News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Aloisius on Sunday February 16, 2025 @10:24PM (#43074742)
The SSA's master records, the Numerical Identification (NUMIDENT) files, store dates in text as either CCYYMMDD or MMDDCCYY strings according to their archived versions.

https://www.openicpsr.org/openicpsr/project/207202/

I have a hard time believing the DB2 systems would convert it to days/seconds/whatever since 1875. It's not impossible, but I think whoever came up with the 1875 thing was simply wrong.

That's not to say there are 150 year olds collecting social security either. Dates of birth are sometimes missing or entered wrong and sometimes death records don't get entered. It's also clear DOGE didn't understand that social security numbers can't be used as a unique identifiers (nor why it's unnecessary) which can lead to all sorts of issues when processing.

Edit: It also seems the SSA presumes anyone over 115 is has died and halts payments which makes it even more unlikely there are 150 year old beneficiaries: https://secure.ssa.gov/poms.nsf/lnx/0202602578

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by CSMastermind on Sunday February 16, 2025 @10:50PM (#43074934)
Social Security started paying out in 1940: https://www.proquest.com/docview/146227490?sourcetype=Histor...

With anyone 65 years or older eligible to start receiving checks.

The 1875 date almost certainly comes from that. I wouldn't be surprised if someone set it as a default for anyone they didn't have a birth date for because you could safely assume someone was older than that if they were receiving social security when it first started _or_ because there are some of those initial payments that truly were never discontinued.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by erik998 on Monday February 17, 2025 @12:00AM (#43075332)
In 1875, the American Express Company established the first private pension plan in the United States.

I can also see a situation where the SSA recipient in 1940 was born in 1875. The recipient age 65 could have married someone very young for 10 years. That younger person could be on survivors benefits and continue receiving payments.

Here is an example: https://www.ssa.gov/history/idapayroll.html

On January 31, 1940, the first monthly retirement check was issued to Ida May Fuller of Ludlow, Vermont, in the amount of $22.54. Miss Fuller, a Legal Secretary, retired in November 1939. She started collecting benefits in January 1940 at age 65 and lived to be 100 years old, dying in 1975.

https://www.ssa.gov/pubs/EN-05-10084.pdf

https://www.ssa.gov/survivor/eligibility

So if in 1965 this retired person married someone age 18... Then that person at 18 never remarried. Could they end up in a situation where they receive survivors benefits from the original applicant?

The recent spouse would be born in 1947 and marry in 1965 for 10 years until their spouse's death... not have remarried or worked, then at age 60 in 2007, derive survivors benefits from original applicant?

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by hylaride on Monday February 17, 2025 @10:37AM (#43080029)
> So if in 1965 this retired person married someone age 18... Then that person at 18 never remarried. Could they end up in a situation where they receive survivors benefits from the original applicant?

"In order to receive this (spousal) benefit, you must have been married for at least 10 years, and both you and your ex must be at least 62 years of age".

Basically, you could but you wouldn't get much to make it worthwhile. I do know that veterans benefits did (at one time?) payout to spouses in the way you ask, though. IIRC benefits from the American Civil War were paid out into the 21st century due to a handful of cases where old veterans married young women. The last known "civil war widow" died in 2008 having married an 86 year old at 19. A daughter received her father's benefits until 2020. There was also another spouse who died in 2020, but she never collected the pension.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Civil_War_widows_who_...

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Projectiboga on Monday February 17, 2025 @12:20PM (#43081208)
The ten year rule is more recent than the SSA.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Suppafly on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @03:05AM (#43087179)
There is a case like that with civil war benefits, the last survivor married a young girl that was his caretaker when he was like 90, and she finally died a few years ago, basically a lifetime after the war had ended.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Aloisius on Sunday February 16, 2025 @11:46PM (#43075252)
They didn't use computers in 1940 for it though. All this was stored on paper where using days since 1875 wouldn't have made much sense. That would lead to most of the beneficiaries having a negative number.

They didn't get their first computer until 1956 and by that point, the 1875 date would have made little sense.

It simply makes more sense there was data entry errors. Indeed, we know there are since the SSA makes records available for dead people. They show people supposedly born as early as 1800:

https://aad.archives.gov/aad/fielded-search.jsp?dt=3059&tf=F...

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by masswerk on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:07AM (#43075720)
> All this was stored on paper

Rather, as also mentioned in the answers, on Hollerith cards, 5-digit encoded (2 for the year, 3 for the day of year). Punch-card appliances were very much a thing. (WWII logistics were run by punch-cards.)

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Aloisius on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:04PM (#43081662)
They used IBM cards, not Hollerith cards (they used IBM 077 collators and 405 accounting machines).

They were coded with 6 digits: 2 for month, 2 day and 2 year according to the SSA.

https://www.ssa.gov/history/ssa/yourss55.html

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by masswerk on Monday February 17, 2025 @03:19PM (#43082938)
Notably, this is from December 1955, already on computers. There's no mention of how data was handled before this. (Also, pre-WWII, people used do talk of "Hollerith cards" in a general way – and the system started in the 1930s.)
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Aloisius on Monday February 17, 2025 @05:24PM (#43083877)
It's mentioned on IBM's site:

https://www.ibm.com/history/social-security-act

https://www.ibm.com/history/punched-card#The+Social+Security...

