COMAC relies on international suppliers, probably hoping that will make it easier for them to be allowed to fly outside China and then over time they can use more and more domestic suppliers. Whereas the Russians are completely cut off from international suppliers and travel, and have to resurrect their airliner projects which have been more or less dormant since the Soviet times.
I think both will be succesful over time; they have huge internal markets that can sponsor quite a bit of development cost.
They have tech for civilian aviation in their massive military industry. And just the sheer size of the country guarantees the demand.
"Buoyant commodity prices" is also known as inflation. They have high inflation despite having a federal interest rate of 18%, which is sky high.
Russia currently spend about 40% of the GDP on Ukraine war ( coming off my memory, may not be 100% accurate). That can’t be sustainable and they will have long lasting impact.
https://carnegieendowment.org/russia-eurasia/politika/2023/0...
Still an insane amount, for a war that has been obviously insane from the very beginning. But a different number, in any case.
Nazi Germany spent defense money to build defense products. The war was going to end eventually.
Like spending too much money on remote work products during a pandemic that will eventually end. It’s going to blow up.
Civil aviation there is a few hundred planes (about the size of Southwest--in total), and is heavily government subsidized.
https://www.reuters.com/business/aerospace-defense/russia-sp...
- https://aviacionline.com/2022/05/sukhoi-tests-100-russian-av...
- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E32TCdBgkoY
Also, Russia just surpassed Japan to become #4 in terms of GDP PPP (the number that matters), was recently reclassified as a high-income county and is expected to experience relatively high GDP growth, and that's even under the heaviest sanction regime on the planet x3 and after getting cut off from SWIFT:
https://www.worldbank.org/en/about/leadership/directors/eds2...
A very good based on what measurement? Operators have complained about extremely poor reliability, and there have been a high amount of crashes.
> and the MC-21 is actually a true domestic plane vs the Chinese C-919:
The MS-21 isn't domestic, it uses Western avionics and engines. There's a russified version which is supposed to be launched in 2025-2026, but it's unknown if that would happen considering it's using the Aviadvigatel PD-14 engines which are still undergoing design refinement and testing. It could literally be years before the engines are ready, so when the jet enters service is anyone's guess.
> Also, Russia just surpassed Japan to become #4 in terms of GDP PPP (the number that matters), was recently reclassified as a high-income county and is expected to experience relatively high GDP growth, and that's even under the heaviest sanction regime on the planet x3 and after getting cut off from SWIFT:
A big issue with these metrics is that they use the official exchange rate for RUB to USD exchange rate, which is entirely theoretical since it's impossible to trade the two due to the sanctions. The real exchange rate is probably much worse for the RUB, so these metrics based on the official theoretical one are highly misleading.
Isn’t the main point of PPP-based metrics that they DON’T use the official exchange rate?
You can get a lot of GDP growth if you focus your entire economy on making war materiel. It's not exactly durable growth and it doesn't really increase your citizens' quality of life.
Russia's industrial development outside of refurbishing Soviet stockpiles for war is extremely limited. Ditto for its civilian development: come on, 20% of citizens are still waiting for indoor plumbing.
GDP PPP is a useful number in comparing relatively-like economies, but here it breaks down completely.
[0]https://www.cbsnews.com/sanfrancisco/news/california-homeles...
[1]https://wpde.com/news/nation-world/san-francisco-cleans-up-b...
GDP is sort of a nonsense metric for "ability to get things done". A huge portion of that GDP are things like rents extracted via intellectual property so it doesn't tell you anything about ability to manufacture anything.
Example: California woman sends her kids to daycare a few weeks after birth and goes back to her job (high GDP), Russian woman stays home with her children (no GDP). Now wait 50 years until you only have neglected iPad kids raised by busy parents left, how many planes you building now? And the ones you manage to build? Maybe they start falling out the sky, doors coming off the hinges, that sort of thing. Maybe the engineers don't have enough of a backbone to stand up to their boss because they never really experienced secure attachment, and some people die.
I imagine it will be more geopolitics than anything else, but the EASA says 2026 is “too soon”.
Certifying a new jet from scratch is usually a multi-year endeavour, so why would it be geopolitics?
The C-Series, latest jet to be certified, took a good 2.5 years from first flight to type certification.
And the C919 hasn't started EASA certification yet.
No, it's not really a factor, because, as I wrote before: airliner manufacturers don't make jet engines. They can only get engine manufacturers to build them engines, and integrate those into their airframe designs. Of course, actually having access to modern, efficient engines is necessary to be competitive, which as you point out is problematic for Russia and China, but if, for instance, a major Japanese company decided to suddenly get into the jumbo-jet business, this shouldn't be an issue for them, provided the existing engine manufacturers have enough manufacturing capacity to provide them engines in addition to those they provide to Airbus/Boeing. So yes, being fuel-efficient is important to the end customers (passenger airline companies), but for the airframe makers, that's really determined by the engines they have access to, not really by any technical capabilities of the aircraft makers. The problem with lack of supply in large passenger jets isn't the engines (AFAIK), it's really just the Boeing/Airbus duopoly and how quickly they can build new aircraft, which use the engines from those suppliers.
I don't think it's that simple. You can count jumbo jet makers and their engine suppliers on one hand. It's not like you can go shop for a new line of engines on Craigslist, these things are designed with the plane maker in mind and production numbers planned for a decade+ ahead. Both parties have to work very closely together to produce something with acceptable fuel efficiency.
The most fuel-efficient aircraft possible would be an electric one (for the sake of argument lets assume batteries of high enough Wh / kg would exist) flying at much higher altitudes (20km+) than the current fuel and oxygen fired engines.
