News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by jondwillis on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @11:41AM (#42502998)
At this point I’m just watching a slightly younger cohort of men repeat all of my worst digital addiction mistakes like getting inserted into the online video game -> toxic online behavior pipeline (or worse, fascism), ideologies (Musk), crypto and options gambling (thanks Reddit a la 2013 for all of the crypto communities and WSB) too much computer (ouch, my neck, arms and back.)

I’m not doing particularly well, especially mentally, despite having tons of opportunity and successes. Worried about the younger cohorts, but I guess that is a tale as old as time.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by intended on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @12:11PM (#42503208)
Wsb was 2013??
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by mminer237 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @12:23PM (#42503312)
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by alumic on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @01:00PM (#42503574)
I remember the “community” having its own well-defined memes and culture by at least 2016
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by siltcakes on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @11:43AM (#42503011)
Are they also drinking tons of soda? I can’t believe how much I used to drink. I don’t touch any drink with sugar (other than lactose/latte) nowadays. It’s so disgusting, don’t know how I ever did it in the first place.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by iknowSFR on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @12:02PM (#42503137)
Broad brushstrokes incoming and pure speculation but I wrote it out anyway…

Today’s youth are more proactive with their identities these days than we were. We were and remain reactive with our identities. That preference influences what triggers the dopamine hits needed for life.

The drugs of a reactive identity culture are sugar, alcohol, narcotics, work, anything that’s a trope in movies made by boomers. These drugs have consequences that shape the user’s identity. For example: weight gain or burnout.

But the drugs of a proactive identity culture are those that drive the person’s perception of their identity. The live ahead of the consequences. Things like digital social networks, status symbols like shoes, colleges, or jobs, and anything that drives success in those status symbols. Example: Adderall helps the user study, which helps the user get better grades, which opens the door to a better college, which allows the user to flaunt that college association as part of their identity. That doesn’t mean there aren’t consequences to those drugs but those consequences aren’t tropes of modern life just yet because we’re still normalizing their outcomes.

All of this to say: sodas aren’t their thing because soda is “unhealthy” and that drags on their identity.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by stonedge on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @12:13PM (#42503228)
> Today’s youth are more proactive with their identities these days than we were.

I wanted to echo this and say that I believe younger people create a "symphony" with their identity; picking and choosing from various sub-cultures to create a unique combination. Flexible, morphing.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by rcpt on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @12:14PM (#42503242)
Gen Z uses a lot more steroids which tracks with your analysis.

But also I think you're falling for sample bias. The ones who don't have a billion followers are overweight and generally less healthy than previous generations.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by jajko on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:34PM (#42504301)
And more depressed since massive quick/instant success is seemingly everywhere, apart from their own hands. Cancer if social media at its best, spreading depression like chemtrails.

This breeds greed for status & perceived success and 0 patience to get there. You see it here on HN all the time when talking economy and real estate - young people complaining how they they cant own some well located nice house right now, how everything is shit and their future stolen, despite stats saying exactly the opposite. Where the fuck is at least a bit of decency to wait a decade of hard effort for such a success? Thats shit for losers, nobody got time for that.

How I feel sorry for them, all the added value of technology is nothing compared to what they 'lost' or more like never experienced. At least many of them, the vocal majority, the rest goes on just like we did

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by rcpt on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:58PM (#42504469)
Ok but housing is legit screwed up.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by b800h on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @12:25PM (#42503330)
What a brilliant observation.

Has anything else been written online about proactive vs. reactive identities, and particularly - how this has changed historically. Could it have been the case that prior to television, generations (for example "The Greatest Generation") grew up with a proactive identity culture, due to having a more proactively social culture?

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by nntwozz on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @01:44PM (#42503926)
"Our youth now love luxury, they have bad manners, contempt for authority; they show disrespect for elders, and they love to chatter instead of exercise. Children are now tyrants not servants of their household. They no longer rise when elders enter the room."

