News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by slimsag on Saturday March 02, 2024 @12:41AM (#39570137)
If your intent is to dump some code on the internet, by all means - and more power to you.

If your intent is to have your code reach the maximum amount of people to benefit them, and you want your project to benefit from networks effects.. then GitHub and Discord, the two proprietary platforms used by the largest portion of people for modern OSS project development, are basically a non-choice. Every other option results in far less people discovering and interacting with your project, by orders of magnitude.

In a project I run, we forced everyone into Matrix as much as possible and refused to operate a Discord for over a year. Once we relented, and decided 'we would run both' - over 95% of people in under a month stopped participating in the Matrix channels and instead went to Discord. The number of people in the community grew orders of magnitude larger, in a shorter time period, as well - even with us pushing it less on our docs/etc.

It sucks. Wish it wasn't true - but that's where people are.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by iforgotpassword on Saturday March 02, 2024 @03:32AM (#39571046)
I get GitHub - it's proprietary, but also just git, so moving somewhere else is just a pull and push away. The same can't be said for issues/discussions/wiki, but at least it's still the web, so it is googleable, archivable, curlable, you name it. It has happened more than a dozen times that I googled a weird error from eg libssl, ended up in a random issue of a random tool I never heard of, but someone still explained the underlying issue well enough while debugging that I was able to solve my problem. This requires a browser and nothing else.

None of this is true for discord. It isn't indexed by anything, even "servers" are walled gardens to each other mostly. Anything shared on discord will be lost to time in a decade or two. Nothing discovered or solved within $project's discord will possibly benefit anyone outside that project.

And sure, we already had that problem with IRC, but I think the text-only nature of it helped that anything a bit more involved moved to forums or mailing lists which again both were web accessible and searchable. And even then some projects did have logbots which just dumped text files into a web server.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by ljm on Saturday March 02, 2024 @05:19AM (#39571504)
What’s worse is that the stuff that does get indexed will usually describe your exact issue, but then you’ll see it’s closed with a message like “this issue is stale because no one answered in 20 minutes,” or “this isn’t a bug, ask it on discord”. There’s no guarantee you get an answer there or if someone snaps at you for asking the same question yet again and not knowing the exact ceremony to perform to find the previous answers.

I don’t have the time or energy to arse about with real time chat and micro-communities for every single thing. The claim is that they are inclusive but I find them rather cliquey and exclusive.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by zarathustreal on Saturday March 02, 2024 @05:52AM (#39571651)
“Inclusive” is a modern day euphemism much like “diversity.” It just means the target audience is present.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by joshspankit on Saturday March 02, 2024 @07:34PM (#39577203)
> Anything shared on discord will be lost to time in a decade or two

Personally, as someone who has watched the evolution of IRC and other types of communication channels, I would argue that unless a thread is archived to the open web, anything shared in a realtime chat channel is lost in hours if not days.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by ambigious7777 on Monday March 04, 2024 @08:57PM (#39598569)
Discord does have a forums feature, which is somewhat searchable, so that's not entirely true.

I think the best thing for this stuff is still a forum, like GitHub Discussions (or Issues), or just run your own message board.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by LightFog on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:17AM (#39570318)
Isn’t ’giving up convenience in the name of freedom’ one of the core trade-offs you’re expected to make with free software? People buy into the ‘free’ bit of FOSS to varying degrees of course but it is disappointing that so many FOSS projects seem ok contributing so much to a proprietary product from one of the most anti-freedom corporations out there.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by andai on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:57AM (#39570503)
Stallman said (paraphrasing) "If free software were inferior, using it would still be the right thing to do. Fortunately, it is also superior in terms of features and experience."

That being said, Stallman (still?) uses mostly terminal based software, so that take is a bit biased.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by vaylian on Saturday March 02, 2024 @03:32AM (#39571048)
> Stallman (still?) uses mostly terminal based software, so that take is a bit biased.

The Linux terminal is fairly comfy and depending on the task, it can be vastly superior to graphical applications. The opposite can also be true for other tasks. It really depends on what someone wants to do with their computer.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by LightFog on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:05AM (#39570543)
I think that might be wishful thinking on his part - I remember hearing about him consuming some types of web content via a friend downloading html and emailing it to him! He has spoken plenty about confronting the convenience-freedom trade off that anyone consuming software will be confronted with though.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by TulliusCicero on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:16AM (#39570602)
> "If free software were inferior, using it would still be the right thing to do. Fortunately, it is also superior in terms of features and experience."

