News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by scarmig on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:34PM (#40783341)
Interestingly:

People who received $1k/month: 44% housed

People who received a $6500 lump sum followed by $500/month: 48% housed

The control group who received $50/month: 43% housed

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by cypherpunks01 on Monday June 24, 2024 @10:11PM (#40783605)
Conclusion from Year 1 report:

While the findings outlined in this report indicate overall improvement for DBIP participants across many targeted outcomes, minimal differences were observed when comparing outcomes across the different payment groups. This may suggest that consistent cash assistance of even $50 can improve many aspects of one’s life. Or, as we heard through member checking, it was the aggregate of the whole DIBP program that made a difference for individuals. This means the trust conveyed by delivering guaranteed income, attention by community based organizational partner staff, phones and phone plans, and connections.

I think this effect is seen a lot in various psychological and well-being studies, I'm not sure if it has a name. But basically, if someone demonstrates they are interested in your well-being and stays in touch with you, it can often have an outsized positive effect on one's life, especially when connection and support have been difficult to find.

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by nradov on Monday June 24, 2024 @11:29PM (#40784157)
This is perhaps similar to the Hawthorne Effect. Just paying attention to people tends to improve outcomes.

https://www.simplypsychology.org/hawthorne-effect.html

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by Eddy_Viscosity2 on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @08:02AM (#40787445)
I was about to post the same thing, this very much sound like a hawthorne effect. Being homeless also can come with strong feelings of isolation and rejection from society which can then demotivate and be an addition source of depression. So the attention and actual sustained help can not only improve their financial but also their mental state - both are needed.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by joegibbs on Monday June 24, 2024 @10:17PM (#40783644)
So it basically does nothing at all? Just from personal observation, it seems like that would make sense - there's a group of homeless people who are homeless due to circumstance, hate being homeless, and will try as hard as they can to only be homeless for a short time.

Then there's the other group, people with severe mental illness, drug addiction, who aren't rational and are chronically homeless because they basically can't function in society. You could give them as much money as you want and it wouldn't make much of a difference. What they need is to be put in some kind of permanent care.

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by dusted on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @05:02AM (#40786152)
I thought the same, and just participating in this study (the "control group" who got $50) selects the former group.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by matltc on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @05:18AM (#40786244)
Good to see you on here posting correct takes, coach.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @05:45AM (#40786415)
> So it basically does nothing at all?

The effects on employment were much more pronounced than housing. The $1000/mo group went from 15% employment to 37%, and the $50/mo group had no change in employment at all.

It makes some sense: employment is probably more elastic to changes in financial status than housing. Just being able to afford transportation or a bit of occasional child care can immediately alter one's employment prospects.

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by lupire on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @08:12AM (#40787534)
It's amazing that employment has almost no effect on housing.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @10:50AM (#40789366)
It probably does, but it might take quite a while for the effect to show up because people need to save up first month + last month + security deposit in order to get a place.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by pintxo on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @07:32AM (#40787163)
We are lacking a comparison to those who did not get anything. As just someone taking an interest in you can have a lasting effect. So hard to say in absolute terms.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by throwaway7ahgb on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @07:57AM (#40787400)
100% and I've thought the same, bucketing all homeless into one group is not helpful.

We should target families and individuals who just lost a job and became homeless, looking for work and a place to live. Then go down the list from there.

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by fasa99 on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @08:13AM (#40787543)
> who aren't rational and are chronically homeless because they basically can't function in society. Diogenes of Sinope, a rational philosopher, would like to have a word
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by fargle on Wednesday June 26, 2024 @08:30PM (#40806101)
a very slight uptick in % housed for those who got the money in a lump sum might make sense: it's enough for first month rent + deposit.

other than that, agree. sure looks like no real effect. i wonder what % housed would be after a year for people who didn't even get $50/month? it's probably also the same. for the reasons you state.

