News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by CM30 on Monday February 26, 2024 @07:39AM (#39510589)
Unfortunately, nuclear seems to get a bad rep from a lot of people. I suspect this is because of a mixture of things:

1. The rare instances of it going wrong look catastrophic, while the many times it does better than coal/oil/gas go ignored. Kinda like how people fear plane travel more than driving, despite the former being far safer than the latter.

2. It's more expensive to setup, so there's an economic incentive to either stick with what's there already (fossil fuels) or try and go with renewable solutions.

3. A certain percentage of the left/environmental movement seem to hate the concept, either because of subtle influencing from the fossil fuels lobby or because the idea of compromising and going with a system that isn't 'perfect' doesn't appeal to them.

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by retendo on Monday February 26, 2024 @07:44AM (#39510640)
Isn't the number one reason that nuclear gets a bad rep because there is no compelling solution for getting rid of the waste?
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by tialaramex on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:00AM (#39510798)
We don't have a solution to the waste from fossil fuels either, so... We just ignore that.

Coal in particular results in incredible toxic waste. Even if it was inert (which it very much is not) you get enormous heaps of rock you dug the coal out of and those have to be stored forever. Typically people just leave it in a big pile as somebody else's problem until one day the wind blows and it collapses and kills a bunch of people. Oops.

But even for natural gas in the best case your waste is excess carbon dioxide, which renders your planet inhospitable so that's not great either.

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by AlexandrB on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:07AM (#39510856)
There are compelling solutions, they just run into the same opposition as the plants themselves.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yucca_Mountain_nuclear_waste_r...

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by rcbdev on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:19AM (#39510944)
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by paulmd on Monday February 26, 2024 @01:22PM (#39514945)
now there's a multilevel dungeon if I've ever seen one... must be some real neat loot stored at the bottom!
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by fsflover on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:02AM (#39510813)
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by master-lincoln on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:23AM (#39510976)
> As a general clarification, ounce for ounce, coal ash released from a power plant delivers more radiation than nuclear waste shielded via water or dry cask storage.

What a comparison... The worry with nuclear waste is of course that the shielding doesn't last long enough and waste then contaminates surroundings with much much higher radiation than in coal ash

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by fsflover on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:46AM (#39511178)
AFAIK it's pretty well know how long the shielding works, so you can always renew it. Also, with coal the shielding is impossible at all.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by ashildr on Monday February 26, 2024 @02:50PM (#39516014)
The shielding of the waste, not the shielding of the plants.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by fsflover on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @03:10AM (#39521433)
Yes this is what I'm talking about.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by smegger001 on Monday February 26, 2024 @02:58PM (#39516086)
We know how to store it safely though melt the radioactive material into glass ingots and store them in stainless steel barrels at the bottom of old mineshaft in geologicly stable dry areas like yukca mountain. But NIMBYs wont let us. The fear of leaking containment vessels goes back to early days of nuclear such as the Hanford site. Yes thats a horrible mess and a Superfund site. It also dates back to the Manhattan project and waste from the first nuclear pile. We have learned a bit more since the 1940's.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by saywhanow on Monday February 26, 2024 @10:21AM (#39512250)
The waste problem is solved. As with the rest of the nuclear discussion, it’s mostly hysteria.

Here’s a guy kissing nuclear waste. It’s a bit tongue in cheek on the surface, but he’s PhD and there is quality information in the video.

https://youtu.be/lhHHbgIy9jU?si=wE0FvscMgBpLUZ0g

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by raxxorraxor on Monday February 26, 2024 @11:13AM (#39512982)
The waste problem is pretty much not solved. Neither on the technical, nor the political front. That doesn't mean nuclear isn't an option.

Try to list the countries with a permanent nuclear storage site. Pretty short list.

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by ben_w on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @12:28PM (#39526780)
The political front, sure.

The technical front, however, really is fine.

All the high-level nuclear waste on Earth would fit in a 21m cube. The lower level stuff is substantially greater in volume, but overall this is one of the (IMO few) cases where nuclear proponent's arguments about energy density do actually matter.

And that means it's fine for the list of countries with a permanent nuclear storage site to be pretty short.

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by thiht on Monday February 26, 2024 @11:19AM (#39513069)
At least the waste is not dumped in the atmosphere. We have better waste management for nuclear than coal or oil.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by FrustratedMonky on Monday February 26, 2024 @08:55AM (#39511259)
"Unfortunately, nuclear seems to get a bad rep from a lot of people."

Well, there was Chernobyl.

Then Fukushima.

I'm all for Nuclear. But I think humans have shown repeatedly they can't really handle it.

So think the trepidation is justified.