It blows me away just how out of touch one otherwise-intelligent man can be.

FOSS often has severe usability issues compared to popular proprietary counterparts -- just look at any article here talking about trying to use Matrix or get friends/relatives to use it, it's basically always a big dumpster fire. Yet somehow you still have people recommending it.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by rapnie on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:53AM (#39570842)
It is true that highest quality FOSS is found at the level of libraries and frameworks, not on the end-user app level. There's still a lot to win by improving the practices on this level, which require more than pure technical focus. And other people than devs getting involved with their skills. Requires better FOSS tools and practices to make that happen. That is a challenge for the future of FOSS. It's also one tackled by people using the FOSS apps, prepared to bear with inconveniences, give their feedback, and not ditching them on a whim for the first proprietary competitor that is better. Yes, that is not for everyone to be involved with. I am quite happy to see more people who do.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by TulliusCicero on Saturday March 02, 2024 @03:00AM (#39570886)
A lot of FOSS enthusiasts want the UX to be bad, because to them the UX that is bad for most people is actually fine.

I think the issue is less getting a designer interested, and more that it would be really hard to get consensus. Changing UX is more subjective AND intrusive compared to adding more features or improving performance. Changing the UI means changing people's existing flows, as opposed to a new feature that can just be one more button somewhere.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by rapnie on Saturday March 02, 2024 @03:13AM (#39570952)
It is understandable, since the majority of FOSS enthusiasts consist of developers, techie folks. An audience of power users that indeed have different preferences for their UX. There's a lack of people involved in FOSS projects (e.g. designers) that inform these developers on the expectations of the user base that their FOSS project is targeting. FOSS devs want to see their project get uptake and use, and need different voices that tell them (with good arguments) how to achieve that. Lacking that biased UX hampers project objectives.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by hx8 on Saturday March 02, 2024 @04:19AM (#39571248)
I don't think there is a consensus among developers of front-end FOSS that becoming the market leader is a high priority. Non-power users will never submit a PR, and rarely even write a useful bug report. They effectively give very little back to the project, except maybe some clout that comes with a large user base.

There are some exceptions, but the ones that care the most about market share either have a corporate backer that is profiting from the project (Microsoft, Chromium) or require large numbers for the project to be successful (Firefox, Fediverse).

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by rapnie on Saturday March 02, 2024 @04:37AM (#39571335)
Before striving for market share and leadership, there's product-market fit. The ambitions of FOSS projects needn't be (and often aren't) to become a leader. Offering a good alternative to some proprietary product is already a good start. FOSS projects are predominantly started and maintained by developers and this is reflected in both the tool choices and the organization / governance model of the project, which makes it hard for other stakeholders to have a proper say in it. Those are areas to focus on and where much can be improved. And with the help of said stakeholders to encourage that trend.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by andai on Saturday March 02, 2024 @12:54PM (#39574277)
> the majority of FOSS enthusiasts consist of developers, techie folks.

Is this for the same reason that most Linux users don't care about free software (i.e. are happy running various proprietary blobs on Linux, Windows games in Wine etc.)

i.e. as far as I can tell most users of free software don't care about the free software aspect very much.

Talked to a Linux user about this last night and he seemed to think the "free" part means "no cost"... Sad!

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by the_gipsy on Saturday March 02, 2024 @03:09AM (#39570933)
Yes, but it's not constantly trying to trick you into paying, or locking you in to some format/platform that will lead to you paying. Those are also big usability issues.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by TulliusCicero on Saturday March 02, 2024 @03:11AM (#39570941)
No, not really. I mean, those are issues, but more of monetization than usability. The usability decrease from those things is fairly small.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by the_gipsy on Saturday March 02, 2024 @03:44AM (#39571101)
Yes, they are usability issues, if I can't trust the software and need to evaluate every step it makes, because it might do something against my interests. That's quite the cognitive overload.

