News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by aurareturn on Monday June 17, 2024 @10:12PM (#40713436)
There are also humans who can’t conjure up an image in their head. Mozilla cofounder wrote a fairly famous piece about his own experience.

https://www.theverge.com/2016/4/25/11501230/blake-ross-cant-...

If there are people who can’t picture and people who don’t have an inner dialogue, I think it lends more credence to the idea that we don’t have free will and are just a bunch of chemicals controlling our behavior. It also makes you think about consciousness and whether it’s even real.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by thfuran on Monday June 17, 2024 @10:28PM (#40713514)
>If there are people who can’t picture and people who don’t have an inner dialogue, I think it lends more credence to the idea that we don’t have free will

That seems like a bizarre leap. What's the connection?

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by aurareturn on Monday June 17, 2024 @11:29PM (#40713807)
Because it implies that we only behave based on how we feel, not how we think. The thinking part is an illusion. Therefore, our “consciousness” has no effect on how we behave.

I’m not willing to die on this hill by the way so if someone else comes along and argues otherwise, I’m open to other ideas.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by MeImCounting on Monday June 17, 2024 @11:41PM (#40713857)
Thinking isnt even a path to "free will". Thinking is pretty clearly determined by exterior stimulus just like feeling is.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mistermann on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:13AM (#40714013)
[delayed]
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by MeImCounting on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:56AM (#40714821)
"Clearly" refers to the obviousness or self-evidence of the statement. In this context, "just" means "similarly" or "in the same way," or ig "exactly" if you like.

"Clearly" because exterior stimuli clearly influence both thinking and feeling, a concept supported by common experience and scientific understanding of human cognition and emotions.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by poochkoishi728 on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:38AM (#40715077)
Influence != Determine
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by MeImCounting on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:51PM (#40719824)
Yes it is indeed possible that in that small and shrinking gap of behavior that isnt explained by some complex set of circumstances and stimuli there lies some magic immaterial soul that grants the ineffable quality of free will. Bbbut since we have yet to find any evidence for such a thing I wouldnt keep my hopes up. Also theres much more interesting questions to be asking.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mistermann on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:30PM (#40720695)
Might "explanations" have a (perhaps private, or semi-private) epistemic value attribute? That could certainly change the game up.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by MeImCounting on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:41PM (#40721388)
Well most of the explanations I personally am interested in have a public and therefore high epistemic value. Since they are published and repeatable. Certain behavioral tests or self-report surveys on the other hand have lower value because of the private nature of what were intending to test. They still have some value though.

Private experiences may be very important for individuals and like I said elsewhere, free-will is certainly a useful idea in religious contexts. I do not believe this has any bearing on practical matters such as our ability to predict or understand the actions taken by any given system such as humans or computers.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mistermann on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:30PM (#40723501)
> Well most of the explanations I personally am interested in have a public and therefore high epistemic value. Since they are published and repeatable.

Are you saying that these two claims have some sort of scientific ~proofs:

1.Thinking isn't even a path to "free will".

2a. Thinking is pretty clearly determined by exterior stimulus

2b. just like feeling is.

Note: a definition for "determined by" (in percentage of total causality) would be required in the specification, as would a non-ambiguous definition for "just like".

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by MeImCounting on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @09:32PM (#40723882)
> Are you saying that these two claims have some sort of scientific ~proofs

No. I think this statement is a conclusion only indirectly supported by scientific fact. This is a logical leap from more and more behaviors and internal states being correlated with various external stimulus over time. I believe it only a matter of time until it becomes entirely possible (though silly and will likely not be done because it only serves to prove a foregone conclusion and would be a unfathomably huge undertaking) to provide a complete accounting of all the factors that influence a system bringing it to the state where it reacts in a given way to some stimulus.

The only other conclusion I can see is that human beings are not deterministic and there is some magical spark IE everlasting soul making randomized decisions for us.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mistermann on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @10:38AM (#40728740)
> I think this statement is a conclusion only indirectly supported by scientific fact.

Can you expand on this "supported by" scientific fact? Is it something more than is not inconsistent with, and more towards must be, necessarily?