And the SSA site mentions using IBM machines for it in 1936. IBM machines only used IBM cards:

https://www.ssa.gov/policy/docs/ssb/v69n2/v69n2p55.html

The checks used to pay people were also IBM punchcards.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by masswerk on Monday February 17, 2025 @06:46PM (#43084366)
Hollerith founded the Tabulating Machine Company, which became the Computing-Tabulating-Recording Company (CTR), which became International Business Machines Corporation (IBM). These are the same thing, admittedly adding other businesses along the way. (Hence, IBM includes the invention of the tabulating punch-card in its company history.) So, after 1924, it's IBM, but this didn't stop people from talking about Hollerith cards, even in the 1950s. Here, it was used to designate the pre-computer era use with punch-card appliances.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Aloisius on Monday February 17, 2025 @07:39PM (#43084728)
I didn't realize IBM called their own cards Hollerith cards.

They changed the format to 80x10 with rectangular punches in 1928, naming it the IBM Computer Card. They modified it to 80x12 in 1930. IBM themselves distinguish between Hollerith's cards and IBM cards, but I suppose they were the same physical size and old names die hard.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by kuhewa on Sunday February 16, 2025 @11:57PM (#43075315)
The very first recipient, Ida May Fuller, would be 150 years old currently.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by EdwardDiego on Sunday February 16, 2025 @11:43PM (#43075232)
That makes a lot of sense.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by qingcharles on Monday February 17, 2025 @12:39AM (#43075559)
Also factor in there were civil war widows legitimately eligible for pensions from their dead soldier husbands until the last one died just a couple of years ago:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_Civil_War_widows_who_...

Also can be via your father, this lady was collecting a civil war pension until 2020:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Irene_Triplett

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by zten on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:04AM (#43075692)
Can’t wait for Musk’s team to finally peel back these layers, realize that the code actually implemented the laws, and have to admit they are the idiots and apologize for wasting the government’s money on a poorly-run audit.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by thecopy on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:09AM (#43075737)
They wont admit anything
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by flir on Monday February 17, 2025 @07:43AM (#43078353)
At least we'll get a good example for the Chesterton's Fence wiki page.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by krger on Monday February 17, 2025 @07:49AM (#43078413)
Until the Heritage Foundation succeeds in dismantling Wikipedia.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by flir on Monday February 17, 2025 @08:19AM (#43078710)
That makes me wonder what the Wikimedia Foundation's disaster recovery plan looks like.

The crucial bit of infrastructure (and the most vulnerable point right now) might be the domain name.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by bee_rider on Monday February 17, 2025 @11:31AM (#43080635)
FWIW they have instructions for downloading the whole thing, which mention that it is also downloadable from BitTorrent. So I think it is functionally impossible to delete Wikipedia.

I’d be more worried about propaganda being inserted.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by flir on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:13PM (#43081742)
I'm not worried about the data, and even losing the servers would be a hiccup. But whatever site is at www.wikipedia.org is, in the minds of the general public, Wikipedia.

Domain names have been seized in the past.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by tomnipotent on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:01PM (#43082191)
I imagine most traffic to Wikipedia is through search, so I imagine such a fate is in the hands of search engines. If a community-driven alternative appeared, we'd have to rely on Google indexing this alternative and ranking it higher than the usurped domain.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by ben_w on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:53PM (#43082706)
Search is also vulnerable.

It's been called "wokepedia" (not to be confused with Wookieepedia, the star wars wiki) by Musk and others, telling people not to donate.

And also people have been denouncing Google's search results as biased, as being "woke".

I'm still not sure what any specific user of the word "woke" means, beyond the Ami/UK right using it as an insult, but I can't tell if it's generic or specific, critiquing something or just telling supporters when to boo and jeer. Does the Ami/UK left still use it to mean "being aware of systemic prejudice", or have they also shifted? I didn't notice at the time when "meme" stopped meaning shared online quiz.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by fc417fc802 on Monday February 17, 2025 @05:37PM (#43083960)
> I'm still not sure what any specific user of the word "woke" means

In the context you're referring to it is essentially an accusation of certain ideological ulterior motives in communication.

Regarding your reference to Google's search results. I have no idea what the current behavior is. However a couple of years ago there were some remarkable differences for certain search terms between different geographical versions of the website. It certainly had the appearance of pushing an agenda at the time.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by skissane on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @02:12AM (#43086866)
> I'm still not sure what any specific user of the word "woke" means, beyond the Ami/UK right using it as an insult, but I can't tell if it's generic or specific, critiquing something or just telling supporters when to boo and jeer. Does the Ami/UK left still use it to mean "being aware of systemic prejudice", or have they also shifted?

It is a mistake to think that negative uses of “woke” are an exclusively right-of-centre thing.

