News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by UniverseHacker on Saturday December 21, 2024 @03:44AM (#42478302)
I don’t get the problem here. You can listen to whatever you want on Spotify. I listen to it everyday, already knowing what I want to listen to, and never encountered this. However, it sounds like they are paying real musicians to create music directly for Spotify, to bypass record labels. That sounds like a good thing all around- record labels don’t seem to do anything useful.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by tmountain on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:15AM (#42478455)
If they are paying musicians to create what is essentially “filler” and using this filler to lower their per song streaming costs, they’re simultaneously denying real artists, producing real music, an opportunity to appear in the stream. For listeners that care, this represents a reduction in the quality of their content, and aligns the platform towards pure profit, as opposed to being an ecosystem where working artists can try and carve out a living.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by throw646577 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:37AM (#42478574)
Exactly this. Musicians do not have a choice but to engage with Spotify, but any hope that the discovery systems it offers will occasionally playlist their work in return is being cynically -- and secretly -- diluted with slop.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:52AM (#42478640)
That only works if people, actual users, actively choose to listen to filler.

If they do, what is the issue?

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by rocqua on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:30AM (#42479058)
If the supermarket slowly adds more fat to their products, people will probably continue eating without noticing. But calling that an active decision is quite a reach.

Similarly, this isn't an active choice of users. And the harm isn't that they are listening to filler, it's that during their random listening, they aren't coming across any new good music. They are prevented from widening their horizons.

They aren't actively choosing this. Spotify deceives them into thinking this is music chosen because it is likely the users will like this music.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:56AM (#42479154)
> If the supermarket slowly adds more fat to their products, people will probably continue eating without noticing. But calling that an active decision is quite a reach.

What I buy in the supermarket is very much an active decision. I pay a premium on the bottles of milk because the ones I pick taste better than the supermarket branded ones. I do buy some things that are supermarket branded when I perceive the quality to be similar (or sometimes even better).

This might be different from consumers that due to budget limitations have to buy the cheapest things available, which is why food regulations are very important.

> And the harm isn't that they are listening to filler, it's that during their random listening, they aren't coming across any new good music. They are prevented from widening their horizons.

I presume that people that are actively listening to filler are not appreciating music in their cozy living room while sipping on a glass of fine whiskey.

They just want background noise while they drive, work, study. Something to make their hours more tolerable, or to improve their focus. Apparently the issue is that generic slop from Spotify serves that purpose just as well.

> They aren't actively choosing this.

If the music was bad for them, they would stop listening to it. They don't.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by rocqua on Saturday December 21, 2024 @09:54AM (#42480016)
> I presume that people that are actively listening to filler are not appreciating music in their cozy living room while sipping on a glass of fine whiskey.

That feels like a false dichotomy. Certainly for myself I can put on a generated playlist hoping to find new stuff I like, whilst still putting on the music as background. As filler.

If spotify has been serving me slop, then they have likely reduced the amount of new music I have added to my collection of things I like. That harms me, and it harms real artists whose music I might like.

In other words, I don't always actively choose the music I listen to. But serving me slop when I don't harms me.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @10:50AM (#42480318)
If you are listening to bullshit playlists Spotify generated, you are the problem. You are actively consuming turds, and now you are complaining that eating feces is bad for your health.

Instead of blaming the company that provided the turds, you should perhaps reconsider your habit of eating feces.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by rocqua on Saturday December 21, 2024 @11:13AM (#42480450)
Well measured and empathetic arguments.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @11:32AM (#42480551)
The language may have been harsh, but the message is not.

Why do you willingly give a company such as Spotify power over what music you listen to? There are better ways to discover new music if that's what you are after.

Try finding communities of people with similar tastes, sometimes they share their own curated playlists.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by rocqua on Saturday December 21, 2024 @01:54PM (#42481442)
I don't not care about music, but I don't want to put in effort. I can live my life without music, but I prefer having good music in my life.

