News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by crazydoggers on Sunday March 03, 2024 @01:57PM (#39583307)
Is there some correlation here with the world lowest fertility rate?

Edit: Legitimate question, not insinuating anything. If questions are off limits, that’s pretty sad for inquiry, understanding and knowledge.

It’s a legitimate question as the article points out such a male/female inversion of fans is unique. Maybe women choosing different lifestyles, which is 100% their choice. But can still be correlated. Or other factors at play?

The article doesn’t have answers. So questions are what we are left with.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by geraldwhen on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:22PM (#39583552)
Any culture where women choose to pursue careers is a culture that will not exist in 200 years, including South Korea. Motherhood is a full time job.

This is obvious.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by giantg2 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:37PM (#39583694)
"This is obvious."

Not really. For example, one could outsource childcare to varying degrees depending on wealth. There may be other reasons, perhaps even correlated ones, but I don't see any obvious link between women pursuing careers completely killing cultures.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by geraldwhen on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:38PM (#39583707)
Show me a nation where women participation in the workforce is significant and population is growing outside of immigration.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by abdullahkhalids on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:04PM (#39583957)
Go here https://ourworldindata.org/female-labor-force-participation-...

Look at the first chart, "Ratio of female to male labor force participation rates, 1990 to 2021". Switch to Table view and sort by 2021 rates. You will find plenty of countries there with +80% rates which are all growing in population. You can see those numbers here [1].

But presumably you mean rich countries only. Just go down to the second chart on the same page, "Female labor force participation rates by national per capita income". This shows there is no or little correlation between GDP/capita and female participation.

[1] https://ourworldindata.org/population-growth

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by giantg2 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:55PM (#39583869)
Isreal at 2.9 fertility rate and significant labor force participation.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by churchill on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:17PM (#39584112)
Israel's population growth is disproportionately drive by the Haredi/ultra-orthodox Jewish communities where their women seek employment quite alright, but often stick to sedentary occupations that give them more time for the home.

The parent comment might have been somewhat aggressive, but the West needs t figure this out: once women enter the workforce en masse, birth rates tend to slide down from there. And with the welfare state most Western democracies have built, there's a continuous need for warm bodies to pay taxes and fuel the state's long-term obligations (social security, medicare, etc.).

With the way the stance around immigration is changing, importing immigrants won't work as a strategy for very long.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Hamuko on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:54PM (#39583851)
Iceland.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by CrazyStat on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:00PM (#39583920)
Total fertility rate of 1.59 in 2022 [1], well below replacement.

[1] https://www.statice.is/publications/news-archive/inhabitants...

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Hamuko on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:20PM (#39584140)
Still a positive natural population growth (2022 Revision of World Population Prospects).

Meanwhile Iran, where women make up about 17% of the total labor force, has only a slightly higher natural population growth and a fertility rate of 1.69.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by CrazyStat on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:53PM (#39584438)
You can temporarily maintain natural population growth with a fertility rate below replacement, e.g. due to past baby booms. In the long run (50-100 years) it means the population is shrinking.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by geraldwhen on Sunday March 03, 2024 @04:55PM (#39584891)
Below replacement levels, population less than a small US city. Iceland will be a historical footnote in 200 years.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by jrflowers on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:20PM (#39584146)
He’s not wrong, my man is simply advocating for the cultural model of the Sentinelese.

The only cultures that have existed untouched for 200 years are uncontacted tribes, so the retvrn guys are advocating that we get women out of the work force, abandon industry, eliminate language entirely until a new one grows in its place, make American great again (at thatching and the tanning of hides by hand)

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by kredd on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:38PM (#39583700)
“Choose” is a strong word, as we simply don’t value parenthood (monetarily or culturally) as much as previous generations. And I can’t blame women in this scenario - rationally speaking, why would you sacrifice multiple years of your life, then go back to the work force to be inferior because of those missed years, and lose out on your youth at the same time? The usual answer of “because having children is eternal happiness” just doesn’t hold water anymore, because the opportunity loss of having a child has grown dramatically.

Fortunately, you can have a fairly fulfilling life without having children as of today. And as the time goes, more childless people grow up which somewhat paves the way to the younger people without children. So, the spiral of low fertility continues, because again, we say we care about having a society full of children, but in reality, we don’t.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Thorrez on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:46PM (#39583789)
>The usual answer of “because having children is eternal happiness” just doesn’t hold water anymore, because the opportunity loss of having a child has grown dramatically.