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by oefrha on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:43PM (#40783404)
Link’s here in case it’s not clear: https://www.denverbasicincomeproject.org/research

I love how they credit themselves for “significant improvements in housing outcomes”, “an increase in financial stability and a greater ability to pay bills and reduced reliance on emergency assistance”, and “substantial cost savings in public spending and a large reduction in public service utilization” even for the $50/mo group.

Makes me wonder why they don’t have a Group D receiving nothing, or if they had one but decided not to publish results on that. (Yes, I know it’s hard to get people to participate if you give them nothing. Maybe delayed payment could work.)

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by scarmig on Monday June 24, 2024 @11:00PM (#40783941)
There's another tidbit I noticed that I missed before: at the time of enrollment, 6% were housed for the first and second group, 12% for the control. Presumably those already housed would be more likely to be housed after a year than someone homeless, so the effect size may have been larger. Who knows if it's distinguishable from noise--the "quantitative" report indicates some minority of effects are statistically significant.

I feel like it's possible to design a much better experiment than this. But my overarching concern is that I don't trust activist studies on homelessness issues, been burned too many times taking them at face value.

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by karaterobot on Monday June 24, 2024 @11:33PM (#40784188)
That last bit is by far the most interesting part. It should be the headline.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by thefourthchime on Monday June 24, 2024 @11:37PM (#40784212)
Totally anecdotal, but my wife and I visited Denver last year, there are certainly plenty of people still homeless.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by prisenco on Monday June 24, 2024 @11:41PM (#40784235)
This was a pilot program with only 800 participants.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by throwaway7ahgb on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @08:08AM (#40787498)
Unpopular opinion: There will always be some amount of homeless in the US. No matter how much money, housing or healthcare we provide.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by vinyl7 on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:35PM (#40783355)
The real question is how are they finding housing for less than $500 a month?
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by jncfhnb on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:56PM (#40783491)
The $500 might have enabled finding a job
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by fwip on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:38PM (#40783369)
They likely had either supplemental sources of income or additional assistance.

E.g: If you have $500/month, you can afford to pay your buddy $200/month to crash on his couch. Now you have reliable access to a shower, an address to put on your resumes, a bit of cash to thrift a suit/dress clothes and a beater laptop, and it's way easier to get a job.

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by bongodongobob on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:42PM (#40783398)
Like the person below said, it doesn't mean you found housing. It might mean you were able to buy a pre pay phone, gym membership, PO box, bus pass, decent pair of clothes, haircut, etc.

Most of the jobs in the world don't rely on Zoom interviews and email. You'll get a phone call and have to physically go interview with someone. Really hard to hide looking and smelling like a mess in that scenario.

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by miki123211 on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @02:42AM (#40785226)
Why would a gym membership be on anybody's priority list? is this a US thing?
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by walthamstow on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @02:44AM (#40785239)
It means somewhere to shower in the absence of a home.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by andrewchambers on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @03:25AM (#40785506)
Very cheap 24 hour place to shower and use the bathroom.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by throwaway7ahgb on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @08:05AM (#40787471)
There used to be stories on HN where kids in SV earning good jobs would stay "homeless" and shower at Google type offices or a gym. It's a thing.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by red-iron-pine on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @11:46AM (#40790029)
* showers. many gyms often have soap as well. the Golds Gym I used to go to had that, albeit it mostly handsoap dispensers (with handsoap) in the showers. but it was enough in a crunch if I forgot my own body wash

* lockers. most places claim "24 hours only" but aren't so great about that, and many will let you rent lockers for 24/7 storage for trivial money.

* decent toilets, sinks, mirrors. it's hard to shower, shave, and shit in a gas station bathroom.

* you can wash clothes. gyms with a pool often have drying equipment (like the little centrifuges for bathing suits). also saunas and blowdryers. like if you only have 3 pairs of undies, you can give 2 of em a good wash and spin them mostly dry, then hang em in a locker.

* 24/7 access. hang out or workout at night, and then quietly grab a nap somewhere (mostly) secure. clean your gear, take a shower, get right, without a ton of people around. hit a couple of reps for arms and shoulders while you're at it.

