Also, Telegram is accused in other things, like importing uncertified cryptographic tools. If you go to Gtihub, there are large deposits of uncertified cryptographic tools. Why ssh or openssl developers are not arrested? I am sure they do not have a proper certificate.
As I guess, this is a typical case when the law enforcement bends the vaguely written laws. A law saying something like "it is illegal to assist commiting a crime" is a typical example of such vague law: until there is a court decision you cannot even know if some event was legal or illegal. And "assist" is also a very vague term.
No. But after refusing it, I sure as hell wouldn't go there.
Don't even go close:
https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/23/belarus-divert...
Also, don't pretend to "go hiking" along the Iranian border...
Yes, France has a stronger rule of law than China, Russia or North Korea [1].
That doesn't mean their laws are inherently better. But their legal system is objectively superior when it comes to something like weighing a warrant.
[1] https://elsevier-ssrn-document-store-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/1...
If we cannot reach this (imho very low) bar of understanding, we have no chance of a fruitful conversation. If we would continue pretending that this is an earnest stance, we would normalize, justify and enhance autocracies, which we don´t need here.
One might be better of to try furthering these kind of view points in China or any other dictatorship of choice.
Consider a law banning the eating of meat, vs one dictating that meat should be eaten at least once per week. One of these laws must be enacted. Which one is superior? Obviously (I think), the vegetarian would consider the former superior, and the meat lover the latter.
But we can also look further into environmental differences. Given an hypothetical area where animals are abundant and plants aren't, the latter law would generally be considered superior. In an area where this is reversed, the former would be. Ultimately these will be subjective values based on the actual situation.
And there's always the power dynamic that "trumps" situations. A vegetarian gaining the power to make laws in a vegetatively poor area will obviously not - necessarily - lead to the latter law being enacted. Even if the majority of the population is made of meat lovers. And in a world dominated by vegetarians, the many will applaud and say the ban on meat is the "right thing" for those in said vegetatively poor area.
All that is just an elaborate illustration to say that yes, equality, personal sovereignty, etc really are - subjective - human constructs. And any laws surrounding them will be considered superior/inferior based on how these constructs are valued.
There were similar questions with Tor exit nodes:
https://lafibre.info/attaques/hebergement-dun-noeud-de-sorti...
It's legal, but you will get police interrogation.
Probably no but I also would expect to face consequences if I go to the country whom court order I choose not to fulfill.
It's the same thing with the USA in the crypto community, you either don't sell US citizens unregulated securities or you sell and avoid USA or any country that might extradite you to USA.
I remember the days when the internet was the wild west, laws wouldn't apply and the cops lacked the tools to catch anyone or enforce anything. Those days are long gone, the rule of the thumb is that countries now have rules and tool for this stuff and if you break them better never ever visit these countries.
When I read that at first, I thought crypto was short for cryptography, and you were referring to the crypto wars, back when most cryptography was classified as arms (weapons) in the US and it was illegal to distribute cryptographic software in many cases.
One of my instructors in college attended a US college, but during his PhD would drive to Canada to write all the code, so that the code could be legally distributed. If it was written in the US, it couldn't be.
Iran apprehending an American official crosses from criminality and law into the anarchy of geopolitics.
For example, the fact that we have nukes is probably one among many considerations a foreign power might weigh when thinking about kidnapping the President.
EU has been doing a lot of really bad stuff regarding the freedom of private communication recently (last few years).
You're proposing that France shouldn't be able to arrest the leader of a cartel or mafia if they file paperwork in Delaware?
Edit: By "operates" I mean its services are accessible from France. If an entity cannot or will not comply with EU laws (e.g. GDPR) they can block clients from the EU. I regularly come across such websites with geoblocks (a few times a year).
Also the website is in French and the illegal messages are likely in French. This is far enough.
Now add on top, that the CEO is French on French soil...
You can access substantially all internet services from France, and from any other country that doesn't explicitly block them, and from most of the ones that do via satellite internet or VPNs etc.
> you can create an account from a French number.
You can have a French number and not be in France. Also, this is the location of the user, not the company. This is basically the same reasoning as the internet; the phone network is global and anybody can call anybody. That doesn't mean that every service provider is in every country.