Spotify suits my needs perfectly. Even if they do this fake music, it still works well enough. I doubt my half apathy is uncommon. The assumption of prevalence of this attitude is why this change by spotify is so damaging. It will harm my experience a little, and harms artists quite a bit.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by UniverseHacker on Saturday December 21, 2024 @05:38AM (#42478830)
Exactly- It seems pretentious to say it’s “filler” or not real music if people are happily listening to it, on a platform that provides any music you ask for.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @05:43AM (#42478856)
Maybe my stance is derived from the fact that I consider many of what is extremely successful in anything to be shit anyway. Music, movies, vídeogames, you name it.

People are fine consuming shit, they always were. Why would I be surprised that they are fine consuming shit music that Spotify add to slop playlists with the purpose of increasing their own profits? This is just a logical consequence of how things always were.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:03AM (#42478397)
"these almost identical tracks were attributed to different artists and composers" doesn't sound like real musicians making real music to me.

And honestly I don't want anyone making cheaper music directly for spotify. I want an even playing field where everyone gets the same rates. (But preferably with a way to kick out spammers.)

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by sandworm101 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:17AM (#42478462)
>> I want an even playing field where everyone gets the same rates.

So no freedom for artists that want to market themselves with higher or lower rates? Should the Taylor Swifts of the world not be free to negotiate higher rates? Should not the upstart be able to accept a lower rate in hopes that doing so will get their music more recommended/played by the service?

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by iamacyborg on Saturday December 21, 2024 @05:03AM (#42478682)
This is further complicated by how Spotify actually divvies up payments.

If they did it proportionally per subscriber you’d suddenly find money being distributed in a much fairer way.

Instead they divvy it up on a global aggregate basis so even if I were to pay the subscription and just listen to indie artists, my money goes towards pop megastars and artificial slop.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @05:11AM (#42478714)
This is the actual problem, and something that should be properly regulated.

I would hope that the money I paid, after the Spotify cut, went to the artists/labels that own the music I actually listen to, proportionally.

The fact that it goes to some Taylor Swift or Lady Gaga annoys me more than Spotify adding their own slop to slop playlists.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by lotsofpulp on Saturday December 21, 2024 @10:45AM (#42480286)
The proper regulation is copyright expiring after 10 years.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by iamacyborg on Saturday December 21, 2024 @11:47AM (#42480648)
I don't see how that does anything but fuck over artists and allow corporations to exploit them even further.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by lotsofpulp on Saturday December 21, 2024 @12:26PM (#42480921)
“Artists” are not a monolith. For example, music streaming services have to spend most of their money on artists that performed many decades ago, otherwise no one will buy it. This reduces spend available for new artists.

Excessive copyright terms go from incentivizing creating art to incentivizing rent seeking. Society also spends a ton more resources litigating disputes and avoiding them.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by iamacyborg on Saturday December 21, 2024 @12:42PM (#42481007)
This seems like an incredible naive way of thinking about how artists should be rewarded for their work.

> music streaming services have to spend most of their money on artists that performed many decades ago, otherwise no one will buy it

Music streaming services should spend their money on artists their customers are listening to, however old that music happens to be.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @12:51PM (#42481063)
> however old

Eh, I don't think there's a very convincing argument that the world is better off paying artists for things that were made more than 50 years ago.

(Yes I know the person above said 10, I think 10 is too aggressive.)

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by iamacyborg on Saturday December 21, 2024 @01:04PM (#42481121)
Probably depends on whether or not they’re still alive after whatever arbitrary time period and some other factors, sure
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @10:58AM (#42480374)
Correct.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by johnnyanmac on Friday December 27, 2024 @01:16AM (#42520287)
The original was 14+14. Given how life expectancy only increased, I fail to see anything lower passing in congress. Not that this is realistic to begin with.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by kazinator on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:25AM (#42478500)
Wouldn't the Taylor Swifts of the world get more money at the same rate, due to being streamed more?

