This whole election is insufferable as it is, we don't need escalating violence.
...honestly, if they're right about the person on the roof being the shooter, there was a serious fuck-up by event security.
"Take a look at what happened", then three initial shots, "Get down! Get down! Get down!", followed by four rapid shots, all likely from the shooter. Trump ducks after the third initial shot. They sound like "crack---boom" where the "crack" is the bullet passing the microphone and the "boom" is the gunfire arriving later due to speed of sound at distance from the shooter.
Immediately after, there is a three-round burst of automatic fire, then several seconds later there is a single silenced shot ("kill confirmed") all likely secret service.
I'd have to look at the audio waveform to distinguish whether the four rapid shots were the same shooter or return fire from secret service.
Edit: After watching this: https://twitter.com/BNONews/status/1812327502028669328
It seems like the first 3 and then next 5 (not 4) shots were from the shooter, and there was a single sniper shot returned by secret service immediately after (some echo made it sound like a 3 round burst in the first video), with the final follow up confirmation shot several seconds later.
Remember that Trump supporters in particular have a long history of using violence to further their political aims including an attack on the capitol building with the intent to interfere, through violence and intimidation, with a free and fair election by preventing congress from counting the Electoral College votes. They've gone so far as to attempt to kidnap a political rival, but what they haven't done (to my knowledge, correct me if I'm wrong) is actually shoot one.
Considering that Trump's supporters were calling for violent retribution (https://www.reuters.com/world/us/trump-supporters-call-riots...) just weeks ago over a verdict against Trump, I think it's reasonable to conclude that more violence after a successful assassination would be likely.
Honestly, it might still happen, but I'm really hoping it doesn't. Everyone I've seen on the left has spoken out against the shooter. The left does not want violence or war. Long before this incident Trump supporters have been asking for exactly that (https://www.businessinsider.com/new-us-civil-war-wont-look-l...) and in some cases trying to instigate it. Seeing this kind of violence from the left (if that turns out to be the case, little is known about the shooter at this point) is very disturbing, but as troubling as it is when someone starts shooting at a powder keg it's also completely normal to brace for the explosion which could follow.
Am I the only one who remembers the Summer of Floyd?
Of course, it probably isn't as "interesting" when phrased that way but feel free to stick to the least charitable interpretation or phrasing you can think of if you need to.
EDIT: looks like they ID'd the shooter. Motivations are still being investigated but it appears that he's a Republican (according to state voter records). The closest thing I've seen so far to a sign that he hated Trump before the shooting was a one time $15 donation to ActBlue on Biden's Inauguration Day.
He was registered as a Republican, but he also made a small donation to Democrats. As the NYT reports: [0]
> A voter-registration record showed that Mr. Crooks was registered as a Republican, though federal campaign-finance records show he donated $15 to the Progressive Turnout Project, a liberal voter turnout group, through the Democratic donation platform ActBlue in January 2021.
State voter registration is pretty meaningless. Some people haven't voted for party X for years, but have never bothered to switch their voter registration away from it. Some people never really supported party X at all, but registered under it so they could vote in its primary (relevant in a closed primary state such as Pennsylvania)
I think we really need to hold off making assumptions about the shooter's politics were until we get some harder evidence.
[0] https://www.nytimes.com/2024/07/14/us/politics/trump-gunman-...
Perhaps motives are best left for the clear light of day.
Relatedly, the US election timeframe is ridiculous.
If a party can’t get its voters to come out - especially reluctant voters, that can make a big difference. If you are a Democrat but aren’t that keen on Biden and you think he’ll win your area anyway, you might lot bother with the half hour trip, and that might swing the election.
Trump proved in two minutes that whatever else you can say about him, he's very capable of responding well to pressure.
Unfortunately, the election was absolutely decided today.
What capability he showed? Knowing you are guarded by tens and hundreds of officers, anyone would raise a fist.
No, it would not be easy and far from common to take that in apparent stride so quickly as he did. It was indeed impressive regardless of what you think of Trump the candidate in all other regards. You saying anyone would raise a fist is absurd.
Come on, it's not like the world hasn't watched Trump's tweets in the past eight years.
Trump was unable of decisive action between 12noon and 5pm on January 6th, despite being commander in chief of the Army, the National Guard, Air Force, and all the powers that be.
He was so unable of decisive action, it was Mike Pence who eventually made the call to ask for National Guard for help.
4+ hours of inaction. And you call a fist-pumping photo-op to be the thing you care about?
Really not wanting to defend Trump here - a dictator in the making - but you should be aware of your own biases. Elections are mostly not decided on rational choices _you_ would make based on _your_ perspective and _your_ logic, any of which might have many failings.
So yes, that fist pumping photo is _that_ important and will probably get Trump a 10+ percentage points of vote, and the win, because unless the DNC pulls a rabbit out of their hat, OTOH you have an elderly tired old man with terminal Parkinson's whose own party is trying to get rid of at the last minute.
Otherwise, there's not much point in discussion or truth discovery.
Had Trump done what you have suggested here, it could have been easily construed as a coup, the real kind.
The Joint Chiefs had publicly announced 6 months prior during BLM riots that if Trump would issue such an order to the Sec. Def., the generals and staff officers of the COCOM wouldn't execute it. And that was not two weeks before investiture of the new president.
If he'd tried it, that would be a very short lived coup of the real kind.
I don't disagree with you. I merely wanted to add that whatever anybody is saying left or right, it probably wouldn't have worked had he tried an actual coup. From a rational POV I don't really understand all the brouhaha.
Compared to a lot of other situations elsewhere, Jan 6th was a minor spectacle, nothing serious (see Yellow Vests protests in France).
But instead, Trump gave us hours of inaction. Precious hours wasted during the time we needed leadership most.
I'm not planning on voting such an indecisive man into office.
You know, long after Pence authorized the National Guard units and activated them?
Shaky Trump had his chance to prove he was a decisive leader back then. He failed the test in the most spectacular fashion.
When has any scandalous Trump story damaged him? The access Hollywood tape came out weeks before the 2016 election and he still got elected.
[1] https://manifold.markets/jack/who-will-win-the-2024-us-presi...