There is always the potential for those mechanisms to be abused, making it taboo instead is the best prevention you can have for this.
There is also the problem that suicide is a very final decision; people regret their choices (often years later) all the time, opening the suicide-door would lead invariably to cases where people throw away the rest of their life even though it would've had immeasurable value to them later had they lived on.
Normalizing suicide in general could also lead to societal changes where death is the expected/desired outcome, and people are basically compelled by group dynamics, even in situations where we would absolutely not see this as justified or desirable currently (i.e. people suiciding because they killed their child in an accident).
It isn't the case that people on a bad day can just walk in to die. It takes months or years of therapy.
I think that's the right approach. Dying is final, but there are also good reasons why someone might want to die early.
I can see that you have never worked in suicide prevention.
Recognizing something as so bad as to be "out of the pale" does not mean that people will not talk about their desire to do it. That depends on a different societal measure - how willing are people to be open about who they really are and what they are experiencing in the moment.
And I think I agree with your comment. Making it taboo might among other unintended things, increase the allure through rebellion or breaking the rules of those who inspired the will to die.
This much is well known: making ANY topic "taboo" for discussion is bad for mental health generally, and prevents people (specifically suicidal people) from seeking the help they need.
It's not a big mystery why: attaching guilt and shame (or legal penalties) to some thought or speech or act will make people much less likely to discuss it. Even when it's burning up their mind from the inside.
Admirable. And difficult I presume.
They assume that half the population isn’t below average when it comes to intelligence.
It’s similar to the analogy that crime would go down if every human had a gun, but the analogy fails because of human flaws.
Assisted suicide will always be abused; mentally ill will be killed; kids who want more tax savings will push the button, etc.
Most mentally ill people are still perfectly capable of making decisions and you need the approval of 2 doctors.
You clearly missed all the discourse about MAID in Canada, where people accused the government/medical care system of pushing people into committing suicide so they'd be less of a burden on the medical system.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euthanasia_in_Canada#Criticism
If they are equally distributed then it's unlikely to be coercive in nature but if there is coercion then the proportion of usage by demographic is unlikely to match those demographic's respective proportions in the total Canadian population.
How would you distinguish between the government coercing a demographic into suicide and that demographic just having a higher-than-average predisposition for it? E.g. people with depression or chronic illness/pain.
In terms of contemporary Canada, what if First Nations people end up using it much more often because they have much higher rates of poverty and drug abuse in their communities? On an individual bodily autonomy level that feels like fair game, but on a societal level the injustice is blatant.
Are you using an extremely controversial source on purpose, to prove some sort of point, or are you genuinely unaware of his cultural position?
Personally, I don't find myself not watching the content of someone just because they say things I disagree with or the world has tried to cancel them. Every now and then I'll watch Peterson's podcast if he's interviewing someone I'm interested in hearing from, but it's not like he takes up a large part of my attention.
I'm still a little bit taken aback that I'm here on HN having to account for merely posting a YouTube link.
Eye rolling emoji.
4:20: MAID drugs cause to people drown to death.
Newsflash: that's how most people die. Drowning causes hypoxia. CHF and cancer patients almost all die of hypoxia.
5:40: They are offering it to veterans instead of treatment.
This is a lie. Anyone who repeats this is a liar.
6:07: Tax avoidance law firm ad.
LOL
7:51: Doing MAID rather than palliative care saves money.
Palliative care means shitting yourself to death as you drown in the fluid slowly filling up your lungs or pleural cavity for weeks while blasted out of your mind on morphine. That costs money. The entire point of MAID is to avoid the degrading and humiliating palliative care phase where your mind and body slowly self-destruct.
8:58: If as a parent you try to stop your child from getting MAID you will be arrested.
This is also a lie. Anyone who repeats this is a liar.
9:24: In group homes people are sitting down and talking about dying.
All persons at the ends of their life should have a frank and open conversation about dying. Dying is inevitable.
Note: She said "i'm hearing that in group homes..." that is the same as "people are saying" and "people are saying" is the #1 indicator that someone is lying.
10:10: I heard about this BECAUSE MY GIRLFRIEND'S MOTHER WAS AT AN EVENT.
What the hell that isn't even second-hand knowledge. My father's, brother's, nephew's, cousin's, former roommate said that she's totally telling the truth.
10:57: If anyone is a god-fearing individual right now.
Oh. I get it. HOW DO WE AS A SOCIETY GET THESE JESUSFREAKS TO LEAVE THE REST OF US ALONE?
11:48: Several minutes of her sucking up and lionizing.
12:22: "Nobody deserves to be waterboarded to death other than people who deserve to be waterboarded to death and there are people who deserve to be waterboarded to death"
Jesusfreak sociopath. Good combo.
12:30: I've seen that (being waterboarded to death) done to someone.
This is an obvious lie.
As an aside, a single molecule of my gooch sweat is more masculine than all of Jordan Peterson. Jordan Peterson is a brainfucked loser. People who worship him are even worse.
For what it's worth, I am a Christian and your choice of words come across as highly offensive. Contrary to your belief, I have no interest in inserting myself into your life. I'm apolitical at best and gave up on politics a long time ago.
To respond to at least one point, I believe the point that she was making was a lack of awareness of the method of death. Her point has nothing to do with how people die of cancer, but that people agreeing to MAID did not have all of the necessary information to make that decision due to this being omitted. I'm happy to see some counter-evidence that she's lying and all of this is made up.
I presented the exact, same, precise, amount of evidence she did, with one exception.
I used common sense.
If you believe that she saw someone waterboarded to death, WHICH IS WHAT SHE CLAIMED at the twelve minute and thirty seconds mark, you are beyond reason.
That entire video is nothing more than the insertion of jesusfreakiness into an argument that should be dispassionate: you, I, and everyone else has the right to choose the time and manner of their death.
If you want to jesusfreak your way into heaven by shitting your pants, bedridden, stoned out of your mind on morphine while your family agonizes for weeks as your respiratory tidal volume slowly decreases as the morphine doses increase until you suffocate that is also your right.
Your book has no right to tell me what to do and the jesusfreaks are trying to cram their book down my throat.
> HOW DO WE AS A SOCIETY GET THESE JESUSFREAKS TO LEAVE THE REST OF US ALONE?
> jesusfreak sociopath. Good combo
> insertion of jesusfreakiness into an argument
> jesusfreak your way into heaven by shitting your pants
> jesusfreaks are trying to cram their book down my throat.
If you replaced "jesusfreak" in your comments with basically any other identity, you'd pretty quickly get accused of multiple "isms" by others. The hypocrisy is deafening.
Do you or do you not believe that thinking that someone should be tortured to death by waterboarding makes you a sociopath?
Do you or do you not believe that a suburban Canadian stay-at-home mother personally witnessed:
1. a human being,
2. being waterboarded,
3. until that human being died?
Yes, or no?
I say yes it makes you a sociopath and no she did not witness a human die due to being waterboarded. That makes her as credible as Alex Jones.
I'm sorry you're offended by the term "jesusfreak", a term reserved for use on christians who try to force their ideology on the wider population. Perhaps you identify with them?
A lot of "intelligent" people get caught up in this way.