You might also be involved in less serious accidents: a low or moderate speed rear end collision is safer overall than hitting a pedestrian, T-boning someone, or colliding at the higher speed from before braking.
That's a trade off that Waymo presumably know about, and are taking intentionally. It would be interesting to know what they prioritise: is it fewer overall deaths and injuries, or fewer accidents where they were determined to be at fault?
So is it ethical to brake aggressively to avoid a 1% chance of an accident up ahead? 5%? 0.1%?
This is a real life trolley problem, and the answer can't be as simple as "always brake, feel no remorse because it's the other driver's problem" even if that might be a good heuristic for a human to teach in driver's education.
Human drivers are taught to avoid scenarios like that. During drivers' lessons you will be taught to check your mirror before braking, and you will be taught to activate your alarm lights when there's a sudden stop on a highway to alert the drivers after you. Basic self-preservation makes it pretty clear that you don't want a car crashing into your rear.
Waymo doesn't need to care. If the other vehicle is considered at fault, their insurance is going to pay for your damages. It's at worst a minor inconvenience, so why bother spending engineering time on writing code to avoid it?
If I'm going to crash into something I'm going to be slamming the brakes without checking my mirrors first.
OTOH, if you're driving and the light changes to yellow and you have room to stop, you should check your mirrors to see if there's a vehicle behind you that's unlikely to stop.
Additionally, in the impending collision decision, once you've taken initial action, you'll want to check on traffic to see if you have an option to evade the obstacle. And if you don't have an out, if there's a vehicle behind you and try to maintain space ahead and behind if possible.
If there's room to stop, then I'll still be braking immediately because braking immediately gives me the most time to brake, which makes the deceleration as gradual as possible and gives the person behind me the most time to react. I'm not sure what the alternative is supposed to be. Delay braking but having brake harder later? Gun it and try to run the yellow?
It sounds like people defending their terrible driving.
It's your problem too if you stop for a yellow and they don't. They may be 100% at fault, but you're delayed at best, at worst may be injured and may not have a driveable car, and they may not carry insurance, so you may have a large, uncompensated loss.
By 'unlikely to stop', I really mean 'unlikely to stop without striking your vehicle if you were to stop', so things like following too closely, clearly not paying attention (which is hard to tell in a quick glance, but maybe you noticed their lack of attention before and haven't had time or space to make space), has a large vehicle that needs more room to stop, etc. I likely wouldn't stop on a fresh yellow if there was a trash truck following me closely, for example. Even at the extreme where I end up running a fresh red, it's more likely a better result than getting rear ended by a vehicle that's around 10x the weight of mine.
At best that's an argument for not slamming on the brakes on a yellow if you already know that someone is following you, not for you to waste precious seconds diverting your attention to your rear view mirror and trying to make a judgment call. In critical moments like that you really can't afford to divert your attention for whatever is happening behind you, because there could be important stuff happening in front of you as well (eg. the car in front decides to slam on the brakes). If you're really in a situation where you think you can't safely come to a stop because there's a truck tailgating you, you really should get yourself out of that situation rather than trying to run the next yellow.
Which would make it a bad driver.
That vehicle will still be taken out of rotation for repairs. In situations like that, does the insurance typically cover lost revenue as well? Otherwise there's still a ton of risk for Waymo if it's a typical deductible + repair costs. I genuinely know nothing about insuring a business like Waymo.
https://www.mwl-law.com/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/LOSS-OF-U...
But generally, yes, loss of use is generally something that courts recognize as a valid claim.
Thats a very human-centric viewpoint, understandably. A human driver can only see in one direction, and should be looking in the direction where things are happening the vast majority of the time. A self-driving car can see in all directions and in fact is looking in all directions at all times. Perhaps the rules will be updated at some point.
Human drivers are required to be aware of vehicles in all directions at all times.
Cars have mirrors. Any halfway-decent drivers' education will teach you to regularly check them, especially when you're about to brake.
You’d never design your system to intentionally be at fault.
