News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by BJones12 on Sunday June 23, 2024 @05:35PM (#40770771)
> A Birkin bought at auction in 2010 would sell for around 50% more today... Hermès’s own stock has been a much smarter investment than the Birkin, rising more than 20-fold since 2010.

The more time goes on the more I think a good rule would be "however much I spend at the company, spend on the company (in shares)". I look at my Spotify sub, my MSFT sub, and an Apple IIgs sitting in a box and wonder 'what if'.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by GrantMoyer on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:36PM (#40771199)
The Efficient-market Hypothesis[1] posits that someone with more resources than you has already made a similar analysis, so the prices of those shares already reflect the true value, including the value of potential future returns. Lucky for you, all those stocks are probably represented in large index funds, which are much less volatile than individual stocks.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Efficient-market_hypothesis

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by WorkerBee28474 on Sunday June 23, 2024 @10:00PM (#40772158)
The thing about hypotheses is that they can be either true or false. And seeing NVDA triple in the past year, even while there are many people devoting their working lives just to do financial analysis of the stock, tells us the hypothesis is false.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by Iulioh on Monday June 24, 2024 @02:24AM (#40773040)
The Nvidia situation wasn't predictable as they sell an unique item with pratical applications.

There are no alternatives to Nvidia GPUs if you want to efficiently train an AI, they have an effective monopoly.

Personally i would have invested in TSMC/ASML or Intel as this point. Buy the shovel maker.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by bluecalm on Monday June 24, 2024 @02:47AM (#40773127)
NVidia make those things for quite some time you know? They also have done heavy investments in software side and had total dominance there for years. It's not like your needed to know 10 years ago.

>>TSMC

Relatively low margins, few good well negotiating customers. Can't grow fast.

>>ASML

What do you think market could have missed there? Good company with simple business model. Very unlikely to grow fast.

>>Intel

Terrible company with long track record of stupid decisions and deception. What make you think they will suddenly turn around and start innovating?

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by Iulioh on Monday June 24, 2024 @05:05PM (#40780763)
Good points but they have the fabs.

That's why my bets are on them.

Everyone is reliant on ASML and unlikely to change.

Intel has fabs and is too big to fail, the us government won't let it happen.

I'm making a safe bet on the long term, not a speculative one based on a technology that will or won't be worth that valuation.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by michaelt on Monday June 24, 2024 @03:15AM (#40773278)
I share your skepticism, but the EMH doesn't mean stocks would never move in price.

After all, if it's election day, my analysis says FooCorp is worth $50 under a Biden administration and $100 under a Trump administration, and the candidates are neck-and-neck, that means the shares are worth $75. But tomorrow the shares will have either gained or lost $25.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by WorkerBee28474 on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:08PM (#40780117)
Yes, that is true.

But as detailed recently in Going Infinite, Jane Street's losses around the 2016 election were because they didn't know outcome was worth the example $50 and which was $100.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by hiAndrewQuinn on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:21AM (#40773618)
It's not that kind of hypothesis. It's more like a mathematical proof, with some underlying assumptions that aren't actually true in reality.

Figuring out which ones, and to what extent, is an unorthodox but effective path to wealth.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by _gmax0 on Monday June 24, 2024 @02:30AM (#40773059)
Cue the classic joke:

A finance professor is walking across the University of Chicago campus with a student. They come upon $20 lying on the ground, and the student leans down to pick it up. The professor said, “Don’t bother. If it was really there, somebody else would’ve already picked it up.”

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by throwaway2037 on Monday June 24, 2024 @10:29PM (#40783741)
It does make you wonder: What do economics professors buy in their stock portfolio?
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by 55555 on Monday June 24, 2024 @02:52AM (#40773147)
You should read that entire wikipedia article because the EMH is useful but clearly extremely false.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by underlipton on Monday June 24, 2024 @12:39PM (#40778151)
John Harvard statue of a comment.

1) Someone with more resources than you has different aims and incentives than you; the prices of those shares likely reflect their valuation, not a "true" value.

