News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by euroderf on Monday November 18, 2024 @03:34PM (#42176649)
So what's the solution ? Assign a surveillance UAV to every Russian ship parked "without a good reason" over a cable ? It would be expensive, but doable, and create a reserve of vehicles for wartime use.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by regnull on Monday November 18, 2024 @03:50PM (#42176841)
The solution is to project strength and hit them where they don't expect. You are dealing with a thug, not a cost/benefit accountant, as Obama seemed to mistakenly believe. As long as they do things and we respond, nothing good will happen. They have already calculated the response and found it acceptable. Instead of this, go to the mattresses. Oh, your bridge has suddenly exploded? Shame.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by petre on Monday November 18, 2024 @04:01PM (#42176982)
"We" already screwed their pipeline, what's left? Provide Ukraine with the means to blow up the Kerch bridge maybe? They're the ones that could legitimately do that sort of escalation.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 18, 2024 @04:09PM (#42177070)
> what's left?

The other pipelines. Their shadow oil fleet. There are lots of options. But to my knowledge, only the British, French and Americans are capable of the long-range clandestine operations.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by petre on Monday November 18, 2024 @04:13PM (#42177105)
Their shadow oil fleet is operated by third parties and shell companies. We are dealing with a mafia state here.

https://windward.ai/knowledge-base/illuminating-russias-shad...

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 18, 2024 @04:18PM (#42177161)
> Their shadow oil fleet is operated by third parties and shell companies

Would be a shame if they started having engine troubles in the middle of the ocean.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by libertine on Monday November 18, 2024 @06:17PM (#42178243)
The "problem" of Western countries is that the political sphere operates under different moral compasses: like taking down a shadow fleet tanker would be a natural disaster... taking down many would mean many disasters.

The real question is, should security and defense concerns be placed on hold? If our basic freedoms and rights are being attacked, how big of a deal would be a shadow fleet tanker catastrophe?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by toomuchtodo on Monday November 18, 2024 @07:41PM (#42178967)
Those ships are going to be transiting somewhere unloaded. That is when you hit them.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by DiggyJohnson on Monday November 18, 2024 @08:57PM (#42179408)
That would be in the busiest shipping ports, channels, and anchorages in the entire world. Aka the most bananas place to interdict.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mlyle on Monday November 18, 2024 @09:15PM (#42179491)
If something bad happened to a mostly empty Russian shadow tanker in the Gulf of Finland, that impact is going to be mostly confined to Russia. i.e. past the major Finnish and Estonian ports.

As long as we're all playing silly only-kinda-deniable games, that's an option on the table.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by geniusplanmate on Monday November 18, 2024 @10:42PM (#42179918)
That's not where that shadow fleet is operating.

The gas sold by Russia to France, Germany, etc. is transported using normal vessels, AFAIK.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mlyle on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:23AM (#42180532)
https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2024/09/30/7477500/

Plenty of targets in the Gulf of Finland.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by petre on Monday November 18, 2024 @11:35PM (#42180123)
Except it isn't in the Gulf of Finland but the East Sea or Soth China Sea. Most of these ships are transporting oil to China, India, Singapore, The Middle East. The only allies able to interdict most of these ships are Japan and South Korea. Japan doesn't engage in such activities after WW2 and South Korea is reluctant to because of retaliatory actions from Russia and China. Maybe they'll change course after the DPRK has sent triops into Ukraine, but don't hold your breath.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mlyle on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:23AM (#42180531)
https://www.pravda.com.ua/eng/news/2024/09/30/7477500/

Plenty of targets in the Gulf of Finland.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by wbl on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:39AM (#42180602)
What exactly do you think we spend all that money on fast attack subs and frigates and destroyers for? Of course the US Navy (and the French and British) can interdict those ships anywhere on the high seas.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by jojobas on Monday November 18, 2024 @09:01PM (#42179430)
Western countries have intelligence services with sabotage departments and in general are not above blowing up things their leaders don't like.

