News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by chirau on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:52PM (#43394566)
May I ask a not so smart question... What is the big deal with thumbnails for YouTube videos. Like, I am always hearing about these thumbnails as if they can make or break a video/channels outcomes.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by bloqs on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:40PM (#43394896)
Youtube content is driven heavily by children and sheltered people who are easily engaged with animalistic displays of expression and bright colors. I wish I was joking
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:58PM (#43395631)
Why are you being so weird about this?

Traditional print publishers put lots of efforts into making the covers of their books and magazines attractive and indicative of what you can expect inside.

You _can_ judge a book by its cover, _if_ the publisher is doing their job right.

Why would online video be any different?

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by bloomingkales on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:10AM (#43395675)
Magazine and book readers are not the same fiends that is Gen Z.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:53AM (#43395903)
People have been complaining about 'kids these days' for longer than recorded history.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by bloomingkales on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:57AM (#43395922)
These are different kids, seriously, ask them yourself. No generation was raised like this ever in history.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by Mogzol on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:18AM (#43396019)
No generation was raised like the previous one ever in history
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by mavhc on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @05:45AM (#43397388)
the kids of 10000 BC are totally unlike the kids of 10020 BC
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by NiloCK on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @06:00AM (#43397505)
This is only true recently! Through most of history people lived and died with technology and culture nearly identical to that of their parents / grandparents. In terms of tech and cultural evolution, we are on the uptick of a hockey-stick growth.

It's absolutely accurate that `kids these days` have grown up in a different environment than `grownups these days` than the same demographics from 50, 100, 200, or 1000 years ago.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by rezonant on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:17AM (#43396015)
OK Boomer.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by outadoc on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:25AM (#43396872)
Were you raised as the TV generation or the video game generation? Because I guarantee you your elders were saying the same thing about your generation.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:41AM (#43396935)
Don't forget Rock and/or Roll!
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by kbelder on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:07PM (#43401078)
And comic books.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by bloomingkales on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @10:22AM (#43399789)
Okay. You don’t think this is serious. Hang out on Twitch for a week. If you don’t walk away thinking it’s a crack den of addiction and sex then, just ew, stop talking to me.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by BoingBoomTschak on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @03:31AM (#43396622)
And have people been wrong? Have our societies not changed a iota? Is protracted decline impossible?
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by rat87 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @03:58AM (#43396731)
Considering that people have been making such complaints for millennium and we aren't so terrible as so many generations of detiraration would imply they're usuallybut not always wrong
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by a-french-anon on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:42AM (#43396939)
Anyway, even if people have always complained about it (which remains to be proven really; inb4 single data point of Plato), doesn't mean it's always or even most of the time wrong.

The "kids just lack manners these days" should also be separated from more detailed criticism.

That whole thing about denying that decadence is even possible is so comically a symptom of people being part of said decadence not wanting to admit it.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by bloomingkales on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:36PM (#43402231)
Thank you, you are much more diplomatic about this. I wrote a few horrifyingly aggressive responses to a few here about this because I'm a little astonished that people still give this whole phenomena a pass.

From my other post:

Overall, when the parents lose control of the child, the culture takes over parenting. When the culture is ridiculous, the child grows to become a ridiculous adult and won't know it and possibly even defend it.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by dsego on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @07:07AM (#43397992)
Empires have fallen and civilizations have crumbled, an idiocracy like scenario is not unimaginable.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by bloomingkales on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:33PM (#43402191)
You just don't know how bad you are or how bad your society is. Do you think the Taliban thinks they are fucked up? I'm not comparing you to the Taliban, I'm just asking what do you think they think? It's important to think about what we think.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @09:15PM (#43407308)
I did a bit of digging, and just like eg your typical American will tell you many of the ways they think the US is 'fucked up', the Taliban will also tell you where their own society falls short of their ideals.

Of course, their ideals will most likely differ from your ideals. In addition, even where multiple people might share abstract ideals, their ideas about how to effect these ideals will often differ.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by galaxyLogic on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @02:02AM (#43396194)
Sorry for being perhaps a bit pedantic but, not really. You can (and should) get an idea about what the book is about by its cover. But you cannot "judge" the (quality of the) content of the book by its cover.

