Access to the public-at-large is obviously controlled as you implied, though, since it is a military facility.
Those insane enough to think it does usually end up arrested for taking pictures of classified things.
I think I'm a sane person, I and think if the press is allowed to take photos on a military base, they should also be allowed to sell those photos. This seems very related to freedom of speech and freedom of the press; it's literally the government trying to limit these things in this case.
They’re allowed to set the rules on private property.
A NASA launch site is not a public park.
A NASA launch site, even a military base - as government property it formally falls within the scope of the First Amendment. However, once you start evaluating the case law exceptions, almost certainly one or more of them will apply, effectively cancelling out the First Amendment in practice.
By contrast, a purely private launch site, like SpaceX’s Boca Chica, isn’t normally within the scope of the First Amendment to begin with, so we don’t even have to consider the exceptions.
I think the fact that ULA’s site is leased government property doesn’t per se remove it from the First Amendment’s scope (unlike purely private property such as Boca Chica). But even though it is technically in scope, once the exceptions are considered, it might as well not be.
One can think up rather unlikely hypotheticals, however, in which it might make a difference in practice. Suppose, however bizarrely, SpaceX chose to allow a religious group to hold services at its Boca Chica launch site, or a political party to hold a rally - and then denied requests from competing religious/political groups for the same privilege - as a purely private site, that would likely be within their 1st Amendment rights. By contrast, if they did the same thing on property they lease from NASA at KSC - or from Space Force at Cape Canaveral or Vandenberg - it could well violate the First Amendment were the government to allow them to do that. However, in practice, it seems extremely unlikely SpaceX would ever want to do such a thing.
I don’t agree with this ULA decision, and I extra disagree with ULA’s apparent avoidance of public discussion of the reasons behind it. But I’d be very surprised if any court ruled against it
Freedom of the press can't be limited to government defined group without being abrogated entirely. It is rather the freedom of a citizen to inform their fellows.
Likewise national security concerns isn't licence to impose commercial limits on such freedoms without an actual security concern. Once you allow photos to be shared there is no security interest in who gets paid.
Failure to attend to the relevant and discard the irrelevant makes it hard to arrive at a reasonable argument.
Or ‘protest zones’.
Either way, I’m struggling to think of a time where the military was okay with folks being around they didn’t have control over.
The ULA has actually kind of screwed themselves with this - its not a safety policy on base because they're still allowing some photographers who belong to media orgs. They're allowing photographers who dont belong to media orgs so long as they agree to not sell pictures. The only thing this policy does is restrain the first amendment rights of a subset of photographers.
As far as I can tell its an infringement on first amendment rights and ULA has carefully crafted it so they cannot argue a safety or security reason. It clearly only affects those who want to sell the product of their photography, and only those not in some media org that has no bearing on who is press to the law.
They kind of f'd themselves with this. Did they not run it by a lawyer? Or do they assume nobody makes enough money doing rocket photography to actually sue them?
If they're OK with posting it on social media, it's very clear security isn't the concern.