I'm not saying that it's strictly worse or the same as with FOSS software. Just a different tradeoff.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by tasuki on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:43AM (#39570425)
I use FOSS because it's convenient, not for some higher philosophical principle...
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by rapnie on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:16AM (#39570603)
If use is the only thing you do it may contribute to the Tragedy of the Commons and you undermine FOSS. If you also contribute back in some ways, even for very practical purposes, you are also serving the higher philosophical principle of FOSS.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by LeoWattenberg on Saturday March 02, 2024 @12:46PM (#39574206)
The tragedy of the commons requires a resource that is being depleted, which definitely isn't something that merely using FOSS would do.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by type0 on Saturday March 02, 2024 @07:03PM (#39577014)
The effort of contributors can certainly be depleted when they see that no one cares to even submit a bug report or suggest any improvements
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by kazinator on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:14AM (#39579114)
If you're using FOSS because it's convenient and don't have any problems, why would you suggest any improvements or report bugs?
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by roenxi on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:26AM (#39570349)
No. Freedom includes the freedom to do what is convenient.

The tolerance of inconvenience is a practical argument. If you have non-free dependencies, the most likely scenario is that sooner or later the dependency will kill support for the project and you have no legal recourse. Eg, if a project uses Discord, at some point it will have to move away to some other technology/protocol. If it uses git, the project won't ever have to move away from git. Those predictions can be made purely from analysing the license.

Since a move is inevitable, it really should make more sense to use FOSS protocols and clients from the get go. People don't though, and I don't pretend to understand the reasons. But what I can confidently say that Discord is going to become inhospitable for the project eventually.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by LightFog on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:43AM (#39570426)
This doesn’t seem to cover the ‘social’ or community side of software freedom though. Sure you have the freedom to make life tough for your future self for short term gain - but by embracing non-free software you are ultimately limiting the freedom of others via network effects and lock-ins. Exactly what has happened with GitHub.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by rapnie on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:09AM (#39570565)
Exactly, ones convenient choice undermines and erodes collective freedoms. In FOSS you 'vote' with your choices. In an analogy with politics this lack of consideration of freedoms and values, and applying of critical thinking may lead to freedom eventually being eradicated for good (or a very long time). In politics unfortunately we see people time and again voting democratically for their own oppression and lack of choice.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by raverbashing on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:43AM (#39570765)
Yes Discord eventually won't be a good choice. Eventually. Then people will just move

People are talking about Discord like Freenode didn't crap on everyone recently

Meanwhile, sure, feel free to use an OSS solution then realize nobody cares

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by roenxi on Saturday March 02, 2024 @05:44AM (#39571621)
I was thinking of Freenode when I wrote that. The changeover process is using a different server - the client doesn't change and nor does the protocol. The switch from Discord will be a lot more disruptive. Everyone needs to find a new client and the protocol will be different. Ie, the entire ecosystem burns instead of one minor component like a DNS hostname.

And that is the upside of OSS. When Freenode caused people trouble they all just walked calmly to a new server. Case closed. Little of value was lost.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by pillusmany on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:34AM (#39570717)
According to this logic FOSS projects should not support proprietary OSes like Windows or macOS.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by LightFog on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:55AM (#39570853)
It seems there are plenty that don’t - although that may also be for practical reasons.

But yes, I do think that free software ideals discourage supporting those platforms - however some may support them to give their users at least some freedom, eg when they are forced to use the platforms due to some work policy.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by rapnie on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:40AM (#39570751)
That's different. These OS'es are more bottom of the stack. Below that they run on proprietary firmware, even Linux.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by Buttons840 on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:35AM (#39570388)
Community over tools. Hopefully if the tools fail the communities will move to new tools.

Ultimately, a huge hacker culture built on proprietary tools might lead to more freedoms, both political and technical, than a tiny hacker community built on other tools. The size and political influence of a larger community matters.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by rapnie on Saturday March 02, 2024 @03:36AM (#39571062)
Maybe. But I wonder how much of a healthy community collapses when you are forced to make a switch from, say, Discord to some alternative tool. Building and maintaining healthy communities requires tremendous amount of effort, especially when they are large. So you should weigh the benefits of a convenient tool to the amount of effort that may go to waste if that tool no longer fits the bill.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by Buttons840 on Saturday March 02, 2024 @09:08AM (#39572639)
Maybe, but that would be part of "community over tools". If one tool results in a smaller but better community, then sure, it's worth it.