Rather than repeat myself, I’ll just link to this comment I posted a bit over a month back - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42695516 - in which I cite several unabashed Marxists using the word negatively (including Adolph L Reed Jr, and the Trotskyist International Committee of the Fourth International).

If you read Reed, he actually means something rather specific by “woke” - whereas classical/orthodox Marxism views non-class-based oppression (race, gender, sexuality, etc) as downstream consequences of class-based oppression, “wokeness” treats them as if they exist independently of class-based oppression, or as upstream of it, or as a higher priority than it

Just the other day, Senator Mark Warner (D-VA) was quoted as saying, regarding his own Democratic Party, that “I think the majority of the party realizes that the ideological purity of some of the groups is a recipe for disaster and that candidly the attack on over-the-top wokeism was a valid attack” - https://www.politico.eu/article/us-senator-mark-warner-democ... - Warner may well be a moderate or centrist Democrat, but I don’t think it makes sense to label him as “conservative” or “right-wing”. He’s not a “conservative Democrat”, in the sense that there was such a thing a decade or two ago [edit: I made some comment here about him not being a member of the Blue Dog caucus, but I’ve removed it because what I was saying didn’t really make sense-the Blue Dog caucus is and was a House caucus, while Warner is a Senator]

I don’t think Warner’s definition of “woke” is as precise as Reed’s, but essentially what he means by it is a form of progressivism which prioritises ideological purity over winning the battle for the median voter’s heart and mind

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by ben_w on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @03:00AM (#43087153)
I see, then it has indeed shifted meaning again.

Thanks for the detailed response; one of the previous times I said this here, the answer was snarky disbelief that I hadn't kept track.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by willy_k on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:21PM (#43081797)
> I’d be more worried about propaganda being inserted.

FWIW, it would be far from the first time that’s happened (including for sensitive US issues).

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by ddgflorida on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:49PM (#43105039)
It is loaded with propaganda right now.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by gota on Monday February 17, 2025 @10:11AM (#43079743)
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by roywiggins on Monday February 17, 2025 @11:18AM (#43080479)
Is it really a Chesterton's Fence if it's covered in signs saying "do not remove" with simple explanations in large, friendly letters?
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by warningforever on Monday February 17, 2025 @05:33PM (#43083941)
Not if you stop understanding or believing the signs.

Very well done doc, though overly concerned, on how keep people in the future away from nuclear waste: Into Eternity https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ayLxB9fV2y4

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by londons_explore on Monday February 17, 2025 @03:09AM (#43076451)
Musks team wont be able to make any sweeping changes here that impact eligibility or payouts - thats the kinda thing where angry pensioners form a mob outside the white house and get front page coverage on every news outlet.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by chrisco255 on Monday February 17, 2025 @05:15AM (#43077220)
Not if it's dead people getting checks while they're telling millennials that social security will be bankrupt by the time they retire.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by jghn on Monday February 17, 2025 @10:41AM (#43080052)
Well good news. There's not pervasive fraud in the system, so that won't happen.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by profeatur on Monday February 17, 2025 @11:04AM (#43080311)
Source: the beneficiaries of such fraud, were it to occur…
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by troupo on Monday February 17, 2025 @03:07AM (#43076431)
This definitely warrants an /s even if it's obvious :)
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by belter on Monday February 17, 2025 @06:28AM (#43077749)
"Fact-checking Elon Musk's claims in the Oval Office" - https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cwyjz24ne85o
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by throw0101d on Monday February 17, 2025 @08:47AM (#43078946)
> Can’t wait for Musk’s team to finally peel back these layers, realize that the code actually implemented the laws […]

Bloomberg's Odd Lots podcast had an episode on this: the hard part in replacing/updating government system is not the coding part. The hard part is understanding the policies that have been changed and modified over the decades.

See "This Is What Happens When Governments Build Software" (Jun 2023):

> There's a lot of frustration about the government's ability to build things in the US. Subways. Bridges. High-speed rail. Electricity transmission. But there's another crucial area where the public sector often struggles, and that is software. We saw it with the infamous rollout of Obamacare. We see it in the UX of the Treasury Direct website. And we saw it in the way state unemployment insurance systems broke during the pandemic. So why is it so hard for the public sector to build and maintain software? On this episode we speak with Jennifer Pahlka, the founder and former executive director of Code for America and author of the new book Recoding America: Why Government Is Failing in the Digital Age and How We Can Do Better, as well as Dave Guarino, who recently left the Department of Labor after working on upgrading the unemployment insurance system. Both have a long history of working on public sector software systems and they explain why the problem is so tricky.

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=nMtOv6DFn1U

One large component is that a lot of business rules and policies have been encoded into the software logic, and (re-)translating that into code in a new(er) language is part of the challenge.

Related, "Why COBOL isn't the problem":

* https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41420217

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by gota on Monday February 17, 2025 @10:09AM (#43079727)
> Bloomberg's Odd Lots podcast had an episode on this: the hard part in replacing/updating government system is not the coding part. The hard part is understanding the policies that have been changed and modified over the decades.

That is the hard part in any system, not just government. Especially government, maybe, but not uncharacteristically and certainly not exclusively!