* most gyms I've been to often have powerbars or other cheap meal replacements / proteins in vending machines as well, which may be your only option if you're down to < $5 a day for food

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by frustratedlazy on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:43PM (#40783405)
That's not crazy in Denver :). I saw a place which was 850$ a month (literally this month), and it was in a decent location, and relatively large. I totally believe you could find something small and cheap for 500.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by bongodongobob on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:51PM (#40783460)
Yeah, it's crazy in Denver... wtf are you talking about? Avg is like 2k. Browse craigslist. Denver has been hot for years. I live in a 100k Midwest town and 500 is crazy here.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by Retric on Monday June 24, 2024 @11:37PM (#40784214)
Average says little about the minimums. At my first job one of my coworkers was splitting a 2 bedroom apartment among 8 working adults while I was the fool putting most of my paycheck into a 1br apartment.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by ojbyrne on Monday June 24, 2024 @11:43PM (#40784251)
Maybe they know some of the other people who got money and they’re sharing an apt.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by dsauerbrun on Monday June 24, 2024 @10:27PM (#40783719)
I'd imagine they mean a room in a house... or someone's basement in englewood that's in a dumpy spot.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by c22 on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @03:29PM (#40792596)
When I was in college I had a pretty sweet house-sitting gig with a guy who was out of town for a lot of the year operating commercial research vessels. He paid me $250/month to watch the place while he was gone, take care of his dog, water the plants, etc. When he was in town I paid $250/mo to rent my room, but since most years he was gone for 5-8 months my net cost was <$0.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by lolnotuse on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @02:20AM (#40785092)
I hate that it is interesting.

”Logic” tells me a 20x monthly income increase would lead to more than a 1% increase in housed population.

6.5x more than _that_ only led to a 5% increase in housed population.

Sigh. Everything sucks, doesn’t it?

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by throwaway7ahgb on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @08:04AM (#40787461)
Why do you hate it it, because it goes against your preconditioning? I'd be happy to have new information.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by echoangle on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @08:08AM (#40787499)
They hate the fact, not that they know it. They would prefer the “boring” option of more money leading to much better outcomes compared to the surprising results that are actually true.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by more_corn on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @11:10AM (#40789617)
I think this just means start with $50 a month to get the first tranche, test other interventions for each subsequent group (maybe mental health support, a fixed mailing address, job training)

It’s just evidence. You wanted a clean solution and you got evidence that the thing you thought solved the problem doesn’t have the effect you’d like.

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by Timshel on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @03:21AM (#40785473)
As far as I'm aware Denver homeless people do not receive $50 a month so there is no control group ...
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by beAbU on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @04:27AM (#40785919)
So either:

A) 1K/month (or the equivalent thereof) is not nearly enough to really make a difference in terms of increasing prospects to finding housing and the 3 groups could have just as well received $50/$51/$52 a month for all that it's worth. Or,

B) There's a roughly ~50/50 split of people who do not want to be homeless, who will do whatever they can do get themselves housed, and the other group that just don't care/unable/unwilling to find housing regardless of money, as the money will be used for other things in stead of finding housing.

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by noobermin on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @04:28AM (#40785931)
Why wouldn't a control be a group of people given no money?
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by washadjeffmad on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @07:17AM (#40787035)
I'm sure they've already collected data on people they've given no money to. The null hypothesis was that "support" as given provided material benefits irrespective of an amount of cash given.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by recursivecaveat on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @05:36AM (#40786346)
You have to pay them something to show up, answer questions, fill out journals, etc. Otherwise participation rates will be super low and very biased.
Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by red-iron-pine on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @11:37AM (#40789928)
esp. for the homeless, who don't have the means, energy, or motivation, to schlep across town to do questions.

some might have a cellphone, but why bother answering questions for someone who isn't going to help you?

Re:Denver gave homeless people $1k/mth. Year later, nearly h... by rrrrrrrrrrrryan on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @05:38AM (#40786366)
It's probably the minimum amount to keep them engaged in the study.