isn't clear -- it is that the present capabilities of the criminal networks are probably much superior these days. (Addition: I assume he knew where the criminals came from because of police reports.)

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by e40 on Sunday August 05, 2012 @12:44PM (#4341867)
When I opened my Ing account I didn't need any of this. They verify your identity through a series of questions about your past, as well as your SSN. In fact, all US banks allow accounts to be opened over the 'net now. I've personally done it with several of them.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ams6110 on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:19PM (#4341964)
Yeah, they pull a credit report in real-time and then will do something like show you three cities and ask you to pick one you lived at in the past (with a "none of these" choice also). It's a good idea but I'd think often hackable for targets who are heavy social media users and basically have their life story online and public.

Still pretty good for now, though.

Edit: anyone know what the cost is per query for these services? I assume it's not free, thus likely not feasible for services that don't stand a good chance of providing enough revenue to offset the cost.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by encoderer on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:12PM (#4341946)
That does require a credit pull to accomplish. Not insurmountable (and can be done without damaging the consumers credit score via a so-called "soft pull") but the company doing the pulling has to pay for access to that data.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by tomflack on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:51AM (#4341732)
You're right. When I forgot my battle.net secret question answer and wanted to change my password I had to send Blizzard two forms of ID. For some games.

The solution exists, its in use now and it is mind boggling that for hundreds of dollars in apps, my file vault password, my payment details and of course a remote wipe facility for my hardware it isn't even an option.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by greedo on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:54AM (#4341743)
No, you had to send copies/images of your ID. ID that is trivial for a hacker to duplicate.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by tomflack on Sunday August 05, 2012 @12:08PM (#4341779)
This is true.

There are lots of ways to mitigate this, but would drive up costs considerably.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by wklauss on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:36AM (#4341688)
Physical IDs can be faked.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by viraptor on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:46AM (#4341715)
Isn't that an area that cannot be controlled at all? There are government issued IDs and if a normal company cannot trust them, then there's no way out. Biometric identification can be the last unbreakable protection, but that's also only valid until you find someone who, for example, lost/damaged his eyes in an accident and is up for scamming the company you're targeting.

I mean, there's a reasonable limit of what companies may want to check, but once those proofs can be faked, it's not their responsibility to fix the issue anymore.

(PS. some countries have more restrictions than others too - for example in Poland you need two IDs with a photo to get any kind of mobile plan on a contract - that leaves plenty of ways to verify your identity)

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by elmuchoprez on Sunday August 05, 2012 @12:14PM (#4341795)
It's a question of how closely the ID can be inspected for accuracy.

When I go to the store and buy beer, they want to see my license. They always make me take it out, which means the clerk can feel it, and the "feel" will often give away a fake to someone who has handled thousands of legit IDs. Next, they look at the pic on the ID and then look at me to make sure they at least kinda match. Nobody is really holding them up for a side-by-side, but you at least kind of have to look like the guy on the ID, which immediately limits the pool of people who could be faking my identity. Then, assuming it feels right and looks like me, they scan the ID and verify a record of that ID card with the state, which simply confirms that the state issued such an ID.

Between those three things, the system is actually pretty secure. But when you ask someone to scan in and email a copy of the front of their license as proof of ID, all three of those "checks" are eliminated.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by gcr on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:17PM (#4342121)
Biometrics aren't unbreakable and can be spoofed quite trivially in many cases.

Here's a professor spoofing high-end fingerprint scanners with gelatin and a printer: http://vast.uccs.edu/~tboult/tmp/fingerprint-boult-koaa-medi... (sorry for the sensationalism at the beginning)

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by tedunangst on Sunday August 05, 2012 @03:12PM (#4342300)
If the government database of IDs were available online (perhaps only queryable by a number on the card), the bank could look at the online version and verify it matches. Then you'd at least need to hire a lookalike to fool them.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by PeterisP on Sunday August 05, 2012 @04:41PM (#4342574)
Physical IDs don't get faked [in places where serious physical IDs are used, USA driverlicences in bars don't count] - it's simpler to make counterfeit dollars than counterfeit passports; from what I have seen from banking fraud statistics, if physical IDs are required, fake ID's are an extremely rare circumstance. You do get cases of (a) stolen IDs and (b) IDs bought off of homeless guys, and then used to open accounts and register companies for money laundering, etc. But not fake IDs - it's apparently too much effort and risk when compared to stealing or buying identities.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by wklauss on Sunday August 05, 2012 @07:55PM (#4343088)
Exactly, but as you say the reason is that there's an easier and less risky (although it depends on the quality of the ID) way to get/steal money.