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by ahartmetz on Monday February 17, 2025 @11:36AM (#43080683)
I have read similar things about payroll software. The thing about laws, regulations and payroll is: you do not get to adapt the rules to the software, the software has to implement everything exactly as prescribed. Even that one-off thing from 1977 that still influences a few pensions by a few cents a month.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by bongodongobob on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:34PM (#43081919)
I work for a company that employs ~5k people. There's an entire IT team just for payroll and it's bigger than Ops. When Elon says he and a handful of devs were going to fix the entirety of the Treasury dept on their own, they are either lying, or have no fucking idea what they're doing. Probably both.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by throwaway81523 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @05:20PM (#43108487)
They saw the movie "Dave" and didn't realize it was fiction.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by AnthonyMouse on Monday February 17, 2025 @05:41PM (#43083986)
> The thing about laws, regulations and payroll is: you do not get to adapt the rules to the software, the software has to implement everything exactly as prescribed.

You do not get to adapt the rules to the software. The government can look at the state of the rules, say "this rule is obsolete, inefficient or unnecessarily complicated" and enact a different rule.

They rarely do this, which is why having someone go through and make the attempt is potentially valuable.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by throw0101d on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:43PM (#43082615)
> That is the hard part in any system, not just government.

Another episode from Odd Lots, "Why Corporate America Still Runs on Ancient Software That Breaks", with Patrick McKenzie (patio11 here at HN):

> Southwest Airlines had a disastrous holiday season, thanks in part to a software bug that left crews out of place and grounded thousands of flights. But Southwest isn't alone in having software in the headlines lately. The New York Stock Exchange recently had a software error that caused weird pricing on stocks and the FAA had its own computer issue that grounded planes earlier this month. So what's the deal with corporate software? Why do these crashes happen? And why does the user experience typically leave something to be desired? On this episode of the podcast we speak with Patrick McKenzie, an expert on engineering and infrastructure, who writes the Bits About Money newsletter and recently left payments company Stripe after six years. We talked about the challenges of keeping any software system alive after years of upgrades and updates, the distribution of tech talent across industries, and whether non-tech companies can close the gap with Silicon Valley.

* https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/why-corporate-america-...

* https://omny.fm/shows/odd-lots/why-corporate-america-still-r...

* https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v6UQaXpzwQA

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by drawkward on Monday February 17, 2025 @08:58AM (#43079057)
Wait if you like, just dont hold your breath.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by lenerdenator on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:15PM (#43081756)
You'll be waiting a long time.

Rule #1 of the new American oligarch: never admit a mistake

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by WalterBright on Monday February 17, 2025 @04:08PM (#43083302)
Musk admitted in the White House interview that he'd made a mistake on the $50m for condoms to Gaza.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by lenerdenator on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:09AM (#43091167)
He could go one step further and admit that his involvement with any sort of government personnel or logistics decision-making is a mistake until Congress gives his cadre of interns a statutory mandate to do what it's doing.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by kolanos on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:41PM (#43081983)
> Rule #1 of the new American oligarch: never admit a mistake

Is this really a new rule? By my understanding of history, this has been the standard operating procedure for governments since... well, since they became a thing. And when mistakes are admitted, they're done so very slowly. For example, it took the U.S. government nearly half a century to apologize for the Japanese internment camps.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by lenerdenator on Monday February 17, 2025 @03:12PM (#43082890)
There was at least the hope that the people in the government would, someday, apologize. Or, failing that, that they would pay at the ballot box come next election.

The new guard are far more like the old royalty of Europe. Look at their lifestyles and riches: how could they possibly be wrong? Back then it was called the divine right of kings: they were chosen by God - the literal creator and master of the universe - and thus, by definition, could not be wrong.

Today it's the absolution of the market: how could you possibly be that wealthy if you are a screw-up? It's hard to get rich, so those who have become so must be better than the conventional wisdom and decency. Any wrong move is written off as another move in a 4D chess game that the average person just can't understand.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Bytewench on Monday February 17, 2025 @07:22PM (#43084602)
I suspect any admission would be made with far less fanfare than what accompanied the accusations made today.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by listenallyall on Monday February 17, 2025 @11:00PM (#43085941)
If an audit ultimately finds that the computer code is perfectly aligned with the law, how does that make it a poorly-run audit, or a waste?
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by zten on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @12:51AM (#43086466)
Do you normally tweet your half baked “discoveries” as propaganda in an effort to undermine the government when performing an audit?

Edit: I really don’t think the way this audit is being conducted is out of a genuine love for America, or the American citizens, or even out of just wanting to do good work. This is very nakedly a dishonest, petty, and malicious investigation.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by listenallyall on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @01:39AM (#43086723)
It's a government audit, not a private company, so the results will be made public regardless. If the audit finds that the computer code is actually correct according to the laws, but it's the laws themselves that are illogical, wasteful, or easy to defraud, that is still quite useful for the public to know. I agree using Twitter is unconventional but again, it's an audit of a massive public program to which virtually every American who pays taxes contributes (except, ironically, many government employees themselves)
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by jcz_nz on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @04:35AM (#43100321)
None of this works the way you imagine it does. Laws are by necessity interpreted. Courts do this all the time. Musk & his kids have zero knowledge, skill or authority in this regard.

