News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by thombles on Friday November 29, 2024 @02:52AM (#42271856)
As an Australian parent this is really pleasing to see. It's clearly inspired heavily by the work of Jon Haidt and Jean Twenge et al. The kids are not okay and the main thing stopping a worried parent from addressing it is that "all the other kids are on it". If you have an addicted/bullied child would you make them a social pariah and create interminable arguments by taking away their devices? Collective action is needed and this is what it looks like.

We don't need watertight compliance, verification or enforcement - just raise the level of difficulty for kids to get on and create a culture among kids, parents and schools that social media is not allowed. This will be enough breathing room for parents to say no and kids not to feel like they're the only ones missing out.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by bigstrat2003 on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:38AM (#42272154)
> If you have an addicted/bullied child would you make them a social pariah and create interminable arguments by taking away their devices?

Yes. That is literally your job as the parent. If there was some teenage trend of injecting heroin, nobody would accept "but my kid's social life might suffer" as a reason to not stop them from doing heroin. It similarly does not suffice as a reason to not stop your kids from using social media. If it really is that bad for your kids, you have a duty to stop them regardless of what other kids (and their parents) do.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by neumann on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:58AM (#42272312)
Yes, but because the entire world agrees that heroin is bad (similarly to social media) governments have laws to restrict its access.

As for the job part. There is so much stuff kids don't need that other parents cave into, that unless you have the means, willpower and energy to find alternative peer groups, schools, teaching mechanisms, your kids _can_ become social pariahs if there isn't sufficient like minded parents in the community.

Of course your kids to internalise self-worth and a sense of confidence and independence and hope they follow your mold and not a potentially damaging peer-groups. But that doesn't mean that some regulation from a body (government/school) isn't helpful. We live in communities.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by rnl82 on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:09AM (#42272375)
Being a parent is not easy, and fights like these are really difficult. As a human you have only so much fight in you, and if a majority of parents adhere to the same rules this becomes so much easier to enforce.

Government rules set the moral bar, yes they are not enforceable but it creates a standard that most parents will adhere to.

As a dutch parent i wish we had the same rules, my kids are young enough that its easy to ban social media, but its getting harder as they are slowly becoming teenager.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by bill_joy_fanboy on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:11AM (#42272394)
It is definitely a parent's job to say "no" to degeneracy.

Saying "no" is easier when your child isn't offered a buffet of degeneracy by the outside world.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by matwood on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:52AM (#42272276)
If every kid was injecting heroin we would not just expect, but demand the government step in. This is in addition to whatever parents are doing.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by theteapot on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:02AM (#42272343)
So true. In addition, if every kid suddenly became a vampire, we would not just expect, but demand the government step in.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by partomniscient on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:24AM (#42272487)
Not only that, at some point the vampires will form a government for vampires which will be at odds and at war with the non-government vampire and there will be individual vampires that disagree with and feel a lack of representation from their vampire government.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by triceratops on Friday November 29, 2024 @10:49AM (#42274644)
Well...yeah. How would be scrounge up enough blood to keep them fed otherwise?
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by t0bia_s on Friday November 29, 2024 @01:22PM (#42275844)
Wouldn't be better to educate children about deadly consequences of using heroin and what does it makes to your body? Noone is learn from ban, and enforcement of regulation also cost much more money.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by tene80i on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:56AM (#42272297)
The point is clearly that you are causing other serious harms by doing so, unlike with the heroin example. You can’t tear kids away from a huge part of their social lives without serious consequences. Coordinated action means it’s not a choice between two terrible options.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by rightbyte on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:38AM (#42272573)
Social media is not social anymore. The algorithmic feeds messed up almost all utility.

Facebook was a great platform for local communities and democracy but later turned into a threat to civilization more or less when they introduced the 'algo' 2010 something and wanted to get money for 'promoted posts'.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by pulse7 on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:57AM (#42272303)
As a parent I literally support bans of social media for under-16s AND I also do my job as a parent: my kids get a smart phone at 16, until then they have a feature/dummy phone (which they hide from peers because they are ashamed to show it).
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by sandos on Friday November 29, 2024 @05:12AM (#42272744)
Not having a smartphone would make my kids "social pariahs" for sure.