The unknown upstart's stuff is not being searched for and played. Is that not already the lower rate that they accept? Does the revenue also have to be lower from those few plays they got?

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by lotsofpulp on Saturday December 21, 2024 @05:36AM (#42478821)
Theoretically, it does not have to be.

Practically, the big names are not going to accept less than the maximum they can get. Just like almost all people would if they were negotiating multiple equivalent job offers.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @12:45PM (#42481019)
For a radio-type service, I don't think anyone should be able to negotiate higher rates. I think there should be mandatory licensing.

For negotiating a lower rate... I wouldn't try to make it illegal, but I still don't like it. I have no particular reason to think it will be an upstart or an entity that you could say 'deserves' more attention. And taking less money for more exposure doesn't sound like something I want to encourage.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by Gud on Saturday December 21, 2024 @07:17PM (#42483422)
What if I want to give it away for free? How does that fit in your authoritarian distribution system?
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by Dylan16807 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @08:25PM (#42483747)
If you want to give your music away to people, that's great. This is just about the price to Spotify and services like it.

If you don't want the royalties from Spotify, you can do something like donate them to charity.

Giving Spotify a discount is something I'm not fond of, because you're either hoping they give you better placement which is basically payola, or you're getting nothing back so you're making a donation to a giant corporation.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by Gud on Sunday December 22, 2024 @05:36AM (#42485544)
But there is no "discount". There is just two parties agreeing to a price point.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by Dylan16807 on Sunday December 22, 2024 @04:47PM (#42489414)
If a big majority are the same price, I don't care what you want to call other prices. My point doesn't depend on what word we use.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by johnnyanmac on Friday December 27, 2024 @01:20AM (#42520295)
then you give it away for free. Where does spotify fit into this?

If this is a metaphor to "I want to work for free", then no. You technically can, but the company will get into trouble for allowing that. Same deal here. Personal projects on your own free time is different from a billion dollar company hiring interns "for exposure".

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by johnnyanmac on Friday December 27, 2024 @01:15AM (#42520283)
>no freedom for artists that want to market themselves with higher or lower rates?

like how it currently is if you're not some 7+ figure earner? Sure, why not? There was no marketing to Spotify to begin with.

> Should the Taylor Swifts of the world not be free to negotiate higher rates?

Debtable, but given that Taylor swift gets millions times more listens than the average artist, I'm not going to pretend she's somehow being ripped off here. Those kinds of people do indeed have the power to jump to another platform, or make their own.

>Should not the upstart be able to accept a lower rate in hopes that doing so will get their music more recommended/played by the service?

to be frank, no. Just like how some deperate would-be employee should not be able to accept below minimum wage to "kickstart their career". We made these laws precisely because "work for exposure" has failed spectacularly and only hurts the working class.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by lotsofpulp on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:19AM (#42478475)
> I want an even playing field where everyone gets the same rates.

The owners of Michael Jackson and Taylor Swift’s music are not going to agree to this deal.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by noelwelsh on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:00AM (#42478379)
It's a problem if Spotify is giving preference to its lower cost slop over other artists. If Spotify is going to be a marketplace for music it has to be a fair one.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by Propelloni on Saturday December 21, 2024 @03:57AM (#42478355)
Same here. I don't use Spotify as a radio (I have radio for that) but as a very big record collection. I listen to records or my own playlists. You can switch off the auto-play feature in the settings, so that Spotify stops after the record or playlist ends.

I learn about new music the old school way, opening and supporting acts at concerts and recommendations by friends. Sometimes I read a music magazine.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:03AM (#42478398)
Maybe I am old, but I am surprised people use Spotify any other way.

I think I never even clicked on anything on the app front page. I only ever go to library or playlist tab.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by jstummbillig on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:13AM (#42478441)
If you never click on anything of a front page, that's a good tell that you are exactly not the average user.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:28AM (#42478523)
If the average user is alright with consuming whatever Spotify puts on the app frontpage, I fail to see what the issue is.