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mistermann on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @09:53AM (#40717896)
How are all of these measured?
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by MeImCounting on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:48PM (#40719800)
Theres actually a ton of different ways. The most obvious is probably MRIs of which many have been conducted with the subject having a huge variety of different stimulus. Then theres the good old fashioned behavioral studies ranging from the classic "does the subject jerk their hand back in the presence of heat?" to the more recent hungry judge phenomenon.

I wouldnt think the fairly self evident assertion that exterior stimulus changes both the internal state of a person as well as their behavior would be controversial.

At this point in history "free will" is really just the god of the gaps and those gaps shrink every year. Its probably a useful religious concept but as far as reality goes its the least interesting question one could ask about the whole human experience.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mistermann on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:27PM (#40720662)
Did you remember to check/contemplate whether your "measurements" are correct?

This seems like a rather recursively self-referential problem.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by MeImCounting on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:32PM (#40721292)
Im not really sure what you mean here, could you elaborate?
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mistermann on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @06:03PM (#40722576)
Well, above you seem to be describing "how things are". What if what you're describing is not the things themselves, but rather only a model of the things?

Like, where are the details of how you are "measuring" these things? And what measurement instrument returns values like "is clearly" and "is really just"? I can think of only one.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by MeImCounting on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @06:51PM (#40722922)
Still not entirely sure what exactly youre getting at here.

Yes what I am describing is my opinion which I have formed from looking at evidence. My opinion isnt really a measurement in the sense that one can measure activity in parts of a brain with an MRI. It is really just the state of the system.

I'm not really interested in abstract epistemological definitions of free will because they arent useful in the way that neurology psychology and biology are generally. I am interested in predicting or explaining behavior or observations mostly. You might be interested in that kind of exploration which is great! If you think it does have bearing on such things I am totally interested in hearing how.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mistermann on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:37PM (#40723540)
> Yes what I am describing is my opinion

Have you an opinion on whether your opinion is necessarily true?

> If you think it does have bearing on such things I am totally interested in hearing how.

I happen to believe humans have > 0 free will, and that if we do it derives from cognition, at least primarily. If this is the case, I believe that it would be advantageous to be able to exert control over cognition on demand. I also believe that doing something often requires trying to do it, and that if one doesn't think something can be done, it decreases the chances that one will try to do it, in turn decreasing the chances that it gets done.

I believe this to be > 0 "true", and that it has extremely broad applicability.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by MeImCounting on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @09:21PM (#40723820)
So yeah I dont disagree with you that attempting to exert control over oneself is a desirable thing or that it generally results in things that wouldnt have happened if one didnt work to have control over ones cognition, behavior etc. This isn't at all at odds with my deterministic view in my opinion.

I guess what I am asking is what is causing you to exert control over cognition? I would say its the sum of too many variables to count (including previous states of the system) acting on you to cause you, the system to be in such a state that that is just what it does. Given enough time and resources we could probably come up with a half decent accounting of the most important of those variables and be able to explain why the system is doing a given thing. In this example that means explaining why the system is modifying its own state in some way. What would you say is the cause?

> Have you an opinion on whether your opinion is necessarily true?

Yes my opinion is that my opinion is likely true as I believe it is supported by evidence. I would bet on it but I am not certain about it.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mistermann on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @10:52AM (#40728884)
> ...or that it generally results in things that wouldnt have happened if one didnt work to have control over ones cognition, behavior etc. This isn't at all at odds with my deterministic view in my opinion.

Can you explain how it is not? As I see it, my theory is directly breaking out of determinism.

> I guess what I am asking is what is causing you to exert control over cognition?

Consciousness (self-awareness, will & determination, etc...the "how" of which I make no claims of knowledge about). I absolutely agree that it is substantially out of our control and thus at least semi-deterministic, where we would differ (at least) is on the 100% part.

There are many problems, here are some:

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Decidability_(logic)

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Necessity_and_sufficiency

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Direct_and_indirect_realism

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cotard%27s_syndrome

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by goatlover on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @09:31AM (#40717649)
How would thinking be determined by exterior stimulus, when we all vary to some extent to the same stimulus? Behaviorism was found wanting because it didn't account properly for goes on between the ears. And the rest of the body, which makes us individuals. The idea of free will comes from the fact that people do make different choices. We make different choices than our past selves did. From a compatibilist perspective, one could say free will comes from being part of determining what goes on. Things don't just happen to us. We participate in what does happen. We're not simply puppets on the string of the external world. We're just as much a part of causing things as everything else is.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by MeImCounting on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @01:01PM (#40719913)
> How would thinking be determined by exterior stimulus, when we all vary to some extent to the same stimulus?