But that doesn't prove that requiring a physical ID is a safer method, just that there is a better workaround.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by narrator on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:47AM (#4341718)
However, showing up in person is a huge inconvenience for a hacker in another country. Another technique banks use is to send a physical piece of snail mail to a physical postal address containing a verification code or card.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by atirip on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:04PM (#4342077)
"I'm not sure how to solve this problem"

Easy. CSR has exactly the same screen as you do. With the same security questions as you have. In this case it seems, those questions were never asked. You design CSR frontend where they must themselves answer those questions before proceed. You may pay off that CSR, but she/he does not know answers to those questions so she/he can not do a thing.

If you forgot answer to those questions, alert is escalated, which needs two together CSR's + their supervisor to unlock your account + you must make Facetime call + whole process gets documented carefully.

What did I miss?

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ChuckMcM on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:13PM (#4342112)
That is an interesting approach. Given the retail presence Apple has the opportunity to ask you to go to an Apple store in person and talk with service personnel there. One could easily put a picture on file (every Apple device has a camera now) of the owner, and the two bits of information:

1) You have the device with you

2) You are the same person as the picture of the owner

Would set a reasonably high bar to cross.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by teach on Sunday August 05, 2012 @05:03PM (#4342645)
I suspect there are a LOT of places in the United States that are a few hours' drive from the closest Apple store.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by draebek on Sunday August 05, 2012 @06:21PM (#4342860)
I agree, I bet there are a ton of Apple users for whom going to an Apple store could be a real pain. However, they could make it an optional account security feature. (Then they just have to handle "you got hacked? Well, that's your fault for turning down our free enhanced security feature!")
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by libria on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:31AM (#4341514)
Perhaps what they need here is an optional 24-hour password reset delay. A user could only adjust this setting when properly logged in. Even if Apple gets social engineered, the user has 24 hours to notice the difference.

Although it's extremely inconvenient to wait 1 full day to get back in, forgetting a password should be a rare circumstance .

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ralfn on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:52AM (#4341569)
No. They just need to implement one of the common protocols. For example, they could just require ID.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by wallawe on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:17AM (#4341638)
If you are willing to take the time to social engineer a CSR to get a password, you are likely willing to take the time to acquire a fake ID. They aren't hard to come by.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ceol on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:53AM (#4341736)
They still require additional effort. Right now, in my pajamas, without leaving my house or spending money, I can do exactly what that hacker did. I probably wouldn't even try it if I knew I would have to get a fake ID just to punish some Gizmodo employee for shits.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ralfn on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:15PM (#4342115)
Besides: banks videotape their customers. We would have the culprit on video.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ralfn on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:07PM (#4342096)
The security of an ID is protected by the state. Screwing around with that is a federal, put your ass in prison, kind of breach, irregardless of your intention or the context.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by r00fus on Sunday August 05, 2012 @05:57PM (#4342788)
Jurisdiction is an issue - what if the attacker is from outside the USA (especially those countries w/o an extradition treaty)?

ID is not a panacea, especially in this case. Apple is probably best to roll out some form of multi-factor auth.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by mikeash on Sunday August 05, 2012 @03:14PM (#4342307)
Spending a few minutes tricking a CSR on the phone isn't even close to the difficulty of obtaining a workable fake ID. Barriers are useful even if they can be crossed with sufficient effort.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by PeterisP on Sunday August 05, 2012 @04:44PM (#4342589)
While it's hard to make a fake ID, it's trivial to make a fake image of ID.