If the CIA or US Navy don't have the technical means to blow up the Crimea bridge with plausible deniability they haven't been paying attention.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by petre on Monday November 18, 2024 @11:44PM (#42180148)
Thry do but it only benefits Ukraine. So they're the ones who should blow it up, preferably with with weapons of their own in order to avoid NATO escalation. Just lke the Moskva sinking.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by lottin on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:36AM (#42180585)
How does destroying the Crimea bridge not benefit the West? They destroy our infrastructure, we destroy theirs. That's the whole idea.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by jojobas on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:44AM (#42182391)
If Russian leadership doesn't change there's just no chance it will stop at Ukraine. Next those sharing your sentiment will say "it only benefits Poland".
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by mrguyorama on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:56PM (#42188001)
The problem is we (The US) used to swing our """nation building"""/Imperialism dick all around, coup'ing and invading whoever we want, but after Vietnam and wasting trillions bombing sand for 20 years, a lot of us have softened on the idea of forcing our desires through explosions.

Add to that a natural conservative tendency in the US to jump at isolationism whenever there's an easy excuse (the guy you like is doing the "bad thing" so you don't actually want to stop him, the war is literally somewhere else and doesn't exactly involve us)

So it's hard for people like me, who used to be pretty pacifist, to decide that yeah maybe violence is the right option sometimes?

Also, the entire time we are trying to shake off bullshit "Democrats are warhawks" nonsense from the party that did the desert bombing just because Bush wanted to defend his daddy's memory. The same people who call the Dems warhawks spent the 2000s screaming that "you're either with us or against us" and calling anti-war people pussies so I guess they don't have very good memories.

So for various reasons, some good, the US is extremely gunshy right now. Even those of us wholeheartedly in support of Ukraine, wishing we gave them a thousand Bradleys and tanks, feel uncomfortable with the idea of boots on the ground. Meanwhile Europe has forgotten what intervention is, and seems utterly unwilling to do anything, lest they have to get off their holier than thou pedestal.

Appeasement definitely doesn't work, but the middle east is full of examples of "just bomb them all" also not working very well. Everyone is very nervous. It sure seems like Russia won't stop their horseshit until someone makes them stop, but that's going to require a million dead.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by paganel on Monday November 18, 2024 @06:39PM (#42178476)
Scratch the liberal pretences of a Westerner and for sure you're going to find the imperialist.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by favorited on Monday November 18, 2024 @07:22PM (#42178832)
That might carry more weight if Russia hadn't started an expansionist war to reclaim former imperial territory.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by geniusplanmate on Monday November 18, 2024 @10:29PM (#42179866)
1. They already do, because those are old, garbage ships

2. It's not exactly in the interests of NATO to have those ships start spilling tons of oil in the North Atlantic

The problem of that "shadow fleet" is precisely that those are old, uninsured vessels that cause environmental risks.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by JumpCrisscross on Monday November 18, 2024 @11:25PM (#42180097)
> not exactly in the interests of NATO to have those ships start spilling tons of oil in the North Atlantic

Since when did engine troubles cause an oil spill?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aziaziazi on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:33AM (#42180339)
In case of an engine failure, it’s way more easier to tug the boat empty than full.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by onionisafruit on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:42AM (#42180371)
Ever blown a head gasket?
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by gnabgib on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:48AM (#42180394)
Bit of a personal question
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dgfitz on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:00AM (#42184919)
Oh, its not. Why do you think that?
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by instig007 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:39AM (#42182773)
since the times ocean waves decided to wreck ships that can't turn and navigate in storms without their prime mover.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by baq on Monday November 18, 2024 @04:20PM (#42177182)
yeah just count the cases of unprovoked attacks on gazprom-related people by open windows.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by consumer451 on Monday November 18, 2024 @06:58PM (#42178626)
They are planning on this:

> Parliament calls for an EU crackdown on Russia’s ’shadow fleet’

https://www.europarl.europa.eu/news/en/press-room/20241111IP...

