News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by lowsong on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:45AM (#43115278)
Nearly two years on from this article's publication, 'AI' tools are still as useless as ever for productive work.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by deoxykev on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:47AM (#43115308)
Curious to hear what kind of work you do. Because there are definitely fields where productivity as 10x'd because of AI tools.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by spmurrayzzz on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:53AM (#43115379)
Definitely has been true for my work. LLMs have absolutely have been useful, I even forked an IDE (Zed) to add my own custom copilot to leverage a deeper integration for my work.

But even if we consider AI beyond just NLP, there's been so much ML you can apply to other more banal day to day tasks. In my org's case, one of the big ones was anomaly detection and fault localization in aggregate network telemetry data. Worked far better than conventional statistical modeling.

I usually assume there is a caricature of "AI Tools" that all of the detractors are working backwards from that are often nothing more than a canard for the folks that are actually using AI tooling successfully in their work.

Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by LunaSea on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:01AM (#43115498)
Please give us a source for the x10.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B on Thursday February 20, 2025 @04:45PM (#43120681)
We never have any proof or source for that, and when we have one (like the Devin thing) it’s always a ridiculous project in JS with a hundred lines of code that I could write in one day.

Give me some refactoring in a C++ code base with 100k lines of code, and we’ll be able to talk.

Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by apples_oranges on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:50AM (#43115341)
also curious to hear which fields these are
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by kemiller2002 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:52AM (#43115374)
Not management. AI hasn't learned to play golf for them yet.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by Muromec on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:52AM (#43115369)
Anything with using tools which you are not an expert with. If you know how to do things and only use one specific language or framework -- there is nothing to use AI for.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by j4nek on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:03AM (#43115531)
being 10x more productivie with ai doesn`t mean that someone is now a full engineer. ^^
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by drewcoo on Thursday February 20, 2025 @03:01PM (#43119423)
No, but if "productivie" becomes one of the variable names eventually used in legacy work . . . full engineer achieved!
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by ainewsinterest on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:13AM (#43115665)
Yep, I think this is definitely the case for e.g. software engineering.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by tempodox on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:03AM (#43115532)
This whole area is so drenched in bullshit, it's no wonder that the generation of BS and fluff is still the most productive use. Just nothing where reliable facts matter. I do believe that machines can vomit crap 10x as fast as humans.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by ramon156 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:53AM (#43115391)
Seriously? 10x? Either those were cushion jobs or you oversold your claim
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by BiteCode_dev on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:02AM (#43115520)
Some jobs it's more.

I had to sign a 140 page contract of foreign language legalese. Mostly boiler plate, but I had specific questions about it.

Asking questions to an AI to get the specific page answering it meant I could do the job in 2 hours. Without an AI, it would have taken me 2 days.

For programming, it's very good at creating boilerplate, tests, docs, generic API endpoints, script argument parsing, script one-liners, etc. Basically anything for which, me, as a human, don't have much added value.

It's much faster to generate imperfect things with AI and fix them that to write them myself when there is a lot of volume.

It's also pretty good at fixing typos, translating, giving word definition, and so on. Meaning if you are already in the chat, no need to switch to a dedicated tool.

I don't personally get 10x on average (although on specific well suited task I can) but I can get a good X3 on a regular basis.

Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by echoangle on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:06AM (#43115562)
But what you're doing isn't a real job. Who hands someone who doesn't speakt the language a contract to sign? Don't you have a legal department that does this job for you and has people that are specialists for that?

Also, what are you going to do if the AI answered inaccurately and you signed a contract that says something different then what you thought?

Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by BiteCode_dev on Thursday February 20, 2025 @12:45PM (#43117810)
You are confusing not being able to do something well with being able to do it quickly.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by echoangle on Thursday February 20, 2025 @01:05PM (#43118048)
But you shouldn't do some stuff you can't do properly at all, not quickly and not slowly. As a layman, you can't sign a contract in a language you don't speak, even if you have a whole year, unless you can become more-than-fluent in that language in a single year. That's just not something you should do, and the AI isn't reliable enough to help you with it. That's what a legal department is for.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by drewcoo on Thursday February 20, 2025 @03:32PM (#43119790)
Similar to "real work," a "real job" is a definitional problem that attacks people's senses of self.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by echoangle on Thursday February 20, 2025 @06:26PM (#43121867)
I am actually pretty sure that the thing described literally isn’t a real job, at least not working for a serious employer. I can’t imagine a company telling someone to sign contracts in a language they can’t speak and somehow try to make a sense of it.