This sentence doesn't make sense to me. How can the opportunity loss outweigh eternal happiness?

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by kredd on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:18PM (#39584121)
I meant that quote to be tongue-in-cheek, and out of reality. Should’ve been a bit more clear, my bad.

When I was a kid, that’s how older people around me described what parenthood gives you (eternal happiness). Later on, as sad as it sounds, I realized that line can be used as a cope for people for whom parenthood didn’t work out for a lot of different reasons (loss of a child, kids not meeting your expectations, work stress, problems in your partnership, societal priorities and etc.). So you start weighing your risks, and some come to conclusion that having no children or just one is good enough.

Then again, you get “you’ll never know until you experience it!” statements, and that still doesn’t cut it. Because, it’s really, genuinely good enough for some people, since you avoided most of the risks and enjoyed your life. Also as childless/small families age, they become a proof of concept to others how you really don’t need 3+ children (basically a requirement to be at the replacement level of the society).

There’s also a huge underlying “everyone wants others to have children, but only care about their own children” issue. And as we’ve gotten more competitive in the society, the best way to play the game is not playing it. But that’s a different topic.

Sorry for being a bit of a downer, but we talk about this with my friends quite often (late 20s-30s groups). And that’s generally how everyone feels - both men and women.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Dalewyn on Sunday March 03, 2024 @04:25PM (#39584675)
I relate heavily. I (Japanese-American male, if that matters) do not ever plan on marrying and thusly having children, life is far too short to deal with that literal bullshit when I have so many bigger fish to fry.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by geraldwhen on Sunday March 03, 2024 @04:56PM (#39584905)
What fish? Without kids, nothing matters. You’re just moving from one hedonistic pleasure to the next.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Dalewyn on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:24PM (#39585101)
Sex is but one of many hedonistic pleasures, one which I personally value around the bottom of my list of fish to fry because relationships carry far too much fucking (pun intended) baggage.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Hamuko on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:04PM (#39584962)
Oh no, not the pleasures!
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by fzeroracer on Sunday March 03, 2024 @09:34PM (#39586532)
According to whomst, exactly? Do you remember the works of great artists or authors because they have children? Is the work of Nikola Tesla worthless because he didn't fulfil the human biological imperative?
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by pseudocomposer on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:43AM (#39589757)
So you’re gonna be a great artist or the next Tesla? And everyone should assume they will be?
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by jrflowers on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:14PM (#39584060)
This is a good question; if somebody tells you that something promises eternal happiness, how could you (or any person) compel yourself to not do that thing? The sheer amount of willpower it must take to overcome the unassailable truth of a statement phrased in that way boggles the mind of a low brow such as myself
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by kredd on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:29PM (#39584238)
Very easy when you subscribe to “if it’s too good to be true it probably is” belief.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by jrflowers on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:34PM (#39584293)
I’ve never heard of this phrase and I find it confusing. How could someone arrive at such a negative outlook when faced with infinite and undeniable proof of eternal happiness everywhere in the world?
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by kredd on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:08PM (#39584993)
Why negative? Not believing that there’s eternal happiness waiting in a corner doesn’t mean someone (well, me in this case) lives a depressing life. Quite the opposite, I’m genuinely satisfied with where I am right now. Everyone’s choices are subjective and involve different calculations. After all, happiness is subjective.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Dalewyn on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:26PM (#39585115)
>undeniable proof of eternal happiness

I've seen enough families clearly miserable with each other to know that anyone who calls marriage and children "eternal happiness" is a fucking snake oil peddler trying to sell me a bridge.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by giantg2 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:11PM (#39584030)
There's risk for men as well, without much reward. Why would you risk becoming a father and being subjected to what many would feel is an unfair and costly family court system. I'm not sure what the benefit would be in a society that looks at you funny (as a threat) if you're the one taking your kid to playground, assuming your wife takes care of you (increasingly rare), etc. The expectations for men have changed and probably increased, the downsides have increased, but the stereotypes remain.

"we say we care about having a society full of children, but in reality, we don’t."

