Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by imaginator on Monday July 09, 2012 @03:00PM
(#4219797)
Everything about undersea cabling is fascinating. Here's a video of powering up an undersea cables's repeaters: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x2zDrUz9lgY (it takes about 30 mins to fully ramp up an undersea cable).
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by MichaelSalib on Monday July 09, 2012 @11:55PM
(#4222034)
The really cool thing about the repeaters is that they're optical. They don't work by converting the incoming signal into an electrical impulse at all; instead, they amplify entirely in the optical domain.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by mcguire on Monday July 09, 2012 @03:11PM
(#4219845)
"the obligatory video showing how they load a submarine cable onto a ship"
They have $57 million worth of fairleads going into the ship and they're still using the thing with the two old car tires like an old baseball pitching machine?
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by knowaveragejoe on Monday July 09, 2012 @04:11PM
(#4220145)
It's ruggedized cable, designed to live underwater for decades(or centuries at this point). Besides, there's hundreds of miles of it, what else are you going to do?
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by eupharis on Monday July 09, 2012 @08:14PM
(#4221306)
Yes, yes. Most important.
From here on out, no more undersea cables. I won't have my data associating with riffraff of this sort. With such undignified origins, who knows what these cables might be capable of?
Now underground cables are a completely different breed entirely. Its installation is an altogether more dignified affair.
The soil is carefully tilled by refined gentlemen wielding silver spades and wearing freshly-pressed tuxedos. They carefully lay the cable down into its final resting place, whilst a full orchestra plays a requiem ever so softly in the background.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by dfc on Monday July 09, 2012 @02:12PM
(#4219512)
A while back Sean Gorman did some really interesting work mapping critical infrastructure. If you are interested in this sort of stuff I highly recommend checking out his work:
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by rilie on Monday July 09, 2012 @02:21PM
(#4219566)
Obligatory link to Neal Stephenson's Wired article from 1996, in which "the hacker tourist ventures forth across the wide and wondrous meatspace of three continents, chronicling the laying of the longest wire on Earth": http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/4.12/ffglass_pr.html
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by vinhboy on Monday July 09, 2012 @02:15PM
(#4219532)
Every time this topic comes up. I am just completely awed by the idea that this is how most of our communication work. It seems so fragile and vulnerable to sabotage.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by GFischer on Monday July 09, 2012 @03:31PM
(#4219952)
My country, Uruguay (look at South America below Brazil) took a very shortsighted approach to fiber links, and as a result we depend on a single cable running from Argentina.
It was cut down by a work crew once, thus leaving the entire country without Internet (well, with a so-slow-it-was-unusable Internet).
I'm sure there are several ways to re-route communications, so if one/several links go down, we just use a different route, with added latency of course.
Ha, I didn't even know it was something I could buy until I saw your comment. And yes, that does seem to be an exceptionally steep price for an undersea cable map...
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by jgrahamc on Monday July 09, 2012 @01:36PM
(#4219276)
Why are there so many submarine cables going between Alaska and the continental US? Does the US not trust Canada to have land based cables, or is it actually better to go under the sea for that link?
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by tokenadult on Monday July 09, 2012 @01:48PM
(#4219359)
There might be regulatory concerns involved in routing the cables, or maybe the investors simply had a more straightforward path in raising money for the project by pitching it as a domestic project. As you can see if you zoom in on the map, those connections are labeled (top to bottom, or if you will, north to south in map presentation)
Alaska United East
NorthStar
Alaska United West
and
ACS Alaska-Oregon
and at least three of those lines have connections to Canada via British Columbia (as can be seen in the zoomed-in view). And of course a map labeled "Submarine Cable Map" will by definition not show the many land connections that surely exist between the United States and Canada.
So it seems to me that nothing about the cable architecture here indicates mistrust of Canada on the part of the United States (or the other way around), but just a presentation decision on the part of the map-maker.
(I'm writing this from one of the states of the United States that borders Canada. I've done limited travel in Canada. Sure enough, the one time I stayed several days in Alaska with my wife we overflew Canada, doing a direct nonstop flight from Minneapolis to Anchorage. I've been in the air over Canada en route between the United States and east Asia almost as much as I've been on the ground in our friendly neighbor to the north.)