— Socrates

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by MndlshnDscpl on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @07:20PM (#42505955)
This is a famous misattribution typically used to state generational views have always been the same. Unfortunately its not Socrates, but actually Kenneth Freeman, Cambridge, 1907.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by mckirk on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @01:50PM (#42503979)
A very interesting observation. I wonder though if the difference is genuinely a different kind of self-understanding between the generations, or more a question of the prevalence of these two approaches to identity. I think in my generation there were also plenty of people that at least tried to be 'proactive' about their identity building (and greatly valued status symbols etc), but I believe it was not as common, because this meme of 'seeing yourself as your own brand and wanting/needing to market yourself' was not as prominent. Maybe there even were, relatively speaking, more people back then that actively tried to avoid the 'status games', because they were still easier to escape then -- but that's just speculation, and certainly influenced by my own aversion to these games and hence my own youth.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by hashishen on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @11:56AM (#42503085)
God my teeth wish i had just stopped drinking soda a decade ago. It wasnt even that hard to kick
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by xattt on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @01:54PM (#42504015)
How much of that was soda, and how much was it access to preventative care?
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by mplewis on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:40PM (#42504741)
If you're drinking soda daily, your teeth are coated in acidic liquid for hours a day. This is incredibly damaging to your enamel.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by xattt on Sunday December 29, 2024 @05:35AM (#42539091)
I would posit there’s an overlap between those who drink cola daily and limited access to healthcare.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by jazz9k on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @05:05PM (#42505265)
Dental care is cheap and insurace is usually sub $100/month (at least in the US)
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by lm28469 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @12:48PM (#42503493)
I feel like the patterns are more or less the same but the cycles are getting shorter and more pronounced.

I met the son of a family friend today, he's 13, already has an opinion about the Israel/Palestine war and spent $500 in roblox so far, they're not wealthy at all. Back in my days I was stuck in the free to play parts of mmorpgs (or had to beg for months for a $5 monthly membership), playing tf2 (free) and had 0 political ideas or even knew people who cared about politics

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by hipadev23 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:39PM (#42504338)
When I was 13 I had a paper route and mowed lawns, and with those earnings I spent about $75 per month on video games and comic books, easily exceeding $500 over a year.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by ghxst on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @06:47PM (#42505816)
This to me on a surface level this seems totally fine, however I can't help to feel conflicted when that money is being spent on some of the more "predatory" games like gachas, however I'm not sure if it's really too different from kids spending their money on pokemon cards either. Do you feel different about those or would you say it's the same thing?
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by hipadev23 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @07:39PM (#42506029)
There’s nothing to say it was predatory games. Roblox is a platform with a vast number of games from unaffiliated developers.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by ghxst on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @08:49PM (#42506290)
Oh yeah I should have clarified my post wasn't necessarily aimed at Roblox but rather generally speaking.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by rsanek on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @12:58AM (#42507160)
i mean they're pretty affiliated, they develop games that only work on their platform and get paid by Roblox directly.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by hipadev23 on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @05:45PM (#42511705)
The developers themselves are anyone who wants to make and publish games is my point, and unaffiliated with own another. And those developers are free to build and monetize games however they want. Just like other closed-ecosystem (e.g. iOS) game devs.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by onemoresoop on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @01:56PM (#42504033)
$500 in Roblox? that's a lot of money for a 13 year old and that money could likely be spent elsewhere... As far as the opinion about Israel/Palestine it's likely that opinion is inherited from family or cohort and it's not fully their own.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by RajT88 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:10PM (#42504127)
I recall in grade school in the 80's lots of kids had opinions on Jews, Poles, black folks, gay folks, etc. Clearly, all acquired from relatives.

Young people emulating the adults in their life is how it always has been.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by voidfunc on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @06:08PM (#42505619)
Oh yea I was a big Republican when I was in high school because I went to a private school and all my friends were also Republicans (except the theater students). We were all Republicans because our parents were Republicans.

Then I got several years in the workforce and realized I wanted nothing to do with the Republican party.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by guelo on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:16PM (#42504173)
If you don't have decades of built up propaganda it's pretty easy to see that Israel is the bad guy. The condescending "it's complicated" line is part of the propaganda telling you that you're not allowed to come to the obvious conclusion for yourself. My 10 year has figured out that Russia is the bad guy in Ukraine and that Israel is the bad guy in Gaza.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by portaouflop on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:35PM (#42504309)
Must be nice if politics is just good and bad guys for you.

It should give you some pause that a 10 yo has the same level of understanding of global politics.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by speakfreely on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:04PM (#42504528)
Yes, it's pretty scary that anyone sees things so black and white and would encourage their children to do the same. These are multi-decade conflicts where no one has clean hands.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by guelo on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:10PM (#42504562)
10 year olds can figure out that killing children for 14 months is evil . That everyone can't see that is the power of propaganda.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by speakfreely on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:59PM (#42504861)
I suspect most parents would be prepared to risk the lives of strangers' children if it stopped their own from being killed.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by blitzar on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @05:54PM (#42505540)
Some of you may die, but it is a sacrifice I am willing to make.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by wruza on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @04:58PM (#42505232)
People know it’s evil, they are just unwilling to point it out because driving the conflict into some resolution is already hard without these simplistic views which helped no one before and continue to do so. Kid’s naivety is just that, naivety. Put him into a rulers chair (either side), provide all the factual info with zero propaganda and see him trying to escape at all costs, because all decisions including doing nothing make people die or worse. At some point you just have to choose sides without much meaning attached to it.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by ToucanLoucan on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @04:23PM (#42505024)
> Must be nice if politics is just good and bad guys for you.

