News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by gherkinnn on Thursday April 11, 2024 @01:28AM (#39998681)
The whole idea of a linear city is daft. A circle is way more efficient at getting around. The dimensions of the Line are, of course, silly as well.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by meindnoch on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:27AM (#39999743)
A circle is still one-dimensional, so it's only a tiny bit less brain-damaged than a line.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by bdjsiqoocwk on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:54AM (#39999955)
I'm pretty sure they meant disk, and they have a point.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by romanovcode on Thursday April 11, 2024 @06:13AM (#40000505)
> disk

So, basically a regular city.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by pndy on Thursday April 11, 2024 @02:30AM (#39998994)
Of course it is - this is clearly prince's personal ego stroking project and wall placed across nearly the whole province looks adequate than just some 'boring' circular megacity
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by leoedin on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:06AM (#39999581)
Yeah, I'm really struggling to understand why a linear city is appealing. I suppose if you set a hard limit of one train line in your city, then building it along that train line might make sense.

You'd spend a lot of time on that one train line though - and I imagine in the central bits it would get really really busy as people are trying to get to the other end. And what happens if that train line breaks?

Making a city circular takes advantage of geometry - even at the cost of having to build more than one train line. It also opens up the possibility of other forms of travel - buses, bikes, cars.

It doesn't surprise me that this is starting to fall apart. When it was announced it seemed completely unhinged.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by arethuza on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:16AM (#39999670)
"I'm really struggling to understand why a linear city is appealing"

Probably because it looks cool in CGI renderings and nobody else has one, for reasons that are probably becoming apparent to all involved.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by keiferski on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:44AM (#39999866)
I don’t know if this applies so much to Neom, but I can think of many scenarios in which a linear city is more appealing than a circular one.

For example - if there is a natural element like a river, lake, canyon, etc. that you want to maximize city exposure to. A linear city roughly following the Grand Canyon would be infinitely more interesting than a circular one situated at one end of it.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by Moldoteck on Thursday April 11, 2024 @06:05AM (#40000439)
in the end it'll still be 'disk like'. You build along the river, distances are getting big and suddenly you realize there's a lot of unused space where you can expand the building of the city while maintaining short commute time(building perpendicular to the river/expanding the width of the city), meaning even more money, more people, more economic activity. In fact most of big cities built on rivers started as small communes that gradually expanded in each direction
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by gherkinnn on Thursday April 11, 2024 @11:13AM (#40003062)
Countless major cities and towns are built on either side a river. Anything beyond a village quickly evolves in to something roughly circular.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by The_Colonel on Thursday April 11, 2024 @05:39AM (#40000288)
A linear city gives you more opportunities for expansion. A disc one needs to be planned well from the start, but it's difficult to account for future needs.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by woodruffw on Thursday April 11, 2024 @09:11AM (#40001713)
I don’t understand how this can possibly be true. You have one only degree of freedom in a straight line. Most cities develop a natural disc pattern because it allows for expansion at every degree.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by The_Colonel on Thursday April 11, 2024 @10:33AM (#40002626)
The line is the initial city design. But then in 20, 100, 500 years you have two empty sides (equally accessible from any place in the line city) which you can use for more infrastructure (e.g. airports), industry, recreation, agriculture etc.

Meanwhile if you design a disc city, you can keep expanding outwards, but that's going to be increasingly far from the center. It's going to be very difficult to build a new airport into a middle of the city (if such needs arises), meanwhile it's much easier to do that for the middle segment of a linear city.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by gherkinnn on Thursday April 11, 2024 @11:32AM (#40003297)
Ifs contingent on whens and you end up with a blob anyway. Until you get to the blob everybody's life is miserable because a line is daft.

This is applying the terrible thinking that gives us micro service hell to city planning.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by The_Colonel on Thursday April 11, 2024 @02:41PM (#40005395)
> a line is daft

I think your argumentation rests on this, but you should explain why it's daft and how it makes people's lives miserable. I would personally enjoy having 20 minute access to any place in the city I live (which is far from having 9 million people) and still have a vast open space nearby.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by leoedin on Friday April 12, 2024 @04:23AM (#40010468)
Why do you think a linear city would give you 20 minute access to any place in the city? Clearly travel time would increase linearly with distance.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by bombcar on Thursday April 11, 2024 @07:08AM (#40000877)
If you have a requirement to build a city where everyone is within 1 mile of virgin forest, say, then you end up with something much like a line. You could circle it, but that's just another form of line.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by ted_bunny on Thursday April 11, 2024 @07:28AM (#40001002)
That's basically the concept in Lean Linear Arcology. The city is built along infrastructure routes to reduce footprint.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by readthenotes1 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @02:03AM (#39998867)
Well, of course, a circle is way more efficient at getting around.

But only with a line can you be aligned with your ruler's dreams.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by keiferski on Thursday April 11, 2024 @02:51AM (#39999099)
Is that actually true from a transportation physics perspective? I can’t imagine that a curved tram/train/etc. would be able to accelerate and decelerate as efficiently as one on a straight path.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by gaazoh on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:10AM (#39999624)
Acceleration and deceleration aren't relevant here, the limit would be passenger comfort either way.