System audits require a well defined structure and scope, context, methodology, governance. They take into consideration the IT systems, and the human systems and processes. They clearly define questions to be answered.

This is neither. It is a PR exercise to create an appearance of the regime doing “something” that sounds impressive to their base.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by ddgflorida on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @12:22PM (#43104673)
No one is wasting money. These audits must be done. I do think however that the chances of anyone over 115, or deceased, collecting money is extremely low.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by haveamission on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @03:58PM (#43107576)
What makes you have the impression that the government doesn't do audits, with actual professional auditors? Because it does, and does so regularly
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by cragger60 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @06:58PM (#43109414)
The code doesn't necessa8ry implement the laws. There could easily be a flag on each record that indicates "current recipent" with a value of "n" or "y". The code, in that case could be something like: if current recipient = y, then print check.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by erik998 on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:00AM (#43075668)
There is so much more info on their site.

https://www.ssa.gov/history/hfaq.html

https://www.ssa.gov/history/index.html

https://www.ssa.gov/history/operations.html

Early Operations Social Security Bulletin

Volume 1 - June 1938 - Number 6

ACCOUNTING OPERATIONS OF THE BUREAU OF OLD-AGE INSURANCE

Joseph L. Fay and MaxJ. Wasserman

Bureau of Old-Age Insurance. Mr. Fay is Chief of the Baltimore Accounting Operations Section and Mr. Wasserman is Chief of the Statistics Section. They were assisted by Edward O. Manning of the Statistics Section. https://www.ssa.gov/history/fay638.html

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by gonzobonzo on Monday February 17, 2025 @03:42AM (#43076659)
> The 1875 date almost certainly comes from that.

Here's 1875 the claim that's been all over Twitter these days[1]:

"Social security runs on COBOL, which does not use a date or time type. So the > date is stored as a number using the ISO 8601 standard. The epoch for this is 150 years ago (1875) - aka the metre standard."

"So if you don’t know the date of something, it will be a 0 value, which in COBOL will default to 1875 - 150 years ago."

Weirdly this post itself didn't get a lot of attention (only 2.2k likes), but a ton of people took a screenshot of it and passed it around as fact, which got a lot more attention. For instance, post like this[2] with 56 thousand likes (there are a bunch of them on Twitter right now, all with a screenshot of this original post).

It's a good example of how misinformation spreads like wildfire, and how extremely few people bother to check to see where or not its accurate. I'm not sure it's useful trying to figure out reasons for a 1875 date when we don't actually have any indication that this was actually occurring, and the discussion started because some made an erroneous claim.

[1] https://x.com/toshiHQ/status/1889928670887739902 [2] https://x.com/enkday/status/1890808249663869204

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by chrisco255 on Monday February 17, 2025 @05:14AM (#43077212)
The 1875 date is a made up thing. There's millions of records more than 100+ years old, some as old as 229 years old by birth date. And, it's still very much a problem if the first people to receive SS are still receiving it, or if the system is still cutting checks because their death wasn't ever recorded.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by skissane on Monday February 17, 2025 @06:26AM (#43077737)
> or if the system is still cutting checks because their death wasn't ever recorded.

My speculation: there are a small handful of long dead people, for whom the SSA has never received proof of death, and they fall through some bureaucratic loophole in the "assume people over 115 are dead" rules, so the SSA is still printing them checks. But these checks haven't been deposited in a bank account in many decades, and the SSA doesn't even have a current address to send them, so it just sticks them in a filing cabinet in their basement. No fraud, the government isn't really losing any money since the checks aren't being deposited or cashed, just a little bit of bureaucratic stupidity that no doubt adds up to a rounding error in the federal budget. But you can see how Musk/Trump/et al could spin this to sound a lot worse than it really is.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by kolanos on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:01PM (#43082196)
> But these checks haven't been deposited in a bank account in many decades, and the SSA doesn't even have a current address to send them, ...

While this is likely true for a majority of cases. I am confident that there are both bank accounts and addresses that have remained valid since the 1940s. For example, ABA routing/account numbers on checks go back to 1910.

Presuming checks are being printed, it would not surprise me if they are being sent through the U.S. postal system. What happens to them after that, though, is anyone's guess. Banks generally stay on top of deceased customers. But even then, a bank account can be transferred to beneficiaries and retain the same account number.

i would expect that banks would flag a check being deposited in the name of a known deceased former account holder. But there have already been cases mentioned in this thread where someone can receive SSA benefits on behalf of a deceased spouse/parent. As such, it is conceivable that those checks could be deposited.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by skissane on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:51PM (#43082684)
I guess the difference is: if you see a social security check for a 150 year old being deposited, that would make you suspect fraud, and so you would investigate to determine if it is fraud, or some obscure case where it is actually legitimate. Whereas, if the checks never get deposited, where is the fraud? Which is why I think that the undeposited check case is the most likely to “fall through the cracks”
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by AnthonyMouse on Monday February 17, 2025 @06:28PM (#43084259)
The general problem is that what plays well in the media and what makes the most difference aren't necessarily the same thing.

