With phones, and before that music, and before that newspapers, it's a social norm. If you are trying to talk to people you feel like the weirdo.
And I get it, cause I don't like making myself vulnerable. I wish I talked to strangers but it's hard to undo a whole childhood of "Don't stare, don't bother them, keep to yourself, everyone loves how quiet you are, you're so mature for your age because you never talk, etc."
That's not 10X the general population. That's 81X. One in nine drink 9X what nine other people do.
So, you have a relationship with alcohol, it's likely not a healthy one. It's addiction, all the way down.
So if you have a relationship with alcohol it is most likely a healthy one, and it's "addiction all the way down" for... a minority.
You have a favorite drink, a regular bar, a liquor store that knows you - you are probably one of the ten percent. Believe it or not, most of us don't go to a bar most months of the year.
That doesn't really match my observations ,or NIH data https://www.niaaa.nih.gov/alcohols-effects-health/alcohol-to...
There the majority (18 and over, and slightly under 50% of 12 and over) report consumption in the last month.
Of those, a bit under 7% report "heavy usage". You can look up the definitions, but doesn't include e.g. "usually has a beer or two with dinner".
The category you describe definitely exists, but I don't think it's anywhere close to a majority, and there are also at least a couple reasonable categories between that problematic or abusive consumption.
No wonder lots of people feel disconnected. They forgot how to connect in even the most conducive settings for it.
This has kind of been normalized!
Once upon a time, being together without having to talk was a measure of closeness. Relationships that achieved this were venerated.
That ideal aside: Proximity itself nurtures trust and feelings of safety.
It seems sad that we could miss examples of bonding because they don't fit our relationship model.
Still other people struggle with social situations, sometimes.
I'm in the latter group; I rarely-to-never eat out. It's exhausting to put on a convincing production of Pretending To Enjoy Myself.
Using a device to ease that burden seems super reasonable to me.
Smartphones make not working social relationships more visible, but I doubt they’re the root cause.
I will forget my phone if I’m having an excellent live experience, eg a great conversation.
BUT there are always a few people who are open to talking. I prefer talking to being on the phone when I'm in flight. I get to have a long conversation about 1/4 of flights.
If you read old books like Pilgrim's Progress you see people walking towards the same town together, and they always struck up a conversation. Look at the Canterbury Tales: some really great literature that consists just of fellow travelers having a storytelling contest! We are missing so much humanity in our kosher lives.
Speaking personally:
I also tend to just load entire books onto my phone for flights. Reading on a small screen doesn't bother me.
With regards to talking - I like talking to strangers. However, the plane is one of the few places I try to avoid striking up conversations. People around me having loud (and it is loud, because talking quietly on a plane is impossible) conversations for hours about nonsense is something incredibly annoying to be on the receiving end of. While I enjoy actually having a conversation, I also know that by doing it I'll be annoying a half-dozen other people not involved in it but forced to listen to it in an environment where they can't do anything to escape it, and it feels rude to do that - especially since I don't enjoy when I'm in their position.
I still do what I did then - read. I just read on a Kindle now instead of a stack of paperback books bought at the airport.
I was flying economy on KLM with my mom and dad, family vacation to Europe. About a few hours prior to landing, the crew put on some Mr. Bean movies. Back then at least on that flight as far as I can still remember, there weren't seatback screens; only those dropdown TV screens on the ceiling above the aisles, so everyone had to watch Mr. Bean.
Well tell you what, Mr. Bean is bloody hilarious and I was a kid. I couldn't help but burst out laughing even though I knew it was bad manners, and in short order the entire cabin was laughing with me. That was a fun day.
If someone talks to me on a plane I say "Sorry, my hearing is really bad", and its really embarrassing when they respond by speaking so loudly the whole plane can hear for the rest of the flight.
If you've got a recommendation for one that is able to identify which voice in the crowd I want amplified, I'd appreciate it!
It sounds like yours were trying to actively amplify certain voices? I wonder if that’s sounds good but doesn’t work sort of feature. Naively it seems like just shifting the volume on everything should work as long as the frequency curve matches the lost frequencies. The brain is what is separating the voices, not the ears.
I'm more interested in the question of whether technology tethers us home more strongly, instead of venturing outside of our homes.
Much better cognitively than endlessly scrolling Instagram reels YouTube shorts that are algorithms trying to keep you hooked. Sometimes I’ve seen people just open random apps and close and do nothing. It’s like a habit they are unable to let go.
I agree that the tendency for wanting distractions has always been present in humans, but the hyper connectivity of today's world really taps into it unlike anything else we had before. It's a different quality.
A significant fraction also did speak to one another sometimes, and engaged in spontaneous conversations, too.
That fraction has dropped to close to ~0% today.
I'm talking to people constantly without looking at them. Some are loose ties like this one. But group chats, texts, Discord servers, even Facebook. Tons of 1:1 communication with people I see in person regularly. But also I don't have to see someone in person to have a real conversation. I'm often fully present with real people when on my devices, and I'm perfectly capable of dissociating while politely not touching my phone when I'm in a boring conversation with people standing next to me.
Fast forward to 2024 and every person home here in India is constantly on their phones. In the gym, in the car, at work, everywhere. Naturally kids are also getting hooked on devices.
How can you talk to someone when they aren’t even looking at you or paying attention ? Communities and real physical social interaction keep people mentally healthy. All these apps and devices are doing is keeping people away from each other instead.
Of course no one wants to admit this but people are addicted to devices and distractions. The sooner they dissociate, the better.