Checking a physical ID would be a somewhat effective barrier. Checking an emailed or faxed image of an ID? Useless.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by mikeash on Sunday August 05, 2012 @05:33PM (#4342730)
That depends greatly on what kind of checking is done on the other side. For example, if they can cross-check your driver's license number with the rest of your info, then making a fake image of an ID that will pass muster will be tough.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by veeti on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:18AM (#4341487)
Maybe this is a great reason to stick with Google's cloud services.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by wklauss on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:31AM (#4341515)
The fact that this happens doesn't have to do with any particular brand. Every company, Google included, is susceptible to this kind of social engineering attacks. Nothing is 100% safe. You can take every precaution possible and there will always be a weak link in the chain.

Apple will double down in security now, especially regarding iCloud, but even doing so there is a chance that this will happen again. Same for Microsoft, Sony and, yes, Google.

There's no magic solution other than being careful. And even with that security is always an illusion. Your door lock is easily opened, no matter how much money you put in it, the only thing preventing you from being robbed is that are more houses in your neighbourhood and that some of those could seem like an easier target.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ralfn on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:50AM (#4341561)
Google isnt susceptible to this kind of social engineering attack.

It requires the existence of a customer service in the first place. Good luck trying to call Google.

There is no "magic" solution, there are just solutions. But to suggests its all the same... Thats just lazy.

Apple is more vulnerable, because they do do customer support. Sony was more vulnerable, because they just dint give a shit, and didnt bother anything to secure it.

Microsoft and Google still have a zero incident record. After all this time. They even went beyond their own responsibility many times, getting police involved because they suspected targetted (political) malware.

And no, in the world of formal discrete systems (computers) there are provable correct, and provably incorrect solutions. For example: DRM can always be hacked, but we can secure ourselves from the middlemen.

Any analog with a "door" deserves only ridicule.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by Tloewald on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:24AM (#4341652)
Microsoft and Google have zero incidents only for very large values of zero. Google "gmail account hacked" or "Xbox live account hacked" or "hotmail account hacked".

In the last case, the top links are to Microsoft's FAQ pages.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by esolyt on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:39AM (#4341698)
Irrelevant because those accounts are hacked by someone who acquired the password of the actual user by a keylogger etc. They were not exploiting flaws related to server side. In iCloud's case, there is nothing the user could have done to prevent this attack.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by Tloewald on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @12:31AM (#4348725)
Nor we're they in this case -- they were exploiting server side features of Amazon ( working as intended ) and Apple's tech support policies ( working as intended ). If anything this is a policy failure.

Not having any customer support worth a damn is a different kind of policy failure. (For example.)

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by itsprofitbaron on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:43AM (#4341709)
Just because a company can have their FAQ pages SEO'd to the top of the SERPS doesn't mean their services haven't been hacked.

Most people who get hacked hardly ever report it, they just want their account(s) back.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by Tloewald on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @12:29AM (#4348718)
I think you missed my point. If recovering a hacked account is an FAQ then presumably some accounts get hacked. Just maybe?
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by siglesias on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:07AM (#4341614)
From the article:

The backup email address on my Gmail account is that same .mac email address. At 4:52 PM, they sent a Gmail password recovery email to the .mac account.

Here Gmail was only as strong as the weakest password recovery email service it was linked to. I consider this a failure on Google's part.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by myko on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:10AM (#4341622)
With two factor authentication enabled this shouldn't be an issue.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by siglesias on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:48AM (#4341722)
Why not require it then?
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by dvhh on Sunday August 05, 2012 @12:00PM (#4341757)
not useable in all country. Not applicable on imap, pop3. Use case where an email account serve more than 1 physical person. Unusable while you travel.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by dnr on Sunday August 05, 2012 @12:44PM (#4341868)
"Unusable while you travel" or in other countries is simply false: one of the two-factor authentication options is the google authenticator app on your smartphone, which requires no internet/phone connectivity at all. It's time-based.

