News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by codedokode on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:14PM (#41361449)
Will you cooperate if you receive a legal warrant from China, Russia, Iran or North Korea?

Also, Telegram is accused in other things, like importing uncertified cryptographic tools. If you go to Gtihub, there are large deposits of uncertified cryptographic tools. Why ssh or openssl developers are not arrested? I am sure they do not have a proper certificate.

As I guess, this is a typical case when the law enforcement bends the vaguely written laws. A law saying something like "it is illegal to assist commiting a crime" is a typical example of such vague law: until there is a court decision you cannot even know if some event was legal or illegal. And "assist" is also a very vague term.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:19PM (#41361538)
> Will you cooperate if you receive a legal warrant from China, Russia, Iran or North Korea?

No. But after refusing it, I sure as hell wouldn't go there.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by danuker on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:22PM (#41361578)
> I sure as hell wouldn't go there.

Don't even go close:

https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/may/23/belarus-divert...

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by mc32 on Monday August 26, 2024 @05:28PM (#41362394)
When Snowden was escaping capture form the West, err, I mean, US, we, the US, err, the Obama admin, wanted to know which plane he was in to see of they could have it "diverted".

Also, don't pretend to "go hiking" along the Iranian border...

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by mistercheph on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:28PM (#41361669)
I don't know if I should be sad that the West is trending towards treating humans as China/Russia/Iran/NK do, or if I should be happy that geopolitical powers have one less thing they disagree about.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by regnull on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:21PM (#41361571)
We are talking about France, no?
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by codedokode on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:29PM (#41361687)
Is French law somehow special or superior compared to other countries legal systems?
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by JumpCrisscross on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:32PM (#41361741)
> Is French law somehow special or superior compared to other countries legal systems?

Yes, France has a stronger rule of law than China, Russia or North Korea [1].

That doesn't mean their laws are inherently better. But their legal system is objectively superior when it comes to something like weighing a warrant.

[1] https://elsevier-ssrn-document-store-prod.s3.amazonaws.com/1...

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by exceptione on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:47PM (#41361953)
I propose that we as participants will have at least a minimum level of sophistication and acknowledge that yes, the law in France, as a democratic country with a rule of law with an independent judiciary, the law is, indeed, somewhat special or superior compared to a dictatorship like China.

If we cannot reach this (imho very low) bar of understanding, we have no chance of a fruitful conversation. If we would continue pretending that this is an earnest stance, we would normalize, justify and enhance autocracies, which we don´t need here.

One might be better of to try furthering these kind of view points in China or any other dictatorship of choice.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by skeledrew on Monday August 26, 2024 @08:54PM (#41363675)
Laws are nothing more than rules that are - usually created and - enforced by entities with the power to enforce them. There is no comparatively objective superiority/inferiority of any particular subset of laws.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by EasyMark on Monday August 26, 2024 @11:54PM (#41364434)
Then there are no morals at all with that particular take on how laws, morals, and the rest are formed. Equality, personal sovereignty, etc mean nothing because they are just constructs of some human’s mind that somehow got mindshare; all meaningless under your guidelines.
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by skeledrew on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @07:15AM (#41366280)
That's the thing though. Morals are subjective, not objective. But also morals are orthogonal to laws.

Consider a law banning the eating of meat, vs one dictating that meat should be eaten at least once per week. One of these laws must be enacted. Which one is superior? Obviously (I think), the vegetarian would consider the former superior, and the meat lover the latter.

But we can also look further into environmental differences. Given an hypothetical area where animals are abundant and plants aren't, the latter law would generally be considered superior. In an area where this is reversed, the former would be. Ultimately these will be subjective values based on the actual situation.

And there's always the power dynamic that "trumps" situations. A vegetarian gaining the power to make laws in a vegetatively poor area will obviously not - necessarily - lead to the latter law being enacted. Even if the majority of the population is made of meat lovers. And in a world dominated by vegetarians, the many will applaud and say the ban on meat is the "right thing" for those in said vegetatively poor area.

All that is just an elaborate illustration to say that yes, equality, personal sovereignty, etc really are - subjective - human constructs. And any laws surrounding them will be considered superior/inferior based on how these constructs are valued.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by rvnx on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:39PM (#41361840)
In France if you operate a telecommunication network, even encrypted, and your network is used to conduct illegal activities, you will end up with the police taking you into custody to ask you for details.

There were similar questions with Tor exit nodes:

https://lafibre.info/attaques/hebergement-dun-noeud-de-sorti...

It's legal, but you will get police interrogation.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by regnull on Monday August 26, 2024 @04:33PM (#41361744)
There is no "law" in Iran or North Korea or Russia or China. So, yes?
Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by mrtksn on Monday August 26, 2024 @06:22PM (#41362825)
> China, Russia, Iran or North Korea?

Probably no but I also would expect to face consequences if I go to the country whom court order I choose not to fulfill.

It's the same thing with the USA in the crypto community, you either don't sell US citizens unregulated securities or you sell and avoid USA or any country that might extradite you to USA.

I remember the days when the internet was the wild west, laws wouldn't apply and the cops lacked the tools to catch anyone or enforce anything. Those days are long gone, the rule of the thumb is that countries now have rules and tool for this stuff and if you break them better never ever visit these countries.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by Thorrez on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @01:47AM (#41364859)
>It's the same thing with the USA in the crypto community, you either don't sell US citizens

When I read that at first, I thought crypto was short for cryptography, and you were referring to the crypto wars, back when most cryptography was classified as arms (weapons) in the US and it was illegal to distribute cryptographic software in many cases.

One of my instructors in college attended a US college, but during his PhD would drive to Canada to write all the code, so that the code could be legally distributed. If it was written in the US, it couldn't be.

Re:Snowden: The arrest of Durov is an assault on the basic h... by mrtksn on Tuesday August 27, 2024 @02:50AM (#41365116)
Yes, US does have export regulations on cryptography and you can indeed get in trouble with the US for math, App developers who distribute through App Stores would go through the paperwork of it to stay compliant.