Some politics are more complicated. Other politics are treated as more complicated because people get uncomfortable when you point out that they're casually endorsing-via-silence the mass murder of one group of people by another.

There's nothing complicated there. If you as a nation state or standing army are obliterating an opponent that can't fight back in a meaningful way, with lethal force, along an ethnic or racial line, that's a genocide. That's just what that is. The past year of desperate attempts by the West to re-frame it as something else have not been successful for exactly that reason.

And before you say it, no Palestine is not innocent. But unless I missed some pretty radical court proceedings in the UN, the punishment for their crimes as a state was not ruled to be "Israel gets to ethnically cleanse you" which is what is now happening.

> It should give you some pause that a 10 yo has the same level of understanding of global politics.

Kids aren't inherently stupid either. Kids have a lot of good questions to ask about our modern world and the fact that you don't have answers beyond "that's the way it always has been" both a) does not make that complete horseshit far more often than not, and b) does not make the question somehow lesser compared to you, irrespective of how many journey's around the sun they've taken.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by wruza on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @05:04PM (#42505256)
Good, what’s your plan of resolution?
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by ToucanLoucan on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @06:06PM (#42505609)
I answered you in the other comment, but my "resolution" would've been not carving out a chunk of a number of middle eastern former colonies and turning it into a Jewish ethnostate. But that's done now, and now Israelis have lived there for so long that simply "packing it up" and moving them elsewhere is now also, if not equally IMO, problematic as an action.

Israel is itself a project of the latter end of colonialism, and like many projects and side-effects and consequences of colonialism, we will be feeling it for hundreds if not thousands of years into the future. I don't know how you fix it, apart from letting Israel demolish Palestine, and all the human horror that comes with that.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by dghlsakjg on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @06:58PM (#42505869)
> I answered you in the other comment, but my "resolution" would've been not carving out a chunk of a number of middle eastern former colonies and turning it into a Jewish ethnostate. But that's done now, and now Israelis have lived there for so long that simply "packing it up" and moving them elsewhere is now also, if not equally IMO, problematic as an action.

That's a lot of words to say you have no resolution.

> I don't know how you fix it, apart from letting Israel demolish Palestine, and all the human horror that comes with that.

I see. Maybe you do have a resolution.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by SkipperCat on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @08:28PM (#42506219)
Israel is not the product of "the latter end of colonialism". It was the product of the Holocaust, which occurred just three years before its founding.

Should Europe have used Palestine for this purpose, that is debatable. But to lump it into the same colonial endeavors such as England's occupation of India or Belgium's occupation of the Congo just doesn't add up.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by pseudonamed on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @11:47PM (#42506901)
Complex entities such as states can be the product of many things.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by xcv123 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @11:53PM (#42506928)
That is an oversimplification of history

https://www.britannica.com/event/Balfour-Declaration

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by SkipperCat on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @01:23PM (#42510249)
Yes, there was a lot of factors, going back years before WWII, but I still believe that the aftermath of the Holocaust was major contributing factor to the creation of the State of Israel.

https://www.yadvashem.org/articles/academic/holocaust-factor...

The Holocaust created hundreds of thousands of European Jewish refugees and international sympathy which had an effect on the UN vote for statehood.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by ToucanLoucan on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @01:43PM (#42510358)
I don't take issue with the creation of Israel as a means to put all the displaced Jews somewhere. I take issue with that the land provided for this project was taken without the consent of any of the nations from which it was taken, which is colonialism and why it's impossible to separate Israel from the colonialist roots that helped create it. Just as it's impossible to not see it as an act of Western dominance towards the middle east to whom it was done. Like, there's no reason at all (apart from latent, extremely quiet antisemitism on the part of the Allied powers post WWII that they didn't want to discuss) that all those refugees couldn't have been subsumed into any of these countries, especially America, who at the time was boasting not only the only economy not obliterated by WWII, but also shit tons of open land. We could've absolutely made room for all the Jews that would be sent to colonize Israel (yes I chose that word on purpose).

However localizing it in an area none of them had any stake in was better politically, and yeah it meant pissing off basically every neighboring country to Israel, but that was also in line with the other priorities the West was holding: a strategic, permanent emplacement in the middle eastern region that would not ever oppose Western interests in any way, because it owed it's existence to the West.

