News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by JoshTriplett on Monday December 09, 2024 @07:44PM (#42372367)
The biggest reason I'm happy about this: while Starlink currently cooperates with local governments, that's not a technical limitation, and a flip of a switch would let every cell phone in a country have unfiltered connectivity. That's a powerful tool to have readily available, the next time an oppressive regime tries to prevent people from communicating and reporting.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by wahnfrieden on Monday December 09, 2024 @07:56PM (#42372454)
Musk has controlled access per political aims, and is also in close contact with Putin and US intelligence, so why do you feel this tech will be anti oppression?
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by typewithrhythm on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:12PM (#42372561)
Because it's something that didn't exist before that could be enabled.

Even if Musk only does it when it suits him it's still an overall improvement.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by carlosjobim on Monday December 09, 2024 @11:00PM (#42373599)
Starlink is providing internet for the Ukrainian government since the beginning of the war, which they gave away for free until the US government started paying for it.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by inemesitaffia on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @02:00AM (#42374495)
Iran and Venezuela
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Monday December 09, 2024 @07:50PM (#42372412)
Yes, North Koreans are clamoring to use this. /s

Things like this are paraded around as helpful for people in oppressive regimes when in reality they're more useful for building a bigger surveillance state in the West.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by menacingly on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:19PM (#42372613)
they seemed to enjoy the internet access in russia
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by jack_pp on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:22PM (#42372635)
Do we have evidence musk wants to help the state with surveillance? The real use case is having connectivity in remote areas imo
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by lxgr on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:31PM (#42373097)
I'm really a big fan of the technology, but even I have to admit that it can most likely be used for surveillance just as easily as it can be for providing legitimate cell service.

Cellular protocols have a very bad security track record, and this is built on the exact same standards.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by threeseed on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:24PM (#42372645)
SpaceX has been building a spy network for the US government for a while now:

https://www.reuters.com/technology/space/musks-spacex-is-bui...

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by jack_pp on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:31PM (#42372692)
Devil's advocate here but global spying isn't the same as surveillance state. For in country surveillance there's enough CCTV to not even need satellites
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by protocolture on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @04:32AM (#42375245)
Kind of is. All the five eyes have reciprocal agreements to trade data. If they cant legally watch you another nation probably can.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by kortilla on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:35PM (#42373130)
Spying on foreign countries for the US gov is not the same as spying on citizens of foreign countries and providing that information to their government
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by 2OEH8eoCRo0 on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @12:18PM (#42378877)
You don't need to want to. If you have the data you can be subpoenaed for it.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by BadHumans on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:25PM (#42372651)
Something tells me Musk is not going to be on the side you think he's going to be on in that scenario.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by kortilla on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:54PM (#42372856)
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by declan_roberts on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:13PM (#42372985)
He seems to be leaning pretty strongly antigovernment at the moment.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Jtsummers on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:19PM (#42373027)
No, he's leaning strongly anti-regulation, particularly those that impede his businesses. He's big on government because that's a major part of his revenue (DOD, NASA, and various TLAs). He's not big on the parts of government that slow him down or would cause his taxes to be higher for things he doesn't care about.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by lacy_tinpot on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:03PM (#42373293)
This is almost true.

The real story is that he's anti-anti-competition. His competitors in particular already have deep ties with the government and its various departments. Companies like Boeing, Lockheed, etc. have engaged in deep regulatory capture to prevent competition from emerging.

These already established corporations have a revolving door with the government and that's the real impediment. That's what he's against.

So while you're right about his self interests, I think it's important to clarify that the decades long entrenchment of these various incumbent corporations is why this is all happening in the first place.

That's the real reason.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by niceice on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:44PM (#42373184)
It's quite simply about efficiency.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Jtsummers on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:45PM (#42373186)
Yes, efficiency for his businesses and interests.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by niceice on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:34PM (#42373456)
A more efficient government helps everyone.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Jtsummers on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:59PM (#42373596)
In principle. But targeted "efficiency" improvements that aid Musk's interests selected by Musk are not necessarily going to help anyone but Musk.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Eisenstein on Monday December 09, 2024 @11:00PM (#42373603)
The reason for a lot of government inefficiency is checks and balances. If we did away with those it would be really efficient.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by LunaSea on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @02:01AM (#42374499)
Making Chinese EV cars more expensive seems less efficient as people will have to spend more money for the same commodity.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by MattPalmer1086 on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @04:45AM (#42375307)
No, a more efficient government would help those easiest to help, and not help those who were expensive or difficult to help.