Because, and this may shock you: we are not all the same person

You make an excellent point that people respond differently to a given stimulus. This is explained by those people having had different genetics, environments, upbringings and even breakfasts leading up to the point of the test. It has been demonstrated that your metabolic state will vastly change your response to stimuli throughout a day.

I ate something different for breakfast today than yesterday because one sounded tastier than the other. I made this decision not because I have an eternal soul making randomized decisions like a roulette machine but because yesterday I craved salty food and today yogurt sounded better. I am different person today than I was yesterday. My gut, brain and everything else has been changed by all the stimulus I experienced yesterday and is now influencing my responses today.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mistermann on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:10AM (#40713997)
[delayed]
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by Earw0rm on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:06AM (#40714515)
Just because you're reliant on words to think doesn't mean others are.

Language certainly helps shape thoughts, even to the extent that, certainly for older kids and adults, different languages influence and constrain thought in different ways.

But consider dreams. These are adjacent to thoughts, and don't require language. Some dreamers are even able to express will not only on their actions, but over the dream itself. And if proof were needed of a conscious agent, it's there even in an apparently unconscious being.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by rightbyte on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:28AM (#40714648)
Turn it around. How would "consciousness" manifest if we behave based on how we think, not how we feel? You meed to prove the opposite too.

There is not a prerequisite of it being either or but I guess it is both.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by thfuran on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @06:24AM (#40716003)
It only implies that some people think (or perceive thinking) differently.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by card_zero on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:13AM (#40716344)
There's alien hand syndrome in split-brain people, where the verbal hemisphere will invent its own confidently incorrect explanation of "why I just did that" when the non-verbal hemisphere does something with the hand it controls. And there's Marvin Minsky's society of mind. But none of this undermines free will, it just means the will is a function of lots of components, only some of which are involved in contemplative thought (and not necessarily verbally).
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by 7thaccount on Monday June 17, 2024 @10:29PM (#40713518)
I find it hard to believe that they can't at all imagine what a tree looks like or imagine a face of a friend. I can understand some difficulty in a perfect image, but nothing?
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by BlarfMcFlarf on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:10AM (#40713992)
I basically only can see in dreams and visions, but rarely remember full images. Basically, everything in my mind is in a compressed symbolic state.

The most notable difference is if you ask me to imagine something, there isn’t any detail in the “image” that I haven’t intentionally placed there. “Imagine the face of a stranger you haven’t met before; what color are their eyes?” Idk, I can add eye color to the image, but I certainly can’t just observe it, because both before and after it’s just the concept, not like a picture I can just look at.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by Earw0rm on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:10AM (#40714541)
Same, at least 90% or so.

I'm terrible at recognising faces - changing a "symbolic" feature like facial hair or glasses will completely throw me - but great at reading maps.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by sethammons on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:47AM (#40717195)
For me, it is a picture to look at. Like a bust, I had a head and shoulders to look at. The stranger's eyes were deep brown; practically black. They were half asian half white, had black hair, palish white skin, dark eyes, a flat near-smirk. He was wearing a blue collared button up shirt with a mild jeans like texture. The sleeves were rolled up. The buttons were white.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by p1necone on Monday June 17, 2024 @11:52PM (#40713904)
I feel like I kinda have this, and I'd describe it like this:

With actual vision, there's a pipeline of steps: light hits actual cone cells -> optic nerve fires -> brain stage 1 -> brain stage 2 -> brain stage 3... where each of those stages also have various side effects associated with the experience of "seeing"

I can't synthesize "brain stage 1" at all I don't think, I need my optic nerve to send some signals to "see". But I think I might be synthesizing "brain stage 2" when I imagine seeing e.g. a red apple in a pretty similar way to actually seeing it - I can feel "red apple vibes" but there is no image of a red apple my field of view. My brain state certainly contains some data about the color of the imaginary apple and the shape of it, but it's not nearly the same as actually seeing it.

