News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by giantg2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:20PM (#43248544)
I hate the large scale turbines. I'm sure small scale or other designs are OK. But screw the large turbines. Where I grew up they outsourced the jobs and then we were left with ugly giants ruining the once beautiful mountains. It's on par with strip mining (aesthetically).
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by cr__ on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:20PM (#43248549)
I like em.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by alabastervlog on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:41PM (#43248709)
They're one of the only pieces of technology that I think often (not always) improve the appearance of a landscape.

Maybe also lighthouses. Sometimes.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by giantg2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:02PM (#43248895)
Lighthouses have only become aesthetic because of their rarity rendering them as quaint or nostalgic. Modern versions and their impacts would be largely protested.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by Nasrudith on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @01:39AM (#43251062)
I suspect the real reason behind objections to technology being visible is basically "It makes me feel old by highlighting that I came from a time before X and now everyone will just become accustomed to X!".
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by Propelloni on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @02:16AM (#43251355)
And I'm like "whoa, I'm living in the future!" It's awesome!
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by giantg2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:26PM (#43248589)
I bet you like when they clear cut a mountain top for a solar project too.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by thinkingtoilet on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:34PM (#43248651)
Where do you think coal and oil comes from? It's ok as long as other people's environment is destroyed for non-renewable energy but not your environment for renewable energy?
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by giantg2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:41PM (#43248714)
Lol, they used to mine coal under that very mountain (until it was outsourced). It's not like we have some insular life. The region is economically depressed. People would rather have jobs while destroying the environment than not have jobs while destroying the environment and recreational value simultaneously.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by kibwen on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:44PM (#43248733)
You have absolutely no idea what you're talking about. Please stop.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mountaintop_removal_mining

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by roenxi on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:58PM (#43248865)
Have they ever used that technique in the UK? I don't think the UK has mountains suitable for mountaintop removal - they are famous for their underground operations.

I've always filed mountaintop removal mining as one of those "weird things Americans do" approaches. Probably associated with unusual geology or something.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by giantg2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:04PM (#43248920)
I think the UK had the none-mountainous version of strip mining - open pit mines. I think there aren't any in operation currently, and I'm unsure if they were for coal or just other commodities.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by nkali on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:22PM (#43249031)
Even if not, the collieries in Wales, built on top of coal shafts, were quite industrial-looking/landscape-runining. https://museum.wales/articles/1260/Nantgarw-Colliery---once-...
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by 6LLvveMx2koXfwn on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:29PM (#43249072)
We used the technique until we ran out of mountains, hence current lack of mountains.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by giantg2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @07:59PM (#43248878)
Haha, I'm sorry but it's hilarious that you guys are arguing with the person who had firsthand knowledge. It's ironic, really. You're talking about strip mining. There are other types of mines (drift, slope, shaft, etc).
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by marliechiller on Monday March 03, 2025 @11:37PM (#43250348)
and all of them are horrendously bad for the environment, the end.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by giantg2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @11:47PM (#43250431)
As are the wind turbines with there non-recyclable blades and bird kills.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:35PM (#43249105)
> People would rather have jobs

Who do you think puts up windmills and solar panels?

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by giantg2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:05PM (#43249368)
In the case I personally know of, they brought in offshore workers. It also only generates reasonable numbers of jobs during initial construction.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @08:59AM (#43254669)
> offshore workers

Also people who need jobs. And that's just the case you personally know of. Maybe people should retrain instead of pining for jobs of the past. And we should support them in the transition as much as possible .

> only generates reasonable numbers of jobs during initial construction

We're gonna need a lot of initial construction though.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by johnnyanmac on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:02PM (#43248901)
Sure why not?

Maybe it's a geographical/cultural difference, but there are so, so many mountains in the western US. it's a good part of why the game Oregan Trail was made. Before carving roads around and through mountains it was a truly treacherous journey.