Unless you just mean we could do exactly the same things, but more efficiently. But that is not what is meant; it means stopping doing a lot of things.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by pests on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:23PM (#42373402)
I recall he had to retool factories for the model 3 due to automating things before they were ready

Very efficient

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by wongarsu on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:21PM (#42373044)
Have I missed something? Last time I blinked he seemed to be looking at a pretty active role in the next US administration
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Jtsummers on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:32PM (#42373113)
His and Ramaswamy's roles will be advisory, and specifically targeting cutting government spending. This is not a pro-government thing except that they both have significant conflicts of interests which will influence which parts of government they suggest cutting and which they suggest leaving more or less intact.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by dools on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:47PM (#42373196)
Using regulatory capture to further your own economic interests is still pro government, it's just that it's a government aimed at meeting the needs of a very small number of oligarchs rather than the majority of the population.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by roamerz on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:48PM (#42373202)
>>which will influence

which <could> influence

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Eisenstein on Monday December 09, 2024 @11:02PM (#42373608)
Only if one is super human would it not.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Shalah on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:50PM (#42373221)
Musk said there are over four hundred federal agencies, that's more than the number of states.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by tverbeure on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:15PM (#42373362)
California has more agencies than the number of states of California!

Using the number of states as some yardstick makes zero sense: merging multiple current states into one wouldn’t make our society less complex.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Jtsummers on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:58PM (#42373272)
> Musk said there are over four hundred federal agencies, that's more than the number of states.

That's a silly way to weigh your decisions and valuations. "There are more than four hundred federal employees, that's more than the number of states."

The number of agencies is itself mostly irrelevant, it's their individual size, effectiveness, and appropriateness that matters. Do all of them need to exist? Almost certainly not. But do we need to cut it down to one per US state? That's an arbitrary and useless target.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Shalah on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:21PM (#42373391)
> But do we need to cut it down to one per US state?

I'm sure they could be reduced down to similar areas of operation. One of the first to be cut being The California High-Speed Rail Authority (CHSRA). Who has so-far spent 16 years building 119 miles of track at a cost of $14 billion. That's roughly $66,845 per yard.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Jtsummers on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:26PM (#42373417)
That's a state agency, outside of the scope of DOGE except that it receives some (probably a lot of) federal funding. If you want this to be a serious discussion don't suggest cutting agencies because of the total count of agencies or cutting state agencies in a discussion about federal agencies.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Shalah on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @05:34AM (#42375550)
How dare I post an opinion on a discussion forum /s
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by kortilla on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:31PM (#42373100)
The role is in killing off large parts of the federal govt
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by ulfw on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:16PM (#42373366)
He's literally part of the Trump government and isn't leaving his site for the last weeks. He hasn't been seen anywhere even near his own offices which he makes his employees go to.

How can you POSSIBLY state he is "strongly antigovernment"

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by 93po on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @08:41AM (#42376701)
> He hasn't been seen anywhere even near his own offices which he makes his employees go to.

uh, what do you base this on? it sort of seems like made up bullshit, especially because it's easily disproven by tracking his jet and seeing that it's visiting the locations of his offices in both california and austin frequently. there's even a video of him in one of his offices literally yesterday as he did a zoom meeting for WSJ.

i don't understand why people just blatantly lie like this

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by mschuster91 on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:28PM (#42372667)
Musk not, but the US government actually has powerful levers at its hand to force his cooperation if necessary. If all things fail, arrest him and nationalize his assets. It's not the first time someone who thought themselves to be above the law got eventually rear-ended by it - remember Al Capone, they got him on tax evasion in the end.