If you want to find large-scale government waste, it's going to be things like Medicare approving unnecessary treatments, or corrupt officials subtly shaping the bidding process for government contracts to make sure they're awarded to the expected cronies for the expected exorbitant costs, or subsidies that are supposed to go to the poor but are shaped in ways that really cause them to go to landlords or drug companies.

But "we streamlined the bidding process for cloud services contracts to make it feasible for smaller entities to make viable bids" is a non-headline even if it would save billions of dollars. "We're eliminating housing assistance and turning it into a refundable tax credit in the same amount for the same people" would improve government efficiency (and outcomes), but it's not viscerally satisfying and makes people feel bored or uncertain rather than happy or angry.

What sells is simple overt fraud. If you can find some 30 year old cashing their dead grandmother's social security checks, that's a headline that will get people worked up. Which means they want to go find some of that stuff to throw meat to the base, while hopefully also doing those other things that are actually more important but don't get the mob excited.

The opposition then plays politics either way. If you actually reduce Medicare spending on unnecessary treatments you're "cutting Medicare" but if you go find a few clear instances of outrageous fraud then it's "just a drop in the bucket" and you're not making any real difference.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by russdill on Sunday February 16, 2025 @11:05PM (#43075011)
Also they do a heck of a lot more than retirement benefits. And really, it could actually be a survivor benefit and the deceased person could have been born 150 years ago and the survivor still living.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by blackeyeblitzar on Sunday February 16, 2025 @11:02PM (#43074996)
How can anyone on the outside make all these guesses about the code and databases? It feels like a lot of speculation to try to prove a claim wrong, but without evidence.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by brendoelfrendo on Sunday February 16, 2025 @11:51PM (#43075280)
Indeed, how can an outsider like Musk and his DOGE compatriots make any claim at all? I think it is far more likely that Elon was mistaken, or lied, than the SSA is paying out to multiple non-existent 150 year-olds. In fact, that there are so many plausible explanations that don't involve fraud, it really behooves us to be skeptical. Elon made the claim: he is responsible for supplying the evidence.

Note that the doge.gov website has a section called "savings," which originally said "Receipts coming by Valentine's Day." Now it says "Receipts coming over the weekend!", and seeing as it's 11:50pm on the East Coast of the US right now, that seems unlikely, too.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by zten on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:12AM (#43075759)
I’ve gone rushing to my boss in the past with similarly hastily researched claims and conclusions to what Musk is tweeting. In my experience, they were usually the result of me having performed insufficient research, and did not have nearly the impact I thought they would. However, these kind of junior level mistakes make for great propaganda. Anyone can read his conclusion and the chart and with zero critical thought, think “duh! The government is so stupid! I knew I couldn’t trust them to run a benefits program correctly!” And that’s exactly what Musk wants us to conclude. As you note, however, we cannot conclude that - there is a much, much higher burden of proof we should be demanding.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by mike_hearn on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:54AM (#43076334)
Given that other systems do have problems with paying out to dead people or people who are alive but faking their age, it'd be impressive if the US system had zero such cases. The claim isn't unlikely on its face, especially given what he said about Treasury never denying payments for any reason in order to minimise complaints.

As to "how can he make claims at all", it's because civil servants have been told to work for him, which means he is supposed to have access to more information than actual outsiders do (everyone on this thread).

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by flir on Monday February 17, 2025 @07:56AM (#43078488)
I'm sure the US system has a few cases of dead claimants. I mean, it's a country of 330m people.

Dead and 150? Bit harder to believe. It's an extraordinary claim, if you get my drift.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Panoramix on Monday February 17, 2025 @11:10AM (#43080392)
Why? Japan found over 200k ghost centenarians in their database. A significant amount were fraud related, relatives that keep receiving checks for example. So not hard to believe for me.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by flir on Monday February 17, 2025 @12:52PM (#43081546)
> Japan found over 200k ghost centenarians in their database

Weeeeeell.... https://cnrs.hal.science/hal-03478634/document

> Why?

150. I already said this.

The children of a 150-year-old would probably be in their ~120s. The grandchildren would be in their ~90s.

You're claiming a social security account that's been passed down through multiple generations, like some kind of family heirloom.

It's an extraordinary claim, if you get my drift.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by danso on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:14PM (#43081749)
The SSA OIG has done a couple of investigations into this the past decade. In 2023 [0], it agreed with the SSA that "almost none of the numberholders discussed in the report [people aged 100 or older] currently receive SSA payments" (while disagreeing that the costs and risks of a mass correction effort outweigh the benefits)

> While we agree that adding presumed death information to these records will result in incorrect dates of death appearing on these Numident records, we do not agree it poses a significant risk of erroneously recording death information on living numberholders’ records. For example, we see little risk in adding presumed death information to the millions of Numident records belonging to individuals born in the 1800s who haven’t worked or received SSA payments in more than 50 years.

