News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by paulpauper on Sunday April 21, 2024 @02:56PM (#40108216)
I don't think it's a s simple as inactivity. IF this were true, then being active would reverse the weight gains, but it does not, at least not for me and others. I was still as active in my 30s as I was in my late teens and 20s but still gained weight. Likewise, gyms are full of people in their 30s and 40s who are not losing weight despite regular attendance. Despite the popularity of fitness apps, people keep getting fatter. It is only GLP-1 drugs that has put some dent in obesity rates. I think metabolism or some other biological, non-environmental variable plays some role. Or some reduction of NEAT that cannot be explained by careers.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by Macha on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:06PM (#40108276)
As a counter-anecdote, I dramatically increased my exercise at 29, and reversed the weight gain I'd had slowly creeping over my 20s, and now in my 30s am at my lowest weight ans best physical shape since at least my mid-teens, possibly ever.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by pitdicker on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:34PM (#40108526)
On average man burns ca. 2500 kcal per day, mostly in rest. One hour of reasonably intensive cardio burns 500~600 kcal. If you have two such workouts a week it comes down to an increased energy use of 2*600/(7*2500) = 7%. Or a large meal. Just looking at the numbers it seems spending some time at the gym is not going to do much for loosing weight. Or said differently: eating 7% less is easier.

Of course cardio and strength training are useful for building/preserving muscle mass and general fitness. But for weight loss looking at food seems more effective.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by paulpauper on Sunday April 21, 2024 @04:55PM (#40109165)
One hour of reasonably intensive cardio burns 500~600 kcal. If you have two such workouts a week it comes down to an increased energy use of 2600/(72500) = 7%. Or a large meal. Just looking at the numbers it seems spending some time at the gym is not going to do much for loosing weight. Or said differently: eating 7% less is easier.

Not sure about this. Herman Pontzer's work shows that the body adapts by burning fewer calories later, so your energy expenditure is the same. Burning 600 calories with exercise means burning 600 fewer later, like burning fewer calories during sleep or fidgeting less.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by mint2 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @05:14PM (#40109316)
Not this again: “Burning 600 calories with exercise means burning 600 fewer later.” No it doesn’t. That work is highly misinterpreted.

Because it doesn’t ELI5 how body mass and composition and steady vs unsteady state actually play into it, people take away a meaningless self serving interpretation.

If you start running 4-5 times a week, I guarantee you’ll be eating significantly more and burning significantly more. Unless you’re intentional about restricting your eating, weight will most probably stay the same, but you’ll be burning far more calories.

But keen eyed reader perhaps you object with “but you’ll move less and nap on the couch more, it will balance out like Pontzer’s work seems to say!” Haha, but no. Well yes to napping, but no to balancing out. It’s literally impossible. There’s no amount of napping that makes up for 13+ miles runs. There’s a lot of people who regularly do 10 to 20 mi runs on weekends. They can literally burn more calories just in the run than a sedentary person does in an entire day. And that’s their regular routine. Take a look at Boston to see 30ish thousand examples of it.

As one example, My weight has been steady state for decades, but I started running marathons two years ago. I had to start eating an extra meal. And when I take it easy for a couple weeks after each marathon, my appetite ramps down.

And if you don’t start eating more you’ll just get injured and be forced to stop running.

Pontzers work is bad. Ask any endurance sport club and they’ll laugh at it.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by Kirby64 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @06:25PM (#40109764)
I don’t think most people (besides some naive readings of that research) should come to that conclusion. The proper conclusion is that it will offset some of the calories burned by exercise through reduction in NEAT (non exercise activity thermogenesis), but not all of it. So a 600cal exercise may only have an effective net calorie addition of say, 400cal, due to reduction in NEAT.

The problem becomes when people do the naive calculation of exercise calories (Eg, I ran 2 miles so I burned 400cal, so I can eat 400 extra calories), and come to the wrong conclusion.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by mint2 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @08:00PM (#40110295)
The comment I replied to stated that was the conclusion - 600 burned meant 600 saved. So apparently the misinterpretation is common.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by alecst on Sunday April 21, 2024 @06:00PM (#40109608)
So is your rebuttal to Pontzer et al that it doesn’t match your personal experience?
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by mint2 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @07:48PM (#40110234)
So we’re focusing on the anecdotal part to ignore the part where I point out the naive reading of his conjecture literally defies thermodynamics? I pointed out it’s literally impossible for it to work for a subset of the population.

