News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by bigthymer on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:19AM (#43149036)
Theoretically, you could short TSLA in the same amount that you own it within the ETF. This would be functionally equivalent to owning a custom market cap ETF minus TSLA.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by loeg on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:35AM (#43149980)
Can't reply to the dead parent comment (which is lame, it's not stupid or offensive -- just asking how to buy a TSLA-excluded stock index), but:

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41246686

Direct indexing allows you to go long ~approximately some stock index like SPY, but you can easily exclude specific stocks (like TSLA) without dealing with options or shorts. Would I do this? No. But it's probably one of the better ways to achieve this goal.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by rafaelmn on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:37AM (#43149131)
With the difference that you could get wiped out on the short ? Edit: I was wrong, if ETF has same amount of Tesla it should even out.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by cthor on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:40AM (#43149148)
You can short without tail risk, e.g. buying puts.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by dist-epoch on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:06AM (#43149310)
A put is not a short replacement.

Buying puts is more about longing volatility.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by fooker on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:13AM (#43149355)
You can simulate a short with multiple options.

https://www.optionseducation.org/strategies/all-strategies/s...

This is not quite all the way there, but close enough. Basically, you do something analogous to 1 = 1/2 + 1/4 + 1/8 + ...

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by fny on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:36AM (#43149506)
No. A long strangle is a way to long volatility.

With a put, you primarily pay for directionality with hedged upside risk: you don't lose your house if the stock moons. While it's true volatility is a component, that's a side effect of the hedging since your counter party takes on volatility risk.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by jgalt212 on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:32AM (#43149468)
In theory, yes. But when you include hedging costs and taxes, the link becomes less direct. The cleanest way to get long volatility is by purchasing ATM straddles.

https://www.investopedia.com/terms/s/straddle.asp

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by adastra22 on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:04AM (#43149300)
How would that work? You are simultaneously long by the same amount. The ETF would go up by whatever amount you are short.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by Imustaskforhelp on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:38AM (#43149134)
yea literally my exact thought.

Wish there was some better financial instrument for such purpose instead of shorting.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by dgacmu on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:07AM (#43149318)
But you won't - you "own" an equal number of shares of TSLA indirectly through the index fund. If TSLA goes up, that part of your ETF has gone up. You're just being simultaneously long and short the same stock. The only difference between that and "not owning TSLA" is that you're paying a bit to borrow the shares -- about 0.41% annually, right now.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by csomar on Sunday February 23, 2025 @10:28AM (#43149919)
Options.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by whereismyacc on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:52AM (#43149218)
well not if the short matches the amount you hold in tesla stock through the ETF right?
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by rafaelmn on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:03AM (#43149290)
True didn't consider that.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by eszed on Sunday February 23, 2025 @03:22PM (#43152857)
You'd want to have cash on hand to cover your short position or you risk having to sell (potentially a lot of) your ETF to cover, which loses out on future whole-market upside. Still seems risky to me.

Or am I thinking about it wrong?

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by whereismyacc on Monday February 24, 2025 @02:21AM (#43156680)
I definitely don't know much about finance, but a short is essentially being obliged to sell a position at a future date, right? You match your short position against the fraction of your ETF which is in TSLA, such that you are obliged to sell in the future exactly as many TSLA shares as you indirectly own through the ETF. This way you do not need cash on hand, because you can sell a portion of your ETF to pay off the short.

Theoretically it's not risky because in the scenario that the short becomes expensive, TSLA has gone up the and in turn TSLA has made your ETF appreciate the same amount that you owe due to the short, and vice versa if it goes down.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by eszed on Monday February 24, 2025 @11:23AM (#43161357)
> TSLA has made your ETF appreciate the same amount

That's no guarantee. I mean, yes, the ETF price reflects its proportion of Tesla stock, but the market as a whole might have declined - even in bear markets some individual stocks appreciate.

Investing in ETFs is a long-term, counter-cyclical strategy. Dips are when you want to buy ETFs, not when you want to be forced to sell them because you took a short that failed to pay off. If you have to do that then you're not only selling the Tesla within your ETF, but also the future upside of all the other stocks in the fund. Isn't that hugely inefficient?

But, I'm not a particularly sophisticated investor, either (thus: ETFs for me), so my intuition may be wrong. Does anyone have some maths to bring to bear on this?

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by whereismyacc on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @03:15AM (#43181795)
Yeah of course you can't escape the general market risk, i'm only talking about a strategy to avoid net exposure to risk specific to the TSLA stock.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by eszed on Wednesday February 26, 2025 @11:00PM (#43191206)
OK. Other people (probably not you) in this thread were talking about this strategy like it was basically risk-free. Compared to a naked short it's, um, obviously a better idea, but I still think others were over-selling it by not mentioning all of the downside risk.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by whereismyacc on Thursday February 27, 2025 @05:27AM (#43193031)
Oh yeah, I don't think I would suggest actually implementing this because it's just a lot of costs and fees to emulate what otherwise would be an index without the stock
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by eszed on Thursday February 27, 2025 @06:49AM (#43193479)
Well, the people advocating it are bearish on Tesla and trying to win a bet on that, while "hedging" it with their ETF portfolio. I mean, on the fundamentals I'm bearish on Tesla, too, but there's a not-inconsiderable chance that any day now Musk announces an eleventy-billion dollar contract with the US government, so no way I'm taking that bet. Anyway, I'm not a gambler, so all my investments are super boring.
Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by echelon on Sunday February 23, 2025 @09:45AM (#43149580)
Don't short a meme stock. Any irrational behavior can continue longer than your solvency.

Buy puts to limit your downside, or do some other combination of options trading to prevent unlimited losses.

Re:BYD has already produced its first solid-state cells by kjrfghslkdjfl on Sunday February 23, 2025 @08:32AM (#43149113)
It's not. If you're shorting, you're paying to borrow the stock.