US also jury has so much land to begin with. We can certainly afford to retrofit a few mountains without fundamentally disrupting the ecosystem. We're very bad at moderation, sadly.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:34PM (#43249097)
When is that?
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by walthamstow on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:52PM (#43249249)
People forget that the natural landscape of Britain is forest. The enclosed fields people think are natural countryside are in fact an entirely human creation.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by Myrmornis on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:26PM (#43249925)
I'm sorry you're saying people think agricultural fields are natural vegetation?
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by walthamstow on Monday March 03, 2025 @11:21PM (#43250248)
Yes. The gently rolling fields of grass, sheep, rape and wheat are considered a national symbol of our natural environment in need of protection from dastardly human creations such as wind turbines. This is the 'green and pleasant land' that William Blake wrote about.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by rsynnott on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:30AM (#43251940)
I’m not sure anyone consciously thinks that, but the kind of nostalgic “old England” thing is big on fields and grass, not so much forest.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by milesrout on Monday March 03, 2025 @11:24PM (#43250264)
The "natural landscape" is a pretty meaningless concept in Britain. Are moors not natural landscapes because they were formed hundreds or thousands of years ago? Is it natural when animals do something but not when humans do it? Or is it natural when hunter gatherers do something but not when agriculturalists do it? Or is it natural when non-industrial people do it, but not when industrialists do it? And why does your chosen definition matter? Is the natural landscape better than human-modified landscapes? Is a change always fine if the starting point was created by humans?

If you replaced the ancient figures carved into the chalk in England with wind farms would that be fine because they arent natural features?

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by walthamstow on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @12:02AM (#43250539)
It's unclear what point you're making with reference to the blanket ban on onshore wind. I wouldn't like to see turbines on Cerne Abbas or Dartmoor. Nobody wants that, as far as I'm aware?

I would like to see more of them on the generic grass/wheat/rape fields that cover much of England. That was prevented by the blanket ban.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by ascorbic on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @02:37AM (#43251521)
> The "natural landscape" is a pretty meaningless concept in Britain

It's quite simple: there is none. Moors are created by farming and logging. All woodland has either been planted and managed by humans, or self-seeded on land cleared by humans. Aside from a handful of tiny patches (which are questionable) there is no primeval forest in Britain.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by devnullbrain on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:16AM (#43251822)
You can't find a principled stance for a naturalistic fallacy.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by rsynnott on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:31AM (#43251951)
I mean on that basis you could say that Milton Keynes is natural because humans did it.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by milesrout on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @04:13AM (#43252268)
I think the point is more that none of it is really "natural". But also yes? We are animals.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by dontlaugh on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:07PM (#43249818)
Ecologically, it is basically barren.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by xaldir on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @09:35AM (#43255166)
What? Pastures? Grassland are actually good for biodiversity.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lenkite on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:21PM (#43249020)
Aren't these also massive mass bird slayers ? The last I read, over half a million birds were killed (official under-estimate) by wind turbines in UK alone every year
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by cam_l on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:41PM (#43249161)
You are going to freak out when you find out how many birds are killed by buildings generally.

But you might want to sit down before i tell you how many are killed by cats.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by giantg2 on Monday March 03, 2025 @11:51PM (#43250463)
The real issue seems to be that they might kill protected birds more often than buildings or cats, which seem to kill smaller common species (usually of lesser concern).
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by manquer on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:54PM (#43249741)
And all of those numbers pale in comparison in how we cruelly we treat birds used in the food supply chain (eggs, chicken etc).

The recent kurzsesagt video is a great intro to the topic ( https://youtu.be/5sVfTPaxRwk)

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by tsimionescu on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @02:41AM (#43251557)
This is completely and utterly irrelevant to the topic at hand. Wild bird populations are potentially at risk, and extinction of a population has massive ecological consequences. Commercially raised chickens and the horrors they are exposed to are completely unrelated to that.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by tempfile on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:23AM (#43251888)
I would hardly call it "utterly irrelevant" that in a discussion about "killing birds is bad" someone mentions that it is not usually considered bad to kill birds for food.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by tsimionescu on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @05:14AM (#43252727)
Killing wild birds accidentally is completely different from raising and bucthering birds for food, from virtually any point of view I can imagine. People who have no problem with eating meat will still not find it OK to kill a pet pig, and might still consider sport hunting wild boars to be barbaric.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by tempfile on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @05:57AM (#43253024)
"completely different" and "utterly irrelevant" are not the same thing. They also aren't completely different. They have things in common (killing and harming birds).