There are only three known entities to have bested the US government in many decades - Vietnam, Scientology and the Taliban. Musk is better advised that it's a foolish attempt to become the fourth one.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by catlifeonmars on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:33PM (#42372713)
What makes you think the US government will be on your side?
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Mountain_Skies on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:57PM (#42373260)
Many HN posters looooooooooooooooooooooooooooove techno-authoritarianism because they are under the delusion that as tech masters of the universe, they will always be in control of it, even being able to use it as a lever to get governments to do their will. Governments and other entities are eager to help them continue their delusion so the control monster will keep getting built into more and more powerful forms. When it is taken from the control of the techno-authoritarians who dream of crushing everyone who doesn't share their vision of utopia, they will be shocked but powerless to do anything about it. Too bad all of us, not just the techno-authoritarians, will end up paying the price.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by carlosjobim on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:55PM (#42373573)
Master of root on the computer, master of all mankind. That's why I demand the government ban all closed source software. Or they will feel my wrath.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by irjustin on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:58PM (#42373266)
> the US government actually has powerful levers at its hand to force his cooperation if necessary

The scenarios you put forth here are effectively not happening. This is not a communist+dictator state (where this is much easier) nor does one branch have the power to unilaterally decide this.

The only time nationalization of a private service should happen in our country is wartime, specifically WWIII has to happen and on US soil. WW2 never saw this, nor did it need to.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @11:03AM (#42378098)
> This is not a communist+dictator state (where this is much easier) nor does one branch have the power to unilaterally decide this.

The Supreme Court practically gave the President full immunity as long as they are in office, Congress is gridlocked and governing has happened mostly through executive orders for decades now.

Assuming a President (and no matter who it is) gives the orders, they will get executed as given - and any kind of protest will be dealt with in the courts, in a process that will likely take years.

> The only time nationalization of a private service should happen in our country is wartime

The US has been at war for the utter majority of the last decades. Vietnam, Libya 1, Iraq 1, Balkans, Afghanistan, Iraq 2, Libya 2, Yemen, and that's just the major ones where the US were an active combattant.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by deadbabe on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:46PM (#42372797)
What if Musk becomes a Scientologist?
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by adolph on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:44PM (#42373182)
Mars does have the largest known volcano in the solar system.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Teever on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:34PM (#42372714)
You may not have heard the news but but Musk is the government now.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by onetokeoverthe on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:55PM (#42373240)
Advisory is not IN.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by techdragon on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:23PM (#42373404)
Advisors can be in government… if it’s a government department even an advisory one, it’s part of government… and thus its employees are in government.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Jtsummers on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:30PM (#42373435)
Except in this case it's a department in name only, it is not an actual part of the US government.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by techdragon on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:48PM (#42373531)
It’s currently just in name only. But that is likely to change soon in some form yet to be revealed when the new government is sworn in.

So legally it isn’t in government yet, however as it is officially part of the elected governments plans, you can make a sensible argument that it is part of the incoming transitional government that has been elected and while having now power due to not being sworn in yet, is indeed part of government by nature transition teams and the president elect having status in government by way of things like security briefings and other rights and privileges normally only held by the incumbent government like increased security protection…

It would be like saying a government in exile (a well established precedent of history) isn’t a government and none of the people in it are in government…

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Jtsummers on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:59PM (#42373592)
It is not going to become an actual part of the federal government, as a new agency, unless Congress makes it an agency. And if they do, then Musk likely would not make the transition to head it as that would involve too many conflicts of interest for him (at least if we still consider laws as things that matter in this country, that is definitely a concept that's quickly being discarded by both the elected leadership and the electorate so you may be right).
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by techdragon on Monday December 09, 2024 @11:11PM (#42373656)
Ok, I’m really not sure why the simple answer isn’t getting across here.

