News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by foobiekr on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @11:57AM (#40513335)
There's some irony in the fact that people will ignore this license in exactly the same way Mistral and all the other LLM guys ignore the copyright and licensing on the works they ingest.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by nicce on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @12:20PM (#40513662)
In many countries you even can't claim copyright for the output of the AI to use license like this.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hannasanarion on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @01:30PM (#40514547)
Copyright on the software that produces something isn't the same as copyright on the output.

The library's copyright is intact, as normal, and they can control who uses it and how just like any other software.

The output of AI systems is not copyrightable, but the systems themselves are, and associated EULAs are valid.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by nicce on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @02:12PM (#40514960)
Is that so certain? To be able to make claims for what you can use the output, can you do it without making any claims for about control and ownership of the output?

Of course, they can revoke your right to use the software, but if it goes to court, that would be interesting case.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by wrs on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @07:20PM (#40518281)
If there’s no copyright in the weights to begin with, the only restrictions you have are the ones you agreed to when you accepted the license agreement. Find the weights somewhere else and you don’t have to worry about the license.

I don’t know why there isn’t more discussion on this point and people just assume there’s an underlying copyright basis to the licensing of weights. As far as I know that isn’t settled at all.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by wakawaka28 on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @07:57PM (#40518570)
I'd like to know how they think they'll prove I didn't write whatever code I generate. Unless it is a direct copy of something else available to the investigator, good luck.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by numpad0 on Friday May 31, 2024 @12:05AM (#40531382)
I think it's not important if this is enforcable, this license sounds to me like a warning that the output may be radioactive, which is where AI copyright discussions are slowly shifting towards.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by belter on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @01:31PM (#40514558)
And nobody will sue anybody because suing means...discovery....
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by aitchnyu on Thursday May 30, 2024 @05:34AM (#40521739)
Umm, are you saying its mutually assured destruction for the book pirate (AI company) and api wrapper startup?
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hehdhdjehehegwv on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @03:08PM (#40515646)
So basically I, as an open source author, had my code eaten up by Mistral without my consent, but if I want to use their code model I’m subject to a bunch of restrictions that benefit their bottom line?

The problem these AI companies have is they live in a glass house and they can’t throw IP rocks around without breaking their own “your content is our training data” foundation.

They only reason I can think of that Google doesn’t go after OpenAI for scraping YouTube is then they’d put themselves in the same crosshairs, and may set a precedent they’d also be bound by.

Given the model is “on the web” I have the same rights as Mistral to use anything online however I want without regard for IP, right?

Utter absurdity.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by htrp on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @03:29PM (#40515906)
call it an Enterprise poison pill.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hehdhdjehehegwv on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @04:13PM (#40516446)
But a pill they also have to swallow.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by dodslaser on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @05:00PM (#40516969)
Enterprise suicide cult.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by IshKebab on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @05:00PM (#40516962)
> So basically I, as an open source author, had my code eaten up by Mistral without my consent

Not necessarily. You consented to people reading your code and learning from it when you posted it on Github. Whether or not there's an issue with AI doing the same remains to be settled. It certainly isn't clear cut that separate consent would be required.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by Liquix on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @05:14PM (#40517089)
MIT/BSD code is fair game, but isn't the whole point of GPL/AGPL "you can read and share and use this, but you can't take it and roll it into your closed commercial product for profit"? It seems like what Mistral and co are doing is a fundamental violation of the one thing GPL is striving to enforce.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hehdhdjehehegwv on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @07:54PM (#40518554)
Precisely, this is such a basic violation of GPL it’s mind boggling they went for it.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by gpm on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:03AM (#40520249)
No. Either MIT/BSD code isn't fair game because it requires attribution, or GPL/AGPL code is fair game because it isn't copyright infringement in the first place so no license is required.

It'll be a court fight to determine which. Worse, it will be a court fight that plays out in a bunch of different countries and they probably won't all come to the same conclusion. It's unlikely the two licenses have a different effect here though. Either they both forbid it, or neither had the power to forbid it in the first place.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by rvz on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:34AM (#40520414)
> but isn't the whole point of GPL/AGPL "you can read and share and use this, but you can't take it and roll it into your closed commercial product for profit"?

You can profit from GPL / AGPL code but just also make all your source code open source and available for everyone to see.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by poopypoopington on Thursday May 30, 2024 @12:10PM (#40525350)
Is there an updated version of these license(s) that explicitly excludes projects from being used for training of AIs?
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hehdhdjehehegwv on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @05:09PM (#40517060)
I did not give consent to train on my software and the license does not allow commercial use of it.

They have taken my code and now are dictating how I can use their derived work.

Personally I think these tools are useful, but if the data comes from the commons the model should also belong to the commons. This is just another attempt to gain private benefit from public work.

There are legal issues to be resolved, and there is an explosion of lawsuits already, but the fact pattern is simple and applies to nearly all closed-source AI companies.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by portaouflop on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @05:19PM (#40517151)
Mistral is as open as they get, most others are far worse. Here you can use the model without issues, as others are saying it’s doubtful they would sue you if you were to use code generated by the model in a commercial app
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by mananaysiempre on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @06:51PM (#40518018)
Replit’s replit-code[1,2] is CC BY-SA 4.0 for the weights, Apache 2.0 for the sources. Replit has its own unpleasant history[3], but the model’s terms are good. (The model itself is not as good, but deciding whether that’s a worthwhile tradeoff is up to you. The tradeoff exists and is meaningful, is my point.)