You're trying to turn "I don't care about that" into "it's logically incorrect to care about that" which is not a game you can win.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by manquer on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @02:55PM (#43259214)
Life is still life, pain(not only death) caused needlessly whether windmills or in factory farms is still cruel. Birds are intelligent, curious, emotional, they are social animals and get depressed.

Other attributes the bird may have (wild/bred) or species (rare/common) has no bearing on the pain and kind of death they suffer. The importance of those attributes is lens we see from, it does not change their suffering.

> People who have no problem with eating meat will still not find it OK to kill a pet pig

It doesn't make it acceptable to view life raised for food[2] as a lesser (therefore ok to be tortured) than other life because they are pets, merely because it is common practice.

How is it different than valuing human life was valued differently in age of slavery or even today if you say correlate level of aid, support, news coverage or empathy to simple numbers on human conflict impact[1].

[1] https://ourworldindata.org/grapher/deaths-in-armed-conflicts...

[2] The argument here is not becoming vegetarian, it is about not torturing needlessly what we need to eat. The human equivalent is akin to not following Geneva conventions in a war not abolish war altogether, while ideal everyone agrees is not practical today.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by abenga on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @08:02AM (#43253973)
> massive ecological consequences

As opposed to the minimal ecological consequences continuing to burn fossil fuels are currently yielding you mean?

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lenkite on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:09PM (#43249398)
That number is a heavy under-estimate and deliberately lowered for public consumption. But, you might want to sit down - The real slaughter is well in the millions annually.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:31PM (#43249082)
And the Exxon Valdez and the Deepwater Horizon were good for birds?

Bringing up bird welfare to oppose wind turbines is bullshit. If people cared about birds or wildlife we wouldn't be in this mess at all.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by zdragnar on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:37PM (#43249122)
It's usually the types of birds that are affected that upset people. Many ideal locations for windmills (in particular mountainous regions, dunno about offshore) happen to also be ideal places for threatened or endangered large raptors.

Likewise, there's the (unproven) connection with noise generated by offshore wind farms disturbing wildlife migration and movement, especially among whales.

It'd be nice to know that we're not replacing one disaster with another, though I'm out of date on my personal research as to whether any of these concerns still warrant further investigation.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:41PM (#43249155)
> Many ideal locations for windmills...happen to also be ideal places for threatened or endangered large raptors.

The person I replied to was making a quantity-of-birds argument. Not an endangered species argument.

> there's the (unproven) connection with noise generated by offshore wind farms disturbing wildlife migration and movement

Do they make a lot more noise than giant cruise ships? Luxury yachts? I don't see much of a movement to ban those. It's almost like people decide the things they want to have for themselves (undisturbed views), then make up whatever noble-sounding reasons (whales, birds) will preserve those things.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by zdragnar on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @09:16PM (#43261818)
> Bringing up bird welfare to oppose wind turbines is bullshit. If people cared about birds or wildlife we wouldn't be in this mess at all.

Your comment seems to be a blanket opposition to bird welfare in general, not a limited critique of quantity harmed. I do think the distinction remains important, hence why I made my post.

> Do they make a lot more noise than giant cruise ships? Luxury yachts?

Given that the ships are itinerant and their turbines are much smaller, I do believe the type of noise pollution they generate is qualitatively less harmful. I imagine the scale is something along the lines of:

    1. windmills
    2. sonar
    3. marine vehicle engine and turbine noise
Windmills take the top spot for being a constant barrage over a large area.

Sonar gets the second for the extreme volume some ships (esp. military) are capable of producing, though there are far fewer of them.