We gave them phones fairly early, but locked down. It was not really a huge problem when they were younger, but social media (no, we shouldnt even call it is, its is 110% ADS FOR CHILREN!) is getting to be a real problem now I feel.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by t0bia_s on Friday November 29, 2024 @01:19PM (#42275816)
Why dont you use any kind of adblock? Why don't you speak with them about harmful consequences of algorithms? Instead of ban that noone learn from, communicate issues.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by InDubioProRubio on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:03AM (#42272352)
And as a parent that duty can be outsourced into legislation and policework. Everyone has a fulltime job- and its okay to limit liberties and delegate.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by abc123abc123 on Friday November 29, 2024 @10:36AM (#42274540)
Pro tip! If that is how you feel, don't have children. Wanting to outsource your childs upbringing to the government because it is "annoying" or "hard work" indicates that you are not ready to have a child.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by bigfatkitten on Saturday November 30, 2024 @06:21PM (#42284799)
If a parent forms that view, they should call Child and Youth Protection Services or the equivalent in their state, and offer to delegate the rest of the parenting to the state.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by jjav on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:20AM (#42272454)
> > by taking away their devices

> That is literally your job as the parent.

Tell me you're not a parent without telling me you're not a parent!

This only works if there is broad support from the entire social group, meaning school and all (or most) of the other parents. If you try this all alone, all you can accomplish is to apply more suffering to your poor child.

For us, here in silicon valley, fortunately that broad support existed in elementary school. Not a single kid had a phone, so it was the norm.

In middle school the support is still broad, although less absolute. A few kids have phones, but they are outliers, so it's still normal not to have one.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by chris_wot on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:25AM (#42272490)
I am a parent. That literally is your job.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by bigfatkitten on Saturday November 30, 2024 @04:17PM (#42284108)
> This only works if there is broad support from the entire social group, meaning school and all (or most) of the other parents.

Which there won't be. Most of these kids have "social media" accounts because their parents allowed it.

To be clear, "social media" for the purposes of this legislation is a VERY broad term that encompasses any almost platform that allows one user to communicate with another.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by thombles on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:28AM (#42272517)
According the stats in Haidt's book, between 2010 and 2020 girls in the US saw a 188% increase in emergency room visits for self harm per capita - never mind the less extreme presentations of mental health issues. Imagine you have an anxious, depressed and potentially suicidal child. This is a horrifying situation. How do you feel about being the hard-arse parent knowing that they will be furious? Is that actually your best move in that moment? Wouldn't it be nice if you didn't have to make that kind of choice?
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by triceratops on Friday November 29, 2024 @10:47AM (#42274629)
> If there was some teenage trend of injecting heroin, nobody would accept "but my kid's social life might suffer" as a reason to not stop them from doing heroin.

You know that's actually one of the reasons they made heroin illegal? So parents wouldn't be the bad guy when they stopped their kids from shooting up /s

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by noufalibrahim on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:03AM (#42271915)
As a non Australian parent, I quite envy you.

Parents are almost as addicted as children and often take dozens of photos of every tiny event and post it on IG without permission of other children who are there in the pictures. Many kids have their own channels which are promoted by parents and their identities are based around them. I do what I can (don't give them devices till they're 18 etc.) but it's hard when the whole society around you is pushing the other way. Some kind of societal regulation like what's happened in Australia will be a good thing. It will add friction to kids getting onto these platforms and that will significantly slow down adoption.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by rightbyte on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:49AM (#42272632)
> Many kids have their own channels which are promoted by parents and their identities are based around them.