2) Because of 1, the the future returns that are reflected in the price of the stock are not necessarily for the company alone, but also of future returns of other companies and ventures that are connected to the stock in question through this hypothetical someone.

3) Volatility is good if you're poor. I want my money with a winner before everyone else knows it's a winner. Index funds are slush for smart money's liquidity scams.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by samatman on Monday June 24, 2024 @12:47PM (#40778240)
The Efficient-market Hypothesis has been proven to be true only if P=NP.

https://arxiv.org/abs/1002.2284

What's your bet on the latter? I'm... skeptical.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by GrantMoyer on Monday June 24, 2024 @01:59PM (#40778914)
I'm skeptical of that "proof". Specifically, for example, one of the first statements in the proof says:

> We ask our question, call it question 1: “Does there exist a strategy that statistically significantly (after accounting for possible data mining) makes money (after accounting for transactions costs)?” An answer to that question essentially tests each of the possible 3n strategies.

which is non-sequitur. It's like asserting the only way to find the shortest path between two vertices in a graph is to exhaustively check every path, because waves hand.

Also note that paper doesn't appear to have undergone any form of peer review.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by PaulRobinson on Monday June 24, 2024 @05:24PM (#40780974)
If the Efficient-market Hypothesis was true, it would not be rational to buy (or sell), any stock, commodity, currency or other investment vehicle as an investment alone. Yet plenty of professionals and amateurs do, and many make a profit, which suggest the hypothesis is not provably true.

One way to think of trading is you're kind of in a ponzi scheme. Not an illegal one, but you're buying stock today you're hoping somebody else will buy off you at a higher price one day in the future. If you short a position, you're hoping that somebody will sell you stock at a lower price than it is today for some reason.

All of this suggests to me that markets are not the perfectly rational machines people insist they are. Sure, most people would do better to buy and hold indexes than to time trades on individual stocks (by a long margin), but the argument that all value is priced in all of the time is just daft.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by GrantMoyer on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:23PM (#40783266)
> If the Efficient-market Hypothesis was true, it would not be rational to buy (or sell), any stock, commodity, currency or other investment vehicle as an investment alone.

This is not an implication of the efficient-market hypothesis. The efficient-market hypothesis implies no investment strategy can have expected returns greater than the total market, but says nothing about what the returns of the total market actually are.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by PaulRobinson on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @07:44PM (#40794992)
If you don't have expcted returns greater than the total market, you should not trade.

Your argument seems to be "yeah, assume there is no value or edge, and let's just hope for variance in our favour" is what the majority of professional traders, funds, quants, and so on are all doing. If that isn't what you meant, I'd be interested in how you clarify it: what do you think they're doing, and why?

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by parhamn on Sunday June 23, 2024 @05:47PM (#40770863)
Thats a good idea. Portfolio of your own verified consumer sentiments.

Quick check: iPhone 1 was $500 at launch. Apple shares were $5, apple stocks 41x'd since. If you bought the same amount in shares you'd have $20k, not bad.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by fbdab103 on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:43PM (#40771246)
That seems like cherry picking winners knowing that Apple roughly ends up on top. If your stock basket resembles other home purchases, you are going to see more modest returns.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by vineyardmike on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:17AM (#40773603)
I happened to buy a blackberry instead of the original iPhone. I can confirm that this is cherry picking.

My 2007 GE kitchen appliances for my new home funded with a WaMu mortgage may are similarly unimpressive as investments in 2024.

(And cherrypicking history is easy!)

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by OJFord on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:44AM (#40775977)
And even if you did it properly, you're basically guaranteed to be overweight on luxury 'consumer discretionary' sectors because you have the surplus cash to do this, making the 'consumer defensive' part an inherently modest portion of your budget and therefore portfolio.

And your mortgage probably makes you wildly over/under (but not correct) weight on residential real estate according to whether you consider it a payment you need to reflect in your portfolio or a part of your portfolio and therefore it's mising a justifying expenditure.

And you'd presumably have no exposure to industrial real estate, defense, anything b2b, ...