That would be like saying you can judge the quality of a cereal-brand by its box. Special-K? That is really special.

The Book might be full of lies or incorrect information no matter how beautiful its cover is.

You can judge the quality of the cover of the book by looking at the cover. :-)

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by ben_w on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:00AM (#43396743)
> That would be like saying you can judge the quality of a cereal-brand by its box. Special-K? That is really special.

> The Book might be full of lies or incorrect information no matter how beautiful its cover is.

Cereal "might be", but almost nobody has motivation to do so — this is market differentiation to tell you what you're buying.

Compare and contrast:

https://i5.walmartimages.com/seo/Kellogg-s-Special-K-Origina...

https://duckduckgo.com/?q=budget+cornflakes&t=iphone&iar=ima...

https://www.kaufland.de/product/338169035/?search_value=cere...

None of these will be surprise Weetabix in soy sauce. None is actually a frozen pizza. None is garden fertiliser.

Similar with books and youtube videos. It's not a claim that "beauty is truth and truth beauty", it's a claim the thumbnail/cover tells you what the video/book is about.

Good branding used to be expensive, before GenAI (now I'm not sure). If you could afford it, you could afford good content; if you could only afford good branding or good content but not both… it happens, of course, but it leads to angry refund demands IRL, and no organic viral growth for videos.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by typeofhuman on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:14PM (#43395076)
Do YouTube engineers make great content, are they allowed to?

I've interacted with Google, Meta, Amazon, Twitch engineers. But yet to with a YouTube engineer.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by KetoManx64 on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:22PM (#43395117)
Mostly videos about:getting chai lattes on the roof, 3 course meals from 4 star restraunts for lunch and yoga sessions in the early afternoon after a quick meeting with the manager. Aka "Average day in the life of a YouTube engineer"
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:59PM (#43395637)
Google food isn't actually all that great in most of their offices.

Sydney, where I used to work for them, is pretty good; New York is decent. But I was rather underwhelmed by my visits to Mountain View.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by asadotzler on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:34AM (#43396085)
It was great when I was eating there in 2005-2007.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @09:11PM (#43407276)
My experience was from the mid 2010s. So perhaps they went downhill?
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by wahnfrieden on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:00PM (#43395335)
those are produced by recruiting
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by all2 on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:47PM (#43395572)
So I need a job on the recruiting team. Got it.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by chris_wot on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:04PM (#43395017)
Hey, some of less unsheltered adults are swayed by it also!
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by vunderba on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:10PM (#43394694)
Though I haven't seen stats to back it up - I've heard from multiple sources that thumbnails which include a gigantic bobblehead of the author with a particularly exaggerated stupid looking expression on their face induce more people to click through.

Even if it's for the sake of feeding the algorithm, I do my best to skip them.

I also internally prioritize videos which:

- avoid usage of superlatives "TOP X", "BEST OF Y"

- have more than 5k views and less than 250k views.

After a while, my YT recommendations have become mostly solid.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by ryandrake on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:14PM (#43394730)
It's called YouTube Face[1] and the fact that it works makes me weep for humanity.

1: https://allscience.substack.com/p/on-the-grim-reality-of-you...

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by zozbot234 on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:21PM (#43394769)
> It's called YouTube Face[1] and the fact that it works makes me

( ͡ಠ ʖ̯ ͡ಠ)

(fixed it for you)

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by araes on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:20PM (#43395110)
From looking at the link you posted, the immediate consideration, is it looks like they're all optimizing for a pornography face. Would not be very surprising based on the reputation of the internet.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by johnmaguire on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:56PM (#43394973)
It doesn't exactly help with your goal, but tangentially, I use a browser addon called DeArrow, from the creator of SponsorBlock, which replaces thumbnails and clickbait titles with a video still / user-submitted ones. I often forget it's installed until I use another browser, but it's a really nice experience!

https://dearrow.ajay.app/

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by DidYaWipe on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:53PM (#43395605)
Even worse are headlines that say

TOP 10 BEST

When you have "top" and a word ending with "est" in the same headline, you've done it wrong.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by petesergeant on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:47PM (#43395577)
> that thumbnails which … induce more people to click through

Entirely conjecture on my part, but I imagine this _was_ true, has now been done to death, and no longer has any juice left in it. It’s how all the marketing stuff goes: discovered, early adopters get great results, everyone starts doing it and it loses any value.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eru on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:01AM (#43395644)
> discovered, early adopters get great results, everyone starts doing it and it loses any value.