They are being given what they are promised.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by UniverseHacker on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:27AM (#42478514)
This is also how I use it, but I am not even sure exactly how one would use it any other way. The whole UI is organized around “Your Library” which is a list of artists you like.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by keybored on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:01AM (#42478383)
It’s a problem if the algorithms are bad and try to nudge you towards slop (path of least resistance).

But I don’t really get the part about “someone should tell Congress”—sir, this is an IKEA.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by izacus on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:04AM (#42478403)
I bet they're pushinbg towards "slop" because they don't want to pay that much to the record label parasites which have been extorting a lot of money out of them.

And I think that's the core of the "problem" here - one group of rentseekers being angry at another because they don't get enough of their cut.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by keybored on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:08AM (#42478415)
Sure. Both Spotify and the Music Industry are just trying to maximize their profits.

The term “slop” is deliberate—music that sounds bad. Now, if Spotify manages to make music that is better than the music that they can get from the Music Industry? Good for them. I’m a music listener. I just want good music.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by tmountain on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:18AM (#42478469)
Then focus on brokering deals with the zillions of independent artists out there. I worked at Grooveshark (a long time ago), and this was a big part of our strategy, and it showed a lot of potential.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by izacus on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:45AM (#42478603)
Spotify already directly publishes plenty of independent artists as far as I know.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by darkwater on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:18AM (#42478468)
The problem is:

Step 1: create a music service and get on-board as many musicians as possible with attractive rates and the promise of a future with big audiences and less intermediaries

Step 2: the business grows because you have many famous/good artists in your catalogue

Step 3: Congrats, you are now the #1 musical service in the world! Many people associate "music streaming" with your brand. You get a lot of "musical normies" as customers in the process.

Step 4: start lowering royalties you give to musicians. They will stay anyway because you are the #1 brand and bring listeners

Step 5: add your own music to places where normies just listen to music, without caring who the hell the author is. So, you have to pay less revenue to the rest of artists, because they are now getting less listenings, even if the royalty per listening stays exactly the same.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by UniverseHacker on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:33AM (#42478548)
I get that is what they are doing, I still don’t see the problem. Hopefully they will gradually cut out the record labels entirely, and pay the artists the full cut directly that is currently going mostly to the record label.

People can listen to whatever they want- artists that are not being listened to aren’t being stolen from if the money is instead going to other artists that are being listened to. If people don’t care who the artist is but like what they hear, that seems great.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by rocqua on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:21AM (#42478997)
The problem is that their automatic song selection now chooses songs based on what earns them money. Rather than their best guess of what people want to hear. This isn't disintermediating the record labels. It's taking audiences from real artists, and placing it with artists that have given up their rights to royalties.

That isn't disintermediating recordlabels. That is just serving customers worse music. Heck, it is disintermediating artists from their audience.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by s6af7ygt on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:41AM (#42479102)
> That is just serving customers worse music.

There is no music monopoly and customers have a choice in which music they listen to and what service they use (Spotify, Apple, Google/Youtube, Amazon, Bandcamp, buying CDs).

Surely if users get served worse music, they will dislike it, and move to another service or another way to listen to music.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by rocqua on Saturday December 21, 2024 @09:58AM (#42480039)
How big (and noticeable) does the reduction in quality need to be. Especially because spotify is such an easy platform.

Changing to another streaming service requires learning a new app, moving over all playlists, and likely means still a pretty bad music suggestion service. Because spotify has a pretty good recommendation engine.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by pas on Saturday December 21, 2024 @02:45PM (#42481744)
> spotify is such an easy platform.

it's not for me. YT was. SoundCloud too. (Now SoundCloud also wants folks to sign in aggressively. I think you can't fast-forward otherwise, but at least listening works without signing in.)

