News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by RiverCrochet on Monday July 22, 2024 @01:53PM (#41037313)
It shouldn't take me an hour and 30 minutes in congested, underbuilt roads to drive 20 miles into the office. Cities and their wealthy politically-connected commercial office building owners have had decades to fix this problem. No sympathy.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by jimt1234 on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:03PM (#41037473)
This! ^^^ The powers-that-be have watched commuter times and experiences go to shit and real estate costs skyrocket (forcing people to live further and further from offices) in the last 25 years. Best case, they've done nothing, completely ignoring people's concerns. Worst case, they've actively enabled this situation in order to support the local commercial and residential real estate markets.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by ryandrake on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:30PM (#41037931)
Yep, when COVID hit, my commute was 2.5 hours each way, totaling an average of 5 hours in the car every day. Once I got a taste of WFH I decided I'm never going back to that hell. I'd love to be able to afford to live close to the office, but I'm not rich enough to have a similar home in that location, and am not willing to move my family into a shoebox-sized townhome just for a short commute.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by com2kid on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:37PM (#41038035)
The problem is your office is 20 miles from your workplace.

20 miles is more than the entire length of Seattle. Heck it is more than the entire width of the Seattle Metro area (western most tip of Seattle heading straight east until it turns into farmland).

There should be sufficient housing stock such that people don't need to drive 20 miles to work!

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by bluebit on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:47PM (#41038190)
Cute that you think a person can just move house when they get a new job.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by com2kid on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:50PM (#41038240)
Historically that is what people did.

When tenure at a job was 20+ years, and a house could be paid off in 10 years, it made a ton of sense.

The fact that such an idea is absurd now is not because the idea itself is absurd, but because how we have structured our economy is absurd.

People shouldn't be wasting their lives commuting.

In older books they have kids and the dad coming back home to eat lunch together! Heck I have friends who grew up in countries where 20-30 years ago that was still the norm.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by johnnyanmac on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @01:37AM (#41042848)
indeed. But in the short term, we gotta do what we gotta do. Despite the RTO mandates, no one in power seems interested in making walkable communities to make the commute easier, nor anything else involving semi-efficient public transportation. I am already fortunate enough to live in a house, I'm not multiplying my rent by 2x+ and reducing my QoL by 3x+ just to satisfy some real estate owners (not that I have an in-office job right now).
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by SoftTalker on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:51PM (#41038251)
Some people prefer not to live in a dense urban environment. It's cool when you're young and single. It sucks when you have a family.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by Fire-Dragon-DoL on Monday July 22, 2024 @11:59PM (#41042380)
It doesn't, it's specific per person
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by crooked-v on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:46PM (#41038176)
And the lack of housing is entirely self-inflicted by locals in most US cities. There's no shadowy conspiracy; people have just spent decades opposing even the most basic new construction.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by bunderbunder on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:05PM (#41038460)
It's not quite so simple.

Another thing that's happened is that all the good jobs in many industries have hyper-concentrated into a small number of locations. There's plenty of space to live available in many "main street" towns, but not necessarily anywhere nearby to work if you do choose to live there.

My own city (Chicago) does have new construction, but it can't possibly keep up with demand from people moving into the city, because all the land is already full of lower-density housing, and you can't replace half a city block's worth of two- and three-flat dwellings with a modern high rise without first getting all the people who already live there to move out. Which, best case scenario, takes time. So instead most the new construction consists of replacing 130 year old 2- and 3-flat residences with luxury single-family homes, because nimbyism or now, reducing housing density is just more economically feasible. All it takes is one wealthy family buying one lot of land, and there area lot more individual lots up for sale than there are contiguous blocks of eight.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by com2kid on Monday July 22, 2024 @05:14PM (#41039891)
> and you can't replace half a city block's worth of two- and three-flat dwellings

It is funny because here in the Puget Sound, if we had two and three flat dwellings that would be a major improvement over the bullshit we have now. Like seriously, 3 story flats would be a dream for density and alleviate much of the area's high house prices.

Unfortunately due to a confluence of factors there are only two types of "density" being built around here:

1. Giant apartment blocks owned by multi-national investment firms where the rent goes up by LOL each year that exist just to drain money out of the community.