Either it’s their own company and they’re doing something unwise, they are doing it without the knowledge of their superior or their company shouldn’t be trusted with anything.

The point was that „AI helps me translate the contracts I want to sign“ isn’t a good example of „AI increases my productivity“ because that’s not something you should ever do.

Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B on Thursday February 20, 2025 @04:47PM (#43120710)
I would never in my whole life sign anything in a foreign language that I don’t understand. It’s the perfect example of what AI is: let’s do anything that looks like a job well done and fuck it. That is not convincing. It’s suicidal.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by ethagnawl on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:01AM (#43115502)
I don't know that I'd say _useless_ but there's _a long way_ to go. I also suspect that many developers are going to wind up being dependent upon them at the expense of getting familiar with reading code/documentation, exploring with debuggers, writing forum/blog posts, etc.

Here is one example from the last time I asked Claude a question about message filtering on AWS SQS, which is a very common exchange in my (relatively limited) experience with these tools.tool

# me responding to a suggestion to use a feature which I was pretty sure did not exist

> ... and you're sure this strategy works with SQS FIFO queues?

# Claude apologizing for hallucinating

> I apologize - I need to correct my previous responses. I made a mistake - message filtering with message attributes is NOT supported with FIFO queues. This is an important limitation of FIFO queues.

If I didn't already have familiarity with this service and its feature set, I would have wasted 15/30/60 mins trying to validate the suggestion.

I can't imagine trying to debug code that was automatically generated and inserted into my toolchain using Copilot or whatever else. Again, I'm sure this will all get better but I'm not convinced that any of these tools should be the first ones we reach for.

Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by OtherShrezzing on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:03AM (#43115533)
In the time since this publication, the Nobel Prize in Chemistry was awarded to an ML Engineer & AI researcher.

While it's accurate that there's a lot of AI slop out there, it's also a reasonable assertion that working at the frontier of AI & ML research can be a worthwhile use of your life.

Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by qoez on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:03AM (#43115530)
Chatgpt is really good at small throwaway scripts to accomplish some task that could have taken a good portion of the day to write up otherwise (almost always gets the code right on first try)
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by dizhn on Thursday February 20, 2025 @11:00AM (#43116284)
It can add usability features pretty well too. "Look at the variables in the script and add a feature to accept them as command line arguments and environment variables. Make the CONTENT variable mandatory."

They are also pretty good at software translations nowadays. You can give them a yaml file and they know what's a variable or placeholder and what's text to be translated.

Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by rikafurude21 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:54AM (#43115402)
They can be incredibly useful for many kinds of knowledge work. I've been much more productive using LLMs than before. I'm at the point where I dont know how I ever managed without.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by drpossum on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:09AM (#43115605)
Can you even call it "knowledge work" then?
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by rikafurude21 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:25AM (#43115790)
the difference is that before LLMs you had to use search to find answers to unknowns. The productivity boost of knowing everything immediately doesnt fundamentally change the work itself. I understand over reliance might become problematic at some point. My solution to that would be a bunch of GPUs so I have an R1 locally, anytime. the future is here, some people just havent noticed.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by jebarker on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:05AM (#43115551)
The article isn't about AI tools. He's saying that people should consider becoming engineers working on building AI training systems.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by chollida1 on Thursday February 20, 2025 @10:09AM (#43115616)
> Nearly two years on from this article's publication, 'AI' tools are still as useless as ever for productive work.

Fully disagree. When developing I use llm's all the time. its far quicker for me to ask an llm to build a react component than for me to type it and have to remember all the little nuances for a technology I use a couple of times a year.

When proto typing things or doing quick one offs, using an LLM makes me 10x more productive.

Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by cudgy on Thursday February 20, 2025 @05:30PM (#43121190)
OK, but React development is one of the simplest development tasks out there. It’s probably the most popular UI framework with the most data for the LLM model to generate off existing solutions. Low hanging fruit that also provides the least value to companies since react developers are a dime a dozen.

Also, one could argue that the LLM provides less value since a simple Google search for most react questions can produce a very viable answer, since 90% of what most React developers do has already been done and shared on the Internet.

Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by tempodox on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:54AM (#43115398)
Still remarkable though that they didn't mean a prompt guesser when they said, “ML engineer”.
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by lr4444lr on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:51AM (#43115360)
They don't help you with the non-productive parts, freeing up more of your time for productive work?
Re:It's time to become an ML engineer (2022) by petesergeant on Thursday February 20, 2025 @09:55AM (#43115413)
After crypto-bros, we now have AI-deniers