News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Monday March 03, 2025 @08:41PM (#43249155)
> Many ideal locations for windmills...happen to also be ideal places for threatened or endangered large raptors.

The person I replied to was making a quantity-of-birds argument. Not an endangered species argument.

> there's the (unproven) connection with noise generated by offshore wind farms disturbing wildlife migration and movement

Do they make a lot more noise than giant cruise ships? Luxury yachts? I don't see much of a movement to ban those. It's almost like people decide the things they want to have for themselves (undisturbed views), then make up whatever noble-sounding reasons (whales, birds) will preserve those things.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by zdragnar on Tuesday March 04, 2025 @09:16PM (#43261818)
> Bringing up bird welfare to oppose wind turbines is bullshit. If people cared about birds or wildlife we wouldn't be in this mess at all.

Your comment seems to be a blanket opposition to bird welfare in general, not a limited critique of quantity harmed. I do think the distinction remains important, hence why I made my post.

> Do they make a lot more noise than giant cruise ships? Luxury yachts?

Given that the ships are itinerant and their turbines are much smaller, I do believe the type of noise pollution they generate is qualitatively less harmful. I imagine the scale is something along the lines of:

    1. windmills
    2. sonar
    3. marine vehicle engine and turbine noise
Windmills take the top spot for being a constant barrage over a large area.

Sonar gets the second for the extreme volume some ships (esp. military) are capable of producing, though there are far fewer of them.

Marine vehicles come last. There's a greater danger of animals being hit by fast moving boats (for example, manatees) than discombobulation from engine and turbine noise.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Thursday March 06, 2025 @09:29AM (#43280599)
> Your comment seems to be a blanket opposition to bird welfare in general

I don't know how you got that. I just think a lot of fake bird lovers come out of the woodwork to oppose wind turbines because of $MADE_UP_REASON. Real wildlife lovers recognize that clean energy is good for wildlife.

Re:How the U.K. Broke Its Own Economy by triceratops on Friday March 07, 2025 @07:05PM (#43296175)
> I imagine the scale is something...

Do you have sources for this scale?

> Windmills take the top spot for being a constant barrage over a large area.

They're also static, so animals can just avoid them. Their blades spin a hundred feet above the water.

Ships move around so their sounds can be anywhere. Their propellers spin in the water. And there are way more large ships than offshore windmills.