Re:Number 16 (Spider)
by ggm on Thursday May 23, 2024 @01:47AM
(#40450906)
They don't just build one. You may mean they don't learn from observation of others or from their mother. They may still acquire a sense of a better trapdoor and make better trap doors by experience. I can't think of an experiment to test the theory, but it might be around qualities like "thickness" or "wind resistance" if you could make a condition of test which put the trapdoor they do un-biassed under specific stresses.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Number 16 (Spider)
by 4gotunameagain on Thursday May 23, 2024 @02:15AM
(#40451076)
Still, even if that's true, it does not refute the point. The knowledge necessary to build the very first burrow or web, or trapdoor (which will be definitely more than good enough otherwise spiders would no longer exist) is hardcoded, not externally acquired.
I agree. An individual may develop improvement over time (43 years!) but there's no evidence of transmission across generations. Still, ability to refine might be heritable?
Isn't virtually all behavior of non-humans driven by instinct? Our learned behavior seems way more unlikely and amazing.
Are you saying that humans are the only animal capable of learning?
No, learning from parents is common for the young of most mammals and many birds, at least.
Primates are on another level compared to most other animals, and humans are definitely outliers, but learned behaviour is far from unique to humans.