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by wbl on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:37AM (#42180589)
They sink just the same.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by chii on Monday November 18, 2024 @08:13PM (#42179156)
> "We" already screwed their pipeline

unfortunately, "we" didnt have to pay a sacrifice to the economy for it, because germany paid it.

The US is too afraid of nukes, and won't escalate. The russians rightly predicted this.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by petre on Monday November 18, 2024 @11:49PM (#42180166)
Germany was told to stop buying Russian gas financing the Russian war machine by the previous Trump administration. They were told to pledge 2% of their GDP for defense, contributing more to NATO. They didn't listen. This is what happened: Ukraine got invaded, the pipeline was blown up to ensure compliance, their defense spending reachd 2% this year, more two years too late in a worse economic climate. Next year, the next Trump administration is going to demand more, because 2% is already insufficient.

https://www.dw.com/en/germany-to-hit-nato-budget-goal-for-1s...

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by throwaway290 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:17AM (#42180280)
Don't forget how Germany's exports of chips and machinery to places like Kyrgyzstan skyrocketed since the invasion.

> Exports of motor vehicles and motor vehicle parts to Kyrgyzstan grew particularly strongly in the first quarter, soaring more than 4,000% from a very small base to over 84 million euros... That came after a six-fold rise in German exports to Kyrgyzstan last year following Russia's February 2022 invasion of Ukraine.

https://www.reuters.com/world/german-exports-russias-neighbo...

I know people in Kyrgyzstan, trust me they did not suddenly become industrialized when Russia invaded

Anecdotally, as a Russian, some of my craziest interactions with foreigners who support the thugs in Russian gov, blame US/NATO for Russian aggression and totally buy the propaganda were with Germans. (Not a proper data point, just venting frustration, Germany get your act together...)

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by hackandthink on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:45AM (#42181251)
>who support the thugs in Russian gov

You can't defeat them, the NATO strategy has failed.

I sympathize with the Russian opposition, but I think it is wrong to interfere in Russian domestic politics.

Apart from that, I have always been suspicious of the West's favorite oligarchs.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by throwaway290 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:29AM (#42183801)
Calling it "Russian domestic politics" just invalidates in my eyes any other argument you make. Because it is so plainly not
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by chii on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:21AM (#42181096)
With the gov't coalition collapse in germany, there's definitely some voices that oppose western actino against russia (adf is one, see https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hG4bxFKBNos).

I can't help but suspect that russian influence and covert action behind the scenes, most of which might be decades in the making, is kicking into high gear.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by throwaway290 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:27AM (#42183778)
This is my impression, too.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by holowoodman on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:06PM (#42188082)
Half of Germany was, for roughly 4 decades, a soviet puppet state. With indoctrination programs, propaganda towards the western part, cadre schools, the whole deal. And even in West Germany the soviets always had a lot of support, especially in the burgeoise (yes, the irony...) upper layers of society. Socialism and communism weren't just invented here out of thin air and such.

This means that a good part of especially the general former East German population as well as the academic and cultural upper class are left-leaning (in USian terms: deep red communists), soviet/russia-supporting and antiamerican by default. This got even stronger the farther we got past the 1990s, because the view back on the communist times naturally lost the memories of the bad parts.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by throwaway290 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:46PM (#42190890)
I always ask Germans which side of the wall they are from, it seems like East Germans are a bit more disillusioned or realistic but people from West parts can be ardent supporters of Putin
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by ponector on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:55AM (#42182092)
>> what's left?

Cut trade? But everyone likes Russian dirty money too much

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by markvdb on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:14AM (#42183645)
NATO filter blockade on Öresund?
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by HumblyTossed on Monday November 18, 2024 @07:54PM (#42179050)
"We" won't respond because "we" just elected a Russian asset and he is going to install more in his cabinet.
[dead]
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Monday November 18, 2024 @09:33PM (#42179582)
Because he needed all that time (2014-2022) to build up his forces and cash reserves.

