News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by aurareturn on Saturday November 23, 2024 @10:15AM (#42221332)
On the topic of black holes, there is a recent paper on black holes potentially converting mass into dark energy: https://iopscience.iop.org/article/10.1088/1475-7516/2024/10...

I'm not a physicist but it's interesting to think about the implications:

1. No singularity at the center of a black hole

2. Universe's expansion rate is not constant because it's blackholes powering it with matter

3. Eventually expansion slows, stops and reverses

And now my own crazy ideas:

1. Maybe the universe is a inside a black hole

2. Maybe the big bang was a result of the birth of another black hole somewhere else, and that the rapid expansion rate of the early universe was due to the a huge amount of matter converted into dark energy by this black hole

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by machina_ex_deus on Saturday November 23, 2024 @11:03AM (#42221556)
The universe is not inside a black hole. Inside black holes the radial coordinate is time like, which is definitely not true in our universe, where the time coordinate is timelike, and the radial coordinate is space like.

Inside of black holes looks nothing like ordinary spacetime. Inside black hole, everything in your future is with decreasing radial coordinate, which means space is shrinking until you hit the singularity where radial coordinate is zero and you have no future.

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by dustingetz on Saturday November 23, 2024 @11:12AM (#42221588)
No, this depends on your choice of coordinate system - has been debunked N times on physics reddit in virtually every thread that it comes up. The EH itself is not a singularity in the observers reference frame as they cross it nor do they particularly notice when they do.
Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by machina_ex_deus on Saturday November 23, 2024 @11:33AM (#42221720)
I never said EH is a singularity. I said you could notice you're inside as your timelike coordinate becomes the radial coordinate. That's something you could easily notice if you look around, it would correspond to a shrinking universe, and our universe is expanding.

The "you won't notice crossing the event horizon" troupe is true only in a very local sense. If you move around and observe the geometry around you, you can definitely tell you're inside a black hole.

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by dustingetz on Saturday November 23, 2024 @02:05PM (#42222993)
Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by machina_ex_deus on Saturday November 23, 2024 @03:03PM (#42223494)
The fact that radial coordinate is timelike inside the event horizon doesn't change when you change coordinate systems. The radial direction remains timelike in kruskal coordinates. Direction being space like or time like is independent of coordinate system.
Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by KolenCh on Saturday November 23, 2024 @03:59PM (#42223839)
As the black hole getting larger, it is more difficult to notice this difference (of crossing the event horizon or “observe the geometry around you”.) and as we are talking about the whole visible universe being inside a black hole, we are in this extreme large scale.

Also, I’m not sure why you’re arguing about the radial coordinate being time-like. You can only measure in your own local reference frame. You wouldn’t necessarily be able to transform between your own local reference frame to the blackhole’s if you don’t know you’re in one.

The universe as a black hole is actually a very old idea: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Black_hole_cosmology

I’m not saying we are in one, but I’m saying it is not as obviously false as you might be arguing.

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by gpderetta on Saturday November 23, 2024 @02:12PM (#42223074)
There is a singularity in our past. Are we in a white hole?
Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by lostmsu on Sunday November 24, 2024 @10:30AM (#42228385)
I think for this to be a complete explanation, it needs to be shown that what was "the time" coordinate is not expanding in some sense.

Does volume even make sense in GR?

Thought experiment here would be: suppose me and you appeared stationery (from the point of view of the outside reference frame) just above the horizon of a non-rotating black hole in the manner of Boltzmann brains. We immediately start falling and cross the horizon. Now will you see me receding from you or going at you? Will I be red-shifted or blue-shifted?

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by techjamie on Saturday November 23, 2024 @10:48AM (#42221496)
> Maybe the big bang was a result of the birth of another black hole somewhere else, and that the rapid expansion rate of the early universe was due to the a huge amount of matter converted into dark energy by this black hole

There is actually a theory that black holes create universes inside them, and that our universe could be underneath countless layers of black holes forming universes that form black holes ad infinitum.

There is a Kurzgestadt video[0] that discusses the theory in more detail. Granted, this is in the realm of science where we have no idea if this is remotely true, but that's part for the course when black holes are involved.

[0] https://youtube.com/watch?v=71eUes30gwc

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by leptons on Saturday November 23, 2024 @11:27AM (#42221680)
>There is actually a theory that black holes create universes inside them

Calling it a "theory" is kind of wrong, it's not a "theory" according to the classical definition of the word. The word has been diluted over time to mean any thought anyone has about anything, but it used to mean something that has been proven by observation and empirical evidence. Yes, I'm being pedantic.

>A "classical" definition of a theory refers to a well-established, comprehensive explanation of a phenomenon, based on a body of evidence and often including clearly defined principles or laws, signifying a robust and widely accepted understanding of a subject, as opposed to a mere hypothesis or speculation; essentially, a "theory" in the true scientific sense

>Granted, this is in the realm of science where we have no idea if this is remotely true, but that's part for the course when black holes are involved.

I'm not sure this qualifies as "science". It's more like stoner speculation.

Science is defined as:

>"The systematic study of the structure and behavior of the physical and natural world through observation, experimentation, and the testing of theories against the evidence obtained."

There is no observation, experimentation, or testing of theories that could ever happen for these notions about black holes and the universe(s).

It could be that the universe is a giant egg laid by a giant chicken, and that is just as plausible as "black holes create universes inside them" as far as we know.