2. Awful 4 story townhouses that are inappropriate for anyone who has small children, or knees that aren't perfect.

Also because of reasons, the townhomes don't have usable yards (they have to be set in the lot such a way that neither the front or back are usable), and they can only be built in a few designated "upzoned" areas.

Zoning changes are slowly supposed to come that upzone[1] more and more of the city, but if building actual usable housing isn't even possible, just pure zoning changes aren't enough.

[1] Where upzoned means not just SFH, but still most of the city will be zoned SFH only.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by synicalx on Monday July 22, 2024 @09:04PM (#41041512)
You can only fit so many real houses in a given area, after which you're building high density housing and a lot of (I'd even argue most) people don't want to live in.

Public transport is key, especially trains that can bypass traffic at high speeds. In my city in Australia I live about 25km out from the CBD, but I can get there in under 30 minutes via train if I ever need to - it works very well and I don't have to live in a tiny shoebox on top of 100 other people.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by laweijfmvo on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:12PM (#41037633)
Weird thing is, you'd think Google+Meta would have enough pull to fix this in areas like SF Bay because they could literally build their own city and wreck the entire Bay Area economy...
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by odo1242 on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:25PM (#41037832)
They actually did try (Facebook has shuttles everywhere, and tried to rebuild the decommissioned passenger railway near US-84), but economic concerns like layoffs, etc. ended up taking priority.

The main issue is it takes like 10-20 years of concerted effort in the US to approve/build a bridge, and nobody except the government is willing to wait that long. This is mostly a political problem.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by giobox on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:38PM (#41038064)
Ignoring the shuttles which I don't think conclusively illustrate your point; Google has for years threatened to develop land into homes in San Jose so workers can choose to live closer, with the idea of doing exactly what OP suggests, but like so many Google projects, never seems to pan out:

> https://www.fastcompany.com/90978855/googles-plan-to-build-1...

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by jmathai on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:55PM (#41038308)
When we bought our home in the Bay Area in 2017, the San Jose offices Google planned on building were on all of the brochures. I was convinced that if the city is giving the incentives and Google is buying up so much property that it must be just a matter of time. I learned it’s not that simple.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by BenFranklin100 on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:19PM (#41037729)
That almost entirely due to current zoning that separates commercial and residential into separate districts, and severely restricts density of residential housing in favor of sprawling single family homes.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by asah on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:18PM (#41037724)
RTO failed in NYC as well.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by andrepd on Monday July 22, 2024 @01:59PM (#41037405)
>drive

There is your problem. Personal automobiles aren't a feasible method of transportation past a certain population density.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by whatever1 on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:03PM (#41037475)
Buses also are useless. Thry routinely waste you hours due to their slowness and inconsistency.

The choices really are two: subway (or any dedicated rail thing) or car.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by jplrssn on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:12PM (#41037630)
Buses can be very dependable and cheaper than rail if they run in dedicated bus lanes.

You’re right that they aren’t much use if they get stuck in the same traffic as everyone else.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by bluefirebrand on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:18PM (#41038637)
Not many places have room for an extra lane that is only used a tiny percentage of the time
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by xethos on Monday July 22, 2024 @09:24PM (#41041626)
That "tiny percentage of the time" is roughly once every 15 minutes when done well, and transports (in my city) roughly 150 people during rush hour.

Every bus lane you build is ~800 cars you don't have to deal with in traffic, assuming an approximately two hour rush hour

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by JBorrow on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:12PM (#41037627)
Buses are only slow and inconsistent because of cars.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by andrepd on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:17PM (#41037710)
Exactly, a bus that doesn't have its own lane is a failure, as they get stuck in traffic it'll always strictly slower than cars. So people—if they can help it—drive cars, making more traffic, making buses slower, causing people to prefer more cars...