After edit: And of course, as two other replies noted, cost and engineering ease of laying cables on the seabed rather than across a mountain range may make a great deal of difference. Thanks for adding that issue to the discussion while I was typing.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by smhinsey on Monday July 09, 2012 @02:13PM
(#4219515)
Alaska is also the location of a whole lot of cold war military installations. It was an anchor of Strategic Air Command during its heydey. It wouldn't surprise me if some of this redundancy was for weapons control systems.
It is not an easy, nor accessible route, and it gets you to Fairbanks, in any event - from there you'd have to double back down to Anchorage.
I could easily see undersea cables with a bit of ice at the end being easier to deal with than cables laid in permafrost in an extremely harsh landscape, with large temperature fluctuations throughout the year.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by matthavener on Monday July 09, 2012 @01:59PM
(#4219425)
If this was true, wouldn't we see more links between cities on the NE coast and in the gulf of mexico? I was always under the impression we ran fiber along railroad routes.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by bradleyland on Monday July 09, 2012 @02:56PM
(#4219777)
We do, kind of.
Note the links between Florida and the Yucatan peninsula. There are also some "hops" along the west cost of the US and many in South America.
Undersea cables make a lot of sense when you need to cover a lot of ground without a lot of interconnects in-between. For example, in the NE United States, the nodes are too close together for an undersea cable to make sense. There are many points of connection very close together, with well established infrastructure that can house the cabling on land. On the West Coast, you have long distances in-between without much infrastructure. For example, between LA and San Fran, you've also got Big Sur. There's nothing requiring a fat pipe in that distance, so running a cable out to sea means not negotiating perpetual land-use rights all the way up the coast.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by lotu on Monday July 09, 2012 @02:33PM
(#4219645)
Land is cheaper when you are running though developed areas. But these areas of Alaska and Canada are desolate, you would first have to develop them and that is way more expensive then running undersea cable.
Also, I speculate that undersea cable is more resilient to seasonal freezing and thawing.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by shimon_e on Monday July 09, 2012 @02:32PM
(#4219629)
I don't know US geography that well but it isn't a universal rule. Africa (cheap labour + under developed), for example, has many coastal cities linked by sea not land.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by lisper on Monday July 09, 2012 @02:43PM
(#4219705)
The eastern seaboard of the U.S. is much more hospitable and stable terrain. Alaska includes some pretty gnarly mountain ranges and a fair number of glaciers.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by mcguire on Monday July 09, 2012 @03:06PM
(#4219823)
Ok, I'll be the one to say it: Canadians and cables don't mix. They chew on the insulation and short the thing out. Pretty soon you're looking at a broken cable and a fried Canuck.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by dredmorbius on Monday July 09, 2012 @05:07PM
(#4220454)
NB: I one thing I notice is how few undersea links Russia has. There's a run to Japan, one to Finland, and a few through the Caucuses. Otherwise, Russian overseas network traffic is almost wholly dependent on third-party links.
Also impressed by India's connections. And of course, the NYC-London linkages.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by sukuriant on Monday July 09, 2012 @02:43PM
(#4219704)
It's really fascinating to see the cables go around Cuba (except for a single cable), compared to much of the rest of the world where there is a great deal of redundancy (except where it would be too much work, like a couple of the more remote islands).
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by pvarangot on Monday July 09, 2012 @10:57PM
(#4221830)
That cable was sold to Cuba by Venezuela. Cuba paid market price for the whole contract. Venezuela triangulated the sale using I believe a French contractor, in order to avoid the economic blockade imposed by the US. Even with Venezuela and France in the middle of the transaction it is still debatable whether someone violated the blockade...
Getting and undersea cable through to you when there is a law in the US that prevents virtually any commercial transaction with your country turns out to be extremely difficult.
I believe the cable is not yet operational because of last-moment technical issues. It was also the first undersea cable to reach Jamaica, though they got another connection from Puerto Rico not a short time ago.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by refurb on Monday July 09, 2012 @06:27PM
(#4220914)
I would imagine has more to do with the absolute shambles that is the Cuba economy. When you can't feed your populous, underseas communication cables seem like a bit of a luxury.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by pvarangot on Monday July 09, 2012 @10:51PM
(#4221808)
The last time there was endemic food distribution problems in Cuba (the "periodo especial") sort of completely ended before the beginning of the 21st century. It was mostly because Cuba was unable to meet its own demand for oil during the collapse of the Soviet Union.