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by Permik on Saturday November 23, 2024 @12:13PM (#42221977)
Theories are always in a sense speculative, as they build upon other theories and measurements. And as measurements aren't definitive, but just a standardized way of comparing results, theories are just an abstract framework how we have a shared understanding of the world around us.

Theories usually are just based on other theories and just create a theory from the current available data. The less data you have, the larger the possible space that your theory might lie in.

Hypotheses are usually things that rework theories because we have some new data that showed that our theories were inaccurate/false/invalid and builds a new framework that more accurately models the data and theories that we have.

Take this just with grain of salt, this is just a philosophical view of the meanings of the words as I understand them.

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by prettyStandard on Saturday November 23, 2024 @10:28AM (#42221390)
It's not crazy. I'm no physicist, but I understand the math of the Big bang is similar to that of a White hole.

What gets a little mind bending for me is the idea that the physics inside the black hole can differ slightly from the ancestor universe. So black holes will preferentially create descendant universes that prefer to create more black holes.

This is a different multiverse theory than the quantum many worlds theory. The limitation of quantum many worlds is that the physics doesn't change. But in the ancestor black hole many worlds theory it does.

When you put these together, you can get an even larger multiverse, where anything that can happen does happen, but only if the laws of physics allow for black holes. That may mean the Marvel Cinematic Universe, is out there somewhere, so long as those laws of physics allow for black holes. Right? Again not a physicist.

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by bryanrasmussen on Saturday November 23, 2024 @11:37AM (#42221736)
According To Tegmark's reasoning the MCU could be out there, black holes not a prerequisite but

"there are all sizes of infinity, some infinities are bigger than others. The infinity of Real numbers is bigger than the infinity of all positive numbers, and it should be noted that while the infinity of all positive numbers is infinite the number 3 only shows up in it once."

https://medium.com/luminasticity/the-marvel-cinematic-multiv...

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by deadbabe on Saturday November 23, 2024 @10:45AM (#42221479)
Not even close. There’s an infinite amount of numbers in between 0 and 1. But in an infinite multiverse for each of those numbers, you could never see 2.
Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by prettyStandard on Saturday November 23, 2024 @12:54PM (#42222303)
Thanks, this is helpful.

So first we need to answer does math follow physics or does physics follow math?

If math follows physics, and the physics is changing across universes in the multiverse in question, then no you're assertion is wrong.

If physics follows math, then we would have to go up the level higher, and we're not talking about that right now.

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by goalieca on Saturday November 23, 2024 @05:54PM (#42224560)
If I spend long enough, I can count whole numbers to infinity. I cannot possibly count all the numbers between 0 and 1. This so why real numbers have a whole different magnitude of infinity from integers.
Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by fastball on Saturday November 23, 2024 @10:23AM (#42221367)
Is your crazy idea not effectively the oscillating universe theory proposed by Einstein?
Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by scotty79 on Saturday November 23, 2024 @11:53AM (#42221832)
Since you like crazy ideas let me add mine to the pile. Black holes are the universe, always has been, always will be. The dust around them is just a sideshow. Our observable universe is just a small short-lived kinetic bubble inside of very highly energetic collision of two dense clusters of black holes that ran into each other at near light speed about 13 bln years ago and "shattered". The only expansion of space that exists is caused by galactic black holes pulling space apart ever since two clusters of them collided mixed and splinters flew in all directions at random speeds. The Hubble law in bulk is caused by simple classical fact that the the faster something was, the further it ran away from us (and everything else) in available fixed time. If the acceleration of expansion is real it's caused by everything getting pulled even more apart by gravity of matter way outside of our observation horizon that's not that neatly isotropic. I've seen a paper where they found oscillations in expansion rate of universe at timescales of billions of years. If that checks out with new data then probably some larger fragments of original bh clusters outside of our view just rotate with that period sending super long gravity waves for bit longer than 13 bln years. Blackholes themselves are approximately eternal. CMB is mostly isotropic because the sphere it was emitted from was not close enough to any of the blackholes to introduce significant distortion. Although there are some interesting statistics about CMB that suggest there was some anisotropy.

In summary universe is small, it's age is short, galaxies are dusty black holes, they fly apart because they got random burst of kinetic energy short time ago, dark matter consists of non-dusty black holes of various sizes, dark energy is just low frequency super strong gravity waves from objects way outside of our small and young observable bubble pumping energy into it. No radically new physics awaits us around the corner and all cosmological mysteries have very mundane explanations of applying laws we already know to the content we have yet to see.

Current Big Bang model is just taking math to theoretical boundaries with assumption that there exists nothing significantly different from what we see within our observation horizon. Humanity has a terrible track record with those kinds of activities. I think big bang theory in its modern form will be remembered one day as the first post-religious creation myth described in language of math (instead of natural) sharing all the follies of ones that came before it.

Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by jdonaldson on Saturday November 23, 2024 @10:28AM (#42221389)
If that’s the case, why was it a bang instead of a slow leak?
Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by YoukaiCountry on Saturday November 23, 2024 @10:53AM (#42221525)
The initial collapse of a star into the black hole would have been the big bang.
Re:Researchers spot black hole feeding at 40x its theoretica... by gooseyard on Saturday November 23, 2024 @12:40PM (#42222193)
you might enjoy some of Lee Smolin's writing on the "Fecund Universes Theory"