While if they run in dedicated lanes there is a counterbalance: the more people drive the worse traffic is, making the bus a comparatively better option, making people drive less... :)

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by LtWorf on Monday July 22, 2024 @06:19PM (#41040444)
Not true. In my city in sweden they underpay drivers, and don't want to pay for them to do the bus driving course. So they have no drivers… so busses don't show up. So when they show up they might already be full.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by johnnyanmac on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @01:40AM (#41042861)
beyond lack of dedicated lanes, the schedules in L.A. are just terrible. Most run hourly and don't really run late.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by TheCoelacanth on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:21PM (#41037771)
Buses are great as long as providing a good level of service is a priority for transportation planners.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by dylan604 on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:15PM (#41037669)
Buses utilize the same roads/infrastructure the personal cars do which is a huge advantage for scaling. Subway/rail requires dedicated rights of way, are very expensive to scale, require much more money for the smaller/less used end product.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by moffkalast on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:14PM (#41037656)
Or get this, a bike (in case you live under ~10 km away). Just rolls the gym hours into the commute for double efficiency, and you can be always on time since traffic can't really affect you.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by htrp on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:42PM (#41038947)
And bring a change of clothes and find a shower at the office for when you show up all sweaty.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by moffkalast on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:51PM (#41039043)
People seriously overestimate how sweaty you get if you use a tiny bit of antiperspirant and don't drive like a maniac.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by machomaster on Monday July 22, 2024 @10:05PM (#41041848)
You are seriously underestimating the amount of sweating a normal, healthy man does if he trained consistently for some time and his body learned to quickly adapt to minimal physical stress (heck, I sweat profusely even if I merely slowly walk). Let alone if there are any kinds of hills.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by moffkalast on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @06:57AM (#41044679)
TIL, I've looked it up and apparently you're right. The more fit someone is, the more they sweat. That's so counterintuitive tbh, I would've thought that it would be the opposite since you don't need to strain as much, but I guess there must be some baseline energy use and more muscle mass equals more heating, plus a faster learned cooling response.

Ironically that makes cycling a much better choice for people who aren't fit. Finally something where being lazy gives you an advantage.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by machomaster on Thursday July 25, 2024 @05:25PM (#41073577)
The better performance of a fit person is partly explained by more muscles (incl. heart), but a significant part of performance boost is the fact that body autoregulates (e.g. by sweating and keeping the temperature perfect for activity, instead of letting body overheat, which results in a performance drop) itself so much better.

Raising the heart rate much faster is also part of a better self-regulation of a fit person.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by andrepd on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:20PM (#41037763)
I bike every day to work because I finally live in a place where there's bike paths/roads almost everywhere there's car roads.

I would never dare to do so where I lived before: I'd almost certainly be a blob of blood and guts splattered on the road by now.

It's infuriating how little thought is given to anything that is not a road for The Car. Billions of taxpayer money spent on massive road construction and repair but god forbid we build bike paths for 1/20th of the cost and 1/100th of the upkeep.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by SoftTalker on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:57PM (#41038341)
The majority of people can't rely on biking. They're too old, too fat, the weather is bad, or too hot, or too cold, they're going too far, or they have to take two kids somewhere and pick up groceries, etc.

If biking works for you, where you are, great. But it's at best a pretty small part of the solution.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by andrepd on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:43PM (#41038962)
You're looking at it wrong. The mere fact that you have to chauffer your kids around everywhere until they're old enough to drive is a consequence of the fact that everything revolves around the car, as is the fact that you have to shop on a big box 10 miles away instead of walking 5mins to the store.

In the Netherlands kids bike everywhere with their friends, because it's safe and comfortable to do so. If they want to play sports they grab their bikes and go, they don't have to sit in traffic for 45mins in the back of their parents SUV. The Netherlands also has some of the happiest children on earth according to studies. Go figure :)

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by johnnyanmac on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @01:43AM (#41042878)
glad the Netherlands are nice like that. I'm in Los Angeles and it's dangerous living downtown with kids. Even if things are walkable I would never let my theoretical kids walk around on the streets. There's a lot more than urban planning that needs to be fixed before a walkable city becomes a reality here.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by andrepd on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @07:40AM (#41044928)
Agreed on that point, but very few places in the US—safe or unsafe—are walkable. Even the safest upper middle class suburb is totally untraversable without a car. So the problem clearly isn't just crime.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by dylan604 on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:18PM (#41037726)
Not really sure how this is possible unless there are dedicated bike paths that use different roads than what the cars use. Otherwise, bikes get stuck at intersections just like cars do except for the asshats that think traffic rules do not apply bicycles causing more problems. Dedicated paths are only slightly less logistically than rail to install after roads have already been in use.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by amh999 on Monday July 22, 2024 @04:10PM (#41039260)
There are dedicated bike paths, separate from cars. Where they cross each other, there are traffic controls. And, as I understand it, in Amsterdam at least, any collision between a car and a cyclist is automatically the car driver’s fault: so drivers are very careful.