The imap/pop thing is still a legitimate concern. App-specific passwords let those continue working, but they have security issues of their own.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by kisielk on Monday August 06, 2012 @12:20AM (#4343708)
And yet another option is a set of emergency use codes that you write down or print on a card.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by m_eiman on Sunday August 05, 2012 @12:36PM (#4341856)
It's quite possible to add two-factor logins for any protocol, that works in any country with a cell phone network. Just demand a response to a challenge via cell phone before validating the password, you could even require one of those RSA token thingies if you want. Just a matter of cost and convenience.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by nazar on Sunday August 05, 2012 @03:40PM (#4342388)
I used 2 step verification for my gmail. Our cell phone operator cannot receive international sms (I know, that sucks), so I used my home phone, so every time I logged in to my gmail I received a call from google voice robot to tell me the pin number. It sounded perfect at first, but when I started to actually use it, I noticed everytime I needed to login to gmail, I wasn't home. I'd call my parents so they could say me the pin or use the backup codes that google provided me with. That was so uncomfortable I had to turn it off.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ams6110 on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:21PM (#4341970)
Not everyone has a cell phone.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by wklauss on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:11AM (#4341624)
Phone is not the only way to access customer support. And for the look of this, BTW, Mat's gmail account got hacked first and then the social engineering on Apple side took part (the password reset was sent to his gmail account).

Im not suggesting that doing nothing is the same of doing something. Im just saying that not matter how secure and prepared Apple had been, this could have happened anyway.

Zero incident record, in any case, seems very unrealistic. I don't know any particular case first hand but then again i'm sure this is not the first time this happens with an iCloud account either. Mat is a public person and has commented his case publicly and thats why we are openly talking about it here.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ralfn on Sunday August 05, 2012 @05:11PM (#4342663)
Security is a two way street: both the user, as well as the company have a responsibility.

When i claimed certain high target technological companies have a zero incident grade, im talking about the fact the companies were never themselves the weak link.

If this guys account was hacked because he tattoos his password on his forehead, Apple too would be in the clear. But here, not the user, but the company screwed up.

There are many, many companies which do not have incidents, or take full responsibility when they do. The type of incidents we complain about, often indicate just gross negliance. (and this is gross negliance by Apple)

You are repeating the claim that there is no watertight security. This claim is wrong. Software can be provably secure. Authentification can be provably secure, just like any type of Content protection is provably unsecure.

Now, you are also making the claim, that we are talking about this, because of the affected users popularity.

Maybe thats why you are talking about it. But most of us are actually surprised because of the gross negliance. ICloud has no authentification, one can just call up, and take over the account. As we now know.

And if this was any other company, i doubt anyone would argue against this obvious and pretty much indisputable fact. But this isnt Sony, this is Apple, and they can never do anything wrong right? Eventhough, statistically, just like any other company, they might could not excel in every way. Maybe this is just one area, where they just screwed up?

Theyll learn from it, hopefully. But lets not pretend it didnt happen, or that it isnt as big as a fuckup as it actually is, back here in reality.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by jontas on Sunday August 05, 2012 @09:03PM (#4343269)
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by cwisecarver on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:38AM (#4341525)
If I got veeti's joke then I think what he was trying to say was that it's nearly impossible to get Google on the phone unless you're a corporate customer. If I didn't get his joke then I'm making it now. joke
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by swdunlop on Sunday August 05, 2012 @01:07PM (#4341936)
It was the first thing I thought. "Hah! Good luck getting Google to answer a phone.." Then I thought, "wait, was that a joke?"
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by wklauss on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:51AM (#4341563)
joke's on me then :)

But back to my point social engineering doesn't require voice. you can do it via email just as easily.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by chmars on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:30AM (#4341669)
Again there is no Google mail support to speak of (even with Google Apps for Business in my experience).
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ThePherocity on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:51AM (#4341730)
Sure there is. if you pay for your Google Apps account: http://support.google.com/a/bin/request.py
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by chmars on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @05:39AM (#4349354)
That's why I mentioned Google Apps for Business, that's the paid service you are referring too. There's support but it's still very difficult to get in contact with an actual human being. Social engineering via Google Apps support seems therefore highly unlikely to me.