This is all astonishingly hard to explain in a way that communicates accurately between two people though.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by tonynator on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:44AM (#40714154)
Absolutely same. I wonder how much of it is most people being like this and many of those saying "well yes of course I see the apple" without really thinking about it. If someone actually sees the apple, v.s. imagining what it would be like if they were seeing it, they're hallucinating. Not that it wouldn't be cool to be able to do that on command, I just wonder how many people really can.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mkl on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @05:48AM (#40715773)
I really see it. It's not hallucinating as the imagined image is not in the real world. It's like a different input to the visual processing part of my brain (but both inputs work at once, a bit like looking at a different thing with each eye). I have visual memories (snapshots I can call up) of things I never saw with my eyes (e.g. scenes from novels) that are as strong as any that came from my eyes.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by tonynator on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:21PM (#40723110)
Can you do it with your eyes open?

Have you tried drawing a real object then the imagined one and seeing which ends up better? I've always thought that this would be a great skill for visual artists.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by trescenzi on Monday June 17, 2024 @11:08PM (#40713719)
The fun thing is that for those of us who cannot it’s as hard to believe others can conjure images. Yes the idea of mental imagery is deeply ingrained in our language but I’d always assumed it was allusion till I learned of aphantasia when I was 30.

One of the more cliche, and not super useful tests, is “imagine a ball on a table, someone pushes the ball and it begins to roll. What color is the ball?” For me that was a revelatory statement because I’d never consider that others might give the ball a color, or size, or texture as the imagine it. I assume not everyone with the ability to visualize does but it seems like many do according to the literature. To me it’s just a statement, a ball is rolling pushed by a nondescript person.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by p51-remorse on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:35AM (#40714108)
So for me I definitely visualized a ball on a table, but the color wasn’t resolved, if that makes sense. After hearing the question asked it kind of snaps out of superposition into a red color (but there was definitely a color-choosing step that happened after hearing the question).

Same thing happens if you ask “what surface is the table on” or “what country is this image in”. It’s layers I can add to the mental state, but if they’re not important they’re just not there.

I’d say the closest thing to what I was “seeing” before the color question is something like a wireframe, or maybe the gray color of a Blender model without colors/textures applied. Grey in the sense that you don’t really notice it’s grey, you just understand the grey color means color is absent.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by tessellated on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @03:27AM (#40715009)
You accurately described my experience.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by dTal on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:44AM (#40715423)
You described my experience well as well, except my abstract colorless ball was barely even visual. I was quite happy to entertain the idea of a ball on a table with very few concepts activated - roundness for the ball, flatness for the table, gravity holding the ball on the table. Rather like a physics problem.

When forced to dereference a color, it felt like an entire system was booted up. Not only did the ball have color, it also had specular reflections. There was lighting. The table gained an abstract sense of having texture.

What I find particularly fascinating is that my mind also assigned "red". I wonder if that is a coincidence, or a deep reflection of something about how brains work. Supporting evidence: in languages with only three words for color, the three colors are "light", "dark", and "red": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_term#Stage_II_(red)

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by r2_pilot on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:27AM (#40717002)
I'll also chime in and say I was able to visualize the generic ball-ness and as soon as the question of color arose, I also immediately picked red despite not being my favorite color or anything. I blame childhood depictions of balls lol
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by ambrose2 on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @05:59AM (#40715838)
My ball was kind of an indeterminate grey, too, but it was on a granite countertop of a kitchen island in an open concept kitchen/living room. Like one from a Bounty commercial or something.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by trescenzi on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:13AM (#40716348)
That’s a really cool description. Makes me think about people complaining of having unwelcome images brought to mind. Which I can relate to through songs. If someone says Baby Shark it’s going to start playing whether I want it to or not.

For me when someone asks “What color is it?” I think to myself “I don’t know you’re the one telling the story you tell me.”

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by sethammons on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:38AM (#40717104)
I imagined a small, red, dense foam ball actively being placed by a feminine hand with matching red nails and a fancy bracelet onto a white marble slab with olive green marbling. The slab is a couple inches thick and overhangs the cabinets below it. The point of view, like watching from my own eyes, is looking down at the counter with the ball being placed by the ephemeral hand as if they stood opposite me.