There are relatively few jurisdictions that have a concrete quantitative definition of tailgating. So it's not yet widespread, but law enforcement certainly has the option available now.
In all serousiness, eventually, driving will be removed from humans.
And it's usually in the direction of their phone. Even while driving.
I'm curious if Waymo does any sort of warning brake lights like that if chance of panic braking > 15% or something.
Is that statement based on evidence?
While that seems plausible, it also seems counter-intuitive to me. I suspect that many crashes happen because someone was afraid to apply maximum brakes, either out of fear that someone might hit them from behind, or simply due to being unfamiliar with braking hard.
Once you've tuned your parameters to be driving pretty safely and minimizing accidents, which is what Waymo is surely doing for some definition of "minimizing accidents", it must be true that every further parameter change involves a tradeoff like this.
I was talking to a kid once that was bragging about how his dad always got rear-ended, due to aggressive braking, but it was 'never his fault'. I was like "your dad is an asshole, that isn't something brag about."
The insurers want to know who those people are so they can jack their rate preemptively because there's a non-trivial chance that a) both parties in a collision have the same insurer b) the rear ended party's conduct is both indefensible and caught on camera and their insurer will wind up paying out anyway.
If you've been rear-ended, chances are the person behind you wasn't a very good driver. If you've been rear-ended 7 times, chances are that you are the person who isn't a very good driver.
They tailgate them
That’s not how insurers are permitted to set rates by state regulators and also it’s a good way to go out of business due to what’s known as adverse selection.
There's only one state in the US that prevents data collected from cars being used to increase your rates. Drive at night? Your rates go up. Drive "too often"? Your rates go up. Hit the breaks and successfully avoid hitting an animal or person suddenly running into the road? Your rates go up. Good luck counting on captured regulators to protect you. They did nothing to stop insurance companies from using records purchased from data brokers for ages. The EFF is calling on them to do more but don't expect much. https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2023/06/steering-mobility-data...
What you’re describing is segmentation, which is another way of saying geico charges the people without speeding tickets less than those with speeding tickets.
If ACME co decides to charge everyone the same, then the drivers without speeding tickets will go switch to geico leaving ACME holding the bag of speeders… and losing a ton of money since prices weren’t set for that.
Switch speeding tickets with hard breaking or whatever other thing correlated with accidents.
Also, as far as fairness goes, using actual driving behavior sound far better to me than using credit scores. But strangely I don’t see nearly the same level of complaints about that
Not to be rude, but American drivers are not normally considered great, and San Francisco is number 7 on the list of cities you are most likely to get in an accident in the US.
https://www.forbes.com/advisor/legal/auto-accident/cities-mo...
One of 4 cars on a city street? Better try to push the car in front of you along, even if the other 2 in front of them are going the same speed.
Driving 2 miles on a 45 mph road? Better crowd the car in front of you that is already going 50 mph.
And then you get to the freeway where people think it's a great idea to try to push the car in front of you out of the way so you can weave through a little bit of traffic.
I don't really see autonomous vehicles as adding some vastly different curve at me. Wait, what?! They obey the law? How will I ever adjust to that?
Waymos on the other hand, they are so new that other traffic participants don't know what to make of them. Maybe it improves in the future because people get more experienced, maybe it doesn't because the alien intelligence is not compatible with human intelligence and those things are inherently unpredictable. We'll see.
Hopefully human drivers learn to apply the same wisdom to their own driving.
Most countries' driving laws for good reason demand that you must maintain enough distance to the vehicle in front of you so that if it hard-breaks surprisingly for _whatever reason_, you will not touch it.
Lots of people ignore that. They are bad drivers. This normalises bad driving.
Robot cars being very good at breaking quickly just makes that more obvious, and will hopefully educate more people to drive in practice how they should have been driving all along.
Basically, it is impossible to keep that distance on half busy road.
Edit: I've been down voted so as clarification I mean a sudden change without any obvious/predictable reason. Think the person that realized too late that they wanted to turn here and instead of continuing and turning around they slam the breaks. Yes you need to be ready for this, but it's still more risky.