Marine vehicles come last. There's a greater danger of animals being hit by fast moving boats (for example, manatees) than discombobulation from engine and turbine noise.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Thursday March 06, 2025 @09:29AM (#43280599)
> Your comment seems to be a blanket opposition to bird welfare in general

I don't know how you got that. I just think a lot of fake bird lovers come out of the woodwork to oppose wind turbines because of $MADE_UP_REASON. Real wildlife lovers recognize that clean energy is good for wildlife.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Friday March 07, 2025 @07:05PM (#43296175)
> I imagine the scale is something...

Do you have sources for this scale?

> Windmills take the top spot for being a constant barrage over a large area.

They're also static, so animals can just avoid them. Their blades spin a hundred feet above the water.

Ships move around so their sounds can be anywhere. Their propellers spin in the water. And there are way more large ships than offshore windmills.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lenkite on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:06PM (#43249374)
How many birds did Exxon Valdez and Deepwater Horizon kill in the years of 2010-25 ? The argument is not bullshit. Are we normalizing the regular and visible slaughter of birds ?

I have seen bird corpses piling up at the foot of wind turbines and needing to be cleared on a regular basis. You can check this out yourself - no need to believe me. Perhaps only your own eyes can convince you of the validity of the "bullshit" argument.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by cycomanic on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:22PM (#43249894)
I have trouble believing you are being honest. Piling under wind turbines?! I have yet to see a dead bird under a wind turbine myself (but I acknowledge they do kill some). Published estimated averages are 4 to 18 birds per turbine per year [1]. Compare that to buildings (where we also don't pile up either) which kill man estimated 1 billion birds a year [2]

[1] https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/wind-power-bird-de... [2] https://abcbirds.org/news/bird-building-collisions-study-202...

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lenkite on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:42PM (#43250012)
Yes, explicitly piling up under wind turbines. This was in the Western Ghats in India and my mother was sickened - (she used to be a regular trekker before Covid). I didn't initially believe her either. Btw, they were so effective as bird killers that wind-turbines were even acknowledged officially as "top predator". They change ecology drastically within a couple of years.

“Our central discovery is that wind turbines can act as top predators, by reducing the density and activity of birds, their prey are now released from the typical level of predation. This release causes a range of changes in lizards,” explained Dr Maria Thaker of Centre for Ecological Sciences at the Indian Institute of Science

https://iisc.ac.in/wind-farms-are-the-new-top-predator-in-th...

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by wzdd on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @12:29AM (#43250700)
> so effective as bird killers that wind-turbines were even acknowledged officially as "top predator"

This is using "top" in the sense of "apex", because turbines have no natural predators. The paper says you could imagine them as something at the top of the trophic web. The paper explores the impact on their prey populations.

That's opposed to "top" in the sense of "kills more than other predators" or whatever. I mention it because number-of-kills is what the rest of the discussion seems to be about.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @08:57AM (#43254648)
> This was in the Western Ghats in India

Climate change in the subcontinent is going to kill way more birds and wildlife. You think oil and gas drilling or coal mining is better for them?

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by tw04 on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:56PM (#43250106)
You haven’t, which is why you have no citation just a ridiculous, unproven anecdote. There are literally hundreds of turbines in my area, there are not and have never been “birds piling up under them.”

Your own link further down estimates 4-18 per year. 1 bird per month would be gone before you had a chance to collect it, much less have a chance to “pile up”.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lenkite on Monday March 03, 2025 @11:15PM (#43250223)
I am honestly surprised - you should see dead birds at-least a couple of times a week. Not annually or monthly, but weekly esp for a full wind-farm like what you are stating.

Which part of the world do you live in ? It is possible that the location of the farm was chosen wisely. Are you also sure someone is not clearing the corpses ? There are laws mandating the collection of corpses in many western nations. My personal anecdotal opinion is that data is more honest in the non-Western nations since nobody cares about bird-deaths all that much and so the deaths are not sanitized.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by monkey_monkey on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:45AM (#43252067)
> My personal anecdotal opinion is that data is more honest in the non-Western nations since nobody cares about bird-deaths all that much and so the deaths are not sanitized.

that was funny

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by tw04 on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @11:21AM (#43256729)
The entire US? I’ve been to Hawaii and hiked under turbines, no dead birds. I’ve been hunting in the midwest in fields, no dead birds.

