News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by mnahkies on Sunday September 15, 2024 @01:36PM (#41548949)
I was going to make a similar comment. One important aspect of being a safe driver is being predictable. Cars (or cyclists/pedestrians for that matter) that suddenly change speed or direction without warning create a lot of risk.

Edit: I've been down voted so as clarification I mean a sudden change without any obvious/predictable reason. Think the person that realized too late that they wanted to turn here and instead of continuing and turning around they slam the breaks. Yes you need to be ready for this, but it's still more risky.

Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by kjksf on Sunday September 15, 2024 @01:48PM (#41549032)
Consider famous autonomous Uber crash that killed a person illegally crossing the road at night.

The right thing to do for the autonomous software would be to break hard to avoid killing that person.

If there was a car behind that Uber car, it would likely rear end the Uber. That would be preferable to killing the human. The software would be right. Unpredictable but right.

If the read ending happens because Waymo erroneously did phantom break (i.e. it did break because software was confused), then software would be wrong.

Without analyzing rear ending accidents to decide if the software was right or wrong, we can't say if Waymo did the right thing or not.

In human-to-human crashes, rear-ender is presumed guilty.

Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by bryanlarsen on Sunday September 15, 2024 @01:50PM (#41549049)
The rear-ender is always guilty. You have to be able to stop safely if the car in front of you stops abruptly for something you cannot see.

The person in front may also be guilty, if they stop for no good reason, or a malicious reason (aka brake checking).

Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by kube-system on Sunday September 15, 2024 @02:00PM (#41549128)
It is hard to paint with a wide brush here; rules for determining fault vary by locale (sometimes significantly), but there are absolutely situations where your vehicle might strike the rear of another vehicle, and you are found completely free of liability.

Often, situations like:

* You are stopped in traffic, the driver in the front reverses into you.

* Traffic comes to a quick stop, you stop, and the driver behind you rear ends you and pushes you into the vehicle in front of you.

Brake checking and unsafe lane changes might result in a split of fault in places that assign comparative negligence, which might be more of what you're thinking of. Often the idea here is that the driver in the rear could have done something more to avoid the accident. This is less likely to be determined to be the case when a vehicle is completely stopped in traffic and the driver has no options.

Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by bryanlarsen on Sunday September 15, 2024 @09:11PM (#41551831)
I wouldn't call a situation where somebody backs into you "rear-ending".
Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by potato3732842 on Monday September 16, 2024 @10:15AM (#41556307)
The rear ender is guilty by default in the absense of other information. You can always prove otherwise if you have the evidince. Preventing other people from gaming this default to your detriment is arguably the main point of dashcams.

In ye olden days before 1080p everywhere it was considered somewhat common courtesy to hang around and make a statement to the police if you witnessed a rear ending that was undeniably the fault of the party who got rear ended.

Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by CalRobert on Monday September 16, 2024 @12:41AM (#41552829)
One big issue is that pedestrians includes kids. And kids change speed or direction very suddenly. In that scenario, the risk comes from the car, though, not the kids. Unless getting bumped in to by a 3 year old is fatal.

Having a child who's a runner made it clear just how much the world is literally asphalt ribbons of death right out everyone's front door.

Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by specialist on Monday September 16, 2024 @10:15AM (#41556309)
> One important aspect of being a safe driver is being PREDICTABLE.

Bingo. (Emphasis mine.)

Design knowing full well that humans are error prone, and account for that. Wisdom popularized by Donald Norman's book Design of Everyday Things [1988].

We added a 3rd brake light, distinct from left & right turn signal lights, to reduce rear-ending. It worked, right?

Changes will be needed to accomodate robotaxis. For instance, one suggestion I read, repeated here without any judgement, is adding blue running lights, so that humans know a vehical is autonomous.

--

From the hip, because I don't know anything about robotaxis or road safety rules: Waymo could use those blue lights to signal when someone is tailgating too closely. As in too close for the robotaxi's own stopping distance.

Who knows? Someone will figure something out.

Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by yadaeno on Monday September 16, 2024 @05:36PM (#41561216)
Safety is the thing we care about.

Let’s not get caught up handwringing about predictability since it’s very possible that being less predictive is safer overall.

We have the safety data to prove that Waymo is safer than human drivers, so I don’t think this predictability thing is that important afterall.

Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by specialist on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @12:37AM (#41564161)
Safer for occupants.
Re:Human drivers keep rear-ending Waymos by Ylpertnodi on Tuesday September 17, 2024 @05:14AM (#41565874)
>We added a 3rd brake light, distinct from left & right turn signal lights, to reduce rear-ending.

...no orange turn signals, then?