News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by kubb on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:16AM (#43149025)
Finance buffs: is there some way to exclude Tesla from market cap ETFs? Some instrument I could buy that would balance out any dip caused by a particular stock crashing?
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by bigthymer on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:19AM (#43149036)
Theoretically, you could short TSLA in the same amount that you own it within the ETF. This would be functionally equivalent to owning a custom market cap ETF minus TSLA.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by loeg on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:35AM (#43149980)
Can't reply to the dead parent comment (which is lame, it's not stupid or offensive -- just asking how to buy a TSLA-excluded stock index), but:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41246686

Direct indexing allows you to go long ~approximately some stock index like SPY, but you can easily exclude specific stocks (like TSLA) without dealing with options or shorts. Would I do this? No. But it's probably one of the better ways to achieve this goal.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by rafaelmn on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:37AM (#43149131)
With the difference that you could get wiped out on the short ? Edit: I was wrong, if ETF has same amount of Tesla it should even out.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by cthor on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:40AM (#43149148)
You can short without tail risk, e.g. buying puts.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by dist-epoch on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:06AM (#43149310)
A put is not a short replacement.

Buying puts is more about longing volatility.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by fooker on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:13AM (#43149355)
You can simulate a short with multiple options.

https://www.optionseducation.org/strategies/all-strategies/s...

This is not quite all the way there, but close enough. Basically, you do something analogous to 1 = 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + ...

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by fny on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:36AM (#43149506)
No. A long strangle is a way to long volatility.

With a put, you primarily pay for directionality with hedged upside risk: you don't lose your house if the stock moons. While it's true volatility is a component, that's a side effect of the hedging since your counter party takes on volatility risk.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by jgalt212 on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:32AM (#43149468)
In theory, yes. But when you include hedging costs and taxes, the link becomes less direct. The cleanest way to get long volatility is by purchasing ATM straddles.

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/straddle.asp

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by adastra22 on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:04AM (#43149300)
How would that work? You are simultaneously long by the same amount. The ETF would go up by whatever amount you are short.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by Imustaskforhelp on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:38AM (#43149134)
yea literally my exact thought.

Wish there was some better financial instrument for such purpose instead of shorting.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by dgacmu on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:07AM (#43149318)
But you won't - you "own" an equal number of shares of TSLA indirectly through the index fund. If TSLA goes up, that part of your ETF has gone up. You're just being simultaneously long and short the same stock. The only difference between that and "not owning TSLA" is that you're paying a bit to borrow the shares -- about 0.41% annually, right now.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by csomar on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:28AM (#43149919)
Options.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by whereismyacc on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:52AM (#43149218)
well not if the short matches the amount you hold in tesla stock through the ETF right?
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by rafaelmn on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:03AM (#43149290)
True didn't consider that.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by eszed on Sunday February 23, 2025 @03:22PM (#43152857)
You'd want to have cash on hand to cover your short position or you risk having to sell (potentially a lot of) your ETF to cover, which loses out on future whole-market upside. Still seems risky to me.

Or am I thinking about it wrong?

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by whereismyacc on Monday February 24, 2025 @02:21AM (#43156680)
I definitely don't know much about finance, but a short is essentially being obliged to sell a position at a future date, right? You match your short position against the fraction of your ETF which is in TSLA, such that you are obliged to sell in the future exactly as many TSLA shares as you indirectly own through the ETF. This way you do not need cash on hand, because you can sell a portion of your ETF to pay off the short.

Theoretically it's not risky because in the scenario that the short becomes expensive, TSLA has gone up the and in turn TSLA has made your ETF appreciate the same amount that you owe due to the short, and vice versa if it goes down.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by eszed on Monday February 24, 2025 @11:23AM (#43161357)
> TSLA has made your ETF appreciate the same amount

That's no guarantee. I mean, yes, the ETF price reflects its proportion of Tesla stock, but the market as a whole might have declined - even in bear markets some individual stocks appreciate.

Investing in ETFs is a long-term, counter-cyclical strategy. Dips are when you want to buy ETFs, not when you want to be forced to sell them because you took a short that failed to pay off. If you have to do that then you're not only selling the Tesla within your ETF, but also the future upside of all the other stocks in the fund. Isn't that hugely inefficient?