I’ve been hiking in Europe, no dead birds.

Again, where is your citation? If birds are “piling up” they’re should be countless articles on it. Hell BP alone would GLADLY fund studies showing all these birds deaths to justify selling more oil.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by jimjimjim on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:41PM (#43249640)
I live in an area where there are a lot of wind mills along a nearby range of hills. There is also another taller hill which allows you to look down on the wind mills. In all the times I've driven up there and stopped to look out at the vista there were no birds at the base of the windmills. None. On any of them.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by mulmen on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:55PM (#43249280)
I doubt that wind turbines are the only power source that kills birds. Marginal bird deaths per unit of power production is the interesting statistic. This MIT post [1] links to a 2009 study [2] which provides that comparison:

  Wind/nuclear: 0.3-0.4 birds/GWh
  Fossil: 5.2 birds/GWh
So if you’re pro bird you’re pro wind power.

[1]: https://climate.mit.edu/ask-mit/do-wind-turbines-kill-birds

[2]: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S09601...

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by kjaleshire on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:09PM (#43249830)
4.98 birds/GWh in the fossil fuel estimate comes from unrealized climate change expectations. They also only looked at two coal power plants for the remainder of the study.

The nuclear source bird death estimates are extrapolated from one bad weather incident over two nights from a single plant on the Florida coast.

This is not a serious or rigorous study. Is there anything more recent?

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by SV_BubbleTime on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:24PM (#43249906)
> comes from unrealized climate change expectations

Wow.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by mulmen on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @05:12AM (#43252714)
“I reject your reality and substitute my own.”

You can dismiss any source by saying “nuh-uh” but you need to back it up to be taken seriously here.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by IncreasePosts on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:47PM (#43249218)
So, 500,000 birds out of 250,000,000?

Aka 0.2% of birds.

How many birds do coal power plants or other power sources kill?

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lenkite on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:12PM (#43249423)
Real number is well above that. Everyone involved in bird conservation agrees this number is a fraction only reported for public consumption - real number is well into the millions. You can ask organizations like ABC birds.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by mulmen on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:43PM (#43249660)
I doubt everyone agrees on anything. If you have contrary numbers please just save all of us the time and share them.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lenkite on Monday March 03, 2025 @11:11PM (#43250204)
Ugghh. I meant everyone in bird conservation. The ABC article explains why the official numbers are a heavy underestimate. But this was in 2021 - it has gotten worse since then. This is not unique to the US - my personal experience of this was in India.

https://abcbirds.org/blog21/wind-turbine-mortality/

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by viraptor on Monday March 03, 2025 @11:41PM (#43250383)
And the recommendation from those people is: choose the sites more carefully. Not stop or slow down, just:

> Climate change is a critical threat to birds. Recognizing this fact, ABC supports renewable energy, including wind energy, and the transition away from fossil fuels. However, not every wind project is proposed in a suitable location.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by jimjimjim on Monday March 03, 2025 @09:43PM (#43249655)
Everyone agrees? I don't agree.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lenkite on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:16PM (#43249870)
Corrected.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by tw04 on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:13PM (#43249852)
Did you read a Donald Trump tweet? Because no reputable source has ever said wind turbines are a major risk to birds.

If you’re trying to save birds, the first place you should be looking is outdoor cats.

https://www.sibleyguides.com/conservation/causes-of-bird-mor...

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by lenkite on Monday March 03, 2025 @10:50PM (#43250060)
> Did you read a Donald Trump tweet? Because no reputable source has ever said wind turbines are a major risk to birds.

I don't care about Donald Trump. (How did this even become about him ?) And your second statement is laughably false as even elementary research would tell you.

Do note that there are ~100 million cats and only ~70k wind turbines, if you use US as a reference. Cats are clearly not the top-predators of birds anymore.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by tw04 on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @12:13AM (#43250600)
> I don't care about Donald Trump. (How did this even become about him ?)

