News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @04:51PM (#42616364)
This is just hysteria. These are not third party ads, rather just Meta upselling its own thing; it is generated natively by the platform, not leading anywhere else but the platform that the user is already on. Even though it came up in an unexpected way, it explicitly says that it's private experience.

The real boring dystopia (referring to the subreddit's name) is how the human psyche is played with by these platforms in the first place. People, including me, sign away so much for convenience, fear of missing out, for wanting to belong, to be appreciated. These systems sell the poison and the topical cure at the same time, and it's not just perfectly legal, it's wanted even, desired.

EDIT: edited "ads" to "third party ads" - to spell out what the common understanding is of an advertisement.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by miltonlost on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:06PM (#42616521)
> These are not ads, rather something that is generated natively by the platform, not leading anywhere else but the platform that the user is already on.

Is this post Advertising a product? Yes, it is advertising a MetaAI product. Just because it's not an external ad, doesn't mean it's not an ad. Hulu shows me adds for other Hulu shows. This is an ad despite me not leaving that streaming site.

What is an advertisement to you?

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by lbhdc on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:13PM (#42616579)
You are right, that is still and ad. Platform ads are really common for anyone running their own ad exchange. Sometimes its just to use up supply, other times its to meet in house goals.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:26PM (#42616732)
This is technically true, these are advertisements. But not what first come to mind when reading the title "Instagram is using my face on ads targeted at me", which would be third-party ads, so this is my point. The title is sensational, a play on this misunderstanding, rather than being substantial.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by bitmasher9 on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:32PM (#42616796)
My ick levels are about the same whether it’s used by third parties or just Meta. It’s a mega corporation using my likeness to manipulate my behavior for their own ends.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by leptons on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @03:46PM (#42627260)
When someone signs up for facebook they are agreeing that any image they upload is something they are explicitly granting them permission to use. Where's the "ick"? They already gave them permission, whether they read the fine print or not.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by to11mtm on Monday January 06, 2025 @07:06PM (#42617636)
well, a properly sensationalized title for your case would be 'Instagram and facebook are giving my pictures away to advertisers for use'.

Still semi-sensational but more direct to your posit.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by sweeter on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:31PM (#42616789)
No one said third-party ads, the description is perfectly accurate to what is happening. The knee jerk reaction to call it sensationalist is odd to me.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by miltonlost on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:45PM (#42616934)
The title is only sensational because you, YOU, conflated "3rd party ads" with "ads". The only misunderstanding comes from you who didn't know what an advertisement is and added your own personal connotation. The title is not playing on anything; it's an accurate description of what happened. You are downplaying what happened, claiming "hysteria" when you are, from the get-go, wrong about the entire premise. Your ignorance of the definition of an ad doesn't mean the title is trying to ragebait you; how could the author know you don't know things?

An ad is an ad is an ad is an ad.

My god, admit when you're wrong fully rather than just saying "you're technically correct".

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:54PM (#42617016)
To help with understanding my point, I edited the original comment, and noted the edit.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by tsimionescu on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:01PM (#42617092)
You edited to claim that "ad" is commonly understood to mean "3rd party ad", when in fact that is not true, and it's irrelevant either way. The idea of using my likeness in ads is disgusting, and likely illegal, even if they are first party ads.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by to11mtm on Monday January 06, 2025 @07:09PM (#42617663)
Agreed that '3rd party ad' is a weird qualifier.

For starters, what's '3rd party'? I remember when Google-Fi or whatever it was had the poorly animated, jingle sung-by-a 'totally not trying to cop Randy Newman vibe' ads. Would that be a 3rd party in that case?

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Wednesday January 08, 2025 @04:57AM (#42632623)
Third party in this case could be two things at least.

One, an advertisement that is about something that provided by someone who is not Meta - like a Nike shoe, or a law firm.

Two, third party could imply that the data left the Meta ecosystem - like how if you visit a blog, and there is a Google Adsense banner, then your visitation data left the blog, the first party, to end up at Google, a third party, and possibly others, again, third parties.

I am making this "third party" distinction, because I think that this is a significant step in what it takes to make advertisements "dystopian", which is the premise of the original post. I think that the situation that OP encountered, that he used a service, and then service itself did something unexpected, is not at all dystopian. However, what the title posited, that his face is now used for targeted advertisements, has much more far-reaching implications - like, for example, it could be the next Cambridge Analytica scandal.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by writtenAnswer on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:00PM (#42617080)
Lol, literally calling an ad by meta not an ad. If they do it for Meta, the next logical step. This is from the same company that wanted to create official bots that would post, comment, react. Meta at this point is just throwing shit at the wall and hoping something sticks as a product. I am not afraid of my data being stolen, but it is a wake up call for what to expect.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:14PM (#42617214)
>Meta at this point is just throwing shit at the wall and hoping something sticks