But, I am hoping with all the technology advances in last 50 years, maybe Nuclear can be made safe. If we do learn from past.

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by atonse on Monday February 26, 2024 @09:06AM (#39511348)
As far as I know though, Chernobyl and Fukushima had completely different reasons and don't really clump together apart from "both were meltdowns"

Chernobyl was entirely a product of design compromises due to cost savings, combined by a totalitarian system suppressing the known impact of those design decisions. It was also a much older design.

Fukushima also seemed like a design mistake (I remember reading it that the generators or something like that were flooded with water) , but then caused by a natural disaster and flooding.

The nuclear plans (in on paper at least) we have now as a result of decades of additional knowledge, and are way more safe. Combined with the fact that we have incredible computing firepower to better simulate scenarios, all this has convinced me to feel much better about the prospect of nuclear power plants and their safety.

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by cesarb on Monday February 26, 2024 @10:16AM (#39512195)
> As far as I know though, Chernobyl and Fukushima had completely different reasons and don't really clump together apart from "both were meltdowns"

A glass-half-empty view of that would be that there isn't a single reason which could be fixed to avoid all future issues. Fukushima AFAIK didn't have the design and operational mistakes which led to the Chernobyl incident, but that wasn't enough to prevent it from having its own incident. Which other causes we might be missing which could lead to new severe incidents in other nuclear power plants?

(And, by the way, the bad part IMO was not "both were meltdowns", but "both were explosions"; if it were just the meltdown, it would stay confined within the power plant, while the explosions are what spread the damage. Yes, they weren't nuclear explosions, but even a non-nuclear explosion in a nuclear power plant is bad.)

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by smegger001 on Monday February 26, 2024 @03:00PM (#39516116)
We have modern designs that Litterally can not melt down. No meltdown means no explosion.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by FrustratedMonky on Monday February 26, 2024 @05:09PM (#39517310)
Maybe. I'm trusting one comment on internet.

I'm pretty sure the Chernobyl engineers also said "this is impossible", "this is very safe design that can not fail". Only in hindsight did the failures appear.

For Fukushima. Sure, once in a lifetime earthquake. It's always something, and at some point walls can't go any higher. Seems like backup pumps should have been on higher ground. But to think nobody will do something similarly silly again, is being pretty trusting.

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by smegger001 on Monday February 26, 2024 @05:40PM (#39517636)
The difference is in Chernobyl there were mechanical safety systems to stop a meltdown. current designs are such that physics prevents it from being able to melt down. While its possible to improperly maintain safety systems causing them to fail, physics doesn't need maintenance.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by FrustratedMonky on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @08:04AM (#39523567)
Do you have link? I am curious what this design is.

If I just randomly search, it is just hundreds of designs, everyone has a 'theory' on some design that is safe and effective. Hard to filter out the 'crack-pot' from the actual physicists.

Do you have one in-particular.

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by smegger001 on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @11:42PM (#39534102)
pebble bed reactors.

to quote wikipedia which expalins it better than i can;

"When the reactor temperature rises, the atoms in the fuel move rapidly, causing Doppler broadening. The fuel then experiences a wider range of neutron speeds. Uranium-238, which forms the bulk of the uranium, is much more likely to absorb fast or epithermal neutrons at higher temperatures. This reduces the number of neutrons available to cause fission, and reduces power. Doppler broadening therefore creates a negative feedback: as fuel temperature increases, reactor power decreases. All reactors have reactivity feedback mechanisms. The pebble-bed reactor is designed so that this effect is relatively strong, inherent to the design, and does not depend on moving parts. If the rate of fission increases, temperature increase and Doppler broadening reduces the rate of fission. This negative feedback creates passive control of the reaction process."

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by FrustratedMonky on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @12:18PM (#39540934)
Thank You Yes, guess any built in Negative Feedback would be better than defaulting Positive Feedback.

Guess someone could still do some bad design to cause some other type of rupture that would expel radioactive material, but much less possible.

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by smegger001 on Wednesday February 28, 2024 @02:53PM (#39542688)
A rupture is unlikely as most pebble bed designs use helium as the coolent. It being a noble gas it won't react chemically, and unlike water cooled designs it doesn't undergo phase change (liquidgas) so no massive pressure build up. And as there is no oxygen fire is unlikely.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by vimbtw on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @10:12AM (#39525023)
But nuclear power starts to look even better when you look up the death tolls and realize that as long as you are halfway competent (i.e. not Chernobyl) even the worst disasters have led to vanishingly few deaths. What is more dangerous is the irrational fear of nuclear power that led to the dangerous evacuation of Fukushima.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by charlieyu1 on Monday February 26, 2024 @09:24AM (#39511528)
So 2 mistakes in the last 50 years, each wiping out a radius of 25km from being habitable for 1000 years. I won’t trust people for not making more mistakes.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by smegger001 on Monday February 26, 2024 @03:07PM (#39516173)
Its not likely to be a thousand years before its habitatable again. Long lived isotopes are safer as they are less radioactive and less energetic. And short lived isotopes while dangerous are short lived. Its the medium lived that are a problem 70-150 years that are the biggest problem. Secondly we dont have to wait for it to all to be gone just down to a safe background level
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by FrustratedMonky on Monday February 26, 2024 @01:35PM (#39515113)
There is a common cause.