Also ... you can upload to YT and SoundCloud, but not to Spotify. So their catalog is just meh. (So even if their recommendations are great in some genres, in general they are not for everyone.)

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by johnnyanmac on Friday December 27, 2024 @01:09AM (#42520260)
> There is no music monopoly

for now. Spotify is a market leader with 32%, though.

>if users get served worse music, they will dislike it

how many more twitters, facebooks, and youtubes do we need to show that this is not historically the case?

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by mingus88 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:42AM (#42479104)
> Hopefully they will gradually cut out the record labels entirely, and pay the artists the full cut directly that is currently going mostly to the record label

Ok stop it. This is too much.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by darkwater on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:40AM (#42478591)
The dominant platform might eventually cut out the labels and afterwards earn their margins.

That's why (I assume, I'm not in the music biz) labels stay relevant for now, because they act or sell themselves to artists as some kind of union to protect them from draconian streaming services. But I might be totally wrong on this.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by UniverseHacker on Saturday December 21, 2024 @05:45AM (#42478867)
Not too long ago music fans were pretty much all agreed the record labels were mostly rent seekers stealing from artists. It seems wild to me that people are now angry that music streaming services are disrupting that and paying artists directly based on actual listens.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by johnnyanmac on Friday December 27, 2024 @01:11AM (#42520268)
>paying artists directly based on actual listens.

that's very likely not the case. hence the issue.

Even if it was, keep in mind these are focused in Sweden. This model may only get worse if an american "label" tries this.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by throw646577 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:42AM (#42478598)
All labels are not the same.

Some really do function like unions: groups of artists sharing the functional/procedural/admin burden that comes with keeping their publishing as Saint Francis of Zappa advocated, or paying someone who cares (perhaps a small indie record shop owner) to do that for them as a side gig.

Some are little more than asset classes for private equity at this point.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by fastglass on Saturday December 21, 2024 @02:22PM (#42481603)
> If people don’t care who the artist is but like what they hear, that seems great.

the confidence made in this statement is jarring

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by johnnyanmac on Friday December 27, 2024 @12:13AM (#42520111)
>Hopefully they will gradually cut out the record labels entirely, and pay the artists the full cut directly that is currently going mostly to the record label.

nah, they will cut out the artist when they figure out how to AI generate this process. It's just begging to be automated.

> artists that are not being listened to aren’t being stolen from if the money is instead going to other artists that are being listened to

you see no conflict of interest with Spofity potentially paying specific "studios" to mass produce slop? The platform that has control over algoithms of what to listen to?

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by loupol on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:28AM (#42478524)
You've outlined the steps but not named the process outright : This is basically establishing a dominant platform and then abusing the dominant position that comes with it.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by wobfan on Sunday December 22, 2024 @02:43AM (#42484947)
i just hate capitalism. couldn't you just stop a #3?
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by whoitwas on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:29AM (#42478531)
I'm not a Spotify user, but people are really wild about it. The process is deceptive as Spotify has tried to hide this and pretend they serve music from "real" artists. It's enshitification. It used to be better, now Spotify is trying to squeeze out as much profit as possible.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by lotsofpulp on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:32AM (#42478544)
> now Spotify is trying to squeeze out as much profit as possible.

Not the worst idea for a business that has lost money every year for 20 years:

https://www.macrotrends.net/stocks/charts/SPOT/spotify-techn...

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by whoitwas on Saturday December 21, 2024 @05:44AM (#42478864)
They should try to profit. People seem to take issue with deception. They should just label the spotify songs as what they are and stop trying to trick people. It's weird and abusive.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by james-bcn on Saturday December 21, 2024 @04:33AM (#42478552)
If I have a playlist and I get Spotify to add to it, I expect it to add things that people who like the things that I like also like. I do not expect it to add whatever is most profitable for Spotify. Especially since I pay for the service.
Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @05:08AM (#42478701)
I have a few playlists on Spotify. I never had it add any track to it. Been using it for years.