Over a hundred thousand endurance athletes in just the USA would have to literally defy the laws of thermodynamics for the naive reading to work.

I can see why the question ignored that and focused on the personal story that went along with the hard facts and stats.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by alecst on Sunday April 21, 2024 @10:08PM (#40110913)
Pontzer's work isn't about napping. It's about your body having a set point for how many calories it burns, independent (up to a factor of +/- a few hundred calories) of how much exercise you do. For most people this is true, as their work shows. It may not be true for extreme athletes. I don't think Pontzer's team of dozens of people working over ten years misunderstood basic thermodynamics. Their work clearly points to "compensation" -- the body making up for energy it burned during the day by gently lowering the metabolism later on.

Saying "burning 600 calories now means burning 600 less later" gets the point across. It's pretty much on the money for some people. For others compensation may not be total. I guess I'm not really sure where your beef is.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by mint2 on Monday April 22, 2024 @12:31AM (#40111426)
For hundreds of thousands of people it’s not true. That is not an exaggeration in numbers.

Handwaving away large numbers data points that disprove a theory is not how science is supposed to work.

And as we have seen in this thread, the lack of clarity on the nuance discourages people from making exercise.

Over simplifying it to 600 burned, 600 saved later is harmful and also inaccurate. (and yes More inaccurate than my loose choice of saying nap which you pointed out that led you to the wrong conclusions on my understanding, please consistently apply that critical standard)

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by rojeee on Monday April 22, 2024 @05:18AM (#40112646)
Also an endurance runner and read Pontzer's book. I do enough running for my wife to get pissed off! I agree with you that there's definitely more work which needs doing to understand metabolism in the context of endurance athletes. I don't think his work is outright nonsense though. Here's something to think about...

I ran 21 km yesterday, in zone 2, in a fairly glycogen depleted state. That was about 4:30min/km for 21km, with 600m of elevation - about 1500kcal of energy. I didn't eat or drink anything throughout the run. I'm a big nerd, so I took a lactate sample at the end. I didn't hit the first ventilatory threshold for the whole run and that indicates I'm burning a large proportion of fat compared to a normal person (and probably a normal recreational runner).

Afterwards, I ate a banana and had a couple of spoons of peanut butter + honey. A few 100kcal. Fast forward to the evening. I didn't eat any more than I usually would do if I had a few days off running. I went on with my day as normal and recovered fine the next day. I didn't feel hungrier than usual. Fairly standard. My body is well adapted to this kind of exertion. I think my body is quite efficient at doing every day things. I don't get out of breath walking up stairs, for example. Maybe it's fair to say I'm more energy efficient than a regular person. Perhps, I don't need to eat any more than usual immediately after running because I'm burning a high proportion of fat and my metabolism is quite efficeint anyway.

Someone who has a poor aerobic system wouldn't be capable of doing that. They'd likely be running at a much higher heart rate and bonk after 10km having not eaten any carbs the day before. They'd also likely need to eat a huge bowl of pasta afterwards just to feel OK. I suspect this person would feel like crap for the rest of the day (maybe even multiple days... Imagine.. they've likely just done a 10km at VO2max untrained) and I could completely imagine them having a nap or watching TV for the rest of the day as they'd have no energy to do anything else. Their bodies are not adapted to this kind of exertion. They are not efficient. Their body needs to rest to get back in equilibrium.

The energy requirement is the same in both cases but it comes from a different source. In my case the high fat oxidation is acting as a battery/buffer. In the average person, those fat stores are not really accessible when doing anything more than sitting or light walking. Both examples are in equilibrium but present in different ways.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by idiomaddict on Tuesday April 23, 2024 @04:08AM (#40129653)
This is mostly unrelated to the current point, but you’re unquestionably fitter than the average person. I used to dance for about 15 hours a week, and I have no idea what I actually burned calorie-wise, but it was plenty of cardio.