But, I'm not a particularly sophisticated investor, either (thus: ETFs for me), so my intuition may be wrong. Does anyone have some maths to bring to bear on this?

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by whereismyacc on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @03:15AM (#43181795)
Yeah of course you can't escape the general market risk, i'm only talking about a strategy to avoid net exposure to risk specific to the TSLA stock.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by eszed on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @11:00PM (#43191206)
OK. Other people (probably not you) in this thread were talking about this strategy like it was basically risk-free. Compared to a naked short it's, um, obviously a better idea, but I still think others were over-selling it by not mentioning all of the downside risk.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by whereismyacc on Thursday February 27, 2025 @05:27AM (#43193031)
Oh yeah, I don't think I would suggest actually implementing this because it's just a lot of costs and fees to emulate what otherwise would be an index without the stock
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by eszed on Thursday February 27, 2025 @06:49AM (#43193479)
Well, the people advocating it are bearish on Tesla and trying to win a bet on that, while "hedging" it with their ETF portfolio. I mean, on the fundamentals I'm bearish on Tesla, too, but there's a not-inconsiderable chance that any day now Musk announces an eleventy-billion dollar contract with the US government, so no way I'm taking that bet. Anyway, I'm not a gambler, so all my investments are super boring.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by echelon on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:45AM (#43149580)
Don't short a meme stock. Any irrational behavior can continue longer than your solvency.

Buy puts to limit your downside, or do some other combination of options trading to prevent unlimited losses.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by kjrfghslkdjfl on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:32AM (#43149113)
It's not. If you're shorting, you're paying to borrow the stock.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by dgacmu on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:26AM (#43149081)
I wish this existed more generally, but it doesn't. However, you can do it in a few different ways:

(1) As another commenter noted, you can short TSLA in rough proportion to the amount of it in your ETF. This incurs some borrowing costs but you also get to park the money from the short, so it's not too bad overall.

(2) You could go for mid-cap funds like VO instead of total-market funds. But this does change your overall investment picture. I kind of like it as a way of reducing my tech exposure, but historically, the total market / s&p 500 funds have outperformed the mid-cap funds, so it's worth recognizing the risk here.

The shorting approach is pretty low risk given that it's counterbalanced by owning those shares indirectly through your ETF holdings.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by nwatson on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:28AM (#43149091)
I would believe ... plan to buy the ETF, find the number of shares of Tesla integrated into your ETF purchase, and then buy the ETF and short-sell that number of shares of Tesla "simultaneously". Keep checking the composition of the ETF and rebalance your Tesla short, or perhaps also the ETF.

Without fractional shares it might be difficult to get an exact counterbalance, and there will be inconvenient short vs long term capital gains tracking for rebalancing events.

Edit: spelling

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by themgt on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:28AM (#43149092)
Better just short all legacy automotive and include Tesla in that group, but at that point you have to wonder about these economies more generally. Tesla is falling behind but the rest of these companies are barely even in the game. The idea that Laotians and Chileans will all have $10k self-driving BYD sedans to complement their $10k Unitree robot servants while "the west" drives Toyota Corollas with v6 engines and folds their own laundry out of the dryer ... doesn't make a lot of sense to me.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by frodo8sam on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:33AM (#43149121)
Shorting is often a bad strategy due to the hight cost if you plan to hold for the long term. And with these companies with irrational evaluations you gave no idea when the stock price will correct. Better to exlude stocks that you can't price accurately from your portefolio.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by Imustaskforhelp on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:34AM (#43149124)
but then it moves us away from index fund.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by jmyeet on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:03AM (#43149288)

    "Markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent."
        -- John Maynard Keynes
Tesla simply shouldn't be a $1T company and that's been true for some time. Last year they sold ~1.8M vehicles in 2024 (down 1.1% from 2023), which values the company at roughly $600k per car sold.

GM has a market cap of $46B and sold roughly 3 times as many cars and that was an increase over 2023. That values GM at under $10k per car sold in 2024.

Consider Tesla sales by country [1]. A large chunk of those sales were in China. Those will get eaten by BYD and others. That says nothing about Tesla. The Chinese government always plays favorites with local companies. There is no "winning" in China for foreign companies.