Humans.

You mention both Cost Savings and Design Mistakes. Those are common, and will occur in future projects.

Don't think totalitarian Gov has any monopoly on hiding design problems. Every company does it.

Those are both things, drives, that the US has shown to be incapable of administering. All industry is rife with cost cutting. And "safety" is very much cut in the name of profits. It happens today, just not 'obvious'. We don't hear about it until there is a meltdown.

I do hope that new designs are better. But I am absolutely not confident that humans have learned anything and wont subvert any improved designs again for cost savings.

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by doetoe on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:07PM (#39531467)
> Chernobyl was entirely a product of design compromises due to cost savings, combined by a totalitarian system suppressing the known impact of those design decisions.

This sounds exactly like what could happen when a private for-profit company would exploit nuclear, which is already happening

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by screye on Monday February 26, 2024 @03:45PM (#39516575)
> Chernobyl

The worst designed reactor that led to 60 deaths ?

> Fukushima

As in, the reactor that was struck with a generational earthquauke and where no one died?

________

Compare this to other energy sources

Coal - 1500 [1]

Coal waste -12000[2]

You can keep going down this[3] list. Nuclear disasters are a mere blip. Only solar is any safer.

[1]April 26, 1942: Benxihu Colliery disaster in Benxi, Liaoning, China. 1,549 workers died, in the worst coal mine accident ever in the world

[2] December 1952: The Great Smog of London caused by the burning of coal, and to a lesser extent wood, killed 12,000 people within days to months due to inhalation of the smog.

[3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Energy_accidents

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by FrustratedMonky on Monday February 26, 2024 @05:23PM (#39517447)
I don't think you are including the deaths in following years from the radiation poisoning. Those numbers are just 'the day of'.

But also. I agree, Coal industry has a lot of deaths too. Far more year over year. And things like settling ponds should be more regulated. Lot of deaths from coal waste holding damns failing.

So. Think you are little cherry picking stats to show Nuclear "isn't that bad", and Coals "very bad". When truth is really somewhere in middle.

Think in this, the disconnect, you are discounting the potential much higher risk potential with Nuclear.

A coal damn giving way, kills everyone in the downstream town, maybe hundreds.

But if worst case Nuclear disaster, has much higher potential, millions.

Really in Chernobyl and Fukushima, we got lucky, they turned out to be bad, close calls, but in each we were saved at the last minute, so not so bad.

Both were minutes away from much higher releases. Both could have wiped out their entire country. Potentially, Ukraine and Japan could both be gone today, not exist as countries, by the time you factor into half the country farmland gone, and major cities un-inhabitable.

That sounds dramatic. But think that is what a risk matrix would point out. So how much risk can we tolerate? Is Climate Change risk finally in the public mind enough to overcome the Nuclear risk?

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by cesarb on Monday February 26, 2024 @09:34AM (#39511642)
You didn't mention what I believe is the true reason nuclear power got its bad reputation: nuclear weapons.

(Tough you could argue that it's your item 3, since nuclear weapons and their open-air testing would be the reason the left/environmental/peace movement started to hate the concept.)

Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by master-lincoln on Monday February 26, 2024 @10:27AM (#39512355)
Wasn't it rather events like in Chernobyl and Fukushima?
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by citrin_ru on Monday February 26, 2024 @10:08AM (#39512092)
1. and 2. are closely related. High cost at least partially can be attributed to the requirement for nuclear to be in not the safest then at least safer than coal/hydro and many other currently used sources. Pretty much like people demand air travel to be the safest form of transportation. But given that without nuclear we would continue to burn coal/gas which is not risk free either may be the balance should be struck on the other point of the cost-safety spectrum.
Re:Xkcd: Greenhouse Effect by fragmede on Tuesday February 27, 2024 @06:10AM (#39522681)
There's also the small detail of fission vs fusion. We don't currently have fusion power except from the sun, but if we could make it work (which, noted, we've been trying for quite a number of years to make it work), then we'd have rather nuclear power that is quite a bit better than what we can do today. that might be enough to move the needle on nuclear power, since it doesn't have the waste or melt down issue.