You can bash the Cuban economy all you want, but feeding of its population is not a good place to start. It ranks among the top american countries (that includes the US and Canada) in the UNs undernourishment rating since 2002. As of 2006 it has also ranked consistently in the top3/top5 of american countries in children undernourishment indexes, sometimes above or matching the USA and Canada.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by uvdiv on Monday July 09, 2012 @06:39PM
(#4220972)
Wikipedia gives some insight:
Most access is to a national intranet which consists of an in-country e-mail system, a Cuban encyclopedia, and websites that are supportive of the government.[7] Such a network, similar to the Kwangmyong used by North Korea, prevents unwanted information from outside of the country getting into the closed system. One network link connects to the global internet and is used by government officials and tourists, while another connection for use by the general public has restricted content. Myanmar uses and Iran has plans to implement a similar system.[11]
[...]
A new undersea fiber-optic link to Venezuela (ALBA-1) was scheduled for 2011.[12][13] [...] In May 2012 there were reports that the cable was operational, but with use restricted to Cuban and Venezuelan government entities. Internet access by the general public still uses the slower and more expensive satellite links.[17]
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by AndrewO on Monday July 09, 2012 @04:02PM
(#4220103)
I'm only a somewhat familiar with the geography there, but IIRC, it's similar to what's described here:
"Cables almost never land in industrial zones, first because such areas are heavily traveled and frequently dredged, second because of pure geography. Industry likes rivers, which bring currents, which are bad for cables. Cities like flat land. But flat land above the tide line implies a correspondingly gentle slope below the water, meaning that the cable will pass for a greater distance through the treacherous shallows. Three to thirty meters is the range of depth where most of the ocean dynamics are and where cable must be armored. But in wild places like Porthcurno or Lan Tao Island, rivers are few and small, and the land bursts almost vertically from the sea. The same geography, of course, favors pirates and smugglers."
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by asolove on Monday July 09, 2012 @01:44PM
(#4219327)
Hey guys, congratulations on the release and the cool interface! I worked as an intern at TG back in 2005 and fondly remember playing around with this data to see where the connections were.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by htf on Monday July 09, 2012 @05:11PM
(#4220491)
When I think of a submarine cable, I think about fiber optics and all the data that can go through it. But when I see a map of all the submarine cables on Earth, it reminds me of a nervous system. Unicellular organisms long ago started cooperating with one another and evolved into multicellular lifeforms. I get the impression that, as data transmissions increase year after year, humans are forming some sort of superorganism.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by molmalo on Monday July 09, 2012 @04:15PM
(#4220160)
Where's that? It looks like they're coming out from Santa Teresita.
I used to go there on vacations with my friends a few years ago (I went there 5 years in a row!)... but I never heard of the cables.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by yownie on Monday July 09, 2012 @07:10PM
(#4221092)
I'm very please to see them listing Atlantic Emerald Express on here in addition to gregs cable map(http://www.cablemap.info/). There's been some talk of it not getting enough funding and we need more redundant links here in Iceland.
Re:2012 Submarine Cable Map
by KeepTalking on Monday July 09, 2012 @03:08PM
(#4219830)
It is very interesting to see how much cabling lies off the horn of Africa and around the Arabian peninsula. If ever this was a stable region it might have severed well to these nations.
And of course the obligatory video showing how they load a submarine cable onto a ship http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v1JEuzBkOD8
They have $57 million worth of fairleads going into the ship and they're still using the thing with the two old car tires like an old baseball pitching machine?
From here on out, no more undersea cables. I won't have my data associating with riffraff of this sort. With such undignified origins, who knows what these cables might be capable of?
Now underground cables are a completely different breed entirely. Its installation is an altogether more dignified affair.
The soil is carefully tilled by refined gentlemen wielding silver spades and wearing freshly-pressed tuxedos. They carefully lay the cable down into its final resting place, whilst a full orchestra plays a requiem ever so softly in the background.
http://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=sean+gorman+critical+inf...
It was cut down by a work crew once, thus leaving the entire country without Internet (well, with a so-slow-it-was-unusable Internet).
http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2011/apr/06/georgian-woman-c...
Alaska United East
NorthStar
Alaska United West
and
ACS Alaska-Oregon
and at least three of those lines have connections to Canada via British Columbia (as can be seen in the zoomed-in view). And of course a map labeled "Submarine Cable Map" will by definition not show the many land connections that surely exist between the United States and Canada.