It's a brilliant strategy overall as long as you ignore how it treated entire swaths of humanity as beneath consideration for what their own futures looked like, as long as those swaths of humanity were darker in complexion than yourself.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by tptacek on Thursday December 26, 2024 @12:18AM (#42513291)
The same thing happened to Jewish people in those "pissed off" surrounding countries, to the extent that a plurality of the Jewish population of Israel is of MENA origin (the "Mizrahim"). There is no simple history of the area, and nothing that will fit into an HN comment.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by SkipperCat on Thursday December 26, 2024 @03:13PM (#42517437)
"I take issue with that the land provided for this project was taken without the consent of any of the nations from which it was taken, which is colonialism and why it's impossible to separate Israel from the colonialist roots that helped create it"

Who was the land taken from? It was owned by the British from WWI to '48. Before that, it was owned by the Ottoman empire, before that it was an Egyptian kingdom and going further back it was the Roman empire. And at some point before that, it was Judea which was the land of the Jews. The Romans renamed Judea to "Palestine" to remove the connection of Jews to that land.

"Like, there's no reason at all (apart from latent, extremely quiet antisemitism on the part of the Allied powers post WWII that they didn't want to discuss) that all those refugees couldn't have been subsumed into any of these countries, especially America, who at the time was boasting not only the only economy not obliterated by WWII, but also shit tons of open land."

Israel was pretty empty too in 1948. There was enough room for the European refugees and the Palestinians. The 1948 partition was not the best for everyone, but it did give both Jews and Palestinians a new homeland, something neither had post Judea or anytime for the Palestinians.

A big reason for wanting their own land, was to provide a safe haven. Jews were doing very well in pre-Nazi Germany, and that changed quickly. The same could happen in the US too. There's historically been very few safe havens for Jews in Europe (And America is pretty much an extension of Europe).

I don't agree with your premise about colonialism or that Israel was created to be a bridgehead for western powers. But I do appreciate your writing and dialog on the matter.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by runarberg on Thursday December 26, 2024 @06:32PM (#42518707)
This is gross history revisionism.

Israel unilaterally declared independence following what was in essence a civil war in Mandatory Palestine. The UN had partitioned the territory but Israel took much more than had been allotted to them. Israel also illegally expelled many Palestinians and refuses them the right of return to this day, which they do counter to international law. In 1967 Israel expanded even further and took the remaining Palestinian territories which they occupy to this day in the world’s longest occupation. To this day, Israel keeps taking more land from Palestinians e.g. by setting up illegal “security corridors” or opening new illegal settlements.

So to answer the question. The land was taken from the Palestinians. And it keeps being taken from the Palestinians, in defiance of a number of UN resolutions, to whom the British had given the mandate to.

In an alternative universe where Israel wouldn’t be colonial, there would not have been a civil war, Israel would not have unilaterally declared independence, but done so in agreement with Palestinians, the UK and the UN. They wouldn’t have expelled any Palestinians, and they wouldn’t have maintained a policy of maintaining an ethnic majority. Jews would live now as a minority in Palestine, hopefully with some minority protections mandated by the UN (and probably demanded by the UK as part of the independence agreement).

In a slightly less alternative universe where the Zionist national project still happens and Israel unilaterally declares independence, at any time after 1948, in an effort to right previous colonial wrongs, Israel would offer the expelled Palestinians the right to return and reparations for their years or decades in exile. They would dismantle their ethnodemographic policies, and either integrate the occupied territories into a single democratic (non-apartheid) Israel-Palestine or recognize an Independent Palestine at the 1967 borders with some freedom of movement between the two states (similar to Ireland and Northern Ireland). For as long as non of this happens. Israel’s current policies are an unbroken link to their colonial past.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by SkipperCat on Friday December 27, 2024 @10:30AM (#42522903)
You are omitting that each of those events happened after the neighboring Arab states declared war on Israel. Israel won those wars. If they didn't, Israel would not exist.

Israel should get out of the West Bank, just like the way Israel exited Gaza. And I would like to see Palestinians flourish in both those areas. I'd even be happy to see Israel go back to pre-67 boundaries. But this will only happen when both sides desire to have peace and acknowledge their rights to exist. Sadly neither do.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by ToucanLoucan on Friday December 27, 2024 @11:41AM (#42523610)
Why the hell should the Palestinians even come to the table anymore? They have been mercilessly brutalized for decades. You're effectively saying that a home invader who has taken your living room, kitchen, dining room, and left you isolated to your bedroom and bathroom upstairs has just as much right to your home as you do, and you need to now come and negotiate to maintain access to your upper floor.

It's patently ridiculous. Do both sides aggress? Yes. But one side enjoys the strategic and financial backing of the West for their aggression, and one does not, and ergo, the conflict will never, EVER be on a level playing field. To go back to my own metaphor, the invader in your first floor has the backing of the police department. What are you going to do in this situation?