These countries have been doing this for a long time.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by nemomarx on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:01PM (#41037432)
I think they're right to complain that cities should be fixing that by building the public transportation more?
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by ryukafalz on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:39PM (#41038079)
But that doesn't seem like what they're suggesting:

> congested, underbuilt roads

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by gedy on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:10PM (#41037598)
Or, heaven forbid, make living near office affordable.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by johnnyanmac on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @01:50AM (#41042905)
ironically enough, if living near the office was affordable then there wouldn't be so many RTO mandates. Real estate are on their death throes trying to recover their tax deals over this
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by RiverCrochet on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:17PM (#41037708)
I'm not picky about the solution and of course it's a complex issue.

- If a safe, reliable bus or train went to and from close to my house to close to the office, I'd take it. Key is safe and reliable.

- If the roads were designed with enough capacity and planning in mind such that groups of vehicles are not stuck driving 15 MPH on a 70 MPH speed limit stretch of highway for 30 minutes or longer every day, that'd be fine.

- If zoning laws/tax laws/whatever were such that it would be easier to build away from yet close to city centers and have smaller or additional offices closer to where people live, that'd work for me.

- If city apartments were in reach costwise or even somehow subsidized by my employer in an equitable way (don't really know how that would look), and crime was not an issue, I would consider moving within walking distance of my workplace.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by stetrain on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:11PM (#41038544)
> If the roads were designed with enough capacity and planning in mind such that groups of vehicles are not stuck driving 15 MPH on a 70 MPH speed limit stretch of highway for 30 minutes or longer every day, that'd be fine.

If you build that, then more people see that there is a nice quick road between where they work and a place where they can buy a more affordable home. The road gains more commuters until the congestion returns.

Your other suggestions are more scalable. If housing is expensive, there should be more, denser housing. If commutes are long, we should be zoning such that houses can be near workplaces, and conversely workplaces can be near housing.

If you create pockets of higher density housing and workplaces, instead of only building large swaths of low density single-family residential, you can preserve the options to live in a city, a walkable town center, or a more quiet location, while still having dense enough groupings to make transit lines viable.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by jspash on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:27PM (#41037883)
I'm just curious, what about your local bus and/or train is not safe? Do you mean it could crash at any moment? Or it is usually full of unsavoury characters?
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by RiverCrochet on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:50PM (#41038233)
I don't have a local bus or train, what I provided were examples.

> Do you mean it could crash at any moment? Or it is usually full of unsavoury characters?

Both. Buses/trains should be secure places and properly maintained at all times.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by burnished on Monday July 22, 2024 @03:00PM (#41038388)
Probably the latter. There doesn't tend to be good enforcement of social norms and etiquette on public transit.
Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by johnnyanmac on Tuesday July 23, 2024 @01:48AM (#41042900)
Homeless people in my area (LA). I don't blame them individually at all, it's a societal issue that some at best got kicked out of their living spaces when rent doubled in the last 5 years. Or at worst were fed fentanyl and had their lives ruined just to line the pockets of some skeevy "medical company" (thank goodness they are having the books thrown at them).

But regardless of fault, they aren't mostly just some people down on luck that at best ask for some change like in my childhood. enough are dangerous, unpredictable, and mentally unwell that public transportation is a non-trivial risk here.

Re:The workers have spoken: They're staying home by skywhopper on Monday July 22, 2024 @02:47PM (#41038196)
Unfortunately it’s not possible to build roads “with enough capacity” in major cities. Beyond a certain point, the geometry of space does not allow enough capacity to satisfy the needs, because growing the roads by enough to have capacity requires spreading things further apart, which means more traffic must go further, which means more cars on the road, and more lanes means more merging and lane-changing, which slows things down further.