Also, he needed a green light. Which was provided in the form of the chaotic Afghanistan pullout in 2021. Not that he was counting on it -- but once it went through, it seems very likely that tipped the scales in his mind in favor of deciding to actually go through with the full-scale invasion in 2022.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by burningChrome on Monday November 18, 2024 @10:13PM (#42179787)
Its also been widely reported that when Trump first met Putin he said if he invaded Ukraine, he would turn Moscow and several other cities into a parking lot. Trump in several interviews has said he warned Putin not to do it, that he would pay a very, very heavy cost and he would see to it that he would.

This is all Trump had to do.

He was able to leverage the media's reporting on him that he was reckless, dangerous and prone to rash behavior and they were convinced he was going to start WWIII with? Yeap, you guessed it, the Russians. Putin believed what the media were reporting because Trump himself had verbally warned him.

He didn't need forces and cash. He did what OP recommended, he threatened Putin with force and Putin complied and just waited out Trump. It was a gift that Biden was elected in 2020 and if you go through the news reports, literally months after Biden was elected, Russia started massing troops on the border and readying their troops to invade. Its a strange coincidence that they didn't invade in the four years Trump was in office. He leaves and less than a year later, Russia is preparing to invade? C'mon man.

Your timeline is completely wrong.

- Biden's inauguration took place on January 2021.

- The Russians were amassing troops by December of 2021 (less than a year after he took office).

- The Afghan pullout wasn't until the Summer of 2021

- The Russian officially invaded in February of 2022

The green light wasn't needing forces and cash built up, it was Trump leaving office. The Afghan pullout had no effect on when they were going to invade since they were already massing troops and air support to the border regions where they finally launched their invasion from. Its not like the Russians decided to invade during the Afghan disaster as you insinuated, the invasion plans were already established by then.

Again, the tipping point was Trump leaving office.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by tenuousemphasis on Monday November 18, 2024 @10:46PM (#42179932)
Surely you should be able to provide a source for the claim that Trump threatened Putin over Ukraine.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by teractiveodular on Monday November 18, 2024 @11:36PM (#42180124)
Here's the man himself claiming this in his inimitably eloquent style:

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/trump-putin-no-way-ukraine-mu...

"No way." "Way."

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:57AM (#42181724)
If all we have to go on is the man himself -- that means it's a lie of course, like nearly everything else he says.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by dgfitz on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:59AM (#42184904)
Least they posted a source. Credit where it is due.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by alecco on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:12AM (#42181819)
Not op. But in 2018 Trump did scold live on camera the German leaders for buying gas from Russia. "Germany is completely controlled by Russia".

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1JpwkeTBwgs

NOTE: I mostly don't like Trump. But the "Russiagate" angle is ridiculous.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by timeon on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:46AM (#42185443)
This is moving the goalpost a bit.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by burningChrome on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:09PM (#42188116)
Here you go:

https://www.thesun.co.uk/news/17852964/donald-trump-threaten...

“They're all saying oh he's a nuclear power, it's like they're afraid of him,” Trump said in a recording of the phone conversation with Daly. “You know, he was a friend of mine, I got along great with him. I say, Vladimir, if you do it, we're hitting Moscow. We're going to hit Moscow. And he sort of believed me like 5 per cent, 10 per cent - that's all you need.”

He's also said the same thing in several interview. That he told Putin he would make it very difficult to take Ukraine and it cost them economically and militarily. You can infer that meant could mean several things depending on your point of view.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:20AM (#42181869)
He said if he invaded Ukraine, he would turn Moscow and several other cities into a parking lot.

Which means it's a lie.