> SSA determined the estimated $5.5 to $9.7 million in expenditures to correct these errors was too costly to implement and that the effort would have limited benefit to the administration of SSA programs. We acknowledge that almost none of the numberholders discussed in the report currently receive SSA payments. However, SSA issued each of these individuals a valid SSN and these SSNs could allow for a wide range of potential abuse.

[0] https://oig.ssa.gov/assets/uploads/a-06-21-51022.pdf#page10

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Amezarak on Monday February 17, 2025 @06:02AM (#43077548)
We all know that Musk is not someone with a strong commitment to the truth. We all know he's a grifter. How long has FSD been coming now? What was the deal with the diver?

But so much of these DOGE criticisms are simply reflexive "Musk bad." There is no a priori reason why it's unlikely that a small amount of people are being paid benefits out of a byzantine bureaucratic system that's almost a hundred years old.

Just a few years ago, I was listening to a story on NPR about SSI fraud (also administered by the SSA) and how common it was. Now, apparently we're all convinced all government agencies contain approximately zero fraud, or at least detectable-by-Musk fraud, simply because it's the cause du jour. It's totally bizarre to read these HN stories (I flag most of them) and people are making totally unfounded claims on the processes, controls, and operation of government IT systems, apparently assuming they are just as good as what exists at Meta or Google. Well, I have personal experience, and maybe my program was an outlier, but these people seem to have extremely rosy expectations, and often have no idea how the government works even in theory ("there's an IG to find things like this!").

It's really exhausting and disappointing. DOGE can be a misguided operation run by a grifter that misreports findings and will never save the amount of money promised and a lot of stuff in the government can be awful, missing even basic controls.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by troupo on Monday February 17, 2025 @08:37AM (#43078860)
> But so much of these DOGE criticisms are simply reflexive "Musk bad."

I mean, these are your own words:

> DOGE can be a misguided operation run by a grifter that misreports findings

And that's the main issue and criticism, not that everyone believes that the government is perfect

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Amezarak on Monday February 17, 2025 @08:41AM (#43078890)
But people aren’t saying that. Instead, they’re just inventing reasons why Musk is wrong, with no evidence or invented evidence, like the subject of this article.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by troupo on Monday February 17, 2025 @09:07AM (#43079146)
Because Musk has already given ample evidence of how wrong he is on multiple accounts.

It's on Musk to provide evidence for his extraordinary claims. So far that evidence has been in very short supply.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Amezarak on Monday February 17, 2025 @09:21AM (#43079259)
Yes, but people are just making stuff up about why he’s wrong. That is literally no better.

You may as well just suspend judgement about these claims. No amount of evidence is going to convince most people here: we saw that with the Hunter laptop, where the goalposts moved with each additional proof the smallest amount possible.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by troupo on Monday February 17, 2025 @09:33AM (#43079389)
"No amount of evidence" does not equal "no evidence".

In case of Hunter laptop there was a grand jury, an FBI investigation, a criminal case, a joint investigation by two Republican committees against Joe Biden etc. etc.

What evidence has Musk provided?

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by buttercraft on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:17PM (#43082346)
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Amezarak on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:25PM (#43082433)
This is not a good article. The Reuters and Politico examples, for instance, are particularly tendentious. Overpaying for subscriptions, or buying unnecessary subscriptions is exactly how such payments would operate.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by thordenmark on Monday February 17, 2025 @12:36PM (#43081385)
Tons of evidence released already, even if you've only been casually following DOGE. And for some, no amount of evidence will ever be enough. Why is it so hard to believe an agency as big and inefficient as the US Govt. would have plenty of waste?
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by cjkarr on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:18PM (#43082350)
I've been waiting for that evidence. All I see is a message stating "Receipts coming over the weekend!"

https://doge.gov/savings

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by troupo on Monday February 17, 2025 @04:10PM (#43083314)
Nope, there's no evidence. There's an endless list of something cut, with no evidence that it was wasteful, fraud, or not within the remit of the agencies in question.

Like this one: https://x.com/DOGE/status/1890593889314038216

Or claims with literally no evidence other than the tweets like this: https://x.com/DOGE/status/1890849405932077378

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by lostdog on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:00PM (#43082178)
I love comments about there being "tons" of evidence without pointing to a single piece of it. Few things make me chuckle as hard as this.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by svachalek on Monday February 17, 2025 @11:52AM (#43080865)
I started out with a similar position, but so far everything I've heard out of DOGE is either:

1. Misrepresenting congressionally approved expenditures he royally disapproves of as "fraud"

2. Misleading, under-researched, unsupported statistics as "waste"

The longer this goes on, the more impressed I am with our government. I had no idea it would be this hard to find anything legitimate to attack.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by kolanos on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:15PM (#43082322)
> 1. Misrepresenting congressionally approved expenditures he royally disapproves of as "fraud"

