Depends what you mean by complex... All creatures get born with an idea how to get food. Human babies have never seen breast or anyone sucking breast, yet they can go through the process pretty much immediately. That's a very clever movement / sensation following combination, but it's there from the beginning.
The "will suck at anything" instinct is IMHO a fall-back mechanism if for some reason a female breast is not available.
>During pregnancy, the nipple has become more pigmented 68 and is easy for the newborn infant to discover (Fig. 1C). We have observed that soon after birth, the areola expands and takes a bulb-like shape (Fig. 1G). The Montgomery glands also become more pronounced (Fig. 1G). The scent of areolar secretions has been linked to behavioural responses, such as head turning 69 and directional crawling in newborn infants 70. This release of the breast odour by the Montgomery glands is known to help the newborn infant find the nipple 17, 27, 69. The newborn infant recognises the scent of the mother's breast from the amniotic fluid 71, touches the breast and transmits the taste of the breast to the mouth (hand-to-breast-mouth movements) 17. This stimulates rooting and crawling movements in the newborn infant to reach the nipple. The connection between the taste of amniotic fluid and the scent of the breast from the Montgomery glands highlights a biological survival mechanism – a pathway of flavour with lifelong consequences. (Fig. 3) (17, 71-80) When knowing of this sensitive odour-dependent mechanism, it might be wise not to interfere with unfamiliar hands.[0]
The simple rulesets which lead to complex outcomes in nature is amazing to me.
obviously their neural networks are limited in size and therefor complexity has to remain somewhat simple relatively to larger animals).
When I was at school a million years ago "smart" kids were ones who learned to read fast, did numbers well, and had good memory recall.
Then along came computers, which had perfect memory, did numbers really well. So "intelligent machines?"
Obviously not, so we tweaked our measure of intelligence. Perhaps to include writing well, or learning quickly. Which, um, computers now do.
But we still view the computers as "not intelligent" but I'm not sure what measure we'll use now. Something to do with art or music? Hmm, no, wait, that's no good either....
(PS schools still mostly measure numbers and memory....)
It seems that intelligence is a term that we apply to people who consistently excel at the mental tasks assigned to them, no matter what those tasks entail.
We could focus on whether the student has actually understood the topic and is not just able to produce nice sounding words and some quotes about it.
More generally, how do you measure ‘actual understanding’, if not by judging the student's output?
Where did I say to not do that?
And someone who can produce a convincing essay usually has understood the topic (unless he copy pasted it). And when there are doubts, one can ask that student specific questions.
You asserted that the student should “not just [be] able to produce nice sounding words”. What do you suggest output is if not words (nice sounding or not)?
> And someone who can produce a convincing essay usually has understood the topic (unless he copy pasted it).
Then, what is the difference between a convincing essay (‘nice sounding words’) produced by a human, and similar words produced by an LLM?
After all, even today, students are passing ChatGPT’s work off as their own. Does this then demonstrate understanding by the student or by ChatGPT?
> And when there are doubts, one can ask that student specific questions.
If an LLM can answer specific questions about a subject, does this demonstrate true understanding? If not, why not?
If it could, I would say there is understanding. But in every area where I have expertise, I see LLMs failing my questions. Just like a bad student would, who memorized textbooks, but did not connect or process the knowledge in any way.
Sometimes the word “intelligent” is used by someone who sells IQ tests.
Sometimes the word is used by someone who sells the idea of a computer that can think like a human.
I don’t know if people in general struggle or care about the definition.
Good book about precisely this (and in agreement with your statement) is cognitive psychologist Steven Pinker's 2002 book The Blank Slate: The Modern Denial of Human Nature.
⸻
1. This is a theory I came up with as a high school student in the 80s so my choices of programming languages reflect that.
2. Insert obligatory Turing-completeness disclaimer here.
Primates are on another level compared to most other animals, and humans are definitely outliers, but learned behaviour is far from unique to humans.
I'm from Western Australia and spent a lot of time in its deserts in my youth.
I have a very distinct memory of walking out among the spinifex as a child, needing to pee. Its hot, my bare feet are burning, the ground is unforgiving and I already have spinifex'ed ankles, so naturally I tread as carefully as I can, trying to avoid the sand and the spikes, only walking on the slightly less heated organic mats that surround some of the spinifex, a kind of carpet of twigs and leaves, gathered in pockets by the wind.
The natural urge is rising, and I stop paying attention and get a bit of pace, as relief must be had. I see a particularly appealing area, covered by this organic dust, and I leap over to it, get my body parts aligned, and begin the process of relief.
A few seconds into it, I feel something moving. The entire mat that I was standing on, is in fact, a field of trap doors. Maybe a hundred of them. They begin to open.
I have never levitated as hard and as fast in my life.
So my Tabula Rasa has given me this lesson: don't go into the spinifex to pee. Ever.
Do we really have evidence for this rather than observation and communication from parents to offspring. I'm deeply skeptical.
That evidence is compelling and well-reviewed. But that evidence is also countered with other evidence: the debate isn't settled. But it's undoubtedly clear that a part of our intelligence and other personality traits are inherited: coded into our DNA. What's not settled, is how much.
I don't know if the parent comment represented the expert consensus correctly, but if they did, I wouldn't automatically be skeptical of it.
That does not follow. It's a logical fallacy. ('Spiders can have eight legs, so humans certainly do too.')
free will wouldn't even change that, since it's presumably also given by our genes.
Michael Levin has been discovering lately that biology is more complicated than we thought. His YT videos are mind-boggling. Flatworm genetics are a dog's breakfast that the cells work around by means nobody understands.
The same as how a bird can be scared on snakes. Interestingly native birds in Australia aren’t scared of humans.
I don't have fear of spiders (was surprised by how many people do fear spiders). When I was young, I "hosted" a bunch of them under my table. Thinking of it, I think most people have their fears transmitted through their mothers. My mom certainly didn't fear spiders but she hated their "dirty" webs.
For example I do have a strong reaction to cockroaches till this day; a harmless insect that my mother fear. I can't even look at the beast. My cousin do not and conversely do fear spiders.
They used a gentic algorithm to evolve the network, its connections and activation functions (per node).
It got quite good.
Perhaps not that surprising that one can encode a lot in the graph structure itself, and given how DNA is quite good at dictating complex organs, I don't see why something similar couldn't be at work for insects and mammals alike. After all, nobody taught the newborn kangaroo babies how to crawl up into the pouch of their mom either.
In Pinker's book The Blank Slate" in particular.
We are born blank of our mother tongue, but are wired to acquire one. Not wired with the skill itself, but with the propensity to acquire it. Both nature and nurture are deeply important to the outcome.
Though, both of these things are almost stereotypical [1]
1: https://www.reddit.com/r/ProgrammerHumor/comments/vnmmuo/whe...
- fascination with fire, - love of tools, - teenage interest in weapons.
I think about this a lot in the context of conversations about intelligence. If spiders can have complex behaviors hard-coded, humans certainly do too. (In other words, the Tabula Rasa theory is wrong.) The ability to learn language and emotion are certainly two examples. We are pretty good at certain things (learning language, picking up social cues) and relatively bad at others (calculating an 18% tip).
So if you’re going to measure “intelligence” the first thing you’ll need to do is choose what to measure. What questions do you ask? You might be inclined to pick things we humans think are important. But then that’s not an objective universal measurement, at best it’s yardstick for human cognitive abilities.