> Also the website is in French and the illegal messages are likely in French.
There are millions of people who speak French who aren't in France.
> Now add on top, that the CEO is French on French soil...
But we're talking about where the company is operating. Should France arrest the French CEO of a US company that does something in the US which is legal in the US but not in France?
It's under the same principle that Megaupload was shut down by the US, despite the company was not connected to the US or operating from the US.
This is why some websites block visitors from France (e.g. newspapers not willing to bother with GDPR for example) or that some sites block visitors, registrations and payments from the US (e.g. investment websites).
Here Telegram refuses to respect French law. Whether they are ethically right or not, it's one debate, but in the meantime, the detectives want to gather elements.
It's the standard way that police talks there. They don't send lawyers. Instead they put you in custody for interrogation.
A bit rude, I recognize it, though relatively common. Even the French CEO of Uber was sent in custody there.
The internet is global. Any website can by default be accessed from any country. Are you proposing that anyone with a website is subject to the laws of every country? Notice that this is impossible to do; the laws of different countries will require mutually exclusive things.
> It's under the same principle that Megaupload was shut down by the US, despite the company was not connected to the US or operating from the US.
You're citing an extremely controversial practice to justify the same. The question is what should be the case and is reasonable, not what some country has managed to get away with through some questionable shenanigans or might makes right.
> At least to show: "we tried our best".
This is just a fig leaf. IP location services are notoriously unreliable and trivially bypassed. Anybody in any location can choose the IP address they make a request from. Also, fragmenting the internet in this way is poison and should be discouraged as a matter of policy. You're effectively asking websites to block foreign countries by default because they don't have the resources to hire a lawyer for every country that exists to see how to comply with their laws.
And if other countries like USA have conflicting laws like Patriot Act then companies can be even forced to divest from EU or split their businesses so that USA branch can not enforce USA spy laws in EU. Google Privacy Shield.
Ships that have sailed can still be sunk.
> And if other countries like USA have conflicting laws like Patriot Act then companies can be even forced to divest from EU or split their businesses so that USA branch can not enforce USA spy laws in EU.
How is this supposed to apply to a small business with one employee?
Governments are funny like that. If I go to Germany and kill a man in the street, I might not end up under arrest if I go to, say, Russia, but if I go back to my home country? Yeah, they'd arrest me for a crime committed elsewhere in someone else's jurisdiction we're allied with.
Durov is a French citizen. He was arrested in France. This isn't a Kim Dotcom situation.
Him being charged is as simple and standard as an administrator being shut down and it's owner charged for propagating illegal content. As standard as a Tor drug site being shutdown and it's owner charged. Worse, Durov was involved with CSAM material and did nothing about it. For this, he is immoral and in my opinion, a disgusting human being.
https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/justice-department-announces-...
https://www.threads.net/@cyndiborowski/post/C_JSEuByAVQ?xmt=...
Source?
Complicity - Administration of an online platform to allow an illegal transaction in an organised band,
- Refusal to communicate, at the request of the authorised authorities, the information or documents necessary for the realisation and exploitation of interceptions authorised by law,
- Complicity - Detention of the image of a minor of a child-pornographic nature,
- Complicity - Dissemination, offer or making available in an organised tape of images of a minor of a pornographic nature,
- Complicity - Acquisition, transport, holding, offer or disposal of narcotic products,
- Complicity - Offer, assignment or making available without legitimate reason of equipment, an instrument, a program or data designed or adapted for the attack and access to the operation of an automated data processing system,
- Complicity - Organised gang scam,
- Association of criminals with a view to committing a crime or offence punishable by 5 years of imprisonment at least,
- Money laundering of crimes or offences in organised gangs,
- Provision of cryptology services to ensure confidentiality functions without a declaration of conformity,
- Provision of a cryptological means not exclusively ensuring authentication or integrity control functions without prior declaration,
- Import of a cryptology means that does not exclusively perform authentication or integrity control functions without prior declaration.
You'd have to show that he knew about specific instances and declined to intervene.
I'm not saying that's unlikely. But I haven't seen it shown, and I suspect part of what the French police are trying to get is that evidence of wilful inaction versus gross negligence.