You might still lose out, if you don't do it?

Just like virtually every car these days has great safety features, so it's not a good selling point; but just try selling a car with 1980s levels of safety.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by petesergeant on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:51AM (#43395887)
Possibly! I guess it's probably best to be guided by if the real pros are still using them. I think people are less likely to click on obvious clickbait these days, precisely because they recognize it, than on more authentic headlines. Supporting your PoV though is that MrBeast's noggin' is still prominently in his thumbnails.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by gblargg on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:38PM (#43394888)
I mostly skip videos with arrows in the thumbnails.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by p_ing on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:03PM (#43395011)
PBS Space Time started doing it. Along with some clickbait/pull titles. I stopped watching.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by abenga on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:58PM (#43395630)
For channels I already subbed to, I forgive that if the quality remains consistent. PBS Space Time's videos have remained stellar, as always.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eco on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:50AM (#43395879)
Check out the DeArrow extension. Crowd sourced thumbnails and titles. It's great.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by account42 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @06:51AM (#43397872)
This is like removing the warning signs from toxic material containers.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eco on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @04:42PM (#43404833)
It's not though. Even generally good YouTubers are forced to play the thumbnail game. Garbage content is typically revealed in the community title.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by gblargg on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:55PM (#43418900)
Nobody is forced to use them. If they really want an audience swayed by arrows, I don't want to be part of their audience.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by p_ing on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @08:37AM (#43398686)
That's actually pretty damned good.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by gblargg on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @08:54PM (#43418896)
I don't want to hide the arrow. I WANT to know what channels to avoid just by looking at the thumbnail. It's a feature, not a bug.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by eco on Wednesday March 19, 2025 @09:58PM (#43419239)
You can configure it to not be enabled by default, but you click a little blue circle next to the title and it will show you the community version.

Plenty of good content is forced to play the clickbait thumbnail/title game and it would be a shame to miss some of it because of YouTube's incentive problems.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by wruza on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @02:34AM (#43396347)
gigantic bobblehead of the author with a particularly exaggerated stupid looking expression on their face induce more people to click through

I never avoided these. They naturally make me puke and disgust and want to smash their degenerate faces if I ever see one on the street. No need for doing my best. The realization that so many people happily click through that was sickening at the time. It’s “open doors” party in asylum and people rushing in in excitement.

Btw, many channels seem to moved on from that, in self-moderation after a short period of experiments. Those who stuck to it showed the most increase in mental deficiency and turning to stupid comedy/meme show rather than original material. One example of that were these new LTT formats, afair.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by dsego on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @07:09AM (#43398010)
> want to smash their degenerate faces

You're supposed to smash the like button and remember to comment and subscribe.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by wruza on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @08:28AM (#43398612)
Yeah, to give it a high five and steal its cheaps while it enjoys my company. And subscribe, cause only 13% of me are subscribed, please (god please).
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by phire on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:37PM (#43394880)
You know how YouTubers are always talking about how "the algorithm" didn't like this video, or loves that video. Or that "the algorithm" is a huge black block which nobody knows how it works.

Youtube's "the algorithm" will make or break both videos and channels.

But "the algorithm" isn't really a mystery. At a basic level, it just shows a bunch of video recommendations to viewers, and measures if they click it or not (watch time, comments, likes also factor into the algorithm, but none of that matters if they don't click first). The higher the click-through rate, the more the video is pushed in recommendations.

And the only things a viewer sees is the thumbnail, channel name, and video title. They have to decide which video they are going to watch based on just that.

