News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by Buttons840 on Saturday March 02, 2024 @01:35AM (#39570388)
Community over tools. Hopefully if the tools fail the communities will move to new tools.

Ultimately, a huge hacker culture built on proprietary tools might lead to more freedoms, both political and technical, than a tiny hacker community built on other tools. The size and political influence of a larger community matters.

Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by rapnie on Saturday March 02, 2024 @03:36AM (#39571062)
Maybe. But I wonder how much of a healthy community collapses when you are forced to make a switch from, say, Discord to some alternative tool. Building and maintaining healthy communities requires tremendous amount of effort, especially when they are large. So you should weigh the benefits of a convenient tool to the amount of effort that may go to waste if that tool no longer fits the bill.
Re:Don't Use Discord for FOSS (2021) by Buttons840 on Saturday March 02, 2024 @09:08AM (#39572639)
Maybe, but that would be part of "community over tools". If one tool results in a smaller but better community, then sure, it's worth it.

I suppose the real problem of using proprietary tools for a larger community is the marginalized people. Like, if Discord didn't allow people from a certain country. It's a tradeoff between having as large a community as possible and making sure you include everyone, even those with uncommon circumstances. That's a tradeoff that gets made in many situation I think.