But it's a fun idea and I'll admit to similar irrational thinking when I was annoyed by Amex charging (and refusing to refund) me and my wife separately while I was in the middle of trying to talk to them about merging them/closing one. (Which reminds me, must do that soon before it happens again..)

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by amelius on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:03PM (#40770982)
Does not scale. If everybody followed this rule ...
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by Retric on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:11PM (#40771033)
> If everybody

You can absolutely guarantee everyone isn’t going to follow that rule so why bother considering it? Also, nothing says you need to keep investments forever, a rolling fund where after X months you sell the stocks and repurchase based on current spending habits could work just fine at scale.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by jncfhnb on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:23PM (#40771113)
If “everybody” continuously purchased the same stocks then those stocks would be precisely the ones you would want to buy

The price of other stocks would plummet from low demand

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by lovethevoid on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:42PM (#40771240)
Stock price isn't based on demand, so no that wouldn't work the way you think it would. These same stocks would be overvalued, with no fundamentals backing them as everyone wouldn't be buying the products/services to create those fundamentals.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by jncfhnb on Sunday June 23, 2024 @08:24PM (#40771757)
Stock price is 100% based on demand and nothing else (well aside from new issuances or splits).

Demand is ideally a function of fundamentals.

The stock price being overvalued is irrelevant if “everyone” is buying it. This is a hyperbolic example but it plays out in the valuation of the sp500 when legions of folks just dump into an index fund.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by teruakohatu on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:08PM (#40771018)
Also, Apple shares also do not replace the functionality of a phone, so the true opportunity cost of buying a premium phone instead buying a cheaper phone and spending the remainder on shares.

Nobody bought a iPhone because they thought it would appreciate in value.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by samatman on Monday June 24, 2024 @12:46PM (#40778222)
It isn't nobody, as evidenced by the continued existence of new-in-box original iPhones, which sell at auction for nosebleed prices.

The trick is to identify products which will be considered iconic, while they're still on the market. This is crystal-ball-gazing, and that kind of game isn't for everyone, but it only takes one smash hit to make a profit on the total investment. There are certainly people who do this as a hobby / side hustle.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by rch on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:15PM (#40771056)
Everybody is more than welcome to buy into my long positions.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by user90131313 on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:39PM (#40771224)
what if they followed the Apple stock advice in movie Forrest gump? They would have millions already.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by posix_monad on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:36AM (#40773695)
Vast majority do not have the disposable income to invest in stocks.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by jayd16 on Sunday June 23, 2024 @08:30PM (#40771798)
You'd probably have far more Nestle, Ford, Kellogg's, Nike and AT&T stock this way too. Apple is on the far far end of successes with this strategy.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by number6 on Monday June 24, 2024 @03:37AM (#40773409)
And you would end up with an MSCI World Index - I recently invested in Intel rather than AMD or NVIDIA. In hindsight, NVIDIA would have been the better choice. I also have some money in Index Funds - half a year ago it composed mostly of Apple, Microsoft and Meta, now NVIDIA is on top of the composition.

The lesson for me: I don't know enough of the industries to base any financial decision on it.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by dboreham on Monday June 24, 2024 @10:27AM (#40776472)
You were following logic, so NVIDIA made no sense, since they're basically a meme stock now.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by distances on Monday June 24, 2024 @11:56AM (#40777616)
This has been my long-time takeaway too. I see the opportunities as obvious only in hindsight, it does not appear to me to invest at the time. Then again, that has probably saved me from quite many bad investments too.

3D cards, web, smartphones, search, social media, CPU advances, chip manufacturing and shortages, blockchains, AI, the list is endless I suppose. Like most here, I've read about them all from the early demos all the way to the mass adoption.