So really, a large chunk of "the algorithm" is just how appealing your thumbnail is to potential views.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by chaorace on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:38PM (#43395525)
There actually is an outcome worse than a missed click: if too many viewers are abandoning your video within the first few minutes (i.e. before midrolls), you'll experience substantial downranking.

More or less, the art of making a successful video requires:

* An attention-grabbing thumbnail

* A curiosity-provoking title & premise

* A strong hook which convinces the viewer to put the screen down and let it run

* Editing which delivers the information at an engaging (yet monetizable) pace

* Packaging said information so that it is intelligibly balanced across the mediums (audio/text/video)

* ^^^ Doing this all in a style which still retains enough uniqueness to establish a repeat viewerbase

"The algorithm" is a system for efficiently delivering novel videos with these qualities to the audiences who will most eagerly consume them, which is an essential function for a platform with 2 billion monthly users. For every video on lowest-common-denominator celebrity junk, there's a dozen niche videos tailored to some ravenous subculture or other. Not all magazines are tabloids... but just about anyone can kill time with a tabloid, so that's what leads.

Unlike magazine stands, however, the platform will eventually learn to only show you the thumbnails for videos you'll want to finish watching. It's almost embarassing to share... but here's an example batch of 12 recommendations, almost all of which I'm likely to (eventually) click on and fully watch: https://i.imgur.com/dygfXXb.png

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by brudgers on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:29AM (#43395761)
the art of making a successful video requires

Only to the degree Youtube defines success for a person.

As a form of creative expression, a Youtube video can be successful independent of the analytics.

Sure defining success on your own terms means you need a day job. But defining success on Youtube’s terms treats Youtube as a day job anyway.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by encom on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:35AM (#43396087)
It requires all of these things, yes, but it also must deal with a topic approved by Google. So not offensive to an american coastal liberal type of person.

One popular channel who commentates on american police body cam footage, replaces the gunshot sounds with animal noises. It's ridiculous. Also no discussion or use of tobacco. Many times I've heard people refer to Adolf Hitler as "bad mustache man" for fear of getting censored or demonetised. One channel that discusses historical firearms, is censoring the 1933-1945 german reichsflag. And so on and so on. It's all so tiresome.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by account42 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @06:56AM (#43397914)
It's unfortunately not just YouTube but all social media. Self-censoring like "unalived" or 'k**ed" to avoid the wrath of the algorithm is becoming all too common.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by mrheosuper on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:43PM (#43394911)
not sure if this is good thing, but recently i've seen youtube recommend videos from very small channel(sub <10k)
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by SoftTalker on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:20PM (#43395438)
I think there’s a randomized inclusion of new content just to see if anyone clicks it.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by dboreham on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:20PM (#43395435)
Like thread priority inversion.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by s1artibartfast on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:00PM (#43394996)
I think the mystery is in the categorization of interests and user profiling. The click is central to the process, but the magic is getting your pie video in front of someone on a baking video binge, and not someone trying to to fix their oven.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by xingped on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:56PM (#43394589)
Think of it like a book cover. Regardless of a book's title or summary, an attractive (attracting? attention grabbing?) cover will get more people to click it. Also depending on where the thumbnail is displayed, you may not see the full video title, such as the grid after a video finishes playing.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by technion on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:21PM (#43394770)
I have tobwonder how many variations of "gaping mouths and shocked expressions" we can come up with.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by xingped on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:13PM (#43395072)
I do hate that style of thumbnail too. But hey, it just tells me not to click on the video. So it serves its purpose for me. But metrics I guess tell the youtubers that that thumbnail brings in lots of traffic. I think especially younger kids gravitate to it, unfortunately.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by KetoManx64 on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:23PM (#43395122)
https://dearrow.ajay.app/ will replace those thumbnails automatically for you
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by dylan604 on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:33PM (#43395179)
Unfortunately, the addage doesn't hold. You can pretty much judge the YT video by the cover.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by pyinstallwoes on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:18PM (#43395428)
I guess you’re in the minority of thinking people.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by danielheath on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:55PM (#43394585)
At the end of a video, youtube shows thumbnails for several "suggested next videos".