The right thing to do for the autonomous software would be to break hard to avoid killing that person.
If there was a car behind that Uber car, it would likely rear end the Uber. That would be preferable to killing the human. The software would be right. Unpredictable but right.
If the read ending happens because Waymo erroneously did phantom break (i.e. it did break because software was confused), then software would be wrong.
Without analyzing rear ending accidents to decide if the software was right or wrong, we can't say if Waymo did the right thing or not.
In human-to-human crashes, rear-ender is presumed guilty.
The person in front may also be guilty, if they stop for no good reason, or a malicious reason (aka brake checking).
Often, situations like:
* You are stopped in traffic, the driver in the front reverses into you.
* Traffic comes to a quick stop, you stop, and the driver behind you rear ends you and pushes you into the vehicle in front of you.
Brake checking and unsafe lane changes might result in a split of fault in places that assign comparative negligence, which might be more of what you're thinking of. Often the idea here is that the driver in the rear could have done something more to avoid the accident. This is less likely to be determined to be the case when a vehicle is completely stopped in traffic and the driver has no options.
In ye olden days before 1080p everywhere it was considered somewhat common courtesy to hang around and make a statement to the police if you witnessed a rear ending that was undeniably the fault of the party who got rear ended.
Having a child who's a runner made it clear just how much the world is literally asphalt ribbons of death right out everyone's front door.
Bingo. (Emphasis mine.)
Design knowing full well that humans are error prone, and account for that. Wisdom popularized by Donald Norman's book Design of Everyday Things [1988].
We added a 3rd brake light, distinct from left & right turn signal lights, to reduce rear-ending. It worked, right?
Changes will be needed to accomodate robotaxis. For instance, one suggestion I read, repeated here without any judgement, is adding blue running lights, so that humans know a vehical is autonomous.
--
From the hip, because I don't know anything about robotaxis or road safety rules: Waymo could use those blue lights to signal when someone is tailgating too closely. As in too close for the robotaxi's own stopping distance.
Who knows? Someone will figure something out.
Let’s not get caught up handwringing about predictability since it’s very possible that being less predictive is safer overall.
We have the safety data to prove that Waymo is safer than human drivers, so I don’t think this predictability thing is that important afterall.
...no orange turn signals, then?
Yup. Just drive the exact speed limit on every highway you're on. And if you're on larger width highways, you can do that in the left lane, since you're at the legal maximum allowed speed.
Driving safely and driving perfectly legally are not always compatible.
This results in people misjudging my vehicular body language, thinking that I’m waiting/indecisive when I’m not.
Activating “Tow Haul” mode every time I start up seems to mostly, but not entirely mitigates the lethargy.
Exactly this. One of the most important things that enhances safety is to avoid doing anything that surprises others.
We don’t need to guess here, Waymo is way safer than human drivers as a car and a pedestrian. So clearly optimizing for “not confusing human drivers” is not correct.
Human drivers frequently run into stationary objects and plow over bikers/pedestrians so maybe there’s a huge category of situations where they *should* be surprised
That's why I said "one of the most important", not "the most important". Driving in the least surprising way is one of the methods of avoiding accidents.
If Waymo's driving style means that they get rear-ended more than normal, that means that Waymo is behaving in a way that surprises other drivers. While it's true that the fault is the driver that did the rear-ending, it can also be true that the accident may have been avoided if Waymo drove in a manner that didn't surprise the tailgater.
It's possible confuse other drivers without technically making a mistake. The article doesn't say whether Waymos are rear-ended more often than human drivers, but it's plausible that this could be the case. Human drivers have a mental model of what other drivers will or won't do, and that model might not work well for autonomous vehicles. It's very possible that Waymos are faster to put on the brakes in unclear situations than a human driver would be, and/or that they categorize different situations as dangerous than a human driver would. I'm sure human drivers will eventually adapt to the behavior of these robots sharing the road with them, but that might take a bit of time and experience.