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by runarberg on Friday December 27, 2024 @11:57AM (#42523783)
I‘m not omitting anything. The neighboring Arab states invaded after Israel declared independence, and after many Palestinians had already been expelled from their homeland. The colonial act came first, and the invasion and wars were a reaction to that colonialism.

Also what Israel ought to do, is not what Israel is doing, and what Israel is doing, is pure colonialism, taken straight from the 19th century, genocides and everything.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by mhb on Monday December 30, 2024 @08:18PM (#42555427)
And all these Arab states were just supporting the poor "Palestinians", much like Hezbollah has for the past year. You're clueless.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by daseiner1 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @05:16PM (#42505327)
That is not at all the definition of genocide. Israel is not pursuing a strategy of indiscriminate killing. Hard to take anyone seriously making such good/evil distinctions, especially when the they are not reckoning with the evil of Hamas & co. beyond “well gee shucks Palestine ain’t perfect either yall!”

Only one side has the state md objective of “ethnic cleansing” and it’s not the Israelis

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by defrost on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @05:32PM (#42505423)
There's no shortage of material in print calling for the destruction of Gaza, the non personhood of Palestinians, etc. from Israel ministers and commentators from before the October attacks by Hamas.

You can, for example, look to the Journal of Genocide Research at articles that draw parallels between Holocaust scholar Eugene's Finkel's declaration of Ukraine as a genocidal event and his point by point justification and similar parallels with Israel and Gaza.

https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/14623528.2024.2...

There's no shortage of evidence of extremists in power on both sides calling for the destruction of the other.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by ToucanLoucan on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @05:54PM (#42505537)
> Israel is not pursuing a strategy of indiscriminate killing.

No they're pursuing a strategy of using intelligence and AI to strategically target "Hamas hideouts" which both conveniently for the state of Israel and in fact are often civilian structures, which result in tremendous "accidental" civilian casualties, which Israel is clearly incredibly broken up about as they continue causing them week after week.

In reply to both this and the other person who's asking for my solution: I don't know, because fighting insurgent forces in any area of the globe at virtually any time in human history has only rarely succeeded for the non-insurgent side, and universally that success came at the cost of numerous atrocities perpetrated against the insurgent forces and the civilians they hide amongst. The most powerful military on the planet tried this exact same thing in Iraq, and 2 decades and trillions of dollars later, we left the Taliban and ISIS billions of dollars in U.S. war materiel, and the state of Iraq such as it was was quickly overrun by those same forces which enjoyed at least some level of support among the civilians they were hiding with, probably because it's extremely easy, even if they don't think you give a shit about them, to explain to people that the other side shelling their cities to rubble every day are bad people that are trying to kill them. Shock of shocks, even civilians largely against the ideological positions of organizations like Hamas, end up more or less on their side, because again, the other side is Israel, who is actively killing them, accidentally or not making precious little difference to the people at the wrong end of their missile strikes.

I would say, with a grain of salt as I am not even remotely in this line of work, but I would say: when your enemy combatants are sheltered by a civilian population, do not possess a standing traditional army that would otherwise meet you on a field of battle, and are prepared to carry this out as long as your state is: then there is no solution, apart from killing everyone. The problem is the more civilians you kill in your quest to kill the combatants simply makes your combatants job of recruiting people to their cause even easier, because you killed their family in the previous bombing run. Ergo, the logical endpoint of this cycle is either returning to the stalemate that has persisted for decades now, where Hamas takes pot shots at Israel from neighborhoods, or the Israeli's just finishing the job and turning Palestine and what remains of her people into dust and corpses. Simply openly declaring that one state, Israel, and her people, have a greater right to exist than Palestine and her people do, and let that play out.

However, that is an ethnic cleansing, and IMO, still a heinous crime against humanity unless we're just going to plunk down some UN courts and say, once and for all, that a resistance movement fighting inside a besieged state is such an impossible strategic puzzle to solve, that it's okay to just obliterate the entire fucking thing. Which is an option, though I think it's a pretty horrific one.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by lm28469 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:16PM (#42504607)
Well he didn't have decades of propaganda but still roots for Israel... I didn't mention this subject there because I have better things to do with my time than ruin Christmas by talking politics with teenagers so I can't tell you where he got that from
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by speakfreely on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:01PM (#42504493)
> If you don't have decades of built up propaganda

But how are you so sure that doesn't apply to you?

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by guelo on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:08PM (#42504551)
I'm saying it doesn't apply to my 10 year old
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by speakfreely on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:57PM (#42504850)
Properly propagandized parents have no issue letting their perspectives flow to their children.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by TiredOfLife on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @06:27PM (#42505713)
Russia invaded Ukraine to kill civilians and Ukraine is fighting back. Conclussion - Russia bad, Ukraine good.