We only care that we have an increasing population to drive our consumer economy.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by AdrianB1 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:14PM (#39584069)
Today the "fulfilling life" is on the verge of disappearing. When most people don't have kids, like South Korea, when you get 60 years old you realize that there will be nobody to support you because there are not enough people left of working age. At 70 you can die of hunger not because you don't have the money for food, but there is nobody there to sell you the ingredients or deliver the order. You can import food, but it will not distribute itself. Electricity is not produced without people, drinking water need people, these people are your potential kids and grandkids when your are 70 years old and they are not there because you did not have any.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by kredd on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:27PM (#39584221)
That argument only works for people who care how they’ll live in their 60s/70s. There’s a morbid reality check in my circles (late 20s/30s) that the way our parents are living right now will never be obtainable for us (this includes friends with children as well). So might as well squeeze out life right now, at least have stories to tell to each other when we’re “dying of hunger in our 70s”. It’s not a scientific data point or anything, just bunch of friends shooting the shit and talking at the bar kind of stuff.

I’m not saying it’s all doom and gloom in the future, but it’s simply a risk assessment. The usual semi-paradox of “if others don’t care about it, why should I”, but apply that to everyone in the world.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by badpun on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:55PM (#39584460)
The standard of living will go down for sure, but I don't think it's reasonable to predict people starving to death due to not enough workers producing food. More likely, we won't be going on vacations abroad, we'll be driving our cars for 20+ years, will be living in small houses or apartments.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by loup-vaillant on Sunday March 03, 2024 @04:46PM (#39584817)
We regularly get the labour shortage argument to push retirement age later and later. There's just one problem: if there's a labour shortage, where does the 10+% unemployment comes from? Can't be explained by unfulfilled positions either, we counted in France, there's one open position for 10 unemployed worker.

And bloody hell, if push comes to shove, we can give up on optional niceties and reallocate labour to the more important stuff.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by AdrianB1 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @07:11PM (#39585757)
In Romania we have a crisis of workers in highway constructions and at the same time people living on benefits. The jobs are paying above the average, most are for operators of heavy machinery (trucks, bulldozers), don't require high skills, but people prefer to not work. Statistics are showing unemployment in areas where candidates want jobs that don't exist (wrong studies, wrong expectations), in the meanwhile there are plans to import 100,000 temporary workers from Sri Lanka.

People having unrealistic expectations are mostly explaining the high unemployment and high vacancy of some positions. It is a mismatch and the numbers are cooked, France is importing workforce from abroad (including Romania) for positions that French natives don't want.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by loup-vaillant on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:20PM (#39586126)
My question is how many?

How many unemployed? And how many opened positions? Your wording suggests that the number of opened positions exceeds half of the number of unemployed workers, but what’s your actual numeric estimation?

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by AdrianB1 on Monday March 04, 2024 @06:35AM (#39589232)
Yes, the number of open positions exceeds even the total number of people looking for a job. The number of unemployed people (they are not "workers", some did not work a day in their life) and the number of people looking for a job are very disconnected around here, living on benefits is preferred by way too many.

1. In some rural areas it is economically more profitable not to work than working a low wage job. You raise some chicken and a pig or cow, grow some food for self-consumption, get benefits, gg

2. Some people go for work in Western Europe for 3 to 6 months, then spend the rest of the year at home doing nothing. Or go to work in the season on the seaside and "rest" for the rest of the year.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by loup-vaillant on Monday March 04, 2024 @09:32AM (#39590952)
I have some official numbers for France, and they directly contradict what you’re saying: https://www.insee.fr/fr/statistiques/4805248 https://dares.travail-emploi.gouv.fr/donnees/les-emplois-vac...

According to our own government, the number of unemployed people in France at the end of last year is estimated at 2.3 millions (7.5% of the active population). the number of open positions for private companies of more than 10 employees (excluding agriculture) is 331,700.

I don’t believe for a second that including agriculture and smaller companies would raise this number even close to 1M, let alone 2.3M. The total number is most likely well below 500K. So it looks like in France, there is there is at most 1 open position for every 4 unemployed people able to work. Likely less. Given these numbers, if all the unemployed French people filled every open position overnight, at least 75% of them would remain unemployed.