After about a year of dancing, I had a moment where I needed to run after someone about a half kilometer away. It was incredible- I’d never felt so buoyant while running. After I passed the message on, I decided to do a measured run. I ran a six minute mile in my late twenties with zero warm-up after having not run in over a decade. I wasn’t even out of breath, it was fucking easy. Cardio is a life hack.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by alecst on Monday April 22, 2024 @07:59AM (#40113484)
What is your interpretation of Pontzer’s data, then?
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by mint2 on Monday April 22, 2024 @11:52AM (#40115534)
First, note that my biggest point is that the way his group presented the work has led to gross over simplifications that actually cause harm when they help deter people from making changes, and the group has not gotten the word out that those interpretations are incorrect.

It’s pretty clear the effect of exercise is neither extreme. It is definitely not the naive 100% of calories burned in regular exercising are balanced out by metabolic reductions elsewhere compared to the same person not regularly exercising. And it’s definitely not 800 burned regularly means 800 mores than the person would if they didn’t exercise regularly.

It’s going to be in between, and I would wager it’s like backwards graduated tax brackets in terms of compensation percent.

It’s been a while since I read his paper, but if I recall right it actually did hand wave away the endurance athletes. But endurance athletes are not a binary yes no state andHand waving away obvious conflicting data isn’t logical or scientific. And so especially when people are on a graduated spectrum all the way up to the immediately obvious theory breakers running 60+ mi/week. Where would the cut off come? 15mi? 20mi? 25mi? Above what cut off should we ignore data to make the naive theory work.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by paulpauper on Monday April 22, 2024 @03:14PM (#40117728)
I guess I'm not really sure where your beef is.

he's being pedantic. no use bothering to argue

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by mint2 on Monday April 22, 2024 @05:05PM (#40120770)
Pontzers work shows that a 150lb male, dependent on their activity they can burn anywhere between 2000 to 3750 calories on average per day in a maintainable fashion that can go on for years. I.e activity is highly impactful to total daily caloric expenditure.

Moreover, they also showed that exercise beyond that upper limit of 2.5x the base metabolic rate is very possible for temporary durations, weeks even. The extra energy comes from stores like fat and obvious is not sustainable over years.

Even at minor increases of daily exercise for sedentary people, a regular 400 calories of exercise in one study, leads to increased total daily expenditure of around 225-250 after the body is fully adapted.

If that’s not your understanding of pontzer’s works then there is nothing pedantic about my comments. But it’s understandable if you’ve been confused because pontzer has almost willfully obfuscated the actual interpretation of his groups data. Their actual data & equations versus how they message them and explain their findings is shameful.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by paulpauper on Sunday April 21, 2024 @06:10PM (#40109668)
My own experience matches closer to Potzner's work. I see some initial loss on the after exercising but the rebound is really fast. Perhaps if you keep it up everyday there can be some long-term weight loss but it will not be continuous, and if you stop the weight will come back fast.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by throwaway22032 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @07:01PM (#40109967)
Isn't that kind of like saying that the tooth decay will come back real quick if you stop brushing your teeth?

Most people need to supplement their activity with exercise nowadays because otherwise their lives are very sedentary. It's a forever thing, unfortunately for those that don't enjoy it.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by sudosysgen on Sunday April 21, 2024 @08:50PM (#40110576)
Your weight is an equilibrium between calorie intake and caloric expenditure. Increased weight increases baseline expenditure, hence the equilibrium.

If you stop exercising, but keep the same caloric intake as before, yes, it will rebound really fast, because the equilibrium point will stay the same. If you want to move the equilibrium, you either need to do the exercise regularly forever, or reduce your caloric intake, or build significant amounts of muscle (fat free body mass) to increase your baseline. expenditure

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by throwaway22032 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @05:44PM (#40109501)
This is literally impossible. The calories exerted during exercise are real work done.

Athletes exist and are real. They are not all genetic anomalies. Most of us are normal people that got off our arse.

Literally every person who has ever tried to make a weight band is living proof.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by sudosysgen on Sunday April 21, 2024 @08:48PM (#40110566)
That's just not possible. You aren't going to be burning less calories during sleep after a workout, you're going to be burning more due to increased protein synthesis as your body recovers (unless the workout was very light).

Reduced fidgeting leading to 600 calories less in a day is not reasonable, either.

To drive this home, just look at professional cyclists : a lot of them have to eat 5000+ calories a day, because they burn 3500+ calories just training, on average, for years and years.

Additionally, if you work out more, you will increase your fat-free mass significantly.

In any case, Pontzer's work never seems to claim you somehow compensate against activity expenditure, it's actually a very strong independent variable in the model of the linked study?