His position as co-head of the nominal “department of government efficiency” only exists due to the legitimacy it has been granted by the recognition granted to it by the incoming administration… otherwise we would all be calling it some variety of the first buddy’s pet think tank and arguing over if the incoming administration would even pay attention to it or not… that is a government granted position of power, a position that it is pretty hard to argue is not part of the government that grants it legitimacy… therefore making it a position in government… even if it’s unpaid and advisory… it’s still practically in the government if not legally (for all the conflict of interest reasons you highlight)…

I’m not trying to make a civics or political science case here… I’m talking politics as the exercise of power by government upon the governed… he is currently having breakfast lunch and dinner with the incoming president, making arguments and shaping the cabinet, and contributing to the transition team… he’s involved with government… he’s “in” it.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by LunaSea on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @02:02AM (#42374505)
Conflicts of interest didn't seem to bother the President elect.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by onetokeoverthe on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:30PM (#42373439)
Yes, in THIS case, it is JUST advisory.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by aguaviva on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @11:50AM (#42389753)
Musk is better advised that it's a foolish attempt to become the fourth one.

Instead he managed to pull off a trick that not even Capone and Scientology were bold enough to try.

He became the government.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by bdangubic on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @11:54AM (#42389797)
becoming the government has an expiration date (with post-expiration date consequences which for him will be severe).

boldness or foolishness to become government we shall see…

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by threeseed on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:29PM (#42372673)
Starlink needs to interface with a local operator which you as an end user need to have an account with.

So a government could easily block this.

Also the bandwidth is too limited to allow every cell phone in a country to have access.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by lxgr on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:29PM (#42373086)
They don't technically need to do that – that's only necessary because they don't have any spectrum themselves, nor the required telecommunication service licenses.

I guess GP is alluding to the fact that they might choose to just ignore these facts in some cases.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by JoshTriplett on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @05:11AM (#42375436)
Precisely. They've already talked about the capability to relay satellite-to-satellite, rather than relying on a ground station near the user.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by cronycapitalism on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:10PM (#42372964)
Provided Musk sees a positive ROI to flexing that particular muscle, of course
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by lxgr on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:27PM (#42373073)
It would also be a blatant violation of international law and set a precedent for all kinds of undesirable things.

Would you enjoy waking up to propaganda blasted to your phone as a non-silence-able "Presidential Alert" in retaliation?

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by inemesitaffia on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @02:00AM (#42374489)
Starlink in Iran and Venezuela
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by lxgr on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @08:50AM (#42376775)
Does it really work in Iran? That would be a US embargo violation on top of an international law one, right?

I suppose they could make the case that it’s technically infeasible to limit their satellite beam footprints that granularly (like it used to be the case for non-spotbeam services), and that their service limitation works on the basis of billing addresses, not physical cells – except that they seem to be very capable of enforcing that to distinguish mobile from stationary plans, and ocean from land areas.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by inemesitaffia on Sunday December 15, 2024 @12:16PM (#42424563)
Yes. They've lost at least two lawsuits at the ITU.

The US has granted SpaceX a sanctions waiver.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by dogma1138 on Sunday December 15, 2024 @12:50AM (#42421763)
Which international law this violates?

People spew this international law nonsense too much. If there is convention that has been signed and ratified by member states there is no law….

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by protocolture on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:10PM (#42373339)
It is a technical limitation lmao. The internet is still down here. Starlink is a network managed by humans who live on planet earth. And the starlink constellation is constantly replacing satellites lost to attrition.

Lets say he flipped that switch, anywhere else but the US. They would: Ban Starlink devices for the sake of it. Block / Filter Starlink IP Addresses. Shut down Starlink ground stations, and tear up telco licenses of anyone who does business with them. Reallocate the frequencies Starlink pays to broadcast on, likely heavily deteriorating the service. Arrest anyone affiliated with Starlink in country.

If they did it in seppoland they could go one better and just prevent new satellite launches.

Heck, he shut down starlink in Ukraine because he is on board with Putin.

You arent magically free of earthbound constraints, you just have a new one, Musk.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by secondary_op on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @05:05AM (#42375420)
Gosh you delusional or brainwashed on "rule based world order", where "cooperating with local government" in your statement in reality means "while foreign government behaves like our vassals and country is our colony".

What this tool allows US state is to circumvent foreigns government sovereignty and ultimately, directly guide people through communication channels via psychological operations.

By inverse(contradiction), observe what happens with TikTok, Huawei or "Chinese ballons" within US borders.