I really, really have a hard time believing your numbers now that I have checked the official numbers for my country. I suggest you check for yours.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by AdrianB1 on Monday March 04, 2024 @02:11PM (#39594614)
I clearly stated I am talking about Romania. I don't have any numbers for France.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by loup-vaillant on Monday March 04, 2024 @05:06PM (#39596784)
> I clearly stated I am talking about Romania.

Sorry, I missed that part. I'm not sure where to find the official numbers there, but the sources I could find suggest the vacancy rates there are still easily less than half the unemployment rates.

https://www.statista.com/statistics/1391389/romania-job-vaca...

https://eures.europa.eu/living-and-working/labour-market-inf...

Supporting yet again that there are much fewer open jobs than unemployed people. Now I don't know how trustworthy the sources I just linked to are, but from what I've seen so far your current model of unemployment and vacancies seems to be wrong.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Dalewyn on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:28PM (#39585124)
>where does the 10+% unemployment comes from?

Would-be workers have too high standards.

I don't necessarily blame them, it's the logical conclusion to being told "Go to college and get a degree if you don't want to end up flipping burgers at McDonald's." their entire life.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by loup-vaillant on Sunday March 03, 2024 @06:45PM (#39585606)
Don’t miss the part where there is only 1 vacancy for 10 workers.

Lowering standards would not solve anything here, even if everyone accepted any job and relocate accordingly to fill every single vacancy, unemployment would hardly go down.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by carlosjobim on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:57PM (#39583895)
"We"...

You mean the rulers don't value parenthood. Of course not, because they need to squeeze as much productivity and profit from the younger generations they can before they (the rulers) die. Parenthood gets in the way for that, when the only priority should be to generate as much taxes and corporate profits as possible, and not snot-ridden kids.

The reason for this is that all real estate value, 401K value and stock value gets transferred to the corresponding accounts in the afterlife, so you can understand why the older generation is in a hurry to get as much as they can.

"For whosoever hath, to him shall be given, and he shall have more abundance: but whosoever hath not, from him shall be taken away even that he hath." Matthew 13:12

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Gibbon1 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @08:29PM (#39586182)
I think women will choose to have children if they can do it on their own terms. The problem is systematic gender roles and the (word hate ahead) patriarchy still score a bullseye when it comes to motherhood.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by llm_trw on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:33PM (#39583657)
Not really, it just means that the majority of women will be dead ends and the few who are happy (and able) to have 12 kids will the be the ones who populate the future.

The genetic effects of this are going to be interesting because until the 1970s a woman had a much better chance than a man of having some average number of children survive.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Thorrez on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:50PM (#39583827)
>The genetic effects of this are going to be interesting because until the 1970s a woman had a much better chance than a man of having some average number of children survive.

How does that math work out? Every child has a mom and a dad. Are you referring to widowhood and remarriage? Divorce and remarriage? Polygamy? Were those so significant in the 1920 that it caused a "much better chance"?

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by llm_trw on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:10PM (#39584015)
There has always been a surplus of men: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3367246/
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Thorrez on Monday March 04, 2024 @07:39AM (#39589719)
That's an interesting point I hadn't though of, thanks. However, I don't think it really backs up the previous comment. The link say's it's been even until recently:

>In humans, this balance has been remarkably even, but the past few decades have seen a substantial shift towards men, notably in some Asian countries

Yes there's an imbalance at birth:

>around 103–107 male babies for every 100 female ones.

However, 2 things about that imbalance:

* I don't think 100:103 or 100:107 is big enough for "a much better chance than a man of having some average number of children survive". I would think "slightly better chance" would be more accurate.

* The imbalance only exists as babys/kids. By reproductive age (the previous comment said "a woman had a much better chance than a man" not "a baby girl has a much better chance than a baby boy"), it evens out:

>the initial surplus of boys decreases to roughly equal number of males and females during the all-important reproductive years in most populations.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by giantg2 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:43PM (#39583753)
"The genetic effects"

I've also wondered similar things. For example, fertility rate is higher with lower wealth. Lower wealth is also correlated to many things. Similar wealth and education levels have been shown to be a large mate selection factor as well. Will that lead to implicitly selectively breeding for those traits over generations?

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by llm_trw on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:48PM (#39583810)
Also higher wealth.

It's the poor and the rich that are having children.