This is extremely bellicose language, and completely inconsistent with Trump's statements and general deportment towards Putin in all other respects. We have video footage of that meeting - you can see both men completely at ease with each other, and Putin positively smiling. That's not the vibe you get when one of the two men had just told (or was about to tell) the other that they were considering turning their major cities into parking lots.

If he actually said anything at all to Putin about it, most likely it was quite different (something on the order of "Don't escalate the situation in Ukraine, that will have serious negative consequences"). But that's too boring for his voting public. So (with no transcript available for anyone to fact-check) he pulled a statement out his hind quarters ("turn Moscow into a parking lot") that he thought his own people would prefer that he said.

Because that's how he rolls.

The Afghan pullout had no effect on when they were going to invade since they were already massing troops and air support to the border regions where they finally launched their invasion from.

Let's go over the chronology that you yourself just provided:

   The Afghan pullout wasn't until the Summer of 2021

   The Russians were amassing troops by December of 2021
How does this square with your statement above?

Which came first? Which followed the other?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by burningChrome on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:17PM (#42188176)
You clearly don't understand the psychology of dictators or people who are in positions of extreme power. The only language they know is that kind of direct, "bellicose" language as you refer to it.

Trump understood this and simply used the same language and approach to Putin.

Of course he wouldn't do it. If you know anything about Trump, he's the most anti-war president we've ever had. He was very outspoken against both Iraq invasions, against the Afghan invasions and now that he's be elected again, has said he will end the Ukrainian conflict and the conflict in Israel. He also pulled out most of our military out of the middle east when he was in office.

You would've thought the millions of Liberals who were against any wars in the middle east would be ecstatic to have him in office. Or have you already forgotten all the "No war for oil!!" and "Bush lied, people died!" bumper stickers and slogans the media and Liberals continually chanted during those years??

But it doesn't count because Trump is a Republican? Now there's some pro level hubris.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:26PM (#42188244)
Trump understood this and simply used the same language and approach to Putin.

Except we have no reason to believe that's what he actually said.

But it doesn't count because Trump is a Republican.

No, because he lies continually and brazenly to everyone he comes into contact with. Whether he "needs" to or not.

Not because he's a Republican. That's just happens to be the party where he feels most "at home".

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by rad_gruchalski on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @08:45AM (#42183346)
> Its also been widely reported that when Trump first met Putin he said if he invaded Ukraine, he would turn Moscow and several other cities into a parking lot.

Yeah. Trump talks a lot. Like his best friend, Melon.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by M3L0NM4N on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:43PM (#42186159)
I am NOT his best friend.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by IncreasePosts on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:55AM (#42184854)
Doubtful. He needed another 8 years after an annexing Crimea to build up the Russian army? Why would he need cash reserves if he has a toadie in the white house?

Imagine how quickly ukriane would have collapsed if the US was not providing support, and the US was preventing European nations from providing support. And then imagine how well off Russia would be if there were no sanctions placed on it by America. All in all your point doesn't make sense. You don't get an asset sitting in the oval office and then not use them.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:40AM (#42185381)
Why would he need cash reserves if he has a toadie in the white house?

You may want to think about the chronology again.

And then ask yourself if your statement above still makes sense.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by IncreasePosts on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:51AM (#42185500)
You're saying Russia couldn't have invaded Ukraine successfully in 2018, if the US and Europe were not providing support, and no sanctions were levied on Russia?
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:30PM (#42185992)
You're saying Russia couldn't have invaded Ukraine successfully in 2018

They didn't invade successfully in 2022, either. Meaning they were never able to invade successfully at any year before that. The whole war is a gigantic delusion for them, remember.

But as for evidence that they needed about 7-8 years to build their resources to a point where its regime thought they could invade successfully:

One of the pieces of evidence in favor of this view is the graph of the CBRF's (that's the Central Bank of Russia) holdings of foreign cash reserves, over the past 20 years. It shows oscillation or decline up until 2014, and then from 2014-2022, steady increases each year, resulting in a net increase from about $100b to $300b by 2022.