I feel the very same from the OP reddit submission. OP used Meta AI, and then Meta AI used it for more Meta AI. I'm sorry but this is a far cry from "Instagram is using my face on ads targeted at me". The implications of this title, and the situation it describes differ greatly. For example, if the user used Meta AI, and then got an ad of themselves driving a car, drinking a coffee, wearing some clothing, and the ad would be about that product itself, then I would have not made the original comment at all.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by ziml77 on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:27PM (#42617328)
You're fighting way harder on this than I would, but I do agree that the title had me imagining being served an ad where I'm using the product being sold to me. Ads already are trying to make you think you'd be happy or popular by using their product by showing you people acting like that. It kicks that up to another level to literally see yourself happy because you're using a product that someone wants to sell you.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by n144q on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:18PM (#42616642)
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Advertising

> Advertising is the practice and techniques employed to bring attention to a product or service. Advertising aims to present a product or service in terms of utility, advantages and qualities of interest to consumers.

Nobody ever said that advertising must involve a third party.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:31PM (#42616787)
I feel like advertisements are on a spectrum, and that (let's call them) "first party" advertisements are not what come to people's minds, when they read a title like "Instagram is using my face on ads targeted at me". I'd like to prove this point by the following image search: https://duckduckgo.com/?t=ftsa&q=instagram+ads&iax=images&ia... . The top results all relate to advertise something on Instagram that is not Meta-related - so, third party ads.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by Handprint4469 on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:07PM (#42616529)
> These are not ads, rather something that is generated natively by the platform, not leading anywhere else but the platform that the user is already on

So if Instagram shows you ads about Meta AI, it doesn't count as ads because both are owned by Meta?

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:28PM (#42616754)
Yes, in my mind, just saying "ads" are more for like Nike or Hyundai, than for a service provider upselling its own products. But this point is technically valid, these are advertisements as well. Just not what I, or others, first think of when they read "Instagram is using my face on ads".
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by lelandfe on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:43PM (#42616920)
If you go into a Hyundai dealer and see a big banner about their new financing plan, isn’t that an ad?

If the Nike catalog includes a full page promo for nike.com, isn’t that an ad?

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:49PM (#42616978)
Yes, it's an ad.

My point is, and I even edited the original comment so that it comes across better: "ads on instagram" implies third party ads much more, than fist party upsells. Another example is "Ads in Windows". The popup for OneDrive is much less egregious than Candy Crush, or tabloid news in the Start Menu. This is because, while the user asked for neither, some consent was already given for the first party, while no consent was given to the third party.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by lelandfe on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:11PM (#42617181)
You rewrote your comment not to come across better but to make a different point.

Your point was that this wasn’t an ad. Your point now is that you personally feel “ad” doesn’t typically mean first party ads.

The former is wrong, the latter an opinion.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:21PM (#42617279)
What you call an opinion is not my original point, and even if so, I don't understand what you are trying to say. Shouldn't I have expressed an opinion here?
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by lelandfe on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:27PM (#42617325)
Editing a comment so substantially that your thesis changes makes you look deeply disingenuous.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by F7F7F7 on Monday January 06, 2025 @07:09PM (#42617665)
I’ve come down this far and can co-sign this comment. Holy canoli.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:40PM (#42617436)
Thank you for your feedback. I'll strive to come across better the first time in the future.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by chillfox on Monday January 06, 2025 @07:37PM (#42617874)
I really don't see a difference between upsell and 3rd party ads. I stopped using Evernote (was a paying subscriber) because I got annoyed by constantly having ads for their other services shoved in my face.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by ahoka on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:06PM (#42617136)
But Meta AI is not Instagram, so it’s not even first party?
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:16PM (#42617234)
The user gave their picture to Meta AI in Instagram previously, and Meta AI and Instagram have the same parent company, and the user also encountered the advertisement on Instagram. This is as first party as it gets, in my Hacker News submissions. Maybe not in legal language.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by fullshark on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:52PM (#42616995)
This is just rationalization, everything the post said is 100% correct and the users are unhappy about it justifiably.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by tsimionescu on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:08PM (#42616532)
They are an Instagram post that is shown to make you buy something, not because anyone you follow posted it. So, it's an ad. The fact that they're using your face in a Meta ad doesn't make it any different from any other ad.

You're probably thinking about this as not a problem from a privacy perspective, and you may be right that this is not technically a privacy issue. But it's still a huge problem from a psychological influence perspective. Ads are already extremely good at manipulating your psyche, adding the ability to show you personally in some wonderful situations that their product would apparently put you in is a whole other level in manipulation.

Plus, if this gets normalized, the next step is absolutely going to be to sell this as a new type of ad to other brands (assuming people end up interacting with such ads more).