What kind of sociatal cast do they belong to? I'd imagine this is mainly a thing among wannabe elite, wannabe 'influencers'? Like failed pro sports parent forcing their children to go for it to.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by GoblinSlayer on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:41AM (#42272173)
My nephew is denied a smartphone due to low grades. Seems like a good enough excuse. Granted, it can work only if your country allows low grades.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by trogdor on Friday November 29, 2024 @11:21AM (#42274868)
What countries don’t allow low grades?
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by justsee on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:18AM (#42272439)
It's very hard not to see the whole marketing of the legislation as an exercise in misdirection.

The media campaign was led by Rupert Murdoch's News Ltd (who see a commercial opportunity in cutting a demographic from their competitors audience for advertisers), and the government's marketing of it entirely focused on children being restricted, avoiding until the last weeks an admission it actually meant all adults would have to undertake verification processes to use social media.

The gulf between the practical effect of the legislation (all adults are impacted) and the claimed intent (only children under 16 are the focus), is so large the claims shouldn't really be accepted at face value.

Combine that with the abuse of democratic process: what would usually be weeks of public feedback was shortened to 24 hours, and after passing the lower house the government attempted to force the legislation through in the senate with no debate, finally conceding to a brief 1 hour debate before passing it in the final hours of the last sitting day of the year.

When opposition arose earlier in the week to the idea this is about a backdoor mechanism to force the government's recently rebranded myId (from myGovId), the government hastily made changes to the bill and loudly said social media companies would not be allowed to ask for government id, in physical or digital form.

But that itself was misdirection. A clause was added saying this does not apply if an alternative option is also provided.

But age assurance based on biometrics from webcams has poor accuracy, as one senator argued in the final debate. Fresh-faced youths will have no option but to go for the myID solution on their 16th birthday - which as that same senator pointed out is the age at which you can apply for a myID account.

On the topic of digital id and myID: it was also apparent that the Government seemingly feigned ignorance that this system, designed specifically for this purpose, would be the ideal and primary solution.

Yet we know just how much focus and energy has been going into designing these systems and working out how to get the public to accept them: witness this piece from 2018 [1].

It's of course fine to argue pros and cons of digital id, both philosophically, and in terms of specific implementation details, but that's not what happened here.

Everything clearly indicates the legislation was designed to sidestep any substantial debates on this topic.

What was also sidestepped was any reasonable discussion of specific implementation options. Instead we have vague details of an age assurance trial being run for many more months, with no specifics that help us understand how this legislation may work, or fail to work.

[1] https://www.aspi.org.au/report/preventing-another-australia-...

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by bdzr on Friday November 29, 2024 @11:02AM (#42274733)
But didn't you know that social media is causing all of the problems we have right now? Haven't you seen the graph that shows society with no problems until social media, and now we have all the problems?
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by 71bw on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:04AM (#42271921)
> If you have an addicted/bullied child would you make them a social pariah and create interminable arguments by taking away their devices?

They'd be addicted/bullied regardless?

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by throwawaythekey on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:38AM (#42272161)
Are these same parents unable to tell their children "no you can't stay out late it's a school night"
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by cchi_co on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:40AM (#42272169)
This perspective highlights a key aspect often overlooked in debates about such laws: the social dynamics of parenting. You’re absolutely right that the “all the other kids are on it” pressure can make it almost impossible for individual parents to set boundaries without isolating their child
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by XorNot on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:50AM (#42272254)
But all the other kids will simply be on the next thing. They're on social media because that's accessible, but the assumption is the demand for such things will vanish because you banned them?

I'm (apparently) one of the few millenials who seems to actually remember and empathize with my teenage self, because the early forms of social media were something I really wanted. I posted on Usenet, used ICQ etc. None of these things were easily accessible, but they fulfilled a need.

The situation being addressed is basically "I am taking no steps to limit my child from access to something I already disapprove of" and I don't see how this would address anything. You got them off Snapchat or TikTok but why wouldn't word of mouth just find a new service to act as a virtual third space? Social media works just fine in a web browser.

Basically there's a strain of assumption which could be summarized as "children aren't smart enough to use Mastodon!" as though to do so is not just "visit this URL here's the QR code".