You said you “read” about turbines killing birds (shockingly with no citation). There is literally nobody else claiming such stupidity.

> Do note that there are ~100 million cats and only ~70k wind turbines, if you use US as a reference. Cats are clearly not the top-predators of birds anymore.

Do note, a tiny fraction of the 100m cats are outdoor cats. And yes, they are absolutely one of the top predators of birds and have been for decades.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by jodrellblank on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @12:37AM (#43250745)
Humans in the UK killed and ate over 111,000,000 birds just in January 2025.

https://www.gov.uk/government/statistics/poultry-and-poultry...

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by tsimionescu on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @02:40AM (#43251548)
They also raised about 110,000,000 birds that otherwise would never have been born. This is completely irrelevant to wind turbines or any other power generation tech - the impact on wild birds is what is of concern, because, by definition, we're not able to raise any number of wild birds we'd like to have.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by CWIZO on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @03:26AM (#43251903)
While indeed irrelevant for the original point. I would encourage you to educate[1] yourself on the life these birds have before you make claims we're doing them a favour by bringing them into existence.

[1] https://www.dominionmovement.com/watch

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by tsimionescu on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @05:17AM (#43252752)
I made no such claim, I was only mentioning that in relation to the fact that population size of domestic birds is not impacted at all by the massive killing, while population size for wild birds might be dramatically impacted by a much smaller number of deaths.

I find the horrors of industrial animal farming horrendous, while not having a moral problem with the idea of raising an animal in decent conditions for slaughter.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by jodrellblank on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @10:28AM (#43255913)
It isn't completely irrelevant; they didn't mention wild birds, or any wider context - the way they commented was as a shock number, the intent of that is "wind turbines kill $bignum, stop wind turbines". The relevance of the much bigger shock number is to put it in context - human activity slaughters a lot of animals.

Okay, something else which affects wild birds: "Bird corpses were counted - and, where possible, identified - at 166 locations throughout Britain during the summer of 1985. The survey covered all roads except motorways. It is the most recent such study, and the most comprehensive. The results were depressing. A minimum of 30 million birds are killed on Britain's roads every year. Depending on the assumptions made in the statistical analysis, the death rate could be even higher: 70 million a year is not impossible."[1] And that's as well as wild rabbits, hedgehogs, badgers, foxes, deer, and so on killed by cars which wind turbines don't affect.

So the wildlife in the UK would be much better off if we built more viable alternatives to driving and road trucking than if we scrapped wind turbines. We can also note that people are working on wind turbines that don't kill birds, e.g. [2]. It's not a fixed fact that all wind turbine designs do the same damage.

In the context of a world where fossil fuel propaganda really does exist[3] and Trump's recent executive order on unleashing energy generation where he tells government departments to look for all kinds of energy sources on their land - geothermal, hydroelectric, oil, gas, anything - except wind or solar - exists, and in the wider climate change context where there isn't a magically perfect answer - and where the UK is uniquely well suited in Europe to wind power - it can't just be left that "sensational $bignum means stop wind turbines" with nothing else mentioned.

[1] https://www.independent.co.uk/arts-entertainment/carnage-on-...

[2] https://www.audubon.org/magazine/surprisingly-simple-solutio...

[3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hX2aZUav-54 - Climate Town video on how the gas industry sets up groups of 'concerned citizens' which pay social media influencers to post about how great cooking with gas is, and agitate politically while obscuring the source of their funding, among other things.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by jodrellblank on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @11:26AM (#43256816)
> "by definition, we're not able to raise any number of wild birds we'd like to have."

(but we can; the UK has 30 million homes; if 500,000 of them put up wild bird feeders, that would lead to more wild birds. Again the context of the comment was the shock value of $bignum not a comment on specific species or habitats or desired outcomes).

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by hermitcrab on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @12:06PM (#43257348)
I disagree. I think they are rather pleasing to look at. Especially compared to a coal fired power station.