I suppose the real problem of using proprietary tools for a larger community is the marginalized people. Like, if Discord didn't allow people from a certain country. It's a tradeoff between having as large a community as possible and making sure you include everyone, even those with uncommon circumstances. That's a tradeoff that gets made in many situation I think.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by advael on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:16AM (#39570601)
As someone also running FOSS projects on discord because it's a non-choice, hard agree. Boycotting proprietary platforms is a good end-goal, but it's about as feasible to convince people not to use dominant organizing tools like discord and github as it is to get them off the mobile duopoly right now.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by alwayslikethis on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:36AM (#39570725)
I maintain a semi-popular project [1] with a support chat which is bridged between Matrix, Telegram, and Discord. The decision to bridge it to Discord was made having thought long and hard about it some time after reading this post.

My stance is that it is okay to use proprietary platforms as long as it does not negatively impact the users not willing to use them, i.e. all channels must be bridged to non-Discord, so that it does not "partition the community" in any way. Discord-specific features should be avoided to not affect the usability of users on Matrix. So far it works well and I get to basically have the cake and eat it too.

1. https://github.com/FreeLanguageTools/vocabsieve

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by mxmlnkn on Saturday March 02, 2024 @05:08AM (#39571464)
What are you using to bridge these three chat providers?
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by alwayslikethis on Saturday March 02, 2024 @08:45AM (#39572477)
An Ansible playbook running on a relatively cheap hetzner box. In general bridges require you to self-host a homeserver. A federated homeserver will need 4GB of RAM at least and 8GB if you plan on joining large rooms. The playbook is controlled from a single config file and sets up all the bridges you need.

https://github.com/spantaleev/matrix-docker-ansible-deploy

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by YoshiRulz on Saturday March 02, 2024 @12:56AM (#39570203)
Did you consider bridging Discord channel(s) into Matrix?
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by slimsag on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:13AM (#39570300)
Yes. But the bridge looked fairly difficult to run and configure properly, requiring a yarn/npm dev environment (which I don't want installed on my machine)

At the time (still?) it seemed impossible to bridge Discord channels (which are viewed very much as 'create as you please') to Matrix rooms without painfully doing it one-by-one via a config file and managing/creating both on each side (Matrix really seems stuck on the idea of preferring its 'one room' model and has not really embraced channels in the Discord sense.) Discord had also just gotten forums with no way to bridge them.

Additionally, our Matrix rooms were seeing a good amount of spam that Discord was not, which would then get relayed to Discord via the bridge and would require moderating in both sides.

Finally, our strongest Matrix advocates firmly disliked the idea of a bridge because it meant their Matrix messages would go to the proprietary Discord company.

In the end, we let them run side-by-side for a little while then the Matrix quickly died.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by TulliusCicero on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:21AM (#39570638)
> Finally, our strongest Matrix advocates firmly disliked the idea of a bridge because it meant their Matrix messages would go to the proprietary Discord company.

> In the end, we let them run side-by-side for a little while then the Matrix quickly died.

The Stallman mentality is a plague.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by herewulf on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:58AM (#39570508)
> requiring a yarn/npm dev environment (which I don't want installed on my machine)

I don't like / trust that stuff either but it's often necessary and easy enough to run in a container (e.g.: Docker/Podman, LXC, Guix Shell) or VM (e.g.: Vagrant, QEMU/libvirt).

I actually run most of my software dev stuff that way these days because all these tools are routinely pulling hundreds of deps from the internet that are doing who knows what in their build systems.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by alwayslikethis on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:48AM (#39570800)
You can use this Ansible playbook. It worked well for me for bridging Discord and Telegram, among other things, running off a Hetzner box.

https://github.com/spantaleev/matrix-docker-ansible-deploy

Personally I've never seen any significant amount of spam on Matrix.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by infinitezest on Saturday March 02, 2024 @09:20AM (#39572705)
In my experience Mautrix has been very easy to run and can bridge new channels automatically as they're created. I use Matrix exclusively to chat with my friends on Discord.

