How decentralized is Bluesky really? - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=42215410 - Nov 2024 (16 comments)
So is Matrix.
I tried out Bluesky last week in hope of finding a social network which ticked this box, but my feed was full of anti Elon Musk / Trump messages. So it was very political from my initial experience.
This was after the setup wizard process where I selected tech/science/entertainment preferences.
Perhaps I did something wrong or didn't give it enough chance?
Either way I deleted my account.
What is happening a lot here in Holland now that the hard-right crowd are constantly spamming topics about totally unrelated issues with stuff like "There are only 2 genders". I don't mind them having an opinion (even though I strongly disagree), I just don't want it shoved in my face constantly and inappropriately. It's like they are so preoccupied with what's happening in other people's pants that they can't talk about anything else.
So yeah that is something I don't want to see in social media anymore and I avoid platforms that allow it. Like Xitter.
I'll use myself as an example. I don't want to see America politics because I don't care about the nothingburger posts that surrounds Trump.
There's a setting to blacklist certain words or topics. It does not work. I hope they fix it at some point, because I don't spend much time on there, and I'd like to.
It was the same with Brexit. Those 2 years I got so fed up with that constantly repeating discussion about separating goods & services which they knew was impossible from the start.
It was a discussion about congestion pricing.
Not the current, but the previous one when Dorsey owned Twitter. And I don't know what's worse, honestly.
I got the impression from the Dorsey interview that this was his commitment, and that he left because they weren't interested in that. They're just trying to be a twitter clone that picks up angry twitter users who hate Musk.
-----
> That was the second moment I thought, uh, nope. This is literally repeating all the mistakes we made as a company. This is not a protocol that's truly decentralized. It’s another app. It's another app that's just kind of following in Twitter's footsteps, but for a different part of the population.
> Everything we wanted around decentralization, everything we wanted in terms of an open source protocol, suddenly became a company with VCs and a board. That's not what I wanted, that's not what I intended to help create.
https://www.piratewires.com/p/interview-with-jack-dorsey-mik...
-----
The problem for Bluesky is that those people aren't actually leaving twitter, they're still using twitter more than they use Bluesky.
The scuttlebutt is that many people have heard that the index, the directory, and the signing keys are centralized.
The good news is the signing keys are not in the hands of the users so we could in theory rewrite all of the messages on the protocol.
If you had those keys would you choose to do this?
Are you delusional? It’s like a left wing clone of Gab. It’s just full of Anti Trump and Anti Elon nonsense
1) A Twitter clone without the political baggage and chaos of the current Twitter ownership.
2) A vastly overengineered distributed software system with a strong ideological commitment to federated design.
There's no inherent relationship between the two, but a lot of the people who run 1 are heavily committed to 2, and so end up sowing a lot of confusion about it.
I would wager that most Bluesky users don't care about it being decentralized, and in fact want a lot of features (soft block, private blocklists) that the federated design makes impossible.