Edit to say: thinking about it, I actually think it's a privacy violation even for a Meta ad. Giving them permission to use an image of my face to generate a better selfie doesn't give them permission to use it to serve me ads. The GDPR is pretty specific about this: when you opt into sharing personal data for a specific purpose, that has to be interpreted in a narrow sense, you can't arbitrarily broaden the scope.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by tantalor on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:35PM (#42616820)
Imagine the ozempic ads that use your real face on a thinner body.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by dylan604 on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:58PM (#42617063)
If you can then use those ozempic images for your own use, then I bet a bunch of people would be quite happy with it.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by tsimionescu on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @01:28AM (#42619883)
I'd bet that this would be a bridge too far for many people, even the newer generations. People want to control how their likeness is used, many are not even happy to appear in their friends' pictures (at least to get tagged) unless they like the result and are asked before hand.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by dylan604 on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @10:47AM (#42623636)
That seems like a strange conclusion with the extravagant use of heavy filtering so that nobody actually looks like what their social presence implies.

They just need to tweaking the marketing and release it as a filter, but then include weasel words text that says anything used by the filter allows for them to selectively choose images to use as marketing. Essentially reversing the flow with sneaky consent

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by amiantos on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:57PM (#42617053)
I'm with you. If I am at a bar and I see a sign that says "PBR - $3", I don't think of that as an advertisement. This user opted into Meta AI and (perhaps 'unknowingly' as no one reads the terms) gave their consent for this to happen, so I think 'hysteria' is appropriate and it's clear to me that here in the comments, opinions about this are based on feelings and not facts, and for that reason, it has to be described in misleading ways.

I, too, have "used Meta AI", and have not had this happen to me. But I did not use Meta AI to generate pictures of me, so I did not check the box that led to this. That is one of the number of ways the way this post is titled in a way that is misleading. Simply "using Meta AI" in any capacity did not lead to this outcome.

Additionally, the title suggests that the user gave his photos to Meta AI, and then a separate service, Instagram, is using his photos. That's not what is happening, he gave his photos to Meta AI (likely inside Instagram) and then Meta AI is using them (inside Instagram). There's no need to pretend two different services are sharing their photos around, but the post title is more engaging if there's the suggestion otherwise.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by fullshark on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:19PM (#42617261)
When I worked as a waiter, we were supposed to tell the customers about the drink / appetizer specials before taking orders. This dialogue was in fact advertising as those were the high margin offerings at every restaurant.

In any case I think it's more analogous to ads for tv shows while you're trying to watch a tv show. The media you want to consume (news feed) has ads interjected in it, in order to get you to spend more time consuming more content.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:39PM (#42617425)
Not really. OP was already an Instagram and Meta AI user. So, in the TV analogy, this would be like telling you about an upcoming programme, while you are watching a channel.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:09PM (#42617155)
I fully agree. There is a lot, a wide spectrum of abuse that Meta can be attacked for, and this little thing is not one of them. I think this is why I feel so personal about this - I do dislike Meta a lot, but I like it when people roast it for the actually valid reasons. I'm sorry for the downvotes, and appreciate your support.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by KaiserPro on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:36PM (#42616841)
If Instagram shows you an old post with a picture thats got a filter on, or grouped some of your pictures together into a frame, saying "look back on your memories and repost" is that an advert?

When your post comes up in the explore page of another user, is that an advert?

what about those stupid "Here is a post from your friends on threads" with most of the stuff cropped off, as soon as you try and click it, its loads the fucking app store?

Meta have done some terrible shit, but this isn't up there. Its not even a mili-cambridge analyitica. (or a pico-myanmar) its just a shitty app in their shitty social network.

It seems like we are just hipster-hate yak shaving on something pointless, and missing the much wider point that the US needs decent data protections laws, and a functioning legislature.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by tsimionescu on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:04PM (#42617115)
Your examples are not ads, because they are not trying to convince you to buy anything, or even to give Instagram/Meta any more data about yourself. Advertising a completely separate Meta business (Meta AI is not Instagram) is an entirely different thing.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:37PM (#42617406)
This ad is also nothing what you describe - the user was already a Meta AI user. From the title: "Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targeted at me". So what happened is that Meta AI did a few extra easy image manipulations, and showed it to its user, on the same platform nonetheless, not even on Facebook or something.
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by tsimionescu on Monday January 06, 2025 @06:58PM (#42617568)
We don't know some of this. MetaAI can be used independently of Instagram, I believe, so I don't know if it's certain that the user used it through Instagram. Also, don't they have a paid tier that they are likely trying to get them to upgrade to?
Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by KaiserPro on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:27AM (#42620809)
> Also, don't they have a paid tier that they are likely trying to get them to upgrade to?

no.

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by KaiserPro on Tuesday January 07, 2025 @04:26AM (#42620804)
> Meta business (Meta AI is not Instagram)

Isn't threads a separate "business"?

Re:Used Meta AI, now Instagram is using my face on ads targe... by npteljes on Monday January 06, 2025 @05:42PM (#42616904)
I fully agree. The reddit post is a nothingburger. It feels like it's more about someone wanting to express themselves, or fish for something that might worth good feedback, than someone who actually has something worthwhile to say.

The actual good that this thing has is some feedback for people, to think about whether they want to use these platforms, or not. Being conscious about stuff like these is what I think does good to the world, and the well-being of people.