Every social network or file sharing site that I've been aware of has a Trust and Safety department for just this reason even X. The executives don't want to go to jail.
Well, that's quite the assumption. The commenter you've replied to said nothing like this. And yet this is your first conclusion?? Is this how you operate in real life, at your job?
Telegram does moderate for CSAM. The claim that it does not is completely unsubstantiated. You can find CSAM across Meta's products. Does that mean they do not check for CSAM? No.
"the app had gained a reputation for ignoring advocacy groups fighting child exploitation.
Three of those groups, the U.S.-based National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC), the Canadian Centre for Child Protection and the U.K.-based Internet Watch Foundation, all told NBC News that their outreach to Telegram about child sexual abuse material, often shorthanded as CSAM, on the platform has largely been ignored."
"Telegram is a key component of the ecosystem of individuals trading and selling child sexual abuse materials, and is the only major platform to implicitly allow the exchange of CSAM on private channels, many of which are not end-to-end encrypted.” Stamos is now chief information security officer at cybersecurity company SentinelOne.
A June report from the Stanford Internet Observatory found that Telegram was the only major platform not to forbid illegal material in private channels and chats. “Telegram has also been observed by SIO as failing to perform even basic content enforcement on public channels, with instances of known CSAM being detected and reported by our ingest systems,” the report said.
Jean-Michel Bernigaud, secretary general of Ofmin, a French police agency focused on preventing violence against minors, said in a LinkedIn post Monday that Durov’s arrest was related to the app’s inability to deal with offensive content against minors. “At the heart of the case is the absence of moderation and cooperation on the part of the platform,” Bernigaud said, “especially in the fight against child sex crimes.”
> Worse, Durov was involved with CSAM material and did nothing about it. For this, he is immoral and in my opinion, a disgusting human being.
You have no idea who Durov is. You have a handful of claims by French authorities without evidence and you immediately jump to loathing this person and reviling them as a "disgusting human being"? Shame on you.
I trust the French government and several global monitoring CSAM agencies more than I trust a random Twitter or HN user.
This is a quote from the beginning of the report:
> Large networks of accounts, putatively operated by minors, are openly advertising self-generated child sexual abuse material (SG-CSAM) for sale.
(by the way this might be because it is very difficult to find a legitimate job if you are a teenager without any natural skills and talents. Why doesn't government do anything to change this? Where are teenagers from poor families supposed to get money from?)
> Instagram is currently the most important platform for these networks, with features that help connect buyers and sellers
> Instagram’s recommendation algorithms are a key reason for the platform’s effectiveness in advertising SG-CSAM.
> Twitter had an apparent regression allowing CSAM to be posted to public profiles, despite hashes of these images being available to platforms and researchers.
Can we expect to see Musk and Zuckerberg in the same jail with Durov then? Or justice doesn't apply to everyone equally?
Note also that the report gives following recommendations in the conclusion:
> When an account is identified as selling SG-CSAM, disabling the account should be accompanied by messaging to the seller to attempt to discourage recidivism. This messaging might include:
> The fact that this content is widely illegal and can result in prosecution; being a minor does not prevent legal consequences
So basically what reports suggests is not to do something to help teenagers from poor families to find a legitimate job, but to threaten them with a jail term for selling their own photos. So American!
> A June report from the Stanford Internet Observatory found that Telegram was the only major platform not to forbid illegal material in private channels and chats. “
If you read the report, this means that Telegram's ToS do not explicitly forbid to post illegal material in private groups. But do you need to forbid explicitly what is already forbidden by the law?
The report contains further claim though:
> It further states that “All Telegram chats and group chats are private amongst their participants. We do not process any requests related to them
This is alarming but this not exactly how it works because you can actually report messages even in one-to-one private chats, for example, if you get spam from a new contact, and they can get blocked. I never got illegal material from contacts (only spam) so I don't have experience reporting it.
> Telegram has also been observed by SIO as failing to perform even basic content enforcement on public channels, with instances of known CSAM being detected and reported by our ingest systems
If you read further, by "failing to perform basic content enforcement" they mean that Telegram doesn't check posted images again CSAM database, and imply that Telegram is obliged to do this. However, I am not sure if the law requires this.
Now I want to comment on other vaguely written claims.