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by lumb63 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:26PM (#40108461)
It is asymmetrically difficult to lose weight compared to gaining weight. The body wants to maintain homeostasis, but tries way harder when it perceives the threat to be starvation. This makes a lot of sense considering historically that conserving energy rather than expending it would probably have been a massive survival advantage.

As an example, say we are discussing someone whose average energy expenditure is 3000 kcal a day and they eat that much currently. Let’s say they start to exercise and their average expenditure rises to 3200 a day, and they start to diet, so their intake falls to 2500. The body wants to minimize that 700 kcal caloric deficit to maintain homeostasis. The person will lose weight, but by the time they’re down, say, 10 lbs, a normal person 10 lbs lighter than they started would expend maybe 2900 kcal, but they’ll be expending 2800, since their body will start to downregulate processes that expend energy to minimize the deficit. This is why when people are losing weight they might feel cold (thermogenesis has decreased), tired (mental processing has decreased), or any other number of negative effects. It’s the body going into self-defense mode.

Another factor is fat. Sadly, as weight is gained, fat cells grow, and split when they get too big. When weight is lost, they shrink, but they never re-combine. Fat is an endocrine tissue that releases numerous hormones that regulate energy balance, appetite, etc. This means that people who previously had more fat will never (without medical interventions) be “the same” as someone who is the same weight, but never carried extra fat to begin with.

This might sound like “why bother trying when there are so many things stacked against you?” but I couldn’t disagree more. Despite the propaganda masquerading as science that says “diet and exercise don’t work”, they do. Nobody is immune to the laws of thermodynamics - if more energy is consumed than is expended, weight gain results, and if more is expended than is consumed, weight loss results. The main reason all these studies are able to say “diet and exercise are a bust” is because people don’t maintain the lifestyle that reduced their weight to begin with, and usually return to familiar habits.

Luckily, our habits are mutable, and just like our body can play tricks like making us more hungry when losing weight, we can fight back if we know what we are up against. For example, caffeine is a commonly consumed substance that suppresses appetite. Staying busy rather than being idle also suppresses appetite. Not having junk food in your house/office/etc. reduces temptations to help aid healthy decisions. Having healthy food available and prepared makes making healthy decisions easier. Scheduling diet breaks or planning free meals (and calling them free meals, not cheat meals) improve diet adherence.

In my opinion, the way to sustainable weight loss is slight modifications to the environment and behaviors to nudge the system in the desired direction. Our culture is too focused on motivation and discipline and toughing out situations no matter what to achieve our ends. Meanwhile tiny differences compound and do not feel like an immense burden. It’s also worth mentioning the power of a self-fulfilling prophecy: have you ever known anyone who lost weight via diet and exercise, and said it is impossible to lose weight via diet and exercise? On the flip side of the same coin, there are a lot of people who think diet and exercise will not cause weight loss, and they’re disproportionately overweight. Believing something is possible is nearly always a precondition for achieving it. Thoughts become things.

Best of luck on your weight loss journey. You can do it.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by lostemptations5 on Monday April 22, 2024 @02:47PM (#40117470)
So you're basically saying give up! Thanks :)
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by pfannkuchen on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:11PM (#40108313)
Gym != being active throughout the day
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by tekla on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:29PM (#40108481)
Nope, people eat too much first, and secondly don't move around enough.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by meindnoch on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:08PM (#40108295)
>Likewise, gyms are full of people in their 30s and 40s who are not losing weight despite regular attendance.

Because they do shit exercises, then drive home, gorge on high-carb trash, and sit on their asses until their next gym appointment.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by BriggyDwiggs42 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:13PM (#40108336)
It’s crazy how many people lift weights trying to lose weight when they desperately need cardio.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by ambicapter on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:23PM (#40108429)
Best way to lose weight for me is eating less, and walking. Cardio makes me hungry as hell.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by 331c8c71 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:26PM (#40108460)
I'd say it's the reverse actually but anyhow the diet is essential.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by WheatMillington on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:11PM (#40108317)
That's a very judgemental, obnoxious and inaccurate statement.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by meindnoch on Monday April 22, 2024 @08:02AM (#40113515)
I know, truth hurts. I'm also overweight, but at least I'm not deluding myself.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by throwaway22032 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @03:06PM (#40108274)
Counterpoint - everyone I know who counts calories is able to either lose or gain weight roughly according to their plan.