Palestine invaded Israel to kill civialians and Israel is fighting back. Conclussion - Israel bad, Palestine good. <= Something does not compute here.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by Muromec on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @07:55PM (#42506093)
That's a 40 year old pretending to be 5 year old, not a proper 13 year old zo
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by netsharc on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @09:05PM (#42506354)
If Ukraine's fighting back include indiscriminate bombing of the majority of Russian cities, cutting off their water and food supplies (letting Ukrainian civilians attack aide trucks), then, we'd have more equivalence in your ridiculously simplistic logic.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by daseiner1 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @05:17PM (#42505336)
It really is not beyond the reach of a motivated and curious 13 year old to have an informed opinion on (geo)politics.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by sangnoir on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @06:37PM (#42505775)
You don't gave to be particularly motivated to get predigested opinions from influencers. There's too damn many boys and young men echoing how the "Matrix" keeping them down
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by daseiner1 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @08:02PM (#42506120)
Sure, but that has little to do with age. To rephrase in terms of an older crowd, there’s too many damn 60+ year old men parroting what they hear on conservative AM talk radio. But there are, nevertheless, 60+ year old men with well informed and well considered opinions.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by sangnoir on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @09:39PM (#42506481)
Yes.

As you noted, the first[1] batch of mass-media "influencers" were AM Radio hosts, then came cable infotainment , and now vloggers.

1. Perhaps preceded by syndicated newspaper columnists, but there was an editorial filter for those.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by Tade0 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @07:58PM (#42506105)
It's normal for 13 year olds to have strong opinions on such topics - they have plenty of time to refine them or even change their mind.

I would be more worried about those who by this age didn't develop any interest in geopolitics - it affects them all the same but they typically don't understand why and pick whatever source tells a more compelling story.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by hollerith on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @08:01PM (#42506115)
When I was 13 (in the US in the 1970s) none of my classmates or friends ever expressed any interest in geopolitics or international relations.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by xxpor on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @08:36PM (#42506248)
No one had an opinion about Vietnam? I was 13 in 2003, plenty of people had an opinion about 9/11, civil liberties, and Iraq.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by hollerith on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @08:38PM (#42506254)
I don't recall any opinions about Vietnam and would probably have remembered if someone had expressed an opinion to me.

And the war or whatever we call the situation in Gaza would be something I'd want to shield my 13-year-old child from having any knowledge of if I were a parent -- for basically the same reason I'd want to shield them from learning about sadomasochistic sex as long as possible.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by Tade0 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @08:51PM (#42506298)
I guess it's part of growing up when there's no longer any living memory of war on your soil.

Anyway I need to ask the same question I always do in such conversations: what's the plan when this hypothetical child hits legal age and immediately receives the legal right to learn about all of this at once?

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by Sam713 on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @01:12PM (#42510157)
Just curious, why would you want to shield them from reality? At 13 they’re only a few years from becoming a full fledged adult. Unsheltered life is coming at them fast. I don’t have children yet, so maybe my perspective would change if I did, but (while I would not intentionally expose them to harsher realities) I would never shield my kids. Instead, I would want them to be curious and ask questions while I still had a large influence in their lives, so that I could help guide them and give them tools and strategies to navigate a complex world. I experienced a fairly sheltered (religious/conservative) upbringing socially, but we had a subscription to US News & World report during the height of the GWOT which I read cover to cover. I understood geopolitics before I understood how to make friends. My transition to adult life was tough socially, but I at least had a decent understanding of how the world worked on a macro scale. If children are not sheltered socially, then they’re already encountering pretty much everything through their social circles. And with the internet, 10x+ that.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by throwaway2037 on Thursday December 26, 2024 @01:33AM (#42513510)

    > I don't recall any opinions about Vietnam
It was constantly on the nightly news. The Vietnam War was one of the first widely filmed conflicts. Plus, there were regular violent protests against the draft. I find it hard to believe that the adults around you didn't have strong opinions about it. Did that not interest you or affect you?

I am bit younger, but I was exposed to the outfall of Vietnam through Hollywood films and documentaries.

    > the situation in Gaza
Your (hypothetical) 13-year old child is probably learning about it in their social studies class. Also: What age do you think German children begin to learn about the National Socialist/WW-2 era? I guess around 12-13 years old, and they turn out pretty well-adjusted to the world (in my humble opinion).
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by netsharc on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @08:55PM (#42506318)
That's probably the benefit of you not being 24/7 glued to the broadcast system called social media. I imagine in the 70s you spent your time mostly with friends in real life, and geopolitics was just 10 easily missable minutes on TV every evening.