Military analyst say that Russia engaged in similar purchasing patterns internally (building up its reserves of shells and missile stocks, for example).

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by IncreasePosts on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:50PM (#42186828)
You're ignoring half of what I'm saying. In 2022, they had to deal with the US and Europe providing aid and arms to Ukraine, and sanctions levied on Russia, because they didn't have their stooge in the White House.

If they invaded in 2018, they wouldn't have had to deal with any of those things. That is, if Trump actually is a Russian agent. So why did they wait until the situation was much worse for them in order to invade?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by aguaviva on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:37PM (#42187845)
I'm not ignoring it.

I considered it, but I just don't think it adds up to what you think it does.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by geoka9 on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:09PM (#42188110)
> In 2022, they had to deal with the US and Europe providing aid and arms to Ukraine, and sanctions levied on Russia

On top of what the GP listed, there was also the post-pandemic uncertainty, soaring inflation and increase in the support of far-right/isolationist politicians in Europe. The Russians probably expected a slow start from them and a quick takeover of Kyiv[0], which would likely mean game over for a big chunk (if not all) of Ukraine. To be fair, they almost succeeded: it came down to the single battle that saved Kyiv from a quick occupation[1].

Last (but not least), there was the Putin's isolation during the pandemic when he might have read too much of Russian fascism philosophers'[2]. To me, the open all-out invasion at that time seemed very much out of his style as he had always preferred covert probing and sabotage before that.

[0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Antonov_Airport [1]https://kyivindependent.com/opinion-russias-failure-to-take-... [2]https://thebulletin.org/2022/03/inside-putins-head-paranoid-...

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by koiueo on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @03:26PM (#42187732)
In 2019-2021 our president zieliensky - ordered retreat from fortified positions - downsized our army - demined southern and eastern borders

I'll leave out whether this was intentional or because he saw peace in putin's eyes (as he himself claimed).

But yes, russia couldn't successfully invade in 2018.

[dead]
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by inpdx on Monday November 18, 2024 @09:31PM (#42179571)
If you believe otherwise...you aggressively haven't been paying attention for the last 8 years.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by a2128 on Thursday November 21, 2024 @07:55AM (#42203870)
Trump says that he wants to finish "fundamentally reevaluating NATO's purpose and NATO's mission", and "the greatest threat to Western Civilization today is not Russia. [...] It's the Marxists who would have us become a Godless nation worshipping at the altar of race, and gender, and environment." I take that as a pretty clear stance that he wants to help Russia this term by dismantling or weakening NATO and creating too much infighting within America to worry about defending allies from Russia

Source: https://web.archive.org/web/20240913225017/https://www.donal...

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by stoperaticless on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:00AM (#42182126)
> You are dealing with a thug, not a cost/benefit accountant

Spot on.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by lxgr on Monday November 18, 2024 @03:42PM (#42176749)
That sounds borderline feasible – in a world where submarines don't exist.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by andy_ppp on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:00AM (#42180711)
I’m certain the sea is as mapped as you can possibly imagine, cutting say 50% of cables would lead to a lot of Russian ships sinking and a ban on them entering western waters. Their equipment is absolutely shit compared to ours and we know exactly where it all is. Surely they have been told this is a declaration of war which clearly they are scared of too.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by willvarfar on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:14AM (#42180769)
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Hamuko on Monday November 18, 2024 @04:38PM (#42177370)
According to CNN reporting, the US is already keeping track of Russian ships near critical submarine infrastructure. Chances are that they already have a prime suspect as to what ship or ships have been engaged in this.

https://edition.cnn.com/2024/09/06/politics/us-sees-increasi...

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Wytwwww on Monday November 18, 2024 @07:23PM (#42178833)
Why would they use a Russian flagged ship for that?
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by XorNot on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:33AM (#42180340)
It's harder to get false identification then people on the internet think.