(I am a Google Apps for Business user and have had to contact Google Apps support a few times … the process has never been really pleasant.)

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by steve8918 on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:41AM (#4341538)
I agree. If it's a random attack, then the probability is relatively low to get attacked. But if you're targeted, quite frankly it's probably very easy to attack you, either virtually or physically.

One thing I do know, though, is that like you said, security is likely going to get tightened across the board, and that means that it's going to get a lot more inconvenient for all of us. I guess that's a good thing, but it will definitely impact the usability of these services.

If it means that all vendors will tie their services to a two-factor authentication scheme linked to our phone, well that might just stop me from using the services altogether.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by wklauss on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:56AM (#4341581)
I think the services can be improved without becoming too annoying. Someone in this thread suggested a 24 hour delay, which seems reasonable. You could also send a "last call" email and text message to make sure the right user is the one that has requested the password change. Apple could easily separate Find my Mac from "wiping", or add a second password for that.

None of these will be 100% effective, but it will make things more difficult for attackers and not too uncomfortable for users.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by yen223 on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:18AM (#4341488)
I once had to reset the password of my stock trading account.

All they needed for verification was my home address.

I am also pretty leery of putting anything online.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by dennisgorelik on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:48AM (#4341719)
Didn't they call you back to your phone number prior to resetting your password?
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by fossuser on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:58PM (#4342256)
This entire thing reminds me of the mud puddle test. (http://blog.cryptographyengineering.com/2012/04/icloud-who-h...)

In fact that entire blog post is pretty on point.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by loceng on Sunday August 05, 2012 @11:34AM (#4341683)
Didn't everyone learn this lesson from Hackers?
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by switch007 on Sunday August 05, 2012 @02:44PM (#4342207)
HR can screen for people that have been bankrupt, and (probably a lot trickier) personalities that might be susceptible to taking bribes.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by dinkumthinkum on Sunday August 05, 2012 @08:20PM (#4343174)
Take two people, one went bankrupt 10 times, one never, both make minimum wage. Offer them a $10 million dollar bribe. Is one really less likely to be bribed than the other?
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by switch007 on Monday August 06, 2012 @04:44AM (#4344450)
I didn't mean to imply it was a good method but rather make the point that HR are actually doing this.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by maxerickson on Monday August 06, 2012 @09:49AM (#4345155)
So people protecting $11 million probably shouldn't use such a weak check.

What about people protecting $500?

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by rogerchucker on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:25AM (#4341505)
This _could_ be a lesson in not trusting cloud services where issues can be resolved by human intermediaries. Sounds a bit counter-intuitive but to me a bit more reassuring. But I could be wrong.
Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ThePherocity on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:40AM (#4341536)
Whoa, wait, what? What occured was a simple confidence hack, not some industrial spy escapade.

Anyway, to answer your initial point, two factor authentication helps with this problem, as you have to still have the security token to authenticate. And if the "Something you have" gets stolen, then you need a manager to work through it to get you set up again, and all resets are heavily monitored and audited.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by steve8918 on Sunday August 05, 2012 @10:51AM (#4341565)
My point wasn't that this particular incident was some great case of industrial espionage. But it's a rather easy slippery slope to that outcome.

But what if your website is secured behind an Amazon EC2 or Linode CSR? Isn't Instagram and Netflix run at least in part on EC2? I have no clue what the security schemes are for either of those service providers, but if they allow CSRs to change passwords, then it's the same thing. If the CSRs can be paid off, or fooled over a phone call, then it might be cheaper to just do that if they want to inflict potentially millions of dollars worth of damage to a rival.

Having the security of your entire business behind a single CSR or a cell phone is the equivalent of millions of dollars worth of Cisco firewalls being outdone by a $20 wifi-router plugged into the internal network.

Re:Apple Support Allowed Hacker Access to Reporter's iCloud ... by ThePherocity on Tuesday August 07, 2012 @11:34PM (#4353752)
Yea, that's all protected by multifactor authentication. Front line CSR's don't need a raise over this. Maybe they have other reasons, sure. But not this.