Sure maybe there's a minority of kids with social media/smartphone bans nowadays, but they're probably as plentiful as 13 year olds interested in geopolitics in the 1970s.

I browse Instagram's TikTok clone ("Reels") when idle, it's rather dull, when that hurricane hit a few weeks ago, the stories were all about that, a few days later it was forgotten. Obviously, lately it's been about Luigi Mangione...

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by Tade0 on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @04:47AM (#42507930)
You don't need social media to be aware of what's going on in the world.

At 13 (early 2000ish) I was reading the newspapers my parents brought home and debated a friend of mine who in turn read his parents' newspapers - mutually exclusive sets from opposite ends of the political spectrum.

I need ask: when is the best moment to, as a parent, introduce a young person to the news cycle? You'll inevitably have to since they're on their way to become voters and taxpayers.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by mezzie2 on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @09:14AM (#42508863)
You don't even need newspapers or debates, sometimes existing leads children to politics. I'm a similar age to you, and social media didn't exist yet but I had political opinions.

My first independent political opinion (if we can expand politics to include techno/digital politics and not just national/state/local government politics) was formed at the age of 4/5. Just from reading discussions and arguments around me.

And, as a girl and a lesbian, I was starting to read ideological theory in part to cope with my life situation pretty early: I followed news about gay issues because I knew I was gay at 6/7 and it was clear that some people were okay with that and some were very much not and I needed to know the difference. Likewise with being female - the switch up in how I was treated by men when I crossed the pubescent threshold led me to seeking out books/works/discussions on feminism (as well as arguments against it). Suddenly, people cared a lot more about my body than they ever had before, and as an intellectual child, I wanted to understand what was going on.

I'd expect that's even more common now and extends to new groups of people. I know I've seen young men/teenage boys talk about how a lot of anti-male sentiment filters down and makes them feel terrible and also having to deal with their own switch in puberty where people go from feeling protective of them to scared of them.

A lot of politics and the news cycle has to do with domestic cultural issues, and many children are very aware of those by the time they reach 9 or 10.

International politics is something that a lot of adults don't engage with on any meaningful level, and conflating the news/political awareness solely with international military conflict would be an error, I think.

I think the best time to introduce children to politics and the news cycle is when they start asking questions about why the world is the way it is, or why different families/places do things differently than their own family or culture. Or when something political touches their life in a very personal way: e.g. the Japanese-American children being interned during WWII would have to be introduced to politics. This is going to vary by child; I don't think there is a hard and fast rule.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by throwaway2037 on Thursday December 26, 2024 @01:25AM (#42513496)
Most US-educated people take a class called "social studies" in middle school (grades 6-8). That will introduce them to the news cycle and geopolitics. Also, if there is an exciting political election in your early teens, many people become interested in politics at that age.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by RHSman2 on Thursday December 26, 2024 @03:16AM (#42513842)
The difference between me as a 13 yr old (1990) and my 13 yr old son now is we have a different dimension which is way more important. Critical thinking about sources of knowledge.

As a parent now, we ‘know’ more than ours did. Helping with guidance is our role!

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by hipadev23 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @01:21PM (#42503752)
online games aren’t the problem imo, it’s disposable identities and ~zero repercussions for bad actors.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by portaouflop on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:36PM (#42504322)
The remedy is far worse than the problem
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by hipadev23 on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @02:42PM (#42504367)
Yeah I don't know how you preserve much-needed anonymity, while also binding humans to their personas and holding them accountable for their actions.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by mrguyorama on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @03:23PM (#42504646)
Why do you believe anonymity is "much-needed"? Human society was built for tens of thousands of years on "stay away from Ben because he has a bad habit of not paying back what you loan him"

Anonymity is new and probably not something the human brain, which isn't meant to handle more than a few hundred familiar faces, can manage reasonably.

If you want anonymity 200 years ago, you had to print your own pamphlets and hand them out on the corner in a costume and hope nobody recognized you. Then you would go to church on sunday where the entire community would gossip about everyone's "sins" after the service.

Human history was radically more transparent about who was doing what, and who was saying what.

Nobody standing on a sop-box ever wore a mask, and while most used pseudonyms or pen names, there were only so many printing presses in the colonies, but that didn't stop the American rebels from spreading their claims.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by growse on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @04:03PM (#42504903)
The need for anonymity is in the face of enormously concentrated organised mass surveillance and power.