But also the Russian MO has never been to do things where it's not obvious they did it: the spate of critics of the Russian government dying by falling out of windows isn't because they lack creativity in assassinating people.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Wytwwww on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @04:31AM (#42181534)
You don't need false documents, buying and operating a ship that has no direct ties to Russia and is registered at an other country isn't that hard at all. Of course yeah, if suddenly if cables get cut 10x more often that they used to it be pretty obvious who is behind it regardless.

> has never been to do things where it's not obvious they did

They could still shot them or something like that, the window thing still grants them some plausible deniability. e.g. the ship that (unclear if intentionally) damaged the cables last year was Chinese.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by XorNot on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:01AM (#42182504)
> You don't need false documents, buying and operating a ship that has no direct ties to Russia and is registered at an other country isn't that hard at all

You literally just described a program of falsifying documents! If you're buying and operating a ship, then to have "no ties to Russia" while using Russian money, someone is showing up with forged paperwork or some off-the-books bribes to make that happen.

Drawing down those sorts of sums from a country's treasury isn't something you can actually just "do" - people have to take actions, funds transferred, meetings held and operations authorized.

You are describing a system of resources which likely does exist, but is by no means easy to use or acquire and would not be expended unnecessarily.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Wytwwww on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @10:25AM (#42184474)
Again, I'm not sure getting a ship registered (or just buying one) in a random island country through a shell company would be that hard.

> funds transferred, meetings held and operations authorized.

It's Russia... I doubt there would be a lot oversight. But they might just as well get the money from one of the "private" companies run by Putin's cronies with zero direct involvement by the Russian government.

Anyway, I still think that acquiring the ship itself is still a relatively trivial problem to solve.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by gruez on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:19PM (#42185851)
>It's harder to get false identification then people on the internet think.

The US can barely enforce its sanctions against Iran. Despite the sanctions, they can still move tens of billions of oil proceeds. What makes you think any country is going to be any more successful at preventing Russia from renting a rogue ship?

https://www.economist.com/finance-and-economics/2024/10/17/i...

https://archive.is/IN5Aj

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by lenerdenator on Monday November 18, 2024 @09:28PM (#42179561)
Make them pay dearly every time there's even reasonable suspicion that Russia has messed with Western/NATO technological infrastructure.

That we still have oligarchs and bratva members walking around on NATO soil in the open this far into things is insane.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by andy_ppp on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:56AM (#42180687)
There’s loads more we can do but the Russian government might just collapse if they go too far attacking western assets. They know there will be a response “at a time and place of our choosing” and cutting the Internet properly will be extremely expensive for Russia, they will have no banking system at all and we will give Ukraine weapons to attack their oil infrastructure.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by loongloong on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:30AM (#42180853)
What do you mean "pay dearly" Not more violence I hope...

https://www.hrw.org/news/2019/12/11/afghanistan-papers-detai...

Imagine if every bad thing USA did... people want USA to "pay dearly"...

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by stoperaticless on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:10AM (#42182191)
It is not the time to call “but US also did it” card.

When thug attacks, what do you do?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by lenerdenator on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @09:29AM (#42183805)
> Imagine if every bad thing USA did... people want USA to "pay dearly"...

First off, whataboutism is a logical fallacy.

Second, Afghanistan is nothing if not a bunch of people who wanted to make the US "pay dearly", even if to their personal and national detriment.

Third, there's a way for the Russians to avoid consequences: stop attacking Western digital infrastructure.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by ungreased0675 on Monday November 18, 2024 @11:51PM (#42180172)
Maybe a saildrone, that seems feasible with today’s technology.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Giorgi on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:45AM (#42180905)
Supply Ukraine so they can win and finally dissolve Russia.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by alkonaut on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:10AM (#42181805)
The Danish straits is European Waters. We fully control shipping in and out of the Baltic. International law dictates that Denmark cannot prohibit transit passage of foreign vessels unless the vessels appear to be violating the international rules on marine pollution prevention.