What color was the ball? I didn't have to think; I knew it was red. However, I can't tell you much about the cabinets or the arm or body attached to the hand. Totally unrendered and void.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by p51-remorse on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @09:32AM (#40717655)
I’m curious, what kind of work do you do? Do your dreams have that kind of detail?
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by sethammons on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @11:25AM (#40718893)
Software engineer, but I've also been a graphic designer, a photo editor, a fire and casualty insurance agent, a financial services advisor, a construction worker (very basic carpentry, electrical, plumbing, roofing, etc), and high school math teacher, all before being a software developer turned manager turned developer again. And, yeah, dreams have that much detail, but also the extra depth that comes in dreams like knowing intent, emotions, relative history, etc
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by jprete on Monday June 17, 2024 @10:31PM (#40713528)
There's a spectrum, but some people see nothing at all. It's known as aphantasia.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by AlexCoventry on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:19AM (#40714035)
I started training to develop the ability around age 10 or so. As far as I can tell, it wasn't an innate capacity in my case.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by pulvinar on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:27AM (#40714071)
It's part of the reason why discussions about consciousness often result in people talking past each other, when they start with the assumption that other humans think just like them.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by vidarh on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:57AM (#40715478)
I see nothing at all.

I spent 45 years or so thinking people were talking metaphorically when talking about picturing things, because surely they couldn't actually see things while awake?

I see things when I dream, so I know what it is like, and some years ago I had a single experience during meditation I've never managed to replicate, but otherwise nothing while awake.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by 7thaccount on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @10:07AM (#40718043)
So if I told you to close your eyes and think about your best friend's face....you cannot see ANYTHING?
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by vidarh on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @12:45PM (#40719778)
No. Nothing.

EDIT: This is a great article about Ed Catmull and aphantasia: https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-47830256

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by 7thaccount on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:15AM (#40727138)
Interesting and thanks for answering.

If you're on HN, I assume this hasn't impacted you academically?

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by vidarh on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @07:30AM (#40727238)
No reason why it would. My abstract reasoning is far above average, and for that matter my ability to draw used to be far above average, though I'm a few decades out of practice. I "visualize" what things look like and where things are in relationship to each other in the sense that I know where things are with a level of precision well above average - I just can't see it in front of me, though I know where they are and what they look like.

I use the term "visualize" because that is what I thought people meant when they said to visualize or imagine things. I remember the shape of the visual rendition of source code, for example, and that is usually the basis for how I navigate large code bases. And I know what parts of papers I last read 30 years ago look like, but I can't see them.

I think the biggest way it has impacted me is that e.g. when it comes to fiction, I find visual descriptions of things usually bore me unless the language used in itself is particularly compelling because the words themselves are beautiful to me. So I often skip and skim visual descriptions.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by throwaway920102 on Monday June 17, 2024 @11:13PM (#40713749)
Mental imagery and mental language could both be a layer above a lower more basic form of abstract thought. You might not need either to think, plan, and reflect effectively.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by rightbyte on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:23AM (#40714618)
I don't see the connection.

When I am doing math or painting I am not spelling out what to do in my head. You can probably do just fine without an inner monologue.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by pcrh on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:54AM (#40714810)
With regards to consciousness per se being real, that question was resolved with Cogito, ergo sum.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by dTal on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:31AM (#40715359)
What even is "free will"? It's an idea that falls apart on close inspection.

You think "I will wash the dishes". You wash the dishes. Ta-daa, free will!

A paralyzed person thinks "I will raise my hand". Nothing happens. No free will!

An ADHD person says to themself "I will wash the dishes". They don't get washed. A different part is broken than to the paralyzed person, but the result is the same.

A lazy person says to their roommate "I refuse to wash the dishes". Free will? They "could", if they were not lazy. Just as the ADHD person "could" if they did not have executive dysfunction. Just as the paralyzed person "could" if their spinal cord were intact.

"Free will", as a philosophical construct, is nothing more than an attempt by the ego to regain a sense of control in the face of the irrefutable realization that the universe is governed by rigid laws, and we are made of universe. (And no, quantum randomness doesn't help you - a random choice is hardly more of an extension of will than a deterministic one).

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by bad_user on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @07:15AM (#40716370)
The samples you gave make no sense.