https://github.com/matrix-org/matrix-appservice-discord

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by watwut on Saturday March 02, 2024 @04:02AM (#39571175)
I dunno about GitHub now. Ever since it requires two factor authentication, it is not really suitable if you want people to be active in any way.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by cokeandpepsi on Saturday March 02, 2024 @02:42AM (#39570762)
I'm not surprised, matrix is not easy or enjoyable to use at all; maybe the protocol itself is sound but every implementation I've tried both server and client is seriously bad
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by astrobe_ on Saturday March 02, 2024 @05:38AM (#39571587)
> If your intent is to have your code reach the maximum amount of people to benefit them

This amount of altruism is rare. More likely it's just the desire to be acknowledged by others. It's ok, but it's also worth reflecting on why you need that, as the process of freeing yourself from that can make you happier.

Also quantity <> quality; Discord users often are the people who have been trapped down the slope of least friction and that are ok with "being the product".

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by jwells89 on Saturday March 02, 2024 @09:48AM (#39572891)
Quantity can give a better grasp on the average user though, which is important in its own way, at least for projects with larger or more general audiences.

For instance if I were the head of browser or desktop environment project I’d want to hear from as wide of an audience as I feasibly can because otherwise there’s almost certainly issues (usability, compatibility, bugs, etc) that I’m not privy to because they aren’t encountered often in small more technical samples of users.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by grey_earthling on Saturday March 02, 2024 @05:42AM (#39571610)
> Every other option results in far less people discovering and interacting with your project, by orders of magnitude.

Yes, this is the problem. The article suggests: try to fix it.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by OJFord on Saturday March 02, 2024 @05:59AM (#39571686)
I find Discord such an annoying tool for it though, it's not a principled objection for me really, I just don't think it's a good solution.

I've never actually had a question answered (rarely even addressed) within some chat-like timeframe anyway, then after some days or a week or so I forget all about it or couldn't find it again scrolling up if I wanted to.

People always talk about search engines not indexing it harming discovering, but another aspect of that is that you can't tell if the 'server' is completely dead until you make an account or log in and join it. Then potentially you just see a flood of people joining, maybe one or two asked a question, and there's just no other activity.

But my main issue I think is just that I can't keep up with the chat for so many different 'servers' and their channels, so why does it make sense for it to be chat anyway? Something like Reddit makes much more sense to me, where there's a bit of a sense of what's current, but not to the same extent.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by jdaw0 on Saturday March 02, 2024 @11:13AM (#39573484)
using discord for community and docs is a dead giveaway for whether a FOSS project is actually about FOSS principle or whether it's about chasing clout
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by lamontcg on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:41PM (#39574749)
All the alternatives to slack and discord seem to have some technological/philosophical axe to grind which is in opposition to "make it easy to setup and pleasant to use for the vast majority of users".

If someone would just clone discord/slack and make it so people could stand up a server in minutes and manage it with near zero effort, and the UI/UX pretty much copied what users find familiar it would probably take off. Don't make it distributed, just apply enough cryptography to secure the client-server communication. Yeah, users will need to trust their admins and it won't be perfect security, most users don't need that.

Make it easy to run fully public and indexed/searchable servers, make it similarly easy to run servers that weren't fully public and indexed and required logins and kept everything private, let the users decide instead of the developers.

If your chat protocol cares too much about perfect forward security against hostile admins and attacks by the FBI while supporting a distributed protocol then you're likely producing something that is too complicated to use for 99% of the happy slack/discord users who don't care about that. The challenge for FOSS developers is to recognize that most people don't care about what they deeply care about and that they're not smart enough to solve the iron triangle of security. And that is when they're not self-sabotaging their product by looking at the way that e.g. slack and discord let you easily edit your comments and declaring yourself philosophically opposed to that.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by myaccountonhn on Sunday March 03, 2024 @12:34PM (#39582421)
There is Zullip. It is quite great and has a free option for open source projects. It is quite easy to setup.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by kazinator on Sunday March 03, 2024 @02:12AM (#39579102)
Okay, so there are some people who will not engage with anything that is outside of the Discord bubble. And for whatever reason, you feel you must woo these people.

What if whatever you are making runs against a popular alternative? How are you going to convince the Discord people to switch from that thing to your thing? They are Discord people: they are programmed to seek whatever large numbers of other people are using, which is why you have to resort to Discord to reach them.