Does it actually happen?

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by rocqua on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:25AM (#42479021)
You can enable it. Either through 'smart shuffle' or by looking at the suggested added songs. There is also 'song radio', discover weekly, and automated playlist based on mood or Genre.

I presume those playlists based on mood and Genre is what these songs have been added to.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by rented_mule on Saturday December 21, 2024 @08:57AM (#42479701)
How bad this is depends on the time-horizon over which they are trying to maximize profit.

If the time-horizon is the next listen, it's terrible, as it doesn't care if it revolts the user so badly that they leave the platform immediately. This is bad for the platform, too, so they won't do it for long.

If it's very long term, then it's not as bad because it takes into account users listening more often and over a longer period of time. One way of getting additional longer term listens is including signals like tastes of similar users and other things many of us music-lovers would consider "good". And the profit part means including signals like cost-per-stream of each song. A very long time-horizon requires finding good tradeoffs between all these signals.

My guess is the time-horizon is monthly to quarterly. This is because of market pressures (public markets demand quarterly results) and the practicality of measuring the results. You can't measure/improve infinite time-horizon optimization.

This will still have the effect of selecting for users that aren't as sensitive to what they are hearing. They will not leave as quickly. These are the users the platform wants, as these users afford the platform more leeway in shifting the tradeoff from quality signals to cost-per-stream. Eventually, this will push out many of us music-lovers and the artists we love. Once this reaches a tipping point, there will be room in the market for another service to cater to music-lovers. But, given market pressures, they will almost certainly walk the same path as Spotify in the long term.

For me, the implication is to own my own music. I always have and always will. I only use streaming platforms for discovery. But as soon as I decide I like something enough, I buy it. I almost always buy albums, not individual songs. That lets me see if I want to follow that artist more deeply. This is expensive and time-consuming relative to streaming. It's dirt cheap relative to what I get out of music.

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by mingus88 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:39AM (#42479096)
If you don’t actually respect the artist who is getting cloned and replaced by lazy/AI versions of their work without compensation, sure. No problem with this at all.

This enshittification of the streaming industry comes after decades of enshittification of radio (all clear channel owned in the U.S. now) and the total collapse of any revenue opportunities for making an album for a new artist.

It’s no wonder that the arts are dominated by nepo babies today. People who can treat creativity as an unpaid hobby, taking all risks with no consequences, and short cutting the path to popularity thanks to having family connections and wealth.

Taylor Swift had a rich daddy buy a record label for her. For everyone else, why bother?

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by surgical_fire on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:58AM (#42479161)
If an actual artist is being plagiarized, I would presume there are avenues for them to sue for that?

Is this actually happening, or is this just a baseless claim?

Re:The Ugly Truth About Spotify Is Finally Revealed by throw646577 on Saturday December 21, 2024 @06:04PM (#42483050)
> Taylor Swift had a rich daddy buy a record label for her. For everyone else, why bother?

Taylor Swift (an insanely hard-working artist) started gigging when she was like 12 or 13, and her dad invested in (didn't buy) a startup record label, that built up a roster of artists and did very well on its own terms. (Despite being attached to Toby Keith)

Record labels, publishing companies etc., do not cost much money to start up, actually. His investment was likely small, and also likely comparable to the cost of seeing a child through a college education. Less, perhaps.

A quick google suggests he got 3% ownership for perhaps as little as $130K, which indeed is comparable to the total cost of getting a child through higher education in the USA.

And of course her parents were helping her: she was 13. Did her dad make a pretty smart decision to ensure some influence over the people responsible for his daughter? Of course he did. You would.

More generally: hang around your local (proper) music scene sometimes, and pay attention to which young starter bands have helicopter parents, and which do not. And then try to correlate that with success. Pushy helicopter parents are very often an active disadvantage, because promoters hate working with them. And they are inherently uncool. Even -- perhaps especially -- when they used to be cool.