Curved tracks do mean limits on top speed, as the centrifugal force needs to be kept below what would be uncomfortable for passengers. It also can cause some issues for building stations, as curved stations require a wider gap between the train and the platform. But neither is a blocking issue, all train tracks in the world do have curve, and curved stations aren't unusual in public transport systems.

The grandparent probably means disk, not ring-shaped when mentioning circles anyway. Pick any 2 point at random into a 33km² circle, the average distance will be 4km, and worst case scenario 6km. Do the same thing in a 33km², 200m-wide "line", the average distance will be 85km, with a worst case of 170km. A circular city doesn't need nearly as much raw speed for it's public transport to be more efficient than transport in a nonsensical linear city could ever be, even if you throw in ridiculously fast trains and sprinkle magical AI thinking.

It's not a coincidence that all major cities are roughly circular even though they are built around roughly linear features (navigable rivers and/or coast line). It's just what naturally works.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by dkdbejwi383 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:20AM (#39999699)
Acceleration etc wouldn't really matter if I live at one end of the line and my friend lives at the opposite end. It would be an annoyingly long journey that stops at every single other station in the entire city.

In a regular city that grows outwards, you'd expect there to be circumferential routes as well as cross-city routes connecting various points, making the travel time more bearable.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by saberience on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:25AM (#39999730)
I sort of assume they would have express trains as well as local trains, a bit like the NY subway. I.e. one train which just goes direct to the other end with no stops at high speed.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by pndy on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:47AM (#39999898)
Wikipedia article mentions "the Spine" - an underground tunnel that would host transport superfast train infrastructure connecting both sides of the complex. Traveling from one end to another would take 20mins, supposedly.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by ta1243 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @08:20AM (#40001345)
So about as long as riding a bike from anywhere in a equivalent sized normal city to another point (6km tops)
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by keiferski on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:26AM (#39999737)
It would matter if an express train could accelerate fast enough to make the end-to-end trip quicker than a cross-city trip in a typical city.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by ta1243 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @08:36AM (#40001443)
No.

With no top speed, accelerate for 85km at 1m/s then decelerate for the next 85km/s at 1m/s and that's about 13 minutes with a top speed of about 900mph. 1m/s is the top acceleration you can have for a typical passenger train for comfort purposes.

Total area of a 170km*200m city is 34 square km, or a city about 6.5km across.

London's Elizabeth line (crossrail) covers a distance of 6.75km from Paddington to Liverpool Street in 11 minutes, with 3 intermediate stops.

The circumference of a 6.5km diameter city would be 20km. 20 cross-city lines with decent headway and interchange would give a worst case journey of

- 250m to nearest station - 3 minutes walk

- 2 minute wait for train

- 5 minutes to central station

- 200m/3 minutes to appropiate platform

- 2 minute wait for train

- 5 minutes to destination station

- 200m/3 minutes to destination

25 minutes. From anywhere to anywhere.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by dragonwriter on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:01AM (#39999537)
Yeah, but it wouldn't have as far to go, since the maximum distance between any two stations is half as far on a ring city of circumference d as on a linear city of length d, and you can get even shorter if you cut across the ring.

To get the same area, you'd have to have slightly more center-line circumference on a ring city as linear distance on a line, but even so your transit distances are going to be shorter on the ring.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by keiferski on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:21AM (#39999704)
Right but if the idea is to maximize the open space / city size while maintaining a fast transit system, then the line makes sense to me.

I guess I don’t really understand the criticism, most of which seems to be “you should just build something that isn’t the thing you want to build.” There is plenty of aesthetic merit to the linear city idea on its own.

To use an example of a place that already exists: the city Łódź in Poland is situated along a single linear 4-5km street. Other neighborhoods branch off from it, but essentially the main road is the city’s layout. I really like it and think it’s a lot more interesting than it would be as a circle, even if the transit is theoretically not as optimal. There is something very aesthetically appealing about it.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by krisoft on Thursday April 11, 2024 @06:04AM (#40000432)
> the city Łódź in Poland is situated along a single linear 4-5km street.

Are we just making things up? Just by a single glance at a map of Łódź you can see that this is not true. The city is clearly blob shaped.

> I guess I don’t really understand the criticism, most of which seems to be “you should just build something that isn’t the thing you want to build.”

The criticism is that there are reasons why cities are built the way they are built. "Looks good on a 3d render" is not a great reason to do something, and the reasons the proponents list don't hold up to scrutiny.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by keiferski on Thursday April 11, 2024 @06:26AM (#40000597)
Had you taken more than a glance, you would have come across this:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Piotrkowska_Street

And yes, as I wrote, it is the main axis of the city, even if other neighborhoods branch off of it. This is a basic obvious fact about the city:

From the very beginning this street was the central axis, around which the city grew bigger, and its development spontaneously gave the present shape to its centre. At first the city was mainly the highway, but later it changed into the city's showcase, the leisure and shopping centre, where the life of growing industrial agglomeration could be observed.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by krisoft on Thursday April 11, 2024 @08:19AM (#40001336)
Found it. None of that claims that "the city Łódź in Poland is situated along a single linear 4-5km street". It is not. So much so that if you look at it on a map, you can't see which one of the many streets is the one which is supposed to be the one you are talking about. I really recommend looking at a map if you want to make claims about how a city is.

What the sentence you are quoting claims is that this is the street the city grow out of. Which is a different statement than saying that the one you said. The "the city Łódź in Poland is situated along a single linear 4-5km street" describe the appearance and layout of the city today, the quote you are quoting describe the history of the city and in which order it was built out.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by keiferski on Thursday April 11, 2024 @08:36AM (#40001449)
I’ve been to Lodz myself probably a dozen times. The city is oriented around the main long street. The street itself is probably the main tourist attraction, as well.

You can’t tell what it is on a map because you wouldn’t expect a pedestrianized street to be 100m wide. But I assure you, it is the busiest street and has the most foot traffic and commercial activity.

This argument is such a waste of time. I’ve been there, you’ve spent five minutes looking at Google maps. I brought it up as an example of a city designed around a straight line. Which it is.

Go waste someone else’s time.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by offices on Thursday April 11, 2024 @05:15AM (#40000100)
>if the idea is to maximize the open space / city size while maintaining a fast transit system

Then it's Goodhart law in action. A fast transit system is desirable because it's a proxy for low-friction travel. This has the speed and the friction.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by StefanBatory on Thursday April 11, 2024 @05:20AM (#40000141)
the city Łódź in Poland is situated along a single linear 4-5km street

Piotrkowska?

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by keiferski on Thursday April 11, 2024 @05:26AM (#40000189)
Yep. The city itself expands in all directions but Piotrowska is the main hub.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by ashildr on Thursday April 11, 2024 @03:13AM (#39999202)
A tram or even regular trains would not have to be very fast for those distances and for faster trains we already have the technology to lean into curves - it‘s quite common in Europe. And why not build a radial subway to get on to the opposing side of a circular city? (And why build this nonsense in a desert at all?)
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by wasmitnetzen on Thursday April 11, 2024 @05:29AM (#40000210)
The Line (full length) is supposed to have a footprint of 34km2, that's a circle with a diameter of 3.3km/2 miles. That's a bike-sized city. You can easily add 50% of parks and waterways to get to a nice city, that makes it 4km/2.5 miles.

And you can still build mostly straight-line trams in a circle anyway.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by Moldoteck on Thursday April 11, 2024 @06:08AM (#40000455)
circular/disk cities are basically line cities that are copied and rotated, you still can build straight line transport. If you talk about real circle cities and not disks-the idea is just as bad as straight line
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by jannw on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:32AM (#39999777)
Not so daft if you consider that it is easier to segment, stratify, and control people in a linear city, as the structure itself acts as a continuous and infinitely adaptable choke point. This seems consistent with Saudi elite's ideas on managing their society.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by RivieraKid on Thursday April 11, 2024 @07:07AM (#40000868)
But that would only make sense if most people lived in a line city.

There are much more effective ways to achieve population control than building line cities and moving people into them.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by fellerts on Thursday April 11, 2024 @07:49AM (#40001146)
Worked well for Snowpiercer, so why not.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by elmolino89 on Thursday April 11, 2024 @07:20AM (#40000950)
Daft in the case of a military conflict or some terrorist attack.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by lupusreal on Thursday April 11, 2024 @05:14AM (#40000090)
That explains why it might have been an appealing concept to the inceptor but it's still daft and it was obvious to me from the start that it wouldn't actually be made. I still don't know why anybody humored the premise of this thing getting built.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by tossandthrow on Thursday April 11, 2024 @04:39AM (#39999830)
nah, a circle is daft. an sphere in space is much better. bring in that 3rd dimension!
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by boesboes on Thursday April 11, 2024 @05:30AM (#40000223)
you need to dream bigger, we need a hypercube city!
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by tossandthrow on Thursday April 11, 2024 @08:04AM (#40001227)
Tesseract City!
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by amelius on Thursday April 11, 2024 @06:11AM (#40000488)
You mean circle -> disk.
Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by amelius on Thursday April 11, 2024 @06:14AM (#40000512)
The idea is not so silly for an authoritarian government.

By using a line they can just shut off one part of the line from the rest with one or two cuts.

Re:End of the Line? Saudi Arabia to scale back plans for des... by FabHK on Thursday April 11, 2024 @10:26AM (#40002535)
That's actually a neat interview question.

a) So you have people living uniformly distributed on a line of length 1. When you pick 2 at random, what's the average distance from one to the other?

b) How about if they live on a circle of circumference 1 (and you can only travel along the circumference)?

c) How about if they live on a disk of circumference 1 (and you can travel straight across the disk)?