Important people on the left (broadly, not just lefties) are starting to leave. I think Kara Swisher just deleted her Twitter and migrated to Threads.
And X transforming into a right-wing one.
> nothing will change for the rest of the world and each one will capture what the other side said and post it on the platform
Network effects almost guarantee each country will choose one. My guess is Europe will migrate away from X, mostly, while South America mirrors our left/right split.
The EU is increasingly trying to suppress dissenting voices on one side of the aisle. We'll see how long people will put off with that before things get out of control.
South America is starting to divide itself between socialism (Venezuela, Bolivia, etc...) and center-right ideas (Argentina, El salvador). Time will tell.
I don’t experience twitter as a right wing app at all, for example
It could be that the "left" content that reaches me is whatever enrages the people I follow, so I get an extreme view of what the left thinks now. That is a danger in the "for you tab", but I also follow plenty of people directly on the left of the spectrum.
That's a problem for, like, Twitter-celebrities, sure. What percentage of Twitter users are actually interested in these, tho? I don't think, back when I was on Twitter, that I followed anyone who made money via Twitter; the only Twitter celebrities I followed were dril and a cat, and I don't think either were making money on Twitter (at any event, both dril and the cat are now on Bluesky; the cat is also on Mastodon).
I'm sure there are plenty of people selling, like, get-rich-quick schemes and so on who are dependent on Twitter, but, well, who cares about them?
You see people like Yann LeCun announcing his leaving. Then he comes back and posts "teasers" of his Threads posts, and he's retweeting posts showing that he's still active. And this guy works for a competing social network!
Maybe this time is different, the left's hate for Musk runs deep now, but my bet is X will be fine in the end.
Still not really what I'm after, but that's what the 'Following' tab is for.
I think I see the problem. There's room for disagree about what the "correct" behavior is in this edge case of a user making unusual decisions about how to use the app. I can see it either way and there are probably pros and cons but "show them whatever bullshit" is not obviously incorrect compared to "show them nothing at all."
If you're refusing to use even the most basic tools to shape your feed or give it any clues about what to show you you're kind of in UI UB territory.
IMHO, online bickerers don't care for understanding. Understanding requires responding, not reacting. If we take a step back to contemplate your words, we lose the stimulation in the exchange.
I've thought about that for myself: missing the other person's point and debating imaginary outrages isn't actually fun or even winning. It's just stimulation for an internet addiction.
not unlike reddit where the first thing you should do is unsubscribe from every single default subreddit (if you visit the home page at all, anyway) - this has been true for as long as I've been there (a decade, and I haven't really visited for the past couple years)
If you don’t like how the algorithm works you can write your own (that’s what feeds are - custom algorithms).
I don't like the format used by X, BS, Mastodon and all the others so I do not use any of them but I do passively partake of what is posted on them. In practice this comes down to probably 95% X, 5% Mastodon/Pleroma and that's it. I have yet to find a BS post of interest and won't use Threads because I don't do Metafacebookthings.
However, it’s not just that. If you want to see more tailored content you have to follow people. Expecting to see anything other than the most currently-popular posts when you’re not following anyone and haven’t set any preferences is frankly ridiculous.
One thing I will say though is that although BSky has good science and arts communities the tech community seems to be sticking with Mastodon.
I also basically only follow indie hackers and some “thought leader” types like Naval Ravikant.
Every time I launch the X app on mobile, it automatically switches me to the algorithmic “For You” feed, so it’s hard to miss. This is apparently not configurable in the app.
When I’m on desktop, the Control Panel for Twitter does a good job of getting rid of most of that.
I tolerate X, I wouldn’t say I like it but I like reading and connecting with certain people and their only platform is X.
I think that’s what keeps X going: network effect.
Maybe my user account isn't in that feature pool yet?
You can see how that's going with the Blue Sky Starter pack directory https://blueskydirectory.com/starter-packs/all which currently has over 12000 entries across a wide range of topics.
Any other platform you adopt will likewise need the same tuning, and it should be no surprise that if it knows nothing about you, you will see content that is widely appealing to the rest of the community (who just left xitter)
I’m new to bluesky and am making liberal use of the “show me less of this” button as I try to discover people with reading.
It will take some time until it reads less like the front page of Reddit and more like a feed I want to engage with.
You have way too much faith in how fancy these algorithms are.
It's not going to change your life or any situation you are in. Nobody outside of this circle is going to care or even notice. But that's true of all these online things, petitions, social drama, and so on.
Everyday life goes on. I'm having a late breakfast. Then doing some important work.
This seems to be a USP: https://openrss.org/blog/bluesky-has-launched-rss-feeds
And no addictive cat videos please.
Bonus points: install this for facebook: https://socialfixer.com/
This is my hide posts section of socialfixer:
Reels and short videos
Join
Follow
Sponsored
Reels
Was this during one of the major outflow events from Twitter? If so, hardly surprising; most new arrivals would have just left Twitter and would be irritated about the whole situation. Over the last week I've noticed a good deal of that sort of content in my Discover tab, but it's largely eased off now (yesterday was probably peak leaving-Twitter day, until the next stupid Musk thing happens; today is the day that the new TOS goes into effect).
Ah, yeah, that might do it. You're probably just getting ~whatever's currently most popular, with no other guidance.
These days, when you sign up, you apparently get asked for interests, and it pre-primes The Algorithm(TM), but yeah, that wasn't a thing during the closed beta.
It seems like if you start a platform mostly as a reaction to another platform, you're gonna get the same sort of social media bubble, only of the opposite variety. That's why I still use Twitter currently, I just don't see the same issue that other people seem to have, and that's likely because I don't engage in politics or respond to trolls on there.