So it seems to me that nothing about the cable architecture here indicates mistrust of Canada on the part of the United States (or the other way around), but just a presentation decision on the part of the map-maker.
(I'm writing this from one of the states of the United States that borders Canada. I've done limited travel in Canada. Sure enough, the one time I stayed several days in Alaska with my wife we overflew Canada, doing a direct nonstop flight from Minneapolis to Anchorage. I've been in the air over Canada en route between the United States and east Asia almost as much as I've been on the ground in our friendly neighbor to the north.)
After edit: And of course, as two other replies noted, cost and engineering ease of laying cables on the seabed rather than across a mountain range may make a great deal of difference. Thanks for adding that issue to the discussion while I was typing.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Alaska_Highway
It is not an easy, nor accessible route, and it gets you to Fairbanks, in any event - from there you'd have to double back down to Anchorage.
I could easily see undersea cables with a bit of ice at the end being easier to deal with than cables laid in permafrost in an extremely harsh landscape, with large temperature fluctuations throughout the year.
Note the links between Florida and the Yucatan peninsula. There are also some "hops" along the west cost of the US and many in South America.
Undersea cables make a lot of sense when you need to cover a lot of ground without a lot of interconnects in-between. For example, in the NE United States, the nodes are too close together for an undersea cable to make sense. There are many points of connection very close together, with well established infrastructure that can house the cabling on land. On the West Coast, you have long distances in-between without much infrastructure. For example, between LA and San Fran, you've also got Big Sur. There's nothing requiring a fat pipe in that distance, so running a cable out to sea means not negotiating perpetual land-use rights all the way up the coast.
Also, I speculate that undersea cable is more resilient to seasonal freezing and thawing.
Also impressed by India's connections. And of course, the NYC-London linkages.
I was in a city which was a couple of hundred k's from the next town or rail connection and they had pretty good broadband from what I could tell.
Feel sorry for us Kiwi's, only one cable (the southern cross) active at the moment.
Getting and undersea cable through to you when there is a law in the US that prevents virtually any commercial transaction with your country turns out to be extremely difficult.
I believe the cable is not yet operational because of last-moment technical issues. It was also the first undersea cable to reach Jamaica, though they got another connection from Puerto Rico not a short time ago.
You can bash the Cuban economy all you want, but feeding of its population is not a good place to start. It ranks among the top american countries (that includes the US and Canada) in the UNs undernourishment rating since 2002. As of 2006 it has also ranked consistently in the top3/top5 of american countries in children undernourishment indexes, sometimes above or matching the USA and Canada.
Most access is to a national intranet which consists of an in-country e-mail system, a Cuban encyclopedia, and websites that are supportive of the government.[7] Such a network, similar to the Kwangmyong used by North Korea, prevents unwanted information from outside of the country getting into the closed system. One network link connects to the global internet and is used by government officials and tourists, while another connection for use by the general public has restricted content. Myanmar uses and Iran has plans to implement a similar system.[11]
[...]
A new undersea fiber-optic link to Venezuela (ALBA-1) was scheduled for 2011.[12][13] [...] In May 2012 there were reports that the cable was operational, but with use restricted to Cuban and Venezuelan government entities. Internet access by the general public still uses the slower and more expensive satellite links.[17]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet_in_Cuba
[0] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Svalbard_Satellite_Station [1] http://www.ksat.no/node/77
"Cables almost never land in industrial zones, first because such areas are heavily traveled and frequently dredged, second because of pure geography. Industry likes rivers, which bring currents, which are bad for cables. Cities like flat land. But flat land above the tide line implies a correspondingly gentle slope below the water, meaning that the cable will pass for a greater distance through the treacherous shallows. Three to thirty meters is the range of depth where most of the ocean dynamics are and where cable must be armored. But in wild places like Porthcurno or Lan Tao Island, rivers are few and small, and the land bursts almost vertically from the sea. The same geography, of course, favors pirates and smugglers."
"Wired 4.12: Mother Earth, Motherboard by Neal Stephenson":http://www.wired.com/wired/archive/4.12/ffglass_pr.html (this article is old, but great if you're interested in sub cables)
Such a small world.
It won't be like that for long: http://www.popsci.com/technology/article/2012-03/thawing-nor...