The thumbnail, video name and channel name are the only bits of information potential viewers see - if your thumbnail isn't good, they aren't even going to _start_ your video, let alone keep watching it.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by DidYaWipe on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:52PM (#43395600)
It's really embarrassing at this point. Even once-respectable content creators feel that they must now resort to absurd mugging in every thumbnail.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by grandempire on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:19PM (#43394756)
Mr Beast says he designs the thumbnail before making the video, then plans how to make a video to fit it.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by SunlitCat on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:04PM (#43395019)
That sounds kinda like first finding a name for a software project (or the final product) and then design the product around that name! :D
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by grandempire on Monday March 17, 2025 @11:55PM (#43395617)
It does sound silly, but it also points to shallow nature of YouTube content. If you don’t have a good thumbnail it’s going to limit the success of your video because some percentage won’t click on it. It’s just how it goes.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by cl0ckt0wer on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:10PM (#43395057)
More like designing the storefront before designing the business.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by speckx on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:58PM (#43395325)
Or getting a domain name before doing everything else.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by Conan_Kudo on Monday March 17, 2025 @08:54PM (#43394581)
Because they can. The thumbnails are the first impression of a video, and if it isn't attention-grabbing, the video suffers.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by loeg on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:28PM (#43394810)
It's like a headline in visual form. The most attention-grabbing thumbnail gets the clicks.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by CyberDildonics on Monday March 17, 2025 @09:19PM (#43394752)
Everyone knows you need the mouth open dumb face or the completely fake AI image for max brain rot which drives views and "engagement" (commenting on the fact that it's nonsense with people then defending the video as an authority as if it isn't stock footage with an AI voice reading a reddit comment).
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by giuseppe_petri on Monday March 17, 2025 @10:01PM (#43394999)
I've been calling this concept "enragement". I'm sure I'm not the only one.
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by brudgers on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @12:22AM (#43395731)
From my practical experience, they seem to make a difference in initial engagement which in turn makes a difference in algorithmic promotion which in turn makes a difference in overall “performance.”

Tracking what you click on versus what you don’t, you might recognize that certain thumbnails make you more likely to take a pass.

For clarity, my experience is at hobby scale and part of that hobby is learning about youtube. Trying to make the line go up is fun (until it isn’t) and a little attention to thumbnails seems to make the line go up.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by JohnTHaller on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @01:21AM (#43396028)
It's a smart question. It wouldn't seem to make much difference since you'd assume people would have channels they're subscribed to or search for something specific. Much of YouTube watch time is based on discovering new videos. And a big part of that is the thumbnail people see when they're looking at suggested content, related content, or search results. Colors, whether there are faces, fonts, images, etc all make a difference. And it varies over time and genre. YouTube has tools built in so you can A/B test different thumbnails and automatically select the better performing one.

Note that I haven't done any of this myself except for making a couple thumbnails for personal videos. I was curious and watched a YouTube video about thumbnails and why they're important.

Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by ako on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @02:07AM (#43396215)
What capabilities was gimp missing to create these thumbnails?
Re:GIMP 3.0 Released by numpad0 on Tuesday March 18, 2025 @03:38AM (#43396648)
I think there's a minor confusion going on here with respect to what constitutes a good YouTube thumbnail as well as what are good YouTube contents.

Very few of channels I subscribe and watch, such as Forgotten Weapons, Technology Connections, Scott Manley, USCSB, CuriousMarc, media.ccc.de, etc. uses that open mouth YouTube face for their thumbnails, if they display a human face in a thumbnail at all. I would consider Doug Demuro videos to be embarrassingly deep into "typical YouTube stupidity" realm to admit watching, but even he tend to leave his mouth less than fully open.

Do they not engineer their thumbnails to "appease the algorithm" - they do, by showing accurate and intriguing previews of what is to be presented, that for those channels often happens not to be an adult male human face with all orifices articulated to near or past mechanical limits, which, by the way, is an another one of optima.

The statement "one can(not) judge a book by its cover" is not functionally equal to "books dipped longest in fluorescent yellow dye sell the most", at all. Apples and oranges both have their place.