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by neumann on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:02AM (#42272335)
It's a lowest energy state approach. The hope is that the hurdle will be raised high enough that enough kids will go to another outlet that is less harmful.

Personally, I think the cat is out of the bag. The information dense but fractured culture we are in makes it so kids will find otherways to communicate and share 'memes' (original sense of the world) and that this is whack-a-mole.

But, for many kids it will be enough to at least allow the parent's some appeal to authority to minimise their kids screen time and access to social media.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by dmalik on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:02AM (#42272333)
The internet still exists outside of social media sites designed to keep you there. I hope kids under 16 get addicted to anything else and don't turn to social media when they're old enough.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by cchi_co on Friday December 06, 2024 @03:03AM (#42337499)
Do you think the focus should shift more toward education and digital literacy rather than trying to ban or limit?
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by trhway on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:56AM (#42272298)
>We don't need watertight compliance, verification or enforcement

the law basically requires document verification, i.e. no anonymous access anymore for anybody. Just government protecting children, as usual.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by chris_wot on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:41AM (#42272175)
As an Australian parent myself, let me say this legislation is useless and you need to stop hiding behind stupid government legislation pandering to the lowest common denominator in place of your parenting.

The “the government won’t let me let you use social media” is one of the most stupid and ridiculous arguments I’ve heard a mature adult make to a juvenile. Your kid is likely to see it as spineless, then go ahead and make a fake login to their favourite social media site without telling you.

I have a 14 year old and a soon to be 17 year old. Just have a conversation with them about social media. Now they are just going to hide their use of it with you and you won’t be able to guide them when their use of it goes wrong.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by wokwokwok on Friday November 29, 2024 @03:57AM (#42272302)
I’m not for this legislation, but your argument doesn’t hold up.

If people are hiding it, that in itself normalises that people are not using social media.

That’s the point; taking someone’s phone away makes them an outcast. If no one at school is “allowed” to have a phone, then it’s normalised, it’s normal to not have one.

It is pandering to the minority, but your argument hides behind insults to avoid facing the reality which is that it will normalise people not being on social media, which will make it easier for parents to ban their kids from using social media.

This isn’t some black market crap where the kids are nipping down to the servo to buy some vapes and get a slap on the wrist if their caught; if they’re banned and they’re caught, their account will get suspended.

That's instant death on SM, because of early adopter network effects.

It really will do something. You don’t understand the dynamics on SM if you think otherwise.

Whether you agree it’s good or not, is certainly open to debate. What it will do is open to debate; hidden group chats and an escape to platforms that are “technically not SM”, who knows… but the current landscape of SM & TikTok follower accumulation will change, dramatically.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by chris_wot on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:04AM (#42272357)
Except it wasn’t up for debate. It was opened for public scrutiny on the 22nd, submissions closed on the 23rd, then it was put through Committee (who asked for only 1 or 2 page submissions because they themselves didn’t have time to review it properly) and was initially put to the House on the 26th and passed on the 29th.

The Act has no provisions for checking ID (that will be decided by the eSafety commissioner with no debate or discussion on the mechanisms they choose), and it doesn’t even define which social media companies will be affected.

To say this was up for debate is ridiculous. There was no debate!

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by wokwokwok on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:24AM (#42272486)
You’ve taken literally one word from my comment, out of context.

Yes, you’re right, they rushed it through. …and that sucks.

Now what? Is that really the only meaningful complaint you can come up with about it?

I don’t support it because I think it’s overreach by a government that is already trying to make a nanny state.

…but I’m not naive enough to think it’s not going to work. It will work.

It probably has unintended consequences; that’s the problem.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by chris_wot on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:33AM (#42272549)
I didn’t take you out of context. You literally say that whether the Act is good or not is up for debate. Before legislation is passed, it needs public consultation and debate. There literally was no public debate and now this is law!

Things like:

1. It will be trivial to bypass the restrictions.

2. The argument given in support of this Act by the OP was that it gives parents an excuse to prevent their kids from using social media. That’s going to work out great.