[1] https://huggingface.co/replit/replit-code-v1-3b

[2] https://huggingface.co/replit/replit-code-v1_5-3b

[3] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27424195

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hehdhdjehehegwv on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @07:53PM (#40518542)
This model is more restricted than Mistral and Mixtral - this is a new development from them.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by bobthecowboy on Thursday May 30, 2024 @12:08AM (#40519979)
> You consented to people reading your code and learning from it when you posted it on Github.

And if I never posted my code to github, but someone else did? What if someone had posted proprietary code they had no rights to to github at the same time the scraper bots were trawling it? A few years ago some Windows source code was leaked onto Github - did Microsoft consent then?

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by esperent on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:16AM (#40520315)
I used to spend a lot of time (thousands of hours) contributing to open source projects. Over the past few years I've stopped contributing (except minor fixes) to any project under MIT/Apache or similar licences.

Has anyone else done this?

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hehdhdjehehegwv on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:21PM (#40526284)
Interesting, I think that’s a totally valid response to this trend of capturing “value” of open source via Cloud Services (for a while now) and Code Gen (more recent).

I think SV is just dead set on killing the golden goose of open source and the web by extracting as much as possible with no regard for the wasteland left behind.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by paulddraper on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:23AM (#40520343)
No. You are welcome to learn from Mistral's works, either as a meatbag or via machine agent.

You are not allowed to reproduce Mistral's works (beyond the usual Fair Use allowances).

Nor is Mistral entitled to reproduce your works (unless you have licensed as such).

If it does, you can sue for copyright infringement.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hehdhdjehehegwv on Thursday May 30, 2024 @03:25PM (#40527674)
This is an actively litigated and unsettled area of law. You, and nobody else, can say any of this with confidence until these lawsuits get to a judge, and even then it’s per jurisdiction rulings. The US, EU, and Japan may end up with different rulings. International trade agreements may be updated. Industry may settle on some sort of broadly acceptable revenue sharing model.

The point is: nobody knows and the AI companies are getting well ahead of the law.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by paulddraper on Thursday May 30, 2024 @03:36PM (#40527758)
Those cases are about applying these principals to specific events/facts.

But what part about what I said do you believe to be undecided?

That a human can learn without violating copyright? That a machine can learn without violating copyright?

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hehdhdjehehegwv on Thursday May 30, 2024 @06:46PM (#40529595)
Literally everything about ML training and IP is undecided.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by paulddraper on Thursday May 30, 2024 @06:51PM (#40529636)
Lol thinking those are outside the law
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hehdhdjehehegwv on Thursday May 30, 2024 @11:11PM (#40531130)
The law is interpreted anew each day. Nothing is outside the law.

Perhaps if all rules were written in stone, and clear of ambiguity, we would not need judges or the legal process. But that’s not how any of this works.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by xigoi on Friday May 31, 2024 @03:46AM (#40532448)
Reproducing is a special case of learning.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by paulddraper on Friday May 31, 2024 @10:21AM (#40535561)
No. You can reproduce the works of Shakespeare without learning them, and you can learn the works of Shakespeare without being able to reproduce them.

There is some overlap, but if you think you've found some undiscovered loophole in centuries of copyright law, you're mistaken.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by rvz on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:25AM (#40520356)
> They only reason I can think of that Google doesn’t go after OpenAI for scraping YouTube is then they’d put themselves in the same crosshairs, and may set a precedent they’d also be bound by.

It will be the smartphone patent wars all over again with hundreds of lawsuits against big tech and AI companies.

We are already past the 'fair use' excuses at this point especially when OpenAI is slowly striking deals with news companies to train on their content (with their permission) and with intent of commercializing the model.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by hehdhdjehehegwv on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:22PM (#40526304)
I think a lot of the license motivation is to have real time information for RAG. I doubt that is being used for foundation training, it’s just not enough volume.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by ximira on Thursday May 30, 2024 @09:18PM (#40530532)
The concept of "intelectual property" is crazy to begin with, you can't own a thing that is not economically scarse. Nobody owns the atmosphere, nobody owns math, nobody owns a sequence of bytes. If you can copy it, you can't steal it. You have the natural right to use their public code the way you want, as they have the natural right to use your public code the way they want. In the positivist game though, wins whoever has more money to spare on lawyers, so you lose by default even if you wanna play the legal game. The deep pockets always win on that front.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by numpad0 on Thursday May 30, 2024 @11:50PM (#40531296)
IP is cultural maximalism paperclipping. It ties ambiguous substrings not economically explained to as much of human output as mechanically possible and arbitrarily inflate importance of living humans.

Which is a great thing.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by jakderrida on Friday May 31, 2024 @01:01PM (#40537549)
>They only reason I can think of that Google doesn’t go after OpenAI for scraping YouTube is then they’d put themselves in the same crosshairs, and may set a precedent they’d also be bound by.

It's like killing Caesar. As long as we all stab him, everyone is guilty and no one can prosecute us.

While you might call it absurd, I feel like these glass houses are why we've seen so much rapid progress with AI recently.

Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by nullc on Wednesday May 29, 2024 @03:15PM (#40515727)
Five years ago it would not have been at all controversial that these weights would not be copyrightable in the US, they're machine generated output on third party data. Yet somehow we've entered a weird timeline where obvious copyfraud is fine, by the same entities that are at best on the line of engaging in commercial copyright infringement at a hereto unforeseen scale.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by esperent on Thursday May 30, 2024 @01:19AM (#40520327)
It's clear that when enough money and power is on the line - and fear that other countries will overtake them - all countries are willing to conveniently and pragmatically ignore their laws. I don't think this is any kind of surprise.
Re:Codestral: Mistral's Code Model by rldjbpin on Thursday May 30, 2024 @04:40AM (#40521467)
should it be morally ok to not follow these kinds of license, maybe except when you are selling a service without making any changes? i wonder what people visiting this site thinks about this.