This seems dubious to me. In almost all congressional expenditures the funds allocated are done so at a department level with broad statutes applied. It is largely left up to that department to decide what to actually do with those funds specifically. It seems like a stretch to characterize this as "congressionally approved" and more like an abdication by congress on large swaths of government spending.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by ModernMech on Monday February 17, 2025 @05:04PM (#43083736)
There is of course a feedback loop here. It's not like they get a check and no one ever looks to see what it was spent on. Congress has multiple levels of oversight over these agencies, including several congressional Committees (House and Senate), inspectors general, and whistleblowers. This oversight serves to minimize fraud, waste, and abuse.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by wonderwonder on Monday February 17, 2025 @06:48PM (#43084377)
I think the issue is a mix of "the boy who cried wolf" and really smart programmers with almost no real world experience who have been told to find "fraud". I am confident the government is rife with it. Issue is we have unleashed these young developers who I am sure are all excellent programmers who can code me under the table. Issue becomes developers with experience will question requirements, very good developers without experience will say "this is easy" and then just implement it. They were told to find fraud so we are presented with the classic "to a hammer, everything looks like a nail" .

On top of that, Musk is so eager to announce progress that he just repeats what he is told as he knows that these are very smart programmers.

I found myself working in an heavily regulated industry recently and I can tell you if you dropped a young really smart programmer into the code base they would find a million things that are inefficient and wrong. In reality they were carefully coded that way to support some byzantine law or legacy program or one off. An experienced dev will ask "anyone know why we do X in module Y"? and he will get an answer saying "yes, its because of...". The young hotshot dev just deletes and rewrites it or yells "fraud"

So Musk is shooting himself in the foot when if he just waited and verified he could release valid and I am sure damning evidence of fraud but currently he is just "crying wolf"

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by jki275 on Monday February 17, 2025 @11:18PM (#43086028)
I've personally worked in such a system. I can tell you -- as someone who asked the question often -- that often, the answer is "because we wrote it that way in 1975 and no one has bothered to spend the time to learn how to make it better since then.

It is not necessarily true something written forty years ago is right. It is not necessarily true that something written forty years ago has some secret logic in it that cannot be improved upon. It is not necessarily true that something written forty years ago cannot be improved by fresh eyes.

Obviously one must not change things recklessly -- but there are often improvements that can be made.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by wonderwonder on Tuesday February 18, 2025 @11:14PM (#43098483)
Fair point
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by int_19h on Monday February 17, 2025 @11:25PM (#43086068)
And don't forget that the programmers in question are specifically selected based on their ideological adherence and loyalty. Which is to say, they are already convinced that waste is there, and that it is welfare and entitlements mostly.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by EdwardDiego on Sunday February 16, 2025 @11:45PM (#43075244)
Yeah, exactly, and no-one can see Musk is tweeting about either.

But we're generally assuming that he's clinging to anything that justifies a pre-existing narrative.

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by masswerk on Monday February 17, 2025 @01:26AM (#43075858)
Let's say, someone grew up in an orphanage in the 1940s with an unknown date of birth. This was before any computer systems and the date would have been recorded on punch-card, probably in 2+3 digits, here defaulting to `00` for the year for a missing value. It's plausible that this would have been transitioned as-is to any more modern date encodings.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by Aloisius on Monday February 17, 2025 @02:52PM (#43082693)
After much searching, I found documentation on SSA's Master Beneficiary Records format from after the Y2K update.

Date of Birth in some of these records is stored as days since January 1, 1800. There's no reference to 1875 anywhere. See section 2.3 Date formats:

https://omb.report/icr/200704-0960-012/doc/2576801

Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by masswerk on Monday February 17, 2025 @03:26PM (#43082994)
But it was common to encode missing two-digits data as something in the high-90s, maybe specifying a reason in the least significant digit. (I was taught to do so at university and did so myself for a project.) So, if the start date is indeed 1980, the code for missing date could still have been 95.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by jedwards1211 on Wednesday February 19, 2025 @02:34AM (#43099610)
I’m still kind of surprised they would store days since 1800, but it makes a lot more sense than 1875. At least with 1800 the last two digits are the same, so debugging it is somewhat sane.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by ein0p on Monday February 17, 2025 @03:06PM (#43082837)
As a person to whom all of this is "clear", and who "understands" everything, could you please explain how a system whose entire function depends on knowing the person's birth date would function without knowing the birth date?
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by dvogel on Monday February 17, 2025 @10:13PM (#43085709)
My understanding of the claim is that the mainframe data is stored in a high fidelity format but some records simply lack a full year. At the time social security was instituted it was common for people to not know their own age precisely. Beyond memory issues arising from old age, most people just didn't have a pressing reason to track it. So social security benefits were granted to people who seemed old enough even though they didn't have a birth certificate or similar. The claim, as I've heard it, is that the DOGE dolts transferred this data to a more modern system where they blindly passed incomplete or placeholder values into an 8601 library implementation that uses the 2004 standard's reference date of 1875 by default.
Re:Does or did COBOL default to 1875-05-20 for corrupt or mi... by NoPicklez on Monday February 17, 2025 @10:55PM (#43085928)
That theory could track since DOGE did seek approval to use SQL visual query software, the software may have parsed those birth dates in that regard.

Again why it is so irresponsible of Musk to have addressed the public in the way he did without (presumably) all of the facts and without nuance