This is borne out in essentially every sport which has weight classes at both the amateur and professional level.

Part of becoming healthy is calibrating yourself against other healthy individuals. No, not genetic freaks, just that neighbour who actually looks after themselves.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by raffraffraff on Sunday April 21, 2024 @04:29PM (#40108949)
My wife always says that her sister must have some type of "condition" that explains her obesity. PCOS, undiagnosed diabetes, etc. And I keep telling her that it's calories in vs calories out. Recently her sister got drunk with us and admitted candidly that she basically binge eats trash food, regularly eats McDonald's for dinner, and if she ever gets stomach cramps and bloating from overeating, the best "cure" is a litre of ice cream because it "helps settle her stomach". So yeah, no magic physics is happening here.

On the other hand me and the wife weigh out things like potatoes, rice, pasta and bread, eat all the fruit and veg we want and don't own a car. So we do minimum 25k steps per day, because we walk the dogs and then walk almost everywhere else we need to go, including buying groceries (which involves back-packing food about half a mile). I also run 3 to 4 times a week. Essentially, this is the same lifestyle I had when I was 18. And guess what? At 47 I'm wearing the same jeans size I wore at 18. It really is that simple.

What's hard? Trying to convince an obese lady who drives to the office, sits on her ass for 8 hours, eats chocolate bars and McDonald's for lunch and is too tired to use the gym, that her weight is 100% down to her life choices, and not magic.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by throwaway22032 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @04:40PM (#40109041)
I hear you. When I was younger I used to try and convert everyone around me (if you want X, do Y). Back then it was personal finance stuff.

Now I just don't bother. My conclusion is that it's just some form of depression, learned helplessness, whatever. There are an infinite number of reasons why you or they are a special case. I don't let it get me down any more.

For what it's worth I don't think my lifestyle is at all "hardcore". I have a number for calories and protein that I try to hit, and I have numbers for lifts and cardio that I try to increase. That's it. I have a car, I eat fast food, I drink on nights out etc.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by nrdxp on Sunday April 21, 2024 @05:06PM (#40109256)
A lot of people put minimal possible effort in at the gym or other kinds of exercising.

I often see people "jogging" that are basically just walking with a bit of a skip, for example.

I believe this is correlated with diet, which most people think is just nutrition, but it's a lot more complex now. There are petrochemicals and toxins in basically everything, avoiding them is expensive and incredibly difficult and you will still inevitably be exposed. There are many of these chemicals that have been shown to have a direct correlation to slow metabolism, so it can make it seem to make everything more difficult if you are consuming large quantities of say, glyphosate.

Most people also don't realize that the bioavailability of food is important. Probiotics, enzymes, etc are usually completely dead or stripped by the time they reach your mouth after the highly processed pipeline.

Another note, there are literally thousands of micronutrients that we barely know anything, so that's also another variable. This is also just not looked at often, so you have to actually know to look to even understand their are natural compounds that may be useful, and then you have to deal with the quality control problem in the industry, and find a reliable, preferably third party tested supplier.

And also just discipline, which is harder when you don't have good nutrition, or your body is constantly processing mass amounts of toxic material. It also just requires willpower though, and applying it will build will to wade through the complex landscape of not poisoning yourself constantly. If you want to get ahead, you are gonna have to push yourself to an uncomfortable position.

Most folks would rather walk for 2 hours than do sprints for 5 minutes, even the the later has been shown to have significantly more effect on your metabolism, and requires much less time.

So in a way I agree, it's not as simple as just activity, it is moreso intentional activity at a level that is just above your comfort zone enough to make consistent progress, and hopefully you can do that without constantly consuming mass amounts of toxins that makes that whole process harder.

Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by mint2 on Sunday April 21, 2024 @05:37PM (#40109457)
2 to 3 hours in a gym, (especially casual weights) does not even come close to scratching the surface of all the reduced activity that comes with office jobs, commutes and screen oriented amusement.
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by lotsoweiners on Sunday April 21, 2024 @11:03PM (#40111116)
2-3 hours how often?
Re:It's not your age that's slowing your metabolism, new res... by red-iron-pine on Monday April 22, 2024 @04:55PM (#40120454)
presumably daily