That definitely involves both engine and aircraft design.
Even for jet engines: an engine from the 50's is not going to cut it in terms of fuel efficiency on ANY airframe compared to current flying machines. Even if you had unlimited budget and time to design the perfect airframe for those engines.
Highly unlikely, it's not even close right now, and nothing in recent progress indicates that soon we might have batteries that are denser and lighter by a factor of 10 any time soon.
At this point the 737 Max 8 and A320 both are sitting around an 18:1 L/D. You can't really go a whole lot higher than that without affecting controllability. Things like winglets give you incremental improvements on the order of single digit percentages.
But weight savings... that's huge. For every pound you shave off, all other things equal, means the engine needs to make less thrust and the aircraft itself needs to carry less fuel.
The most cyberpunk thing I've ever seen is the international aerospace company bunkers at Beijing's airport.
Literally, bunkers. Barbed wire. Structural access control gates. Tiny one-room building.
I assumed that was the only privileged link back to HQ for information connectivity.
The Ukrainian aircraft industry was indeed interesting, but it was all about cargo planes. An-225 was a magnificent device, but it could not serve as an airliner. Neither could An-124. BTW both were designed back in the USSR times.
Not exclusively, they had the An-148/158 regional civilian airliners (and related An-178 military cargo jet). They definitely had catching up to do (the An-148/158 didn't perform really well, in large part due to issues with the supply chain which was part Ukrainian, part Russian, and the war(s) between the two complicated things a lot), but there was a good base on which to build.
> I wonder where Embraer fits in your picture.
They're the only ones that can do it, but probably won't because they don't have the capital and there's the example of Bombardier which bankrupted themselves trying to make a new short to medium haul airliner.
Part of why they had to do it is because they had so many testing issues and delays with their new design that people were not willing to bite the bullet on an unproven design.
Nope, it's not unheard of in aviation because a plane, or an engine, has a multi-decade life, over which there will be a lot of maintenance and spare parts needed.
GE and Rolls-Royce used to sell jet engines at a loss, banking on maintenance and spare parts making up the losses.
And of course, the punitive tariffs were later removed because Boeing weren't actually impacted by the C-series, dumping or not.
And to add to that, the desire for strategic airliner autonomy tends to be inversely proportional to domestic companies' chances of non-trivial international sales. There will be a few airlines and lessors that passed on the Russian SSJ-100 out of longstanding concerns about Russian supply chains (even though it had an Italian marketing JV so you didn't necessarily have to deal with them directly) that will be patting themselves on the back for making the correct decision, and presumably the Russian state picked up the tab for all the losses Sukhoi made on the programme.
I used to work at Pratt & Whitney, and trust me a LOT goes into this. We also worked with some of the Rolls-Royce guys. There’s a reason Boeing and others don’t even attempt it.
Airline became United, and engine manufacturer - Pratt & Whitney!
Modern jet engines are technological marvels of engineering with extreme complexity. And there are massive advancements like turbojets, turbofans, high bypass turbofans, geared turbofans, open fan every few decades.
Any engine manufacturer from the 1930s could and did manufacturer plane engines. Nowadays it's so complex and capital intensive there are 3.5-4 companies remaining with modern efficient designs.
204/214 are no longer built I think.
but the PS90 turbofan is still the mainstay along with D30 derivatives.
avionics is a separate question ofc
They are now being built again, because it's the only design that wasn't built with the assumption that Western providers (of avionics, specialised parts, engines) will be available and therefore it's the easiest one to manufacture with an entirely Russian supply chain. Still painful because most of that supply chain is decades old and very rusty, but theoretically possible.
Russia did design and build a few designs recently - SSJ-100, MS-21, Tu-204/214. Almost all of them used Western parts (such as engines/avionics) to speed the process up because Russian manufacturers are a few decades behind in some critical parts (like engine efficiency). That being said, they're currently trying to ramp up production on a domestic only Tu-204/214 version, but it's slow, probably quite expensive, and super inefficient.
> Japan might be able to do it, but just isn't geared up for building lots of large aircraft so it would be a huge investment to build such an industry almost from scratch.
Mitsubishi had a regional jet design in progress, the SpaceJet, which got cancelled after a few billion in R&D and years in delays.
Ukraine also had decent manufacturing facilities and capabilities with Antonov and Motor Sich, including decent recent designs and subcontracting work for other companies.. but with the war a lot of things were destroyed (like Antonov and Motor Sich factories and facilities), and their focus is mostly on drones and missiles now.
> Fuel efficiency isn't a factor because building an airliner doesn't involve building engines for that airliner, and engines determine an aircraft's fuel economy for the most part. Boeing and Airbus don't make jet engines: those are all made by Rolls-Royce, Pratt & Whitney, and GE.
Fuel efficiency is a major factor. Outside of countries big enough to prop up a domestic airliner industry with enough spare cash to compensate for inefficiency (which is a list of 1 country, China), nobody will buy a jet which is less efficient than an alternative. Airline margins are razor thin.
And not everyone can buy an engine from Rolls-Royce, GE/CFM(their joint venture with Safran that designs manufactures short-haul engines and the future open fan design) and Pratt and Whitney. The Russian UAC cannot. The Chinese COMAC got sold a decade+ old variant for their latest jet out of fear of industrial espionage (the Chinese engine manufacturers have failed at producing reliable and efficient jet engines for any application, usually relying on Russian designs).
TL;DR is that modern airliners are extremely complicated, expensive, and have very long lead times. A new design won't be making any money within the first 10-15 years of its life, which means that only countries with very developed and advanced industrial bases, lots of money, and the desire for strategic airliner autonomy will invest in them.