3. The mechanisms for verifying ID are not defined and will be decided without public debate. Adults will be forced to get a government controlled digital ID, or alternately social media companies will need to collect your official documentation to prove your age. Neither of these are palatable.

None of this has been considered. None of these concerns were allowed to be expressed by interested parties and the general public with sufficient time for comment.

That more than sucks. This is a government who wants to shove badly flawed legislation onto the Australian people because they are immensely unpopular.

I’m a Labor voter. Not next year.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by ghiculescu on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:48AM (#42272628)
Who will you vote for instead? Everyone supported it :(
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by chris_wot on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:54AM (#42272664)
An independent. Labor is more worried about the Greens and Independents than they are about the LNP.

Albanese and Co, who I voted for and quite liked, have shown that they need to be forced into a hung parliament to prevent their worst excesses. A huge pity.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by ghiculescu on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:58AM (#42272689)
They’ve been shockingly bad.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by chris_wot on Friday November 29, 2024 @08:19AM (#42273660)
"The Act has no provisions for checking ID (that will be decided by the eSafety commissioner with no debate or discussion on the mechanisms they choose), and it doesn’t even define which social media companies will be affected."
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by contingencies on Friday November 29, 2024 @04:47AM (#42272626)
As an Australian parent, congratulations: you are the problem.

I for one was on a public panel with politicians discussing how ridiculous this proposal was, a couple of months ago, before it passed.

The government gives all children email addresses while simultaneously banning them from social media. Only a bureaucracy could do this with a straight face.

IMHO as a technology-engaged parent the answer to complexity online (and in the entire world) for young people is education, not "ask the Nanny state to change the rules".

Timelessly compressed: "Those who would give up essential Liberty, to purchase a little temporary Safety, deserve neither Liberty nor Safety." - Benjamin Franklin.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by thombles on Friday November 29, 2024 @05:13AM (#42272751)
> The government gives all children email addresses while simultaneously banning them from social media. Only a bureaucracy could do this with a straight face.

If you think it's email that is causing youth mental health issues then I see why you are confused about my enthusiasm.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by contingencies on Saturday November 30, 2024 @05:38PM (#42284560)
Yeah sure, by that logic: what's next, ban networking for septuagenarians? Ban bingo as a dangerous gateway to online gambling? Ridiculous. Or perhaps the ultimate result: a brain license. You can comment online when you can construct a logical argument free of fallacy. Otherwise, stay in your hole. I'm sure society would be much better off with a Truman Show 'constabubble' for all, consuming rehashed and reverberated stereotypical pre-preference like spoonfed semi-souls locked in eternal preteen angst where the illiterati's pop-pinnacle of eloquence is dwelling on the artfully anticipative breathless pause before celebrating the only universally valid response: emotional offense and outrage at anyone or anything that can be construed as threatening the sacred illiterati-ignobubble. Stop being spoon-fed, grow the fork up, pick up the metaphoric knife and teach your kids to use it to pop their own bubble and dissect unfiltered reality: that's the one we actually live in.

See also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/THX_1138 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nineteen_Eighty-Four

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by somishere on Friday November 29, 2024 @05:46AM (#42272902)
As another Australian parent (with school age kids) I heartily agree. Eager to see how this plays out.
Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by 1vuio0pswjnm7 on Friday November 29, 2024 @01:40PM (#42275977)
There are some ads targeting parents running on TV in the US about special accounts for under 16-yr-olds on Instagram.

It appears Big Tech has reason for concern when anyone interferes with their efforts to indoctrinate young people into their total takeover of the www.

Expecting an aggressive PR counteroffensive from Big Tech in response to experiments like Australia.

Re:Australian Parliament bans social media for under-16s wit... by bigfatkitten on Saturday November 30, 2024 @04:16PM (#42284097)
As an Australian parent, I'm concerned that there are parents out there who see it as the job of the state to do their job for them.