The middle class has decided to have a hysterectomy for some odd reason.

At any rate, I just need to outlive the people not having children today, not too hard since they won't have a family safety net or enough to retire on, and I'll stop hearing these arguments since the people who believed them will be dead and the people who didn't listen to them are the only ones who will be around to talk.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by jwells89 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:53PM (#39584437)
The middle is in an awkward position of higher quality everything for their children being within reach, yet not accessible without taking on significant financial risk – e.g. the kids might have excellent food, housing, schooling, etc but as a result the family would financially be walking a tightrope from which it can be easily knocked off should an unfortunate chain of events befall them.

To try to work around this awkwardness and provide the best for their family while mitigating risk, this group is likely to wait as long as possible to accumulate resources to act as padding. Unfortunately it’s not a given that these goals can be met before time runs out on the biological clock.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by geraldwhen on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:54PM (#39583854)
Indeed. My grandchildren will not need to debate these points. And their grandchildren would find the ideas absurd.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by giantg2 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:52PM (#39583845)
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by llm_trw on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:55PM (#39583868)
That data is far too granular. It stops at middle class as though $200k is something impressive in this day and age.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by giantg2 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:00PM (#39583930)
" as though $200k is something impressive in this day and age."

Middle class is defined as 2x the median, and adjusted for locality. In the vast majority of the US, $200k+ is not middle class and is impressive.

"That data is far too granular."

It's granular enough to show a trend. Perhaps you have other data to share?

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by mycologos on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:41PM (#39583736)
At first I wasn't sure about your claim, but then you said it's obvious, and my doubts went away!
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by silverquiet on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:29PM (#39583614)
> Motherhood is a full time job.

I assume one with no pay or health insurance/benefits. Bills must be paid, and they never seem to get any cheaper.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by geraldwhen on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:37PM (#39583686)
A naive analysis. Health insurance and “pay” comes from the husband, naturally.

Whether you like this or not is irrelevant. It is the only future that will exist.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by silverquiet on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:48PM (#39583806)
Makes you quite vulnerable to a layoff if an entire family is riding on one person's employer. No thanks to that.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Hamuko on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:59PM (#39583911)
And obviously vulnerable to your husband if he controls your entire financial future.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Jensson on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:03PM (#39583953)
Basically every first world country already fixed that by forcing ex husbands to pay after the divorce in some way.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by AdrianB1 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:16PM (#39584095)
And the result is a huge drop in marriage rates.

The problem did exist for millennia, but the modern laws destroyed marriage without bringing a net positive outcome.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by badpun on Sunday March 03, 2024 @04:03PM (#39584530)
Women equality destroyed marriage. Before women could work in attractive jobs, a marriage was often only way for a woman to a middle class lifestyle. The husband was a neccessity. Now, women can just get a job that provides such lifestyle, so they marry for love and not for money.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by AdrianB1 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @07:04PM (#39585714)
"marry for love" does not last. It makes the marriage a chronometer for infatuation. Not saying marrying for money is better, marrying for long term family partnership is neither of these.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by hagbard_c on Sunday March 03, 2024 @07:22PM (#39585807)
That's what unemployment insurance is there to take care of, the idea being that there is another job to be had. Of course I'm speaking from a European - Swedish and Dutch specifically - perspective so things may not be as 'easy' in countries where there is no such thing.

Do mind though that unemployment insurance should be time-limited and there should be incentives to find alternative employment to avoid the system becoming a replacement for paid employment which leads both to dependency on the side of the unemployed as well as eventual insolvency of the insurance system.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by dottjt on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:36PM (#39583682)
Correct, but you're describing the problem.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by IIAOPSW on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:51PM (#39583836)
Nah, the culture where 90% of people are gay work-aholics and 10% of people are employed as full time breeders is optimal. The final stage of capitalism is a human ant colony.

This is obvious.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by crazydoggers on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:25PM (#39583577)
That’s a very sexist take, and not supported at all by the data. There are plenty of very successful women raising families. I have a relative where both the father and mother are very successful engineers working full time. Their two girls are doing amazing and going to top schools.

Raising children is full time, but both parents can and should be a part of it.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by geraldwhen on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:31PM (#39583640)
Two girls. 2.1 is replacement rate. Some do manage to have 2-3 kids! But many do not. And the cultures that do not push women into careers are more able to grow their population.