Tesla relies on trade barriers to exist. In the US, Europe and Australia, the floodgates could open to much more affordable EVs from China. Even if they can survive that, it'll drive down average selling prices.

The Supercharger network is a competitive advantage but one with a ticking clock on it.

On top of all this, Elon's personal politics hurt him most with the very people who are most inclined to buy EVs: people who live in cities and care about the enviroment.

The American government tends to protect large American companies so maybe Tesla is a safe bet. But you're betting this administration or a later one not having a falling out with Elon or simply eviscerating the EV market because it's "woke". We're already getting rid of Biden's EV tax credit. That's going to hurt Tesla too.

[1]: https://worldpopulationreview.com/country-rankings/tesla-sal...

[dead]
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by madmask on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:43AM (#43149564)
I am considering buying a used one, prices are very low now. And if someone messes up with it they better run fast
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by IlikeKitties on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:33AM (#43149480)
> Any European who still buys any product from musk is either direct fascist supporter or totally oblivious POS. I can't use nicer terms.

And you don't have to Nazi Salutes and 14 Word References on Twitter by Elon are more than enough to legitimize your opinion.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by 127 on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:38AM (#43149522)
I don't think Musk has any ideology outside amassing as much money and adoration as possible, while spinelessly saying anything and everything that gets him to that goal. He's a professional larper with no morals or ethics.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by bmicraft on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:54AM (#43149652)
That's no better either
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by realusername on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:47AM (#43149600)
I estimate that there's a good 50% chance that Tesla will be banned in the EU anyways.

If a trade war is started by Trump, Musk properties are a prime retaliation target by the EU. You can't hit any closer to the president than that.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by bmicraft on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:55AM (#43149675)
The EU isn't generally in the business of banning specific things, it's usually a more nuanced systematic approach.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by realusername on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:04AM (#43149756)
For a trade war, the EU does have a targeted approach, that's what happened with Trump last time where they targeted specific states and that's what I'm betting will happen this time.

Musk is really the biggest target of all.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by Imustaskforhelp on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:37AM (#43149132)
I had created a similar (but for AI) based request on r/bogleheads on reddit , because though it has its uses , it just feels too close to the web3 hype which I have equated so deeply in my mind with scam.

The response was generally to buy a etf which pays high dividends and since these tech companies don't pay high dividends , but that puts you away from a whole market.

On internet , it seems that most people mention tesla doesn't give dividend so you are safe with that option.

Shorting doesn't feel like it would work in the long run , I am not sure but it seems that you just don't want to take any (not profit nor lose) risk associated with tesla but shorting puts you at a you win if they lose kind of situation. I am not sure.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by baxtr on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:40AM (#43149145)
Isn’t he just 50 years old or so? Another 40 years of presidency ahead!
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by fastball on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:44AM (#43149166)
That just sounds like shorting TSLA with extra steps.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by baq on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:52AM (#43149217)
Go long etf, short tesla weighted by etf weight. Relatively basic stuff. You can also go long TSLQ etf if you can't or don't want to short outright.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by Fade_Dance on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:39AM (#43149528)
All you need to do is proportionally short out Tesla, and keep your portfolio up to date with the SP500 rebalancing to make sure you are aligned.

That said, it's probably not a good idea. Think of Index Flows as a container (the index tracking vehicles) with water inside that sloshes around to constituents.

Because there is essentially a mega-trend of migration to low fee Index tracking funds (on many levels, resulting from Global Capital flows being net positive for the U.S. and the intra-U.S. migration from active to passive as well as complexes like the 401k space), the underlying characteristic of market cap weighted funds propping up to Size factor is dominant (the inflows proportionally get directed to the largest constituents).

As shown with Tesla, it can seemingly look a bit arbitrary when it comes to which names float to the top. Take Tesla's case, where a perpetual short squeeze, constant expectation beats, high retail ownership, and extreme upside option activity vaulted the name to extremely high valuation. What most didn't expect, of course, was for Tesla to stay at a $1 trillion market cap. But you have to realize that flows into index funds are consistently positive, and even forces like option flows that were once a volatility enhancer and took liquidity can act like a volatility suppressor under more normal circumstances (depending on if Dealers are long or short gamma/convexity, and they are usually long). So you have a sort of typical case where a name vaults to a high valuation and then pins there, supported by flows, while the water now flows around this large entrenched name and moves around other illiquid names.

