News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by mschuster91 on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:28PM (#42372667)
Musk not, but the US government actually has powerful levers at its hand to force his cooperation if necessary. If all things fail, arrest him and nationalize his assets. It's not the first time someone who thought themselves to be above the law got eventually rear-ended by it - remember Al Capone, they got him on tax evasion in the end.

There are only three known entities to have bested the US government in many decades - Vietnam, Scientology and the Taliban. Musk is better advised that it's a foolish attempt to become the fourth one.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by catlifeonmars on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:33PM (#42372713)
What makes you think the US government will be on your side?
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Mountain_Skies on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:57PM (#42373260)
Many HN posters looooooooooooooooooooooooooooove techno-authoritarianism because they are under the delusion that as tech masters of the universe, they will always be in control of it, even being able to use it as a lever to get governments to do their will. Governments and other entities are eager to help them continue their delusion so the control monster will keep getting built into more and more powerful forms. When it is taken from the control of the techno-authoritarians who dream of crushing everyone who doesn't share their vision of utopia, they will be shocked but powerless to do anything about it. Too bad all of us, not just the techno-authoritarians, will end up paying the price.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by carlosjobim on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:55PM (#42373573)
Master of root on the computer, master of all mankind. That's why I demand the government ban all closed source software. Or they will feel my wrath.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by irjustin on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:58PM (#42373266)
> the US government actually has powerful levers at its hand to force his cooperation if necessary

The scenarios you put forth here are effectively not happening. This is not a communist+dictator state (where this is much easier) nor does one branch have the power to unilaterally decide this.

The only time nationalization of a private service should happen in our country is wartime, specifically WWIII has to happen and on US soil. WW2 never saw this, nor did it need to.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by mschuster91 on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @11:03AM (#42378098)
> This is not a communist+dictator state (where this is much easier) nor does one branch have the power to unilaterally decide this.

The Supreme Court practically gave the President full immunity as long as they are in office, Congress is gridlocked and governing has happened mostly through executive orders for decades now.

Assuming a President (and no matter who it is) gives the orders, they will get executed as given - and any kind of protest will be dealt with in the courts, in a process that will likely take years.

> The only time nationalization of a private service should happen in our country is wartime

The US has been at war for the utter majority of the last decades. Vietnam, Libya 1, Iraq 1, Balkans, Afghanistan, Iraq 2, Libya 2, Yemen, and that's just the major ones where the US were an active combattant.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by deadbabe on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:46PM (#42372797)
What if Musk becomes a Scientologist?
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by adolph on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:44PM (#42373182)
Mars does have the largest known volcano in the solar system.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Teever on Monday December 09, 2024 @08:34PM (#42372714)
You may not have heard the news but but Musk is the government now.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by onetokeoverthe on Monday December 09, 2024 @09:55PM (#42373240)
Advisory is not IN.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by techdragon on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:23PM (#42373404)
Advisors can be in government… if it’s a government department even an advisory one, it’s part of government… and thus its employees are in government.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Jtsummers on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:30PM (#42373435)
Except in this case it's a department in name only, it is not an actual part of the US government.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by techdragon on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:48PM (#42373531)
It’s currently just in name only. But that is likely to change soon in some form yet to be revealed when the new government is sworn in.

So legally it isn’t in government yet, however as it is officially part of the elected governments plans, you can make a sensible argument that it is part of the incoming transitional government that has been elected and while having now power due to not being sworn in yet, is indeed part of government by nature transition teams and the president elect having status in government by way of things like security briefings and other rights and privileges normally only held by the incumbent government like increased security protection…

It would be like saying a government in exile (a well established precedent of history) isn’t a government and none of the people in it are in government…

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by Jtsummers on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:59PM (#42373592)
It is not going to become an actual part of the federal government, as a new agency, unless Congress makes it an agency. And if they do, then Musk likely would not make the transition to head it as that would involve too many conflicts of interest for him (at least if we still consider laws as things that matter in this country, that is definitely a concept that's quickly being discarded by both the elected leadership and the electorate so you may be right).
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by techdragon on Monday December 09, 2024 @11:11PM (#42373656)
Ok, I’m really not sure why the simple answer isn’t getting across here.

His position as co-head of the nominal “department of government efficiency” only exists due to the legitimacy it has been granted by the recognition granted to it by the incoming administration… otherwise we would all be calling it some variety of the first buddy’s pet think tank and arguing over if the incoming administration would even pay attention to it or not… that is a government granted position of power, a position that it is pretty hard to argue is not part of the government that grants it legitimacy… therefore making it a position in government… even if it’s unpaid and advisory… it’s still practically in the government if not legally (for all the conflict of interest reasons you highlight)…

I’m not trying to make a civics or political science case here… I’m talking politics as the exercise of power by government upon the governed… he is currently having breakfast lunch and dinner with the incoming president, making arguments and shaping the cabinet, and contributing to the transition team… he’s involved with government… he’s “in” it.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by LunaSea on Tuesday December 10, 2024 @02:02AM (#42374505)
Conflicts of interest didn't seem to bother the President elect.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by onetokeoverthe on Monday December 09, 2024 @10:30PM (#42373439)
Yes, in THIS case, it is JUST advisory.
Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by aguaviva on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @11:50AM (#42389753)
Musk is better advised that it's a foolish attempt to become the fourth one.

Instead he managed to pull off a trick that not even Capone and Scientology were bold enough to try.

He became the government.

Re:Starlink's first constellation of direct-to-phone satelli... by bdangubic on Wednesday December 11, 2024 @11:54AM (#42389797)
becoming the government has an expiration date (with post-expiration date consequences which for him will be severe).

boldness or foolishness to become government we shall see…