> Telegram is a key component of the ecosystem of individuals trading and selling child sexual abuse materials,
What makes Telegram a "key component"? Did Durov designed Telegram and added features with primary intent to make selling illegal materials easier? This sounds implausible.
> At the heart of the case is the absence of moderation
Does he mean a lack of pre-moderation (reviewing every message before posting) or lack of response to reports? There definitely is moderation in Telegram, so the "absense of moderation" doesn't ring true to me. If would be good if they presented more details instead of vague words.
> absence of ... cooperation
"cooperation" is a vague word. Maybe France just wants to be able to read all messages in private groups under an excuse of fighting crime? This would be a completely different story then.
[1] https://stacks.stanford.edu/file/druid:jd797tp7663/20230606-...
"the app had gained a reputation for ignoring advocacy groups fighting child exploitation.
Three of those groups, the U.S.-based National Center for Missing & Exploited Children (NCMEC), the Canadian Centre for Child Protection and the U.K.-based Internet Watch Foundation, all told NBC News that their outreach to Telegram about child sexual abuse material, often shorthanded as CSAM, on the platform has largely been ignored."
https://www.nbcnews.com/tech/security/telegram-ceo-pavel-dur...
The article mentions a 2023 report of SIO [1] on minors trying to earn money by selling their own photos online; the report mentions Telegram, but notes that Instagram and Twitter are worse:
> Instagram is currently the most important platform for these networks, with features that help connect buyers and sellers
> Instagram’s recommendation algorithms are a key reason for the platform’s effectiveness in advertising SG-CSAM.
> Twitter had an apparent regression allowing CSAM to be posted to public profiles, despite hashes of these images being available to platforms and researchers
Yet, for some strange reason Musk and Zuckerberg are not under investigation.
Note, that the report also doesn't give any recommendations to govts to help minors to earn money they need the legal way to solve the root issue.
[1] https://stacks.stanford.edu/file/druid:jd797tp7663/20230606-...
Great argument. :)
The protocol is public. Signal software is free and open-source. Its mobile clients, desktop client, and server are all published under the AGPL-3.0. Any modifications for the app binaries and protocols would be quickly noticed. Hackers and cybersecurity companies are not fools.
Would it though? The Signal server source repo was once not updated for almost a year until somebody noticed and called them out on it:
Signal doesn't support reproducible builds, does it?
I don't understand why Signal is not pursuing the reproducible builds. It looks suspicious. Verification of a binary takes a huge effort and can only be done by knowledgeable people. Case in point: nobody noticed or cared about the lack of undisclosed binary updates of Signal without released sources.
Signal responding to a subpoena with, in essence, a fuck you is authoritarian?
Given the accusations against Telegram, many of the points apply to Signal equally, including importing uncertified cryptographic tools.
The DoJ has its own Telegram channel [1].
The comparison was only made to justify arresting Telegram's CEO. Which, yes, is authoritarian.
If Signal had blown off the court completely, yes, that would have resulted in arrest warrants. That's at least what France alleges Durov did in the warrant.
Authoritarians? Might makes right, motherfucker, now kneel before me or get in the hole. Better an anarchist wary of the State and those that salivate to drive the Leviathan, than a deranged fool who thinks he's got the right of it just because the lever is there.
Real anarchy does all of these things. It's why living under fighting warlords is a reliable precursor to authoritarianism: it's better than anarchy in the short term.
So we should be asking if this makes sense. If the government can snatch the data from third party services without a warrant then the people interesting to them will use the ones that don't store it, and then the government can't get the data with only a subpoena anyway. They may not even be able to get it with a warrant. But it also means that people can't have any features that require a trusted third party if they're concerned about legal liability from e.g. prosecutors taking things out of context, which should be everybody because they do that all the time.
But Signal did get it right too, this is basically malicious compliance. But making a state make a fuss is another.
There is the right way and the wrong way.
Wrong way: Telegram keeps records and refuses to cooperate. Telegram faces consequences.
Right way: Signal cooperates. They give two Unix timestamps. One for when the account was created and the date the account last connected to the Signal service. https://signal.org/bigbrother/cd-california-grand-jury/ See also: https://signal.org/bigbrother/