So, yes, it's relatively new. But it's not the only thing that's new.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by teddyh on Tuesday December 24, 2024 @10:49PM (#42506702)
Anonymity is, in fact, quite crucial to a surprisingly wide range of people: <https://geekfeminism.fandom.com/wiki/Who_is_harmed_by_a_%22R...>
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by Manuel_D on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @02:23AM (#42507470)
That page doesn't make a very compelling argument. Yes, bullying and harassment without an anonymous identity is potentially more damaging. But nowhere does it seem to consider that many of the bullies and harassers would only dare do so with an anonymous identity.

Which has the better culture? 4chan, or professional settings and churches? Non-anonymous settings almost universally have better culture because people's behavior has an impact on their social standing in their community.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by portaouflop on Wednesday December 25, 2024 @02:30AM (#42507489)
How do you define “better culture”?

I wouldn’t say you can compare churches and 4chan - one is an online activity with millions of people around the world joining; the other is a highly intimate affair conducted in a small community.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by Manuel_D on Thursday December 26, 2024 @06:56PM (#42518823)
Exactly: the fact that people aren't anonymous and their behavior affects their standing in the community is a big part of why anti-social behavior isn't nearly as common as in anonymous spaces.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by teddyh on Thursday December 26, 2024 @01:37PM (#42516860)
> But nowhere does it seem to consider that many of the bullies and harassers would only dare do so with an anonymous identity.

Have you seen Facebook? Anonymity does not, in any way, preclude horrible behavior and harassment.

Also, reducing the problem to “bullying and harassment” is frankly laughable, and gives rise to the suspicion that you at most only skimmed the page.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by Manuel_D on Thursday December 26, 2024 @02:11PM (#42517064)
I'm sure you can find cherry-picked pages of Facebook people acting out. Likewise, you can browse /r/LinkedInLunatics. But the vast majority of interactions on these platforms are better than on anonymous and pseudonymous platforms.

Anonymity and pseudonymity are big enablers of bad behavior, since it shields reputational harm that would normally be incurred by engaging in that behavior.

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by teddyh on Thursday December 26, 2024 @04:47PM (#42518102)
I mean, public flogging also (arguably) reduces crime, but we don’t want to have it, for good reasons. Disallowing anonymity has a lot of negative effects for all but a select privileged few, as documented by the link I gave.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by Manuel_D on Thursday December 26, 2024 @06:54PM (#42518812)
And again, I've read your link and found the arguments lacking. It doesn't consider the fact that much of the bad behavior it identifies is enabled by anonymity. I'm not sure how public flogging relates to anonymity. There are alternatives to public flogging, like incarceration. By comparison, the lack of accountability and lack of disincentive to engage in anti-social afforded by anonymity is inherent to anonymity. There's no way to get the same level of social responsibility in an anonymous space.
Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by teddyh on Thursday December 26, 2024 @09:43PM (#42519533)
> By comparison, the lack of accountability and lack of disincentive to engage in anti-social afforded by anonymity is inherent to anonymity.

Possibly. One could argue that the problem is not nearly as closely linked to anonymity as you argue it is, but even if it was, we would still need to have anonymity, including all its drawbacks, in order to make participating in the public sphere possible to all, instead of being restricted to a privileged few.

> There's no way to get the same level of social responsibility in an anonymous space.

You do know that this very forum qualifies an an anonymous space, right?

Re:More Men Are Addicted to the 'Crack Cocaine' of the Stock... by Manuel_D on Thursday December 26, 2024 @10:31PM (#42519733)
> but even if it was, we would still need to have anonymity, including all its drawbacks, in order to make participating in the public sphere possible to all, instead of being restricted to a privileged few.

You realize non-privileged people have participated in non-anonymous forums for ages. What on earth justifies the statement that without anonymity public discourse is impossible for non-privileged people? You realize that just because an article on geekfeminism.com claims something is true... doesn't actually make it true?

It's just a demonstrably false statement. Take, say, labor organizing. People who weren't privileged participated in the public sphere in a non-anonymous fashion. The Civil Rights movement was spearheaded by people who were de jure second class citizens. I could go on with example after example of people who weren't privileged participating in public discourse with their real identities. I'm truly at a loss as to how one can assert that anonymity is necessary to "make participating in the public sphere possible to all, instead of being restricted to a privileged few" in spite of the all the non-privileged people throughout history who participated in public discourse under their real identifies. It's objectively not necessary.

> You do know that this very forum qualifies an an anonymous space, right?

Correct. Which is why commenters are emboldened to say demonstrably false things, like claiming only privileged people are capable of participating in non-anonymous public discourse. I'm willing to bet that without the shield of anonymity people would actually think through such a statement and consider the number of non-privileged people that have participated in public discourse. They'd think twice before making patently false statements under their real identities.

But with anonymitiy, one's reputation isn't tarnished by making false statements. So here we are.