Firstly, a person suffering from ADHD can do the dishes, despite the odds being against them. And a paralyzed person can raise their hand, given advances in technology.

And these are bad examples, as being incapacitated isn't an argument against free-will. The paralyzed still wants to raise their hand, even if they are unable at the moment. And the far more difficult question is if that want was entirely predetermined by the universe or not.

Quantum randomness and the huge number of variables at play point to the fact that believing that we don't have free-will is a non-falsifiable notion.

Consider this thought experiment: God comes to you and says ... "Here are 2 universes you can observe, one in which people have free-will, and another, that looks similar, but its people are just sophisticated automatons. Make an experiment to say which is which."

Your irrefutable argument quickly falls apart because there's no way you can show any relevant evidence for it. And it's worse than talking about the absence of God, because we experience free-will everyday. It's like talking of consciousness — we can't define it yet, but we know it's real, as we're thinking and talking about it. And a theory being non-falsifiable does not make it false. God could exist and you could have a soul.

You may or may not believe in free-will. But not believing in free-will is dangerous because it makes one believe that everything is predestined, so there's no point to doing anything, no point in struggling to achieve anything, no point in trying to escape your condition. If no free-will is possible, does life have any value at all? And that's the actual philosophical bullshit.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by vasco on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @05:13AM (#40715570)
I agree with the only caveat that the universe should have a maximum amount of precision it uses to calculate every next frame, and at the margin of error of these calculations, non-determinism may arise.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by dTal on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @05:51AM (#40715785)
Even if those assumptions were true (and why should they be? the universe is not a computer, does not have "frames") what would that have to do with "free will"?
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by vasco on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @06:22AM (#40715996)
Why should yours? It seemed like you liked musing about this topic so I added a bit.

You (and I) have no idea if the universe is or not a computer. If you don't see the connection of free will to error margin of a deterministic system then I'm not sure how else to put it. Just imagine a deterministic program getting a bit flipped by a cosmic ray and turning non deterministic and apply that to the universe's system of laws.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by thfuran on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @06:28AM (#40716027)
I'm also not seeing the connection to free will. Did the program choose to be broken by a cosmic ray? Did the cosmic ray choose to break the program? Stochasticty doesn't imply volition.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by vasco on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @06:36AM (#40716085)
It's the only way I've come up with that allows for free will, maybe other people have other ways. If the universe is not like a computer then I have even less ability to explain where free will would be possible.

Cosmic rays are just an example to explain that there's external causes of non-determinism to a deterministic system. Another example I gave above was the limit of precision of the system itself, allowing for "free will" (meaning something which isn't perfectly explainable by just the laws+starting conditions).

To me it's obvious the universe is deterministic, but the fun part is imagining ways in which it might not be. Comparing the universe to a computer is a fun way to think about it.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by dTal on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @08:37AM (#40717099)

  10 print "If the universe is non-deterministic, that provides an explanation for free will!"
  20 print "How? Coin flips don't have free will..."
  30 goto 10
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by vasco on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @09:04AM (#40717364)
We're too deep so I can't reply anymore, but I didn't say this was an explanation for it, more like a possible requirement for it. There may be other ways in which free will would be possible. Remember, I said already multiple times I start from the premise there is none, but it's fun to take the other side and try to come up with possibilities. I think you're too boring if you just take a position and never try to defeat it in your mind!
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by mrguyorama on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @02:54PM (#40720907)
>You (and I) have no idea if the universe is or not a computer.

You actually cannot just say "Man, the universe is so complicated, so it is possible it could be anything!"

That's a non-sequitur and not sound reasoning or logic.

Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by vasco on Wednesday June 19, 2024 @04:59AM (#40726320)
I didn't say it could be anything - I said it could be a computer! I don't think the universe can be a towel for example.
Re:Humans began to rapidly accumulate technological knowledg... by orwin on Tuesday June 18, 2024 @04:42AM (#40715412)
If consciousness, or rather, "philosophy of mind" interest you, and you like thinking about it, your position about "consciousness isn't real" (i simplify here) is a more and more talked about position, and the tenants are called "illusionists". Basically, they think we have an illusion of consciousness/subjective experience. Once again, poorly simplified, i'm not smart/dedicated enough to totally understand the idea and it is hard to explain something you don't totally get.