So Denmark can start assuming every vessel (or at least more vessels) are in violation. Russia can take that to some international court if they so desire. Inspect every ship. Question the crews. Take plenty of time doing it. Perishable goods on board will perish before reaching St Petersburg and Kaliningrad. Tankers will be refused entry, limiting or delaying export income for Russia.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by ponector on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @05:51AM (#42182065)
The solution is to refuse passage of the ships to\into Russian part of the Baltic. Naval blockade. But it is impossible as so many Russian-backed politicians are elected in EU. And all other doesn't have a strong will or doesn't care about Russian threat. No Churchill\Reagan types are there.

Good times creates weak men.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Hikikomori on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @06:52AM (#42182441)
Good thing we have strong reality tv hosts.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by Hilift on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:34AM (#42182741)
The long term solution is to stop being naive about submarine cables. This is a well-known vulnerability, inevitable, and ignored. There are better alternatives now, and locally this may be temporarily re-routable. But there's no way to protect existing cables on par with something like the Hardened Intersite Cable System (HICS). I'm surprised it hasn't occurred more in the Persian Gulf area. And it could occur in western urban areas with relative ease. Most critical cabling intersect points in the US are unguarded, although may have cameras or other remote monitoring.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by valval on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @07:39AM (#42182772)
Well, since Russia has nothing to gain from such actions, you might want to assign surveillance on some other parties in case. But yes, I suppose surveillance might act as some form of deterrence.
Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by tgsovlerkhgsel on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @11:26AM (#42185221)
Treat it as the act of war that it is, and confiscate or sink the ship involved in it. If it can be done before it reaches a harbor, of course also arrest the crew.

If it happens repeatedly, declare the passage of all Russian ships (or possibly starting with ships of the type involved in the incident, allowing other shipping and giving Russia a chance to stop abusing it) "prejudicial to the peace, good order or security of the coastal State" and deny passage through territorial waters. Extend the territorial waters between Finland and Estonia to the full 12 miles without the current corridor in between.

Russia understands and responds to strength better than to diplomacy and appeasement.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by gruez on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @12:14PM (#42185789)
>Treat it as the act of war that it is, and confiscate or sink the ship involved in it. If it can be done before it reaches a harbor, of course also arrest the crew.

The ships involved aren't warships. They're ostensibly civilian vessels. Also other people mention that accidental fiber cuts happen all the time. Are we going to drone strike Russian civilian ships on the off chance is malicious?

>Russia understands and responds to strength better than to diplomacy and appeasement.

The best way to stop someone committing war crimes is... to commit war crimes ourselves?

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by ceejayoz on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:53PM (#42186860)
> The ships involved aren't warships.

That has hardly stopped people before.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sinking_of_the_Rainbow_Warrior

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by gruez on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @01:59PM (#42186901)
Is this supposed to be an argument in favor of sinking civilian ships? From the linked article:

>The sinking was a cause of embarrassment to France and President François Mitterrand. They initially denied responsibility, but two French agents were captured by New Zealand Police and charged with arson, conspiracy to commit arson, willful damage, and murder.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by ceejayoz on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:30PM (#42187187)
It was embarassing because they got caught, it was against Greenpeace, and it was done in an ally's territory.

There's unlikely to be anywhere near as much outcry if Russian trawlers lurking around undersea cables start getting holes in them.

Re:Finland and Lithuania Report Severed Undersea Data Cables by tgsovlerkhgsel on Tuesday November 19, 2024 @02:12PM (#42187006)
The key word here is "ostentibly".

There seems to be consensus that this was not an accident (politicians have stated as such), and treating it accordingly would show Russia "no, you can't just pretend it was an accident and expect us to do nothing".

On the off chance it actually is an accident at some point - that's the downside (for Russia) of having pretend-accidents too many times.

The alternative is ignoring it "because we can't be sure" until we get to ignore the "little green men" that totally aren't Russian when they come across the border...