I'm very happy to invest in index funds and observe tech only from the tech point of view, without stressing about picking the winners.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by throwaway2037 on Monday June 24, 2024 @09:35PM (#40783351)
MSCI World Index is much worse for historical performance compared to S&P 500. I would guess that half the profits of companies in the S&P 500 are international. There is little need to directly own companies in developing economies, when you can own their safer counterparts from developed countries that do a lot of investing in developing economies. This is probably true in the US, Europe, and Japan.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by dboreham on Monday June 24, 2024 @10:26AM (#40776459)
I did this (bought Apple stock at iPhone launch). I did it for a non-standard reason -- I'd worked around the telephony space and found it amazing that Jobs had been able to persuade AT&T to a) not charge $100/mo for data service and b) not lock down the device. That was such an incredible feat that I felt they were going to sell large numbers, because the greed of the telcos had in my mind been the impediment to the success of older similar devices. It had nothing to do with all the normal Apple-fan stuff.

Of course I subsequently sold when I felt Apple had jumped the shark (I think they were making iPods in multiple colors, something like that). Around 2012 probably.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by randerson on Monday June 24, 2024 @10:48AM (#40776722)
In that particular example, an unopened iPhone 1 sold at an auction last year for $190,000, a 380x return!
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by jliptzin on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:35PM (#40771189)
Essentially that’s what I do. I’ve made more on company shares than what I’ve spent on the companies’ products, including Tesla. This is especially true for Costco and Apple.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by nimish on Sunday June 23, 2024 @05:42PM (#40770815)
Shares do nothing except gain or lose value. The other stuff can actually, you know, do things! Some people value the ability for things to do other things.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by paulcole on Sunday June 23, 2024 @05:59PM (#40770955)
I think it’s not buying the shares “instead” of buying the thing, it’s also buying the shares and the thing.

Because yeah, not buying things you want to watch your money high score go up is a pretty sad way to go through life.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by lotsofpulp on Monday June 24, 2024 @11:08AM (#40776940)
An expensive bag or watch “does” nothing different than a less expensive one, so it is not functionally different than a share in that its purpose is to gain or lose value, so the owner can show off.

Except a publicly traded share is much more liquid.

An expensive watch does even less than less expensive watches, especially smart watches.

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by Frummy on Sunday June 23, 2024 @06:15PM (#40771057)
Yeah I figured Id do that after watching a video of a summary of ‘one up on wall street’. I bought tons of stock in my newest favorite energy drinks brand as well as my favorite nicotine pouch brand. i sold after half a year because it went down slightly. Now, the energy drinks stock has tripled, and the nicotine pouch company got sold and went private, buying out all stock for a lot higher as well.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by xwolfi on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:29AM (#40773654)
But if everyone does this, companies have no client and only shareholders. Like GME.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by Temporary_31337 on Monday June 24, 2024 @04:30AM (#40773661)
A much better strategy is to just buy an index for the equivalent amount every time you decide on a disposable / luxury purchase. That way there is no guilt about being able to afford it and generally you hit your savings rate etc.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by rsynnott on Monday June 24, 2024 @08:25AM (#40775192)
I mean, on average you would expect this to be true if only because the markets tend to go up, whereas the value of an actual item tends to go down.
Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by TacticalCoder on Monday June 24, 2024 @12:13PM (#40777847)
> The more time goes on the more I think a good rule...

That's my main investment rule. I invest in companies who's products I like and own. But then I also buy the dip. So when a company I like/whose product I use is at a discount, I invest.

It makes me feel better too when I buy something from them: "oh, some of that money I just paid is going back to me"!

There are people here who bough NVDA at a bargain with the same reasoning.

I did an exception for Meta (no FB, no WhatsApp, no instagram: all the Meta CIDR blocks are blocklisted by my firewall and all the Meta domains are blocked by my DNS resolver: that's how much I hate that turd) which I hate with a passion because the stock at $100 in 2022 (was it 2022?) was just too good to be true. But then I do use React so there's that!

Re:The unusual economics of the Birkin handbag by ragazzina on Tuesday June 25, 2024 @06:30AM (#40786693)
>There are people here who bough NVDA at a bargain with the same reasoning.

There are people here who bough Blackberry, Kodak and Blockbuster at a bargain with the same reasoning.