The library's copyright is intact, as normal, and they can control who uses it and how just like any other software.
The output of AI systems is not copyrightable, but the systems themselves are, and associated EULAs are valid.
Of course, they can revoke your right to use the software, but if it goes to court, that would be interesting case.
I don’t know why there isn’t more discussion on this point and people just assume there’s an underlying copyright basis to the licensing of weights. As far as I know that isn’t settled at all.
The problem these AI companies have is they live in a glass house and they can’t throw IP rocks around without breaking their own “your content is our training data” foundation.
They only reason I can think of that Google doesn’t go after OpenAI for scraping YouTube is then they’d put themselves in the same crosshairs, and may set a precedent they’d also be bound by.
Given the model is “on the web” I have the same rights as Mistral to use anything online however I want without regard for IP, right?
Utter absurdity.
Not necessarily. You consented to people reading your code and learning from it when you posted it on Github. Whether or not there's an issue with AI doing the same remains to be settled. It certainly isn't clear cut that separate consent would be required.
It'll be a court fight to determine which. Worse, it will be a court fight that plays out in a bunch of different countries and they probably won't all come to the same conclusion. It's unlikely the two licenses have a different effect here though. Either they both forbid it, or neither had the power to forbid it in the first place.
You can profit from GPL / AGPL code but just also make all your source code open source and available for everyone to see.
They have taken my code and now are dictating how I can use their derived work.
Personally I think these tools are useful, but if the data comes from the commons the model should also belong to the commons. This is just another attempt to gain private benefit from public work.
There are legal issues to be resolved, and there is an explosion of lawsuits already, but the fact pattern is simple and applies to nearly all closed-source AI companies.
[1] https://huggingface.co/replit/replit-code-v1-3b
And if I never posted my code to github, but someone else did? What if someone had posted proprietary code they had no rights to to github at the same time the scraper bots were trawling it? A few years ago some Windows source code was leaked onto Github - did Microsoft consent then?
Has anyone else done this?
I think SV is just dead set on killing the golden goose of open source and the web by extracting as much as possible with no regard for the wasteland left behind.
You are not allowed to reproduce Mistral's works (beyond the usual Fair Use allowances).
Nor is Mistral entitled to reproduce your works (unless you have licensed as such).
If it does, you can sue for copyright infringement.
The point is: nobody knows and the AI companies are getting well ahead of the law.
But what part about what I said do you believe to be undecided?
That a human can learn without violating copyright? That a machine can learn without violating copyright?
Perhaps if all rules were written in stone, and clear of ambiguity, we would not need judges or the legal process. But that’s not how any of this works.
There is some overlap, but if you think you've found some undiscovered loophole in centuries of copyright law, you're mistaken.
It will be the smartphone patent wars all over again with hundreds of lawsuits against big tech and AI companies.
We are already past the 'fair use' excuses at this point especially when OpenAI is slowly striking deals with news companies to train on their content (with their permission) and with intent of commercializing the model.
Which is a great thing.
It's like killing Caesar. As long as we all stab him, everyone is guilty and no one can prosecute us.
While you might call it absurd, I feel like these glass houses are why we've seen so much rapid progress with AI recently.
On who's code is Mistral trained?
Examples: recurring infringement from Microsoft on open-source projects, Google scraping content to build their own database, etc...
> Mistral AI may terminate this Agreement at any time [...]. Sections 5, 6, 7 and 8 shall survive the termination of this Agreement.
> licensed under the new Mistral AI Non-Production License, which means that you can use it for research and testing purposes. ...
Which basically means "we give you this model. Go find its weaknesses and report on r/locallama. Then we'll use that to improve our commercial model which we won't open-source."
I'm sick of abusing the word "open-source" in this field.
They don’t call this open source anywhere, do they? As far as I can see, they only say it’s open weights and that it’s available under their Mistral AI Non-Production License for research and testing. That doesn’t scream “open source” to me.
If you're talking about exclusively personally use, sure. If you're talking about a business setting in a jurisdiction that Mistral can sue in, not so much.
Being able to use it in a business setting is a pretty darn important part of what Open Source has always meant (it's why it exists as a term at all).
I'm reminded of the Japanese concept called Sosumi :)
> Being able to use it in a business setting is a pretty darn important part of what Open Source has always meant (it's why it exists as a term at all).
I'm quite familiar with the history of that term, but neither I nor Mistral used it. None of their models have been open source; they have been open weight. You can argue that they are actually "weight available" given the terms they write next to the download link, but since there has been no ruling on whether weights themselves are covered by copyright (and I think that would be terribly bogus if they are), I simply choose not to care what they write in their "terms of use".
That's typically called freeware, though.
This is maybe a debatable claim, but I’ll contend that without the magnificent rebel who leaked the original LLaMA weights the last, what, 15 months would have gone completely differently.
The legislators and courts and lawyers will be years if not decades sorting all this out.
For now there seems to be a productive if slightly uneasy truce: outside of a few groups at a few firms, everyone seems to be maximizing for innovation and generally behaving under a positive sum expectation.
One imagines if some really cool tune of this model shows up as a magnet or even on huggingface, the courteous thing probably happened: Mistral was notified in advance and some mutually beneficial arrangement was agreed to in outline, maybe inked, maybe not.
I don’t work for Mistral, so that’s pure speculation, but the big company I spent most of my career at would have certainly said “can we hire this person? can we buy this company? can we collaborate with people who do awesome stuff with our stuff that we didn’t think of?”
The icky actors kind of dominate the headlines and I’m as guilty as anyone and guiltier than most of letting that be top of mind too often.
In the large this is really cool and kind of new.
I’m personally rather optimistic that we’re well past the point when outright piracy or flagrantly adversarial license violations are either necessary or useful.
To me this license seems like an invitation to build on Mistral’s work and approach them with the results, and given how well a posture of openness with some safeguards is working out for FAIR and the LLaMA group, that’s certainly the outcome I’d be hoping for in their position.
Maybe open AI was an unrealistic goal. Maybe AvailableAI is what we wind up with, and that wouldn’t be too bad.
Now they just lack the means to enforce it.
How effective these techniques are and how acceptable as a proof it is is yet to be defined.
I don't think it is the case here, they probably don't really care, and watermarking has a cost.
[0] https://o565.com/content-ownership-and-licensing-agreement/
There seems to be an exclusion for using the code outputs as part of "development". But wait! It also prohibits "any internal usage by employees in the context of the company's business activities". However you interpret these clauses, this puts their claims and comparisons on completely unequal ground. They only compare to other open-weight models, not GPT-4 or Opus, but a normal company or individual can do whatever they want with the Llama weights and outputs. LangChain? "Your favourite coding and building environment"? Who cares? It seems you're not allowed to integrate this with anything else and show it to anyone, even as an art project.
[1] https://mistral.ai/licenses/MNPL-0.1.md