Of course this process isn't actually arbitrary, it's just esoteric, and it's a huge part of what trading is today, even compared to 5 years ago. In many ways, the tail wags the dog, so to speak, and when you're looking at something like Tesla's stock price, you're really looking at the derivative of the option positioning. If there is a large block of option open interest on a name, that's now included in all of the trader oriented reports of the name, and nobody is going to want to come in and take a position against these mean reverting flows, somewhat reinforcing that process.

Conversely, traditional active value evaluation is less dominant of a force in the markets than it used to be. Index funds buy big things, and they reinforce momentum factor as well. This is reflected in investor behavior on all levels, including the active fund management space, because you can't fight these forces or you will lose your accounts.

That's not to say that price discovery isn't happening. The saying that markets are voting mechanisms in this short term and weighing mechanisms in the long term still holds true. The short and even mid term movements are less of a random walk combined with animal spirits from sweaty men in trading pits, and is instead a sort of bizarre "gamma vortex" battlefield, and then the long term price moves are increasingly dominated by these distortions from market cap weighted domination. Price discovery works within this cadence, and often happens in short ferocious bursts and sector rotations.

So back to why it's not a good idea. I said that because of the interplay of forces above not because of Tesla's actual valuation or even Tesla's outlook. The moment you step against the index flows, you are taking a negative expected value position. I'm somewhat up to date on markets and am constantly exposed to them during the day, and I've personally lost 1mm on TSLA over the past decade because I refused to let the lessons above really get into my bones ("lost", as other trading positions with opposite exposure have netted out to more than compensate for that, but it's a good anecdote to share here).

In many respects, Tesla's valuation is fairly arbitrary and it represents a sort of token of the strange interplay of forces within the walls of index flows. Unless you specialize in that area, it's probably best to just let it play out. With TSLA in particular your short is very much stepping into an active trade where forces like options flows are running at extremely high heat. If you are buying the S&P 500, you want pure access to these positive megatrends. If you aren't comfortable with it, and I certainly don't blame you, then instead of shorting out Tesla against your index investments, Consider putting some money aside in investments that do not track the index and maybe do something more traditional like small cap value that is perpetually undervalued as a result of these very same index flows. It goes without saying, but these investments will not include Tesla either. I would strongly argue for taking this approach instead of meddling with SP500 weighting. Get your pure SP500 exposure (which is guaranteed to participate in future TSLAs/NVDAs/etc), and then pick something else pure that steps away from the somewhat arbitrary market cap weighting that dominates markets today. In return for stepping away from the crowd flows (which arguably comes at a cost) you are then rewarded in kind by mindfully taking advantage of the lack of interest in certain market factors (again, using SmallCap Value as an example, since there is a rich academic literature on many of these traditional factor areas, but there are many areas with sound academically supported areas which gain steam from stepping against the index forces, ex: part of my cash is permanently in volatility trading that harvests the volatility expansion and contraction cadence within which price discovery happens in modern markets).

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by kubb on Sunday February 23, 2025 @02:09PM (#43152119)
Thanks for the writeup!
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by kkarpkkarp on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:03AM (#43149744)
If you are not in US but for example Europe or other areas where most of people lives in blocks, not houses, start buying car garages. The own place to charge your car will be luxury in such areas.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by kubb on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:12AM (#43149803)
They’ll build street chargers.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by kkarpkkarp on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:16AM (#43149831)
of course they will and they do. But still having your own will be luxury: no need to cruise looking for free one.

Garages are overlooked (by most of investors) real estate but rules are the same as for houses: in general prices goes up and EV-revolution will just give it a boost.

I've already bought two (they are relatively cheap), one from a guy who has over ten already in his portfolio. I am still parking on the street and renting them for passive income.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by csomar on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:54AM (#43150142)
I don't get it. With ICE vehicles you can't park your car on the roof. You still need a parking spot. Adding charging to parking spots, garages, multi-levels, underground or whatever costs money but is possible.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by kkarpkkarp on Sunday February 23, 2025 @11:58AM (#43150868)
we probably leave in different areas/countries. In mine it is normal people park anywhere even illegally (grass yards, pavements) just to park.