As for the job part. There is so much stuff kids don't need that other parents cave into, that unless you have the means, willpower and energy to find alternative peer groups, schools, teaching mechanisms, your kids _can_ become social pariahs if there isn't sufficient like minded parents in the community.
Of course your kids to internalise self-worth and a sense of confidence and independence and hope they follow your mold and not a potentially damaging peer-groups. But that doesn't mean that some regulation from a body (government/school) isn't helpful. We live in communities.
Government rules set the moral bar, yes they are not enforceable but it creates a standard that most parents will adhere to.
As a dutch parent i wish we had the same rules, my kids are young enough that its easy to ban social media, but its getting harder as they are slowly becoming teenager.
Saying "no" is easier when your child isn't offered a buffet of degeneracy by the outside world.
Facebook was a great platform for local communities and democracy but later turned into a threat to civilization more or less when they introduced the 'algo' 2010 something and wanted to get money for 'promoted posts'.
We gave them phones fairly early, but locked down. It was not really a huge problem when they were younger, but social media (no, we shouldnt even call it is, its is 110% ADS FOR CHILREN!) is getting to be a real problem now I feel.
> That is literally your job as the parent.
Tell me you're not a parent without telling me you're not a parent!
This only works if there is broad support from the entire social group, meaning school and all (or most) of the other parents. If you try this all alone, all you can accomplish is to apply more suffering to your poor child.
For us, here in silicon valley, fortunately that broad support existed in elementary school. Not a single kid had a phone, so it was the norm.
In middle school the support is still broad, although less absolute. A few kids have phones, but they are outliers, so it's still normal not to have one.
Which there won't be. Most of these kids have "social media" accounts because their parents allowed it.
To be clear, "social media" for the purposes of this legislation is a VERY broad term that encompasses any almost platform that allows one user to communicate with another.
You know that's actually one of the reasons they made heroin illegal? So parents wouldn't be the bad guy when they stopped their kids from shooting up /s
Yes. That is literally your job as the parent. If there was some teenage trend of injecting heroin, nobody would accept "but my kid's social life might suffer" as a reason to not stop them from doing heroin. It similarly does not suffice as a reason to not stop your kids from using social media. If it really is that bad for your kids, you have a duty to stop them regardless of what other kids (and their parents) do.