Is there any country on earth with a neutral or positive population growth where women are encouraged to pursue careers? As far as I know, not a single country that has a significant female career participation rate has a 2.1+ child rate per family outside of immigration.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by crazydoggers on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:37PM (#39583693)
Okay, well I did a little googling and came across this data.. it does seem having 3 or more children equates with negative effects on women being able to have a career.

https://www.huffpost.com/entry/women-three-children_n_895517...

But it seems to me the issue is not that women are choosing to have careers, but that the work/career culture is not supporting women choosing to have children. So things like better maternity and paternity leave, allowing women to take years off, or part time without consequence to career, etc.

So takeaway should be, support our population by better supporting working mothers.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Jensson on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:45PM (#39583781)
> But it seems to me the issue is not that women are choosing to have careers, but that the work/career culture is not supporting women choosing to have children. So things like better maternity and paternity leave, allowing women to take years off, or part time without consequence to career, etc.

Countries that did all of those things as much as possible still fall below replacement rates, so no that isn't a sexist take that is just reality.

I'm not saying we should force women to not have careers, just that the women who have careers will eventually go extinct, which is their choice and I fully support that. I don't see a reason to force people to spread their genes. Instead of forcing career women to be unhappy at home with children, the women who are happy at home with children will eventually replace them.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by giantg2 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:49PM (#39583815)
"So things like better maternity and paternity leave, allowing women to take years off, or part time without consequence to career, etc."

A lot of these have been implemented in some European countries. They don't seem to be that effective on fertility rate given they are still below replacement.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by flextheruler on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:43PM (#39583754)
I’d love to live in a world where I can take years off from work without consequences to my career.

Let me know if you find one.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by Rapzid on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:43PM (#39583758)
That's a very sexist take. We should support working fathers allow them to take years off work with no consequences.
Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by SunlitCat on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:39PM (#39583713)
Although it is pretty sexist by itself, that statement contains interesting points to talk about.

Motherhood by itself can be a full time job, if the partner and the society doesn't help. Like enough (and affordable) daycare centers, kindgartens, schools that take care of children after school hours, i.e. offer all-day care or activities.

And as you said "very successful engineers". What's about not so successful people, making good money but not being able to afford the options around them?

Yeah! So you are totally right, that statement was pretty sexist, but to really help couples raising children there is still a lot of work do to.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by geraldwhen on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:47PM (#39583794)
Countries with better support for working women have even lower birth rates.

It is my belief that you are fundamentally misunderstand the issue.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by SunlitCat on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:07PM (#39583989)
Fair point, I was talking about the statement that "Motherhood is a full time job" not the other point you made about women choosing careers over motherhood.

You are right that there are studies showing that especially in Northern European countries where women receive more support in raising children have lower birth rates. But there was no statement as to why this is so (at least that was the last time I was interested in the topic, maybe there is something new?).

So yeah, I didn't feel confident enough to tackle that point of yours, sorry.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by geraldwhen on Sunday March 03, 2024 @05:02PM (#39584953)
There is no passing the buck. Raising children is a full time job, mother or father aside. And it is a rewarding job, unlike many middle management paper pushing “bullshit” jobs talked about here frequently.

Someone has to raise children. I believe a loving, caring parent would want to do that themselves and or with their immediate family structure. I would not want strangers raising my children.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by llm_trw on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:38PM (#39583704)
There is no industrialized society at replacement fertility.

So far the west is getting by on immigrants from countries it has destroyed. What happens when all of Africa falls below replacement rates in the next 15 years?

Keep in mind that _you_ will need doctors and nurses to keep you alive once you're past 60. At this point soylent green is the only retirement policy people with less than 10 million in the bank can expect.

Re:Why Women Outnumber Men in South Korea's Sports Stadiums by AdrianB1 on Sunday March 03, 2024 @03:21PM (#39584156)
I have seen a few cases of successful women at work. But what surprised me was to find out that most of them took a break of 10-15 years to raise the kids, then returned to the workforce with full focus. I have a friend that did that after 14 years and found that Project Management is the same as before she left, so